Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Screening as Syntactic Limitation: Nine Puzzles of Quantum Mechanics from a Single Hilbert-Space Constraint

Fabien Dechery

Published Nov 6, 2026• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We demonstrate that nine foundational puzzles of quantum mechanics — superposition, the Born rule, state reduction, decoherence, entropy, entanglement, the arrow of time, the black-hole information paradox, and the Unruh effect — are not independent problems requiring separate solutions but nine facets of a single structural limitation: the inability of the linear Hilbert-space habitat $\mathcal{H}$ to express the nonlinear, non-separable dynamics of the generative substrate $\mathcal{G}$. The argument rests on the axiomatic closure of the descriptive interface $\mathcal{D}$ established in the companion articles [20, 22]: the informational axioms that define $\mathcal{D}_{\mathrm{QM}}$ as a coherent syntax force its linearity as a theorem, and this linearity constitutively screens all nonlinear content arriving through the coarse-graining map $\Pi: \mathcal{G} \to \mathcal{D}$. We formalize four structural properties of $\Pi$ (non-injective, non-surjective, non-linear, non-factorizing) and show that each property generates a specific subset of the nine phenomena. Crucially, the screening is not a binary on/off filter: quantitative results from the Emergence Programme [25, 26] reveal an *anatomy of screening* resolved by isospin channel, Dirac bilinear structure of the insertion operator, and proper-time depth $\tau$, with deficit magnitudes ranging from $< 2\%$ (mass, Class A) to $100\%$ (isoscalar magnetic quark form factor, Class D). The Gisin-Polchinski no-signaling constraint, which appears to forbid any ontological nonlinearity, is dissolved as a category error: it prohibits nonlinearity at $\mathcal{D}$, not at $\mathcal{G}$. The spectral invariants of $\mathcal{G}$ (including the mass gap) propagate faithfully through $\Pi$ as global properties of the coarse-graining equivalence classes.

Related papers

Ontological Constraints on Epistemic Syntax: How Informationally-Constrained Access to Reality Shaped the Axiomatic Structure of Quantum, Relativistic, and Gravitational Theories

Fabien Dechery

Three physical properties of any measurement probe $\pi$ in a substrate $\mathcal{G}$ --- non-zero energy cost (A1: $E_\pi > 0$), finite propagation speed (A2: $v_\pi \leq c$), and constitutive excitation (A3: $\pi \in \mathcal{G}$) --- tightly constrain the axiomatic structures of quantum mechanics, relativity, and quantum field theory. A1 $\wedge$ A3 tightly constrains non-commutativity and the Born rule; A2 entails Lorentz invariance and microcausality; their conjunction yields the Wightman axioms and CPT. A3 enriches both registers: complexification in $\mathcal{D}_\mathrm{QM}$ and curvature in $\mathcal{D}_\mathrm{GR}$. Each major step is grounded in a published theorem (Ignatowski, Gleason, Jost, Malament, Jacobson). The linearity of quantum mechanics is identified as a screening artefact of the Hilbert-space habitat. A classification criterion for the mass gap --- nonlinearity plus non-trivial homotopy --- is consistent with all six known test cases (consistency checks, not blind predictions).

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

03 - Emergence of Quantum Mechanics and Born Measure from a Coherence-Driven TwoField Discrete Framework

