Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Premises That Drew the Line: EPR's Criterion and Separation, Priced

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 5, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In 1935 Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen asked whether the quantum-mechanical description of physical reality can be considered complete, and they answered no. I credit that paper at full strength: EPR did not dispute a single quantum prediction. They built a two-system state with perfect correlations so that a measurement choice made on one system fixes, with certainty, either the position or the momentum of a distant system it no longer interacts with, and, given their two premises, the inference that follows is valid: simultaneous elements of reality for position and momentum, and with them the incompleteness of the wave-function description. What I evaluate is the pair of premises that inference rests on: the criterion of reality — if, without in any way disturbing a system, we can predict with certainty the value of a physical quantity, then there exists an element of reality corresponding to that quantity — and the separation premise — at the time of measurement the two systems no longer interact, so no real change can take place in the second system in consequence of anything that may be done to the first. Neither premise is derived in the paper; both are used as definitions, and the conclusion is exactly as strong as the pair, no stronger. On declared inputs only, my bench evaluates the conjunction of the two premises, not either premise alone: an exhaustive enumeration of all 16 deterministic local-realist assignments returns every assignment at |S| = 2 exactly — 8 at S = +2 and 8 at S = −2 — so the conjunction forces the bound |S| ≤ 2, while the declared spin-singlet correlation at the standard angles returns S = −2.828427, |S| = 2.828427 = 2√2. The gap is 0.828427 — the quantum return exceeds the bound the premises force by 41.421356 per cent of the bound — and the excess is a band, not a tuned point, running 2.449490 at 15 and 75 degrees and 2.732051 at 30 and 60 degrees across the declared sweep. John Bell is credited at his own address as the later address that made this conjunction testable, in 1964; the experimental record since runs against local realism, stated plainly. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23998520

Related papers

Objects That Must Exist: Kohn–Sham's Missing Functional and EPR's Criterion, Priced Jointly

William Alexander Aldred

Two of my census papers price, thirty years apart, the same logical move: an exact theory resting on an object that is asserted to exist, or a property asserted to be certified, without the object being given or the certification being derived. CC-128 priced Kohn and Sham's 1965 equations: the interacting system mapped onto a fictitious non-interacting one under an assumed representability, and everything the mapping does not compute swept into one object, the exchange–correlation functional E_xc[n] — named, not given, with no explicit form for arbitrary density in 1965 or derived since, and the open face sized by a declared later parametrisation at 0.164462 of the local exchange–correlation energy per electron at r_s = 2, rising to 0.334172 at r_s = 20. CC-126 priced Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen's 1935 argument: a criterion of reality that certifies an element of reality wherever a value can be predicted with certainty without disturbance, riding on a separation premise — two premises, both spent as definitions, whose conjunction an exhaustive enumeration prices exactly, forcing |S| ≤ 2 against the singlet's returned 2.828427, an excess of 0.828427, or 41.421356 per cent of the bound. This paper states the joint claim the two parents make together and prices it with their own exhibits: across the two addresses, four load-bearing postulated objects — one representability, one functional, one criterion, one separation — stand against zero derivations, and in each case the theory built on the object is exact or valid exactly where the object is granted, so that the object's standing, not the machinery downstream of it, is the whole question. My bench reproduces both parents' exhibits digit for digit — the sixteen-assignment enumeration returning 8 assignments at S = +2 and 8 at S = −2, the singlet sweep returning 2.449490 at 15 and 75 degrees, 2.732051 at 30 and 60, and 2.828427 at 45, and the exchange–correlation table returning the open-face fractions 0.115165 at r_s = 1 through 0.334172 at r_s = 20, growing by a factor of 2.031910 across the declared grid — and then counts, jointly: 4 postulated objects, 0 derivations, 2 exact theories, and 1 shared structure, the existence claim spent where a construction was needed. Grade for this joint entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification of either parent paper. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.

