Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Turbulence: Vinen Vortex-Line Densities in Helium and Condensates Against the Shear Bound

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 12, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A dense, random tangle of quantised vortices — quantum turbulence — is the most strongly sheared state a superfluid ordinarily reaches. This paper assembles representative vortex-line densities for helium-4 counterflow turbulence and for turbulent condensates, converts them to intervortex spacings and gradient scales, and compares the strongest case with the torsion shear ceiling. Strong helium counterflow reaches a line density of 1e+11 per square metre, corresponding to a spacing of 3.16 micrometres and a gradient ratio of 2.34e-11 to the ceiling; moderate counterflow gives a spacing of 31.6 micrometres. Even the turbulent state, in which the flow is nothing but vortex cores and their induced velocities, remains orders of magnitude below the fundamental shear scale, and its dynamics are governed by reconnections and Kelvin waves within classical-like cascade physics. The line densities are taken from the published turbulence record and converted here, not measured.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24155461

Related papers

Quantised Vortex Densities in Rotating Condensates and the Shear Bound

William Alexander Aldred

A rotating superfluid mimics solid-body rotation through an array of quantised vortices whose areal density is fixed by the Feynman relation. This paper computes vortex densities, intervortex spacings and the associated gradient scales for rotating rubidium-87 condensates and rotating helium-4 across experimentally accessible rotation rates, and compares them with the shear ceiling from the spin-torsion bound. Rubidium-87 rotating at 10 hertz carries 2.74e+10 vortices per square metre with a spacing of 6.0 micrometres; helium-4 at 10 radians per second carries 2.01e+08 per square metre with a spacing of 70.60 micrometres. The largest gradient associated with the array, set by the inverse spacing, stands at a ratio of 1.23e-11 to the torsion ceiling. Vortex arrays therefore reproduce the kinematics of rotation at densities of circulation that remain vastly below any fundamental shear limit, and the practical ceiling on vortex density is set by core overlap and condensate depletion, not by the bound. This study is computed from stated assumptions, not measured.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Dynamics of the vortex line density in superfluid counterflow turbulence

Dmytro Khomenko, Victor S. L’vov, Anna Pomyalov +1 more

Describing superfluid turbulence at intermediate scales between the intervortex distance and the macroscale requires an acceptable equation of motion for the density of quantized vortex lines $\mathcal{L}$. The closure of such an equation for superfluid inhomogeneous flows requires additional inputs besides $\mathcal{L}$ and the normal and superfluid velocity fields. In this paper, we offer a minimal closure using one additional anisotropy parameter ${I}_{l0}$. Using the example of counterflow superfluid turbulence, we derive two coupled closure equations for the vortex line density and the anisotropy parameter ${I}_{l0}$ with an input of the normal and superfluid velocity fields. The various closure assumptions and the predictions of the resulting theory are tested against numerical simulations.

arXiv:1709.00671•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 16, 2018•5 citations

Quantum turbulence

Tsubota Makoto, Kasamatsu Makoto

Abstract Chapter 5 delves into quantum turbulence in superfluid helium and atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). The foundation of quantum turbulence research lies in classical fluid dynamics and turbulence, which is why we begin by covering essential concepts like the Reynolds number and Kolmogorov’s -5/3 power law in the energy spectrum. These principles are crucial for understanding quantum turbulence. We then explore the shared aspects of quantum turbulence in superfluid helium and atomic BECs, such as the differences in vortex configurations compared to classical turbulence, energy spectra, cascades, and the distinction between quasiclassical (Kolmogorov) and ultraquantum (Vinen) turbulence, focusing on their decay behaviors. In superfluid helium, we emphasize experimental studies in thermal counterflow and numerical simulations using the Vortex Filament Model (VFM). The advent of visualization experiments in the mid-2000s was transformative, allowing the observation of normal fluid velocity profiles and accelerations via tracer particles, which led to more accurate simulations coupling the VFM with normal fluid dynamics. Another significant topic is the energy spectrum of quantum turbulence, and whether it mirrors classical turbulence remains a key question. In addition to thermal counterflow, localized quantum turbulence generated by oscillating objects has been a major area of study. We present research showing how quantized vortices grow and evolve into turbulence. Superfluid 3He-B also provides a platform for quantum turbulence, with advancements in microfabrication bringing MEMS and NEMS into focus for studying quantum hydrodynamics at micro- and nanoscale, influenced by boundary conditions. In atomic BECs, confined by potentials, turbulence is induced through techniques like shaking or moving potentials. A unique aspect of BECs is two-dimensional quantum turbulence, featuring inverse energy cascades, Onsager vortices, and negative temperature states. Finally, atomic BECs, being compressible, serve as a platform for both vortex and wave turbulence. Multicomponent BECs, such as spinor BECs, introduce spin turbulence, further diversifying the field.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 2, 2025•0 citations

Observation of Vinen turbulence during far-from-equilibrium Bose-Einstein condensation