Enrico Ferrero

This series presents a structured and logically sequential formulation of a discrete informational framework governed by global coherence constraints. Although it originates from the same research program developed in the earlier exploratory preprint series (P-series), the works presented here constitute an autonomous and self-contained series, organized in a progressively axiomatic form and focused on the explicit derivation of the framework’s effective structures. The goal of the construction is to investigate whether structures commonly associated with quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, and geometry may emerge from a discrete relational substrate without being introduced as fundamental postulates. Each article addresses a specific level of the theoretical derivation and forms part of a progressive logical structure based on results established in the preceding works of the series. This article develops the emergence of Hilbert-space structure and Schrödinger-type effective dynamics from the coherent two-field sector established in Paper 02. The work demonstrates that the global coherence constraints imposed on the discrete informational substrate naturally generate an effective complex representation endowed with linear superposition properties and unitary-preserving evolution. The analysis shows that the two-component coherent sector admits a mathematically stable reformulation equivalent to a Hilbert-space structure, and that the effective evolution of the coherent amplitudes leads to a Schrödinger-type dynamical equation without introducing quantum mechanics as an initial assumption. The article further derives the probabilistic interpretation associated with the effective amplitudes and clarifies how quantum-like statistical behavior emerges from the internal coherence conditions of the underlying discrete system. No quantum postulates are assumed at the foundational level. The purpose of the article is to demonstrate that the formal structures associated with quantum mechanics can emerge as effective consequences of coherence-preserving informational dynamics. The article does not assume quantum mechanics as a foundational theory and does not postulate the Hilbert-space formalism a priori. Instead, the work demonstrates that, within the internal hypotheses and coherence constraints of the proposed discrete informational framework, structures mathematically equivalent to Hilbert-space representations and Schrödinger-type evolution can arise as effective emergent descriptions. The purpose of the derivation is therefore not to reproduce standard quantum mechanics by assumption, but to show that quantum-like formal structures may consistently emerge from deeper coherence-preserving informational dynamics.

•May 13, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics as the Boundary Algebra of a Non-Invertible Projection

Pasquale Camelia

This paper argues that quantum mechanics is not a separate postulate system to be reconciled with spacetime physics. It is the boundary algebra of a non-invertible projection: the algebraic structure that a globally coherent bulk field is forced to produce when it becomes observable. The bulk field is a Majorana spinor, Ξ = CΞ̄, on M^5 = R^4 × S^1(τ), governed by a single conservation law. The projection Π onto the observable boundary is not an external measurement device added afterward: it is the form the field must take in order to admit an observable image at all. What survives Π defines the observable sector; what enters ker Π is lost structurally, not thermodynamically. From this single mechanism, four boundary structures emerge: the Hilbert space of quantum mechanics, physical time, matter stability, and the Born rule. These are four boundary readings of one conservation law, K_τ = ξη = α^−1, resolved by the same tangential dynamics on the invariant surface Σ. Observable states are equivalence classes [Ξ] = Ξ + ker Π. The Born rule is the canonical quadratic probability measure induced by the projection geometry. Measurement irreversibility is the non-injectivity of Π, with non-vanishing protected by the transcendence of π. Physical time is not assumed in advance: it emerges as the output of chiral projection through a conformal map from the compact cyclic fibre to the irreversible real line. The Wheeler–DeWitt equation is not a paradox but the correct timeless description of the bulk. Spacetime emerges after quantum mechanics, not before it. The fine-structure constant is not a free parameter. It is the unique observable residue forced by the self-coherent projection structure. The double-slit interference pattern, the Born rule, and measurement irreversibility are derived as structural corollaries of this paper in the companion work doi:10.5281/zenodo.19654630

•Apr 12, 2026•0 citations

Information Conservation and the Emergence of Complex Quantum Amplitudes

Cooney, Paul

"This paper derives the complex Hilbert space structure and Born rule of quantum mechanics from five information-theoretic axioms governing coarse-grained microhistory branches. No quantum structure is assumed; linearity, complex numbers, unitary dynamics, and Born probabilities all emerge from constraints on how operational information can be stored, transformed, and composed. The reconstruction is independent of any specific microscopic model but naturally accommodates microhistory ontologies indexed by various ordering parameters (physical time, relational clocks, scalar fields)."

•Nov 26, 2025•0 citations

Operational Dissolution of the Measurement Problem in Quantum Mechanics: Born Rule, EPR Paradox, and Bell Inequalities