•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

The EPR Paradox Is Not a Paradox: A Supplement to "Observation as Simultaneous Emission and Absorption" — Reading the Position–Momentum Pair as a Closure Identity

Noriaki Kihara

The EPR argument has three steps. (i) Measuring the position of one member A of a pair predicts with certainty the position of the other member B, and measuring the momentum predicts B's momentum (perfect correlation). (ii) The measurement at A does not disturb the distant B (locality). (iii) Hence B's position and momentum are simultaneously elements of reality, and the quantum-mechanical description is incomplete. This paper takes the readout rule of the preceding paper "Observation as Simultaneous Emission and Absorption" (Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23857884) as its premise and re-reads the argument. The pair is a closure q_A + q_B = 0 that held once at the source, from which x_B = −x_A and p_B = −p_A follow simultaneously as identities. A single end has no value (the one-sided distribution is uniform), nothing happens at B when A is read, and the correlation depends neither on the order of the readouts nor on the distance between the two. The element of reality is the relation called the closure, not an attribute of one end. Step (ii) is correct, step (i) is a relational identity, and only the attribution in step (iii) is mistaken. That a destructive readout exists, drops the chosen variable to one of two values and severs the relation with the conjugate variable, is placed as a known fact (resonant absorption, photodetection, homodyne detection); deriving its mechanism is a separate task. "Instantaneous selection" is not written: what can be shown is only that no finite-speed influence exists. No new number appears. The claim is that, given the preceding paper, EPR is neither a paradox nor a mystery but a misreading of a relational identity. Earlier work reaching the same conclusion (Peres, Mermin, Smerlak and Rovelli, Griffiths, Jarrett, Spekkens, Wharton and Argaman, Cramer) is placed up front, and what belongs to this paper alone is limited to four points. Japanese original (authoritative) and English translation, with TeX sources, PDFs, two figures (Japanese and English labels), the figure program and the numerical identity checks.

•Nov 1, 2026•0 citations

Relativity, Quantum Mechanics and EPR

Robert K. Clifton, Constantine Pagonis, Itamar Pitowsky

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics involves two assumptions: one about locality and the other about when it is legitimate to infer the existence of an element-of-reality. Using one simple thought experiment, we argue that quantum predictions and the relativity of simultaneity require that both these assumptions fail, whether or not quantum mechanics is complete. EPR’s (1935) argument for the incompleteness of QM turns upon the following sufficient condition: “If, without in any way disturbing a system, we can predict with certainty (i.e., with probability equal to unity) the value of a physical quantity, then there exists an element of physical reality corresponding to this physical quantity.“ EPR apply this condition in a case where knowledge gained from measuring one quantum system allows one to predict with certainty a value for a physical quantity on another.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1992•29 citations

My life with Einstein, December 2005

N. David Mermin

On 25 March 1935, the Physical Review received a paper from Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen, with the title “Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?” A few days later, on 30 March 1935, I was born. My life with Einstein was off to a promising start. Some would call it an inauspicious start. Abraham Pais, for example, says in his otherwise admirable biography of Einstein [1] that “the only part of this article that will ultimately survive, I believe, is this last phrase [ No reasonable definition of reality could be expected to permit this ], which so poignantly summarizes Einstein's views on quantum mechanics in his later years.” But today, in this centenary of the Einstein annus mirabilis, as the EPR paper and I both turn 70, it is, in fact, the most cited of all Einstein's papers [2]. The debate over its conceptual implications rages hotter than ever, and for the first time, practical (well, for the moment still gedanken practical) applications of the EPR effect have emerged in cryptography and in other areas of quantum information processing. Being only five weeks old, I was unprepared to pay attention to the article that appeared in the New York Times on 4 May 1935 under an elaborate set of headlines and subheads: And I was completely oblivious to the stern rebuke from Einstein himself, published three days later in the Times , which declared that “any information upon which the article … is based was given to you without my authority. It is my invariable practice to discuss scientific matters only in the appropriate forum and I deprecate advance publication of any announcement in regard to such matters in the secular press.” Apparently Podolsky had tipped off the Times to the article, which did not appear in the sacred press until the 15 May issue of Physical Review. It is not clear that Einstein ever forgave him, and I wish I had been old enough to send Podolsky a cross letter myself. Anyone growing up in America in the 1940s knew that the preeminent genius of our age, and perhaps of any other, lived in Princeton, New Jersey, had a predilection for baggy sweaters, and was always badly in need of a haircut—as far ahead of his time in dress and grooming as he was ahead in science during his 1905 annus mirabilis.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 5, 2016•0 citations