Sebastian J. Morris, Martin Gazo, Simon M. Fischer +5 more

Relaxation of far-from-equilibrium quantum fluids, intimately related to the emergence of long-range order, is theoretically associated with the decay of a turbulent isotropic tangle of vortex lines. We observe and study such decaying quantum turbulence in a homogeneous 3D atomic Bose gas. Using matter-wave techniques to magnify the gas density distribution, and then imaging a thin slice of the magnified cloud, we observe imprints of randomly oriented vortex lines and measure the vortex line-length density $\mathcal{L}$. The observed decay of $\mathcal{L}$ agrees with the prediction for Vinen `ultraquantum' turbulence. Although our weakly interacting gases are highly compressible, their large-scale dynamics are consistent with the behavior of an incompressible hydrodynamic fluid, with the decay of $\mathcal{L}$ not depending on the strength of the interatomic interactions and being similar to that in the strongly interacting superfluid helium.

cond-mat.quant-gasCross-listedarXiv:2604.28191•Physical Review Letters•May 1, 2026•5 citations

Bottleneck crossover between classical and quantum superfluid turbulence

Victor S. L’vov, Sergey Nazarenko, Oleksii Rudenko

We consider superfluid turbulence near absolute zero of temperature generated by classical means, e.g., towed grid or rotation but not by counterflow. We argue that such turbulence consists of a polarized tangle of mutually interacting vortex filaments with quantized vorticity. For this system, we predict and describe a bottleneck accumulation of the energy spectrum at the classical-quantum crossover scale $\ensuremath{\ell}$. Demanding the same energy flux through scales, the value of the energy at the crossover scale should exceed the Kolmogorov-41 (K41) spectrum by a large factor ${\mathrm{ln}}^{10∕3}(\ensuremath{\ell}∕{a}_{0})$ ($\ensuremath{\ell}$ is the mean intervortex distance and ${a}_{0}$ is the vortex core radius) for the classical and quantum spectra to be matched in value. One of the important consequences of the bottleneck is that it causes the mean vortex line density to be considerably higher than that based on K41 alone, and this should be taken into account in (re)interpretation of new (and old) experiments as well as in further theoretical studies.

arXiv:nlin/0612018•Physical Review B•Jul 26, 2007•154 citations

Structure of a chaotic tangle of quantum vortices in turbulent superfluid liquids and in a Bose – Einstein condensate

Sergey K. Nemirovskii

Abstract Based on the theory of the thermodynamic equilibrium in a system of quantum vortices in superfluid liquids and in a Bose – Einstein condensate in the presence of a counterflow of normal and superfluid components, we investigate the structure of a chaotic tangle of quantum vortices in turbulent superfluid liquids. Using the characteristic functional method, the properties of hydrodynamic vortex filaments are examined. It is shown that the average curvature of the vortex lines is on the order of the intervortex distance, with the proportionality coefficient being independent of the counterflow velocity. It is found that the degree of anisotropy of the vortex loops does not depend on the applied counterflow velocity. The obtained results explain the origin of the anisotropy as well as the relationship between the curvature of the lines and the intervortex space and their dependence on the parameters of the problem.