T. O.

The quantum measurement problem has resisted resolution for nearly a century, fragmenting into three seemingly independent challenges: the Born rule's probabilistic interpretation, the EPR paradox of simultaneous reality, and Bell inequality violations challenging local realism. This fragmentation has obscured a common structural origin. This work demonstrates that all three problems arise from a single theoretical defect: the misapplication of commutative probability theory to non-commutative operational structures. Within the framework of Cognitional Mechanics (CM), grounded in two axioms—non-commutativity ([Ô_A, Ô_B] ≠ 0) and finite operational resolution (Level of Detail)—these problems dissolve simultaneously through structural reconstruction. The Born rule emerges as the unique projection measure compatible with resource conservation and tensor-product linearity under non-commutative constraints, repositioning probability as an epistemic consequence of finite resolution rather than ontological randomness. EPR correlations are resolved as constraint propagation across shared operational stacks, eliminating the apparent conflict between quantum completeness and local realism without invoking non-local signaling. Bell inequality violations follow from the logical impossibility of factorization: non-commutativity structurally excludes the simultaneous eigenstates required by the factorization condition, rendering the measure space for joint distributions undefined rather than merely violated. The framework derives from Tier 1 axiomatic necessity within Cognitional Mechanics. Mathematical formalisms—Hilbert spaces, operator algebras, measure theory—serve as Tier 3 projection tools expressing this structure, not as foundational requirements for its validity. This paper builds on Operational Quantum Mechanics I (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18649525), which resolved Schrödinger's cat through operational stack management, and forms a symmetrical counterpart to Universal Relativity (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18645324) within the CM framework.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

On the Structural Origin of Quantum Mechanics: A Projection-Based Reconstruction of the Quantum Formalism

Erik Axelkrans

This paper presents a structural reconstruction of the formal core of quantum mechanics fromthe properties of a bounded, linear, distinguishability-reducing projection acting on a generalfunctional space. Effective quantum states are identified with equivalence classes under theprojection ΠQM : H∗ → HQM and the Hilbert-space structure of HQM is induced by a positiveoperator K on the underlying space.Within this framework, the characteristic elements of quantum theory emerge as direct conse-quences of projection geometry and operator structure. Linearity yields superposition, quadraticnorms on equivalence classes give rise to the Born rule, non-factorizability leads to entangle-ment and commuting local algebras ensure no-signalling. Schrödinger-type unitary dynamicsarises from projection of symmetric generators, Dirac-type operators follow from algebraic com-patibility with Clifford structures and violations of classical Bell inequalities together with theTsirelson bound are enforced by operator-norm constraints in the projected C∗-algebra.No hidden variables are introduced and no modification of standard empirical quantummechanics is proposed. Rather than postulating the quantum formalism as axiomatic, theanalysis shows that its defining structures form a highly constrained and stable outcome oflinear projection, equivalence-class geometry, and norm-preserving dynamics.Rather than introducing new physical dynamics, the purpose of this work is to clarify why theestablished quantum formalism admits so little structural freedom once a small set of minimalrequirements is imposed.