On some EPR (Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen) issues

Giuseppe Giuliani

A critical reconsideration of the EPR (Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen) paper shows that the EPR argument can be developed without using the concept of `element of physical reality', thus eliminating any philosophical element in the logical chains of the paper. Deprived of its philosophical ornament, the EPR argument plainly reduces to require what quantum mechanics can not do: to assign definite values to two incompatible physical quantities. Hidden variables theories built up according to Bell - type theorems are formulated on the basis of the assumption that the locality condition implies the statistical independence between two measurements space - like separated. This assumption is valid only with the additional one that statistical dependence between two measurements requires a causal connection between them. This additional assumption rules out the possibility that statistical dependence may due to an intrinsic property of the physical system under study. Therefore, hidden variables theories are built up with a restriction which leads them to be disproved by experiment. Quantum mechanical non - locality, invoked for describing EPR - type experiments, is strictly connected to the hypothesis (NDV hypothesis) according to which the twin photons of entangled pairs do not have a definite polarization before measurements. Both hypotheses are used only for describing EPR experiments and not for making predictions. Therefore, they can be dropped without reducing the predictive power of quantum mechanics concerning entangled photons pairs. Furthermore, both hypotheses can be experimentally tested by a modification of a standard experimental apparatus designed for studying entangled photons pairs.