Quantum Electronics•Jun 1, 2020•1 citation
A dense, random tangle of quantised vortices — quantum turbulence — is the most strongly sheared state a superfluid ordinarily reaches. This paper assembles representative vortex-line densities for helium-4 counterflow turbulence and for turbulent condensates, converts them to intervortex spacings and gradient scales, and compares the strongest case with the torsion shear ceiling. Strong helium counterflow reaches a line density of 1e+11 per square metre, corresponding to a spacing of 3.16 micrometres and a gradient ratio of 2.34e-11 to the ceiling; moderate counterflow gives a spacing of 31.6 micrometres. Even the turbulent state, in which the flow is nothing but vortex cores and their induced velocities, remains orders of magnitude below the fundamental shear scale, and its dynamics are governed by reconnections and Kelvin waves within classical-like cascade physics. The line densities are taken from the published turbulence record and converted here, not measured.
A rotating superfluid mimics solid-body rotation through an array of quantised vortices whose areal density is fixed by the Feynman relation. This paper computes vortex densities, intervortex spacings and the associated gradient scales for rotating rubidium-87 condensates and rotating helium-4 across experimentally accessible rotation rates, and compares them with the shear ceiling from the spin-torsion bound. Rubidium-87 rotating at 10 hertz carries 2.74e+10 vortices per square metre with a spacing of 6.0 micrometres; helium-4 at 10 radians per second carries 2.01e+08 per square metre with a spacing of 70.60 micrometres. The largest gradient associated with the array, set by the inverse spacing, stands at a ratio of 1.23e-11 to the torsion ceiling. Vortex arrays therefore reproduce the kinematics of rotation at densities of circulation that remain vastly below any fundamental shear limit, and the practical ceiling on vortex density is set by core overlap and condensate depletion, not by the bound. This study is computed from stated assumptions, not measured.
Describing superfluid turbulence at intermediate scales between the intervortex distance and the macroscale requires an acceptable equation of motion for the density of quantized vortex lines L\mathcal{L}L. The closure of such an equation for superfluid inhomogeneous flows requires additional inputs besides L\mathcal{L}L and the normal and superfluid velocity fields. In this paper, we offer a minimal closure using one additional anisotropy parameter Il0{I}_{l0}Il0​. Using the example of counterflow superfluid turbulence, we derive two coupled closure equations for the vortex line density and the anisotropy parameter Il0{I}_{l0}Il0​ with an input of the normal and superfluid velocity fields. The various closure assumptions and the predictions of the resulting theory are tested against numerical simulations.
Abstract Chapter 5 delves into quantum turbulence in superfluid helium and atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). The foundation of quantum turbulence research lies in classical fluid dynamics and turbulence, which is why we begin by covering essential concepts like the Reynolds number and Kolmogorov’s -5/3 power law in the energy spectrum. These principles are crucial for understanding quantum turbulence. We then explore the shared aspects of quantum turbulence in superfluid helium and atomic BECs, such as the differences in vortex configurations compared to classical turbulence, energy spectra, cascades, and the distinction between quasiclassical (Kolmogorov) and ultraquantum (Vinen) turbulence, focusing on their decay behaviors. In superfluid helium, we emphasize experimental studies in thermal counterflow and numerical simulations using the Vortex Filament Model (VFM). The advent of visualization experiments in the mid-2000s was transformative, allowing the observation of normal fluid velocity profiles and accelerations via tracer particles, which led to more accurate simulations coupling the VFM with normal fluid dynamics. Another significant topic is the energy spectrum of quantum turbulence, and whether it mirrors classical turbulence remains a key question. In addition to thermal counterflow, localized quantum turbulence generated by oscillating objects has been a major area of study. We present research showing how quantized vortices grow and evolve into turbulence. Superfluid 3He-B also provides a platform for quantum turbulence, with advancements in microfabrication bringing MEMS and NEMS into focus for studying quantum hydrodynamics at micro- and nanoscale, influenced by boundary conditions. In atomic BECs, confined by potentials, turbulence is induced through techniques like shaking or moving potentials. A unique aspect of BECs is two-dimensional quantum turbulence, featuring inverse energy cascades, Onsager vortices, and negative temperature states. Finally, atomic BECs, being compressible, serve as a platform for both vortex and wave turbulence. Multicomponent BECs, such as spinor BECs, introduce spin turbulence, further diversifying the field.
Relaxation of far-from-equilibrium quantum fluids, intimately related to the emergence of long-range order, is theoretically associated with the decay of a turbulent isotropic tangle of vortex lines. We observe and study such decaying quantum turbulence in a homogeneous 3D atomic Bose gas. Using matter-wave techniques to magnify the gas density distribution, and then imaging a thin slice of the magnified cloud, we observe imprints of randomly oriented vortex lines and measure the vortex line-length density L\mathcal{L}L. The observed decay of L\mathcal{L}L agrees with the prediction for Vinen `ultraquantum' turbulence. Although our weakly interacting gases are highly compressible, their large-scale dynamics are consistent with the behavior of an incompressible hydrodynamic fluid, with the decay of L\mathcal{L}L not depending on the strength of the interatomic interactions and being similar to that in the strongly interacting superfluid helium.
We consider superfluid turbulence near absolute zero of temperature generated by classical means, e.g., towed grid or rotation but not by counterflow. We argue that such turbulence consists of a polarized tangle of mutually interacting vortex filaments with quantized vorticity. For this system, we predict and describe a bottleneck accumulation of the energy spectrum at the classical-quantum crossover scale $\ensuremath{\ell}$. Demanding the same energy flux through scales, the value of the energy at the crossover scale should exceed the Kolmogorov-41 (K41) spectrum by a large factor ${\mathrm{ln}}^{10∕3}(\ensuremath{\ell}∕{a}_{0})$ ($\ensuremath{\ell}$ is the mean intervortex distance and a0{a}_{0}a0​ is the vortex core radius) for the classical and quantum spectra to be matched in value. One of the important consequences of the bottleneck is that it causes the mean vortex line density to be considerably higher than that based on K41 alone, and this should be taken into account in (re)interpretation of new (and old) experiments as well as in further theoretical studies.
Abstract Based on the theory of the thermodynamic equilibrium in a system of quantum vortices in superfluid liquids and in a Bose – Einstein condensate in the presence of a counterflow of normal and superfluid components, we investigate the structure of a chaotic tangle of quantum vortices in turbulent superfluid liquids. Using the characteristic functional method, the properties of hydrodynamic vortex filaments are examined. It is shown that the average curvature of the vortex lines is on the order of the intervortex distance, with the proportionality coefficient being independent of the counterflow velocity. It is found that the degree of anisotropy of the vortex loops does not depend on the applied counterflow velocity. The obtained results explain the origin of the anisotropy as well as the relationship between the curvature of the lines and the intervortex space and their dependence on the parameters of the problem.