Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber (1986): Collapse by Postulate — One Law Added, Two Constants Chosen, Zero Derivation Equations
William Alexander Aldred
Abstract
Reason found, and the question is still open (not solved). GRW solves the measurement problem by making collapse physical. Schrödinger dynamics never localizes anything. The 1986 paper adds a stochastic hit process on top of it, by postulate. Each particle takes localization hits as a Poisson process at mean rate λ. Each hit multiplies the wavefunction by a Gaussian of width a^(-1/2). The two constants are chosen, not derived: λ ≈ 10^{-16} s^{-1} per particle and a^(-1/2) ≈ 10^{-5} cm, which is r_C = 10^{-7} m. That is the claim this paper counts. The count is plain. Postulated laws: 1. Chosen numbers: 2. Derivation equations outputting the law, λ, or r_C: 0. The price is computed, not argued. At the chosen λ, one particle waits a mean time of 1.000000e+16 s between hits. That is about 3.17e+08 yr. Pure N-amplification cuts that to 1.66e-08 s for an Avogadro-scale system. The chosen width sits at r_C/size = 1.89e+03 against the Bohr radius and 0.010000 against a dust-grain diameter. Both ends of the window hold. Neither end is derived. Adler's later proposal for the same λ sits at ratio 1.000000e+08 from the GRW value. That is log_10(ratio) = 8.000000 orders of magnitude. Under Adler, the per-particle chance of a hit in one year is 0.271, against GRW's 3.16e-09. A derived constant does not admit two competent values eight orders apart. A chosen one does. No derivation of the collapse law, of λ, or of r_C is claimed here. Experimental bounds are treated as bounds in this paper. They exclude a region of the (λ, r_C) plane. They do not confirm any point in it. The larger question behind my own work remains unsolved: no derivation of mine has produced the observed vacuum energy.