arXiv:2001.00553•Jan 2, 2020•0 citations

The EPR paper and Bell's theorem

James T. Cushing

When it was first put forward, special relativity struck many people as counterintuitive and possibly inconsistent, as we saw when we considered the twin paradox in Chapter 17. Quantum mechanics had a similar effect, only to a much greater and longer lasting degree, from the time of its inception in the mid 1920s until the present. This reaction to quantum theory was not confined to an initial confusion that often accompanies a new subject, but remained a life-long puzzle for Einstein, to mention only the most prominent opponent of what he took to be the reigning orthodoxy. In this chapter we study a famous attempt by Einstein and two of his colleagues to show that quantum mechanics was, if not logically inconsistent, then at least an incomplete theory. This charge of incompleteness is just that raised by Schrödinger's cat paradox (Section 21.4). THE EPR PARADOX In 1935 Einstein, Boris Podolsky (1896–1966) and Nathan Rosen (1909–1995) (hereafter referred to as EPR) published a paper titled ‘Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?’. They take as their criterion for the completeness of a theory that it contains terms corresponding to every relevant entity found in reality. For example, in the classical description of a system, such as a planet going around the sun, there are symbols representing the position r , the momentum p and so forth for the various parts of the system.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 29, 1998•0 citations
In 1935 Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen asked whether the quantum-mechanical description of physical reality can be considered complete, and they answered no. I credit that paper at full strength: EPR did not dispute a single quantum prediction. They built a two-system state with perfect correlations so that a measurement choice made on one system fixes, with certainty, either the position or the momentum of a distant system it no longer interacts with, and, given their two premises, the inference that follows is valid: simultaneous elements of reality for position and momentum, and with them the incompleteness of the wave-function description. What I evaluate is the pair of premises that inference rests on: the criterion of reality — if, without in any way disturbing a system, we can predict with certainty the value of a physical quantity, then there exists an element of reality corresponding to that quantity — and the separation premise — at the time of measurement the two systems no longer interact, so no real change can take place in the second system in consequence of anything that may be done to the first. Neither premise is derived in the paper; both are used as definitions, and the conclusion is exactly as strong as the pair, no stronger. On declared inputs only, my bench evaluates the conjunction of the two premises, not either premise alone: an exhaustive enumeration of all 16 deterministic local-realist assignments returns every assignment at |S| = 2 exactly — 8 at S = +2 and 8 at S = −2 — so the conjunction forces the bound |S| ≤ 2, while the declared spin-singlet correlation at the standard angles returns S = −2.828427, |S| = 2.828427 = 2√2. The gap is 0.828427 — the quantum return exceeds the bound the premises force by 41.421356 per cent of the bound — and the excess is a band, not a tuned point, running 2.449490 at 15 and 75 degrees and 2.732051 at 30 and 60 degrees across the declared sweep. John Bell is credited at his own address as the later address that made this conjunction testable, in 1964; the experimental record since runs against local realism, stated plainly. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.
Two of my census papers price, thirty years apart, the same logical move: an exact theory resting on an object that is asserted to exist, or a property asserted to be certified, without the object being given or the certification being derived. CC-128 priced Kohn and Sham's 1965 equations: the interacting system mapped onto a fictitious non-interacting one under an assumed representability, and everything the mapping does not compute swept into one object, the exchange–correlation functional E_xc[n] — named, not given, with no explicit form for arbitrary density in 1965 or derived since, and the open face sized by a declared later parametrisation at 0.164462 of the local exchange–correlation energy per electron at r_s = 2, rising to 0.334172 at r_s = 20. CC-126 priced Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen's 1935 argument: a criterion of reality that certifies an element of reality wherever a value can be predicted with certainty without disturbance, riding on a separation premise — two premises, both spent as definitions, whose conjunction an exhaustive enumeration prices exactly, forcing |S| ≤ 2 against the singlet's returned 2.828427, an excess of 0.828427, or 41.421356 per cent of the bound. This paper states the joint claim the two parents make together and prices it with their own exhibits: across the two addresses, four load-bearing postulated objects — one representability, one functional, one criterion, one separation — stand against zero derivations, and in each case the theory built on the object is exact or valid exactly where the object is granted, so that the object's standing, not the machinery downstream of it, is the whole question. My bench reproduces both parents' exhibits digit for digit — the sixteen-assignment enumeration returning 8 assignments at S = +2 and 8 at S = −2, the singlet sweep returning 2.449490 at 15 and 75 degrees, 2.732051 at 30 and 60, and 2.828427 at 45, and the exchange–correlation table returning the open-face fractions 0.115165 at r_s = 1 through 0.334172 at r_s = 20, growing by a factor of 2.031910 across the declared grid — and then counts, jointly: 4 postulated objects, 0 derivations, 2 exact theories, and 1 shared structure, the existence claim spent where a construction was needed. Grade for this joint entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification of either parent paper. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.
The EPR argument has three steps. (i) Measuring the position of one member A of a pair predicts with certainty the position of the other member B, and measuring the momentum predicts B's momentum (perfect correlation). (ii) The measurement at A does not disturb the distant B (locality). (iii) Hence B's position and momentum are simultaneously elements of reality, and the quantum-mechanical description is incomplete. This paper takes the readout rule of the preceding paper "Observation as Simultaneous Emission and Absorption" (Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23857884) as its premise and re-reads the argument. The pair is a closure q_A + q_B = 0 that held once at the source, from which x_B = −x_A and p_B = −p_A follow simultaneously as identities. A single end has no value (the one-sided distribution is uniform), nothing happens at B when A is read, and the correlation depends neither on the order of the readouts nor on the distance between the two. The element of reality is the relation called the closure, not an attribute of one end. Step (ii) is correct, step (i) is a relational identity, and only the attribution in step (iii) is mistaken. That a destructive readout exists, drops the chosen variable to one of two values and severs the relation with the conjugate variable, is placed as a known fact (resonant absorption, photodetection, homodyne detection); deriving its mechanism is a separate task. "Instantaneous selection" is not written: what can be shown is only that no finite-speed influence exists. No new number appears. The claim is that, given the preceding paper, EPR is neither a paradox nor a mystery but a misreading of a relational identity. Earlier work reaching the same conclusion (Peres, Mermin, Smerlak and Rovelli, Griffiths, Jarrett, Spekkens, Wharton and Argaman, Cramer) is placed up front, and what belongs to this paper alone is limited to four points. Japanese original (authoritative) and English translation, with TeX sources, PDFs, two figures (Japanese and English labels), the figure program and the numerical identity checks.
