Do we have two kinds of reality: physical and mathematical? What is the role of mathematics in physics? These fundamental questions have intrigued original and brilliant minds since ancient times. A recent article (Aharonov, Cohen and Oaknin, arXiv:1902.08798) offers a viewpoint on the use of abstract mathematics in quantum theory. They argue that, in some cases, it may result into a paradox focusing on an example in quantum mechanics regarding Aharonov-Bergmann-Lebowitz (ABL) rule. In this comment we discuss three issues: theory reduction and approximation, origin of a paradox, and the reality of time. It is pointed out that paradoxes appear even in mathematics; we explain them as the results of the acceptance of pure logical artifacts. In physics too, the impact of the so called quantum and relativity revolutions, have led to the emergence of counter-intuitive and mysterious notion of the physical reality. The most fundamental change has been on rejecting the reality of time. A radically new perspective that physics is the language of mathematics is suggested. The mathematical reality of the natural numbers manifests in the form of physical time.
In previous work, we introduced Coarsest Distinction Theory (CDT) as a primitive mathematical framework from which both structural theories, including partition theory and rough sets, and quantitative theories, including decision theory and measure theory, emerge. In the present work, we investigate the converse problem: whether CDT itself possesses a physical origin. We prove that CDT emerges independently from five fundamental theories of physics: Newtonian mechanics, quantum mechanics, perturbative string theory, BFSS Matrix Theory, and General Relativity. For each theory, we construct a finite physical realization consisting of pair-selective interactions, experimentally observable persistent realization records, and a finite realization process. Using only the native physical principles of each theory, we prove that every realization satisfies a common Physical Realization Criterion and consequently generates the complete mathematical structure of CDT, including distinction decompositions, monotone refinement, terminal distinction atoms, and the Distinction Realization Index. We further establish a universal Physical Realization Template and prove that the resulting distinction hierarchy is independent of the underlying physical theory. The emergence results therefore identify CDT as a theory-independent primitive mathematical structure shared by five fundamentally different descriptions of physical reality, suggesting that distinction constitutes a common mathematical substrate underlying diverse physical theories.
Shared awareness is an essential concept in the joint decision-making context. Typically, it is oversimplified and associated with shared information. To share an understanding in totality is to say that there is a sharing of meaning and awareness, not only of information. However, existing shared awareness models fail to explain situations in which two people view the same event but attend to different information or act differently based on the same information. Although several categorization models of shared awareness exist, the models are ad-hoc or inadequate to generalization. This paper presents a theoretical discussion of shared awareness based on its cognitive structure. We apply the pragmatic idealism framework, which provides a theoretical construct where the domain of awareness is an abstraction of reality. This framework supports the existence of multiple incompatible perspectives and understandings. We discuss the ontology of this abstract concept with the mathematical tools of quantum probability theory. We discuss the cognitive processes that transform a simple situation into a complex situation. The presented model of shared awareness includes a quantification of the degree of sharing in complex situations.