•Feb 1, 2026•0 citations
We demonstrate that nine foundational puzzles of quantum mechanics — superposition, the Born rule, state reduction, decoherence, entropy, entanglement, the arrow of time, the black-hole information paradox, and the Unruh effect — are not independent problems requiring separate solutions but nine facets of a single structural limitation: the inability of the linear Hilbert-space habitat H\mathcal{H}H to express the nonlinear, non-separable dynamics of the generative substrate G\mathcal{G}G. The argument rests on the axiomatic closure of the descriptive interface D\mathcal{D}D established in the companion articles [20, 22]: the informational axioms that define DQM\mathcal{D}_{\mathrm{QM}}DQM​ as a coherent syntax force its linearity as a theorem, and this linearity constitutively screens all nonlinear content arriving through the coarse-graining map Π:G→D\Pi: \mathcal{G} \to \mathcal{D}Π:G→D. We formalize four structural properties of Π\PiΠ (non-injective, non-surjective, non-linear, non-factorizing) and show that each property generates a specific subset of the nine phenomena. Crucially, the screening is not a binary on/off filter: quantitative results from the Emergence Programme [25, 26] reveal an anatomy of screening resolved by isospin channel, Dirac bilinear structure of the insertion operator, and proper-time depth τ\tauτ, with deficit magnitudes ranging from <2%< 2\%<2% (mass, Class A) to 100%100\%100% (isoscalar magnetic quark form factor, Class D). The Gisin-Polchinski no-signaling constraint, which appears to forbid any ontological nonlinearity, is dissolved as a category error: it prohibits nonlinearity at D\mathcal{D}D, not at G\mathcal{G}G. The spectral invariants of G\mathcal{G}G (including the mass gap) propagate faithfully through Π\PiΠ as global properties of the coarse-graining equivalence classes.
Three physical properties of any measurement probe π\piπ in a substrate G\mathcal{G}G --- non-zero energy cost (A1: Eπ>0E_\pi > 0Eπ​>0), finite propagation speed (A2: vπ≤cv_\pi \leq cvπ​≤c), and constitutive excitation (A3: π∈G\pi \in \mathcal{G}π∈G) --- tightly constrain the axiomatic structures of quantum mechanics, relativity, and quantum field theory. A1 ∧\wedge∧ A3 tightly constrains non-commutativity and the Born rule; A2 entails Lorentz invariance and microcausality; their conjunction yields the Wightman axioms and CPT. A3 enriches both registers: complexification in DQM\mathcal{D}_\mathrm{QM}DQM​ and curvature in DGR\mathcal{D}_\mathrm{GR}DGR​. Each major step is grounded in a published theorem (Ignatowski, Gleason, Jost, Malament, Jacobson). The linearity of quantum mechanics is identified as a screening artefact of the Hilbert-space habitat. A classification criterion for the mass gap --- nonlinearity plus non-trivial homotopy --- is consistent with all six known test cases (consistency checks, not blind predictions).
This series presents a structured and logically sequential formulation of a discrete informational framework governed by global coherence constraints. Although it originates from the same research program developed in the earlier exploratory preprint series (P-series), the works presented here constitute an autonomous and self-contained series, organized in a progressively axiomatic form and focused on the explicit derivation of the framework’s effective structures. The goal of the construction is to investigate whether structures commonly associated with quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, and geometry may emerge from a discrete relational substrate without being introduced as fundamental postulates. Each article addresses a specific level of the theoretical derivation and forms part of a progressive logical structure based on results established in the preceding works of the series. This article develops the emergence of Hilbert-space structure and Schrödinger-type effective dynamics from the coherent two-field sector established in Paper 02. The work demonstrates that the global coherence constraints imposed on the discrete informational substrate naturally generate an effective complex representation endowed with linear superposition properties and unitary-preserving evolution. The analysis shows that the two-component coherent sector admits a mathematically stable reformulation equivalent to a Hilbert-space structure, and that the effective evolution of the coherent amplitudes leads to a Schrödinger-type dynamical equation without introducing quantum mechanics as an initial assumption. The article further derives the probabilistic interpretation associated with the effective amplitudes and clarifies how quantum-like statistical behavior emerges from the internal coherence conditions of the underlying discrete system. No quantum postulates are assumed at the foundational level. The purpose of the article is to demonstrate that the formal structures associated with quantum mechanics can emerge as effective consequences of coherence-preserving informational dynamics. The article does not assume quantum mechanics as a foundational theory and does not postulate the Hilbert-space formalism a priori. Instead, the work demonstrates that, within the internal hypotheses and coherence constraints of the proposed discrete informational framework, structures mathematically equivalent to Hilbert-space representations and Schrödinger-type evolution can arise as effective emergent descriptions. The purpose of the derivation is therefore not to reproduce standard quantum mechanics by assumption, but to show that quantum-like formal structures may consistently emerge from deeper coherence-preserving informational dynamics.