The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics involves two assumptions: one about locality and the other about when it is legitimate to infer the existence of an element-of-reality. Using one simple thought experiment, we argue that quantum predictions and the relativity of simultaneity require that both these assumptions fail, whether or not quantum mechanics is complete. EPR’s (1935) argument for the incompleteness of QM turns upon the following sufficient condition: “If, without in any way disturbing a system, we can predict with certainty (i.e., with probability equal to unity) the value of a physical quantity, then there exists an element of physical reality corresponding to this physical quantity.“ EPR apply this condition in a case where knowledge gained from measuring one quantum system allows one to predict with certainty a value for a physical quantity on another.
On 25 March 1935, the Physical Review received a paper from Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen, with the title “Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?” A few days later, on 30 March 1935, I was born. My life with Einstein was off to a promising start. Some would call it an inauspicious start. Abraham Pais, for example, says in his otherwise admirable biography of Einstein [1] that “the only part of this article that will ultimately survive, I believe, is this last phrase [ No reasonable definition of reality could be expected to permit this ], which so poignantly summarizes Einstein's views on quantum mechanics in his later years.” But today, in this centenary of the Einstein annus mirabilis, as the EPR paper and I both turn 70, it is, in fact, the most cited of all Einstein's papers [2]. The debate over its conceptual implications rages hotter than ever, and for the first time, practical (well, for the moment still gedanken practical) applications of the EPR effect have emerged in cryptography and in other areas of quantum information processing. Being only five weeks old, I was unprepared to pay attention to the article that appeared in the New York Times on 4 May 1935 under an elaborate set of headlines and subheads: And I was completely oblivious to the stern rebuke from Einstein himself, published three days later in the Times , which declared that “any information upon which the article … is based was given to you without my authority. It is my invariable practice to discuss scientific matters only in the appropriate forum and I deprecate advance publication of any announcement in regard to such matters in the secular press.” Apparently Podolsky had tipped off the Times to the article, which did not appear in the sacred press until the 15 May issue of Physical Review. It is not clear that Einstein ever forgave him, and I wish I had been old enough to send Podolsky a cross letter myself. Anyone growing up in America in the 1940s knew that the preeminent genius of our age, and perhaps of any other, lived in Princeton, New Jersey, had a predilection for baggy sweaters, and was always badly in need of a haircut—as far ahead of his time in dress and grooming as he was ahead in science during his 1905 annus mirabilis.
A critical reconsideration of the EPR (Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen) paper shows that the EPR argument can be developed without using the concept of `element of physical reality', thus eliminating any philosophical element in the logical chains of the paper. Deprived of its philosophical ornament, the EPR argument plainly reduces to require what quantum mechanics can not do: to assign definite values to two incompatible physical quantities. Hidden variables theories built up according to Bell - type theorems are formulated on the basis of the assumption that the locality condition implies the statistical independence between two measurements space - like separated. This assumption is valid only with the additional one that statistical dependence between two measurements requires a causal connection between them. This additional assumption rules out the possibility that statistical dependence may due to an intrinsic property of the physical system under study. Therefore, hidden variables theories are built up with a restriction which leads them to be disproved by experiment. Quantum mechanical non - locality, invoked for describing EPR - type experiments, is strictly connected to the hypothesis (NDV hypothesis) according to which the twin photons of entangled pairs do not have a definite polarization before measurements. Both hypotheses are used only for describing EPR experiments and not for making predictions. Therefore, they can be dropped without reducing the predictive power of quantum mechanics concerning entangled photons pairs. Furthermore, both hypotheses can be experimentally tested by a modification of a standard experimental apparatus designed for studying entangled photons pairs.
When it was first put forward, special relativity struck many people as counterintuitive and possibly inconsistent, as we saw when we considered the twin paradox in Chapter 17. Quantum mechanics had a similar effect, only to a much greater and longer lasting degree, from the time of its inception in the mid 1920s until the present. This reaction to quantum theory was not confined to an initial confusion that often accompanies a new subject, but remained a life-long puzzle for Einstein, to mention only the most prominent opponent of what he took to be the reigning orthodoxy. In this chapter we study a famous attempt by Einstein and two of his colleagues to show that quantum mechanics was, if not logically inconsistent, then at least an incomplete theory. This charge of incompleteness is just that raised by Schrödinger's cat paradox (Section 21.4). THE EPR PARADOX In 1935 Einstein, Boris Podolsky (1896–1966) and Nathan Rosen (1909–1995) (hereafter referred to as EPR) published a paper titled ‘Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?’. They take as their criterion for the completeness of a theory that it contains terms corresponding to every relevant entity found in reality. For example, in the classical description of a system, such as a planet going around the sun, there are symbols representing the position r , the momentum p and so forth for the various parts of the system.