This paper argues that quantum mechanics is not a separate postulate system to be reconciled with spacetime physics. It is the boundary algebra of a non-invertible projection: the algebraic structure that a globally coherent bulk field is forced to produce when it becomes observable. The bulk field is a Majorana spinor, Ξ = CΞ̄, on M^5 = R^4 × S^1(τ), governed by a single conservation law. The projection Π onto the observable boundary is not an external measurement device added afterward: it is the form the field must take in order to admit an observable image at all. What survives Π defines the observable sector; what enters ker Π is lost structurally, not thermodynamically. From this single mechanism, four boundary structures emerge: the Hilbert space of quantum mechanics, physical time, matter stability, and the Born rule. These are four boundary readings of one conservation law, K_τ = ξη = α^−1, resolved by the same tangential dynamics on the invariant surface Σ. Observable states are equivalence classes [Ξ] = Ξ + ker Π. The Born rule is the canonical quadratic probability measure induced by the projection geometry. Measurement irreversibility is the non-injectivity of Π, with non-vanishing protected by the transcendence of π. Physical time is not assumed in advance: it emerges as the output of chiral projection through a conformal map from the compact cyclic fibre to the irreversible real line. The Wheeler–DeWitt equation is not a paradox but the correct timeless description of the bulk. Spacetime emerges after quantum mechanics, not before it. The fine-structure constant is not a free parameter. It is the unique observable residue forced by the self-coherent projection structure. The double-slit interference pattern, the Born rule, and measurement irreversibility are derived as structural corollaries of this paper in the companion work doi:10.5281/zenodo.19654630
"This paper derives the complex Hilbert space structure and Born rule of quantum mechanics from five information-theoretic axioms governing coarse-grained microhistory branches. No quantum structure is assumed; linearity, complex numbers, unitary dynamics, and Born probabilities all emerge from constraints on how operational information can be stored, transformed, and composed. The reconstruction is independent of any specific microscopic model but naturally accommodates microhistory ontologies indexed by various ordering parameters (physical time, relational clocks, scalar fields)."
The quantum measurement problem has resisted resolution for nearly a century, fragmenting into three seemingly independent challenges: the Born rule's probabilistic interpretation, the EPR paradox of simultaneous reality, and Bell inequality violations challenging local realism. This fragmentation has obscured a common structural origin. This work demonstrates that all three problems arise from a single theoretical defect: the misapplication of commutative probability theory to non-commutative operational structures. Within the framework of Cognitional Mechanics (CM), grounded in two axioms—non-commutativity ([Ô_A, Ô_B] ≠ 0) and finite operational resolution (Level of Detail)—these problems dissolve simultaneously through structural reconstruction. The Born rule emerges as the unique projection measure compatible with resource conservation and tensor-product linearity under non-commutative constraints, repositioning probability as an epistemic consequence of finite resolution rather than ontological randomness. EPR correlations are resolved as constraint propagation across shared operational stacks, eliminating the apparent conflict between quantum completeness and local realism without invoking non-local signaling. Bell inequality violations follow from the logical impossibility of factorization: non-commutativity structurally excludes the simultaneous eigenstates required by the factorization condition, rendering the measure space for joint distributions undefined rather than merely violated. The framework derives from Tier 1 axiomatic necessity within Cognitional Mechanics. Mathematical formalisms—Hilbert spaces, operator algebras, measure theory—serve as Tier 3 projection tools expressing this structure, not as foundational requirements for its validity. This paper builds on Operational Quantum Mechanics I (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18649525), which resolved Schrödinger's cat through operational stack management, and forms a symmetrical counterpart to Universal Relativity (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18645324) within the CM framework.
This paper presents a structural reconstruction of the formal core of quantum mechanics fromthe properties of a bounded, linear, distinguishability-reducing projection acting on a generalfunctional space. Effective quantum states are identified with equivalence classes under theprojection ΠQM : H∗ → HQM and the Hilbert-space structure of HQM is induced by a positiveoperator K on the underlying space.Within this framework, the characteristic elements of quantum theory emerge as direct conse-quences of projection geometry and operator structure. Linearity yields superposition, quadraticnorms on equivalence classes give rise to the Born rule, non-factorizability leads to entangle-ment and commuting local algebras ensure no-signalling. Schrödinger-type unitary dynamicsarises from projection of symmetric generators, Dirac-type operators follow from algebraic com-patibility with Clifford structures and violations of classical Bell inequalities together with theTsirelson bound are enforced by operator-norm constraints in the projected C∗-algebra.No hidden variables are introduced and no modification of standard empirical quantummechanics is proposed. Rather than postulating the quantum formalism as axiomatic, theanalysis shows that its defining structures form a highly constrained and stable outcome oflinear projection, equivalence-class geometry, and norm-preserving dynamics.Rather than introducing new physical dynamics, the purpose of this work is to clarify why theestablished quantum formalism admits so little structural freedom once a small set of minimalrequirements is imposed.