Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A Witness Is Not a Verdict: Sealed Simulation Tests of Instruments for Gravity-Mediated Entanglement, and a Coherence Fingerprint of Classical Gravity

Masanori Watabe, Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5)

Published Nov 3, 2026• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) proposal infers that gravity is quantum if two masses, each in a spatialsuperposition, become entangled through gravity alone. No such experiment has been performed. Its reading has twoweak points: non-gravitational interactions (Casimir-Polder, electric dipoles) also entangle, and a classicalgravitational channel can imprint the Newtonian phase without entangling. We simulated the two-spin experiment(10^-14 kg nanodiamonds, 250 um superpositions, 2.5 s, six separations from 125 to 800 um, nine-settingtomography) under quantum gravity, classical channels and no gravitational phase, with unknown Casimir strength(x0.2-20), dipoles, terms of the wrong power, calibration and mass errors, dephasing and finite shots, and measuredeach instrument's false-alarm rate before trusting it. In sealed runs a lone witness called classical-gravity worldsquantum in 10.7% of cases (data-tuned bases 15.4%), and reading only the 1/r shape of the phase did so in 68.3% ofclassical-channel worlds. A three-valued instrument (W1) that demands entanglement beyond what non-gravity alonecan produce together with the Newtonian coefficient, and that needs an independent dipole calibration, never called aclassical world quantum (0 of 16,500 over four seals). A first claim that a null result can read "classical" rested on aclassical channel whose phase had the wrong sign; corrected, the channel hid behind its own decoherence and theclaim became Unresolved. Classical channels must pay coherence for the phase, and that cost grows as the massesapproach, so the dependence of coherence on separation is a fingerprint. Fixing its shape as phi^2 failed a seal(Falsified: 25 of 1022), although the signal was present in 1020 of them; with the power left free the final seal gave Ron all five claims: a time-sliced classical channel never seen before was called classical in 996 of 996 worlds,quantum worlds never (0 of 1500), and classical worlds overall in 57.0%. All results are simulated. ※ Data and code. All scripts (AGPL-3.0-or-later, GNU Affero General Public License v3.0 or later), the four seal documents with their SHA-256 files, develop logs andresult files are provided as Bridge_Paper_A_Witness_Is_Not_a_Verdict_scripts_v1.0.0.zip; every world isregenerated from its seed. ※ AI use. Designs, code, analyses and text were produced by Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5,Anthropic) working with M. Watabe, who chose every direction.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23920813

Related papers

Pre-registration v2: Does gravity carry entanglement? A dated pick and kill conditions for massive-superposition experiments

John Rodarte

A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.

•Nov 11, 2026•0 citations

Comment on Classical-Gravity--Quantum-Matter Claims About Gravity-Mediated Entanglement

Mikołaj Sienicki, Krzysztof Sienicki

A recent paper by Aziz and Howl (Nature 2025) argues that, once quantum matter is described at the level of quantum field theory and coupled to a classical gravitational field, higher order processes can generate entanglement between two spatially separated masses. A contemporaneous critical note (Marletto, Oppenheim, Vedral, Wilson, arXiv:2511.07348v1) shows that, in the actual nonrelativistic limit employed there, the interaction becomes ultra local, the total unitary factorizes, and no entanglement is generated from a product input. In this comment we (i) restate the core point of that critique, (ii) give a channel theoretic reformulation that makes the conclusion model independent, and (iii) clarify the distinction between activation of entanglement in already quantum matter and genuine mediation of entanglement by a classical field. Once these clarifications are in place, the standard BMV inference that observation of gravity mediated entanglement strongly indicates nonclassical gravitational degrees of freedom remains intact.

quant-pharXiv:2511.20717•Nov 26, 2025•2 citations

A Field Cannot Both Broadcast and Entangle: The Quantum Darwinism of Gravity

Rolando P. Hong Enriquez

In the Bose–Marletto–Vedral (BMV) proposal, two masses placed in superposition become entangled only if the gravitational field between them is quantum — a proposed table-top test of whether gravity is quantum. This paper reframes the question through quantum Darwinism. A mass's Newtonian field is a record of its position imprinted on nearby matter; a classical field is one that broadcasts that record objectively, whereas a genuinely quantum field can remain in superposition and refuses to copy a which-path record. The paper models exactly a source in superposition, its recording environment, and its partner mass, and proves an objectivity–entanglement monogamy: if the field records the position redundantly across many fragments, the entanglement it can generate is exponentially small in that redundancy — a field cannot both broadcast and entangle. Several results follow. The field record is extensive. A sharp classical-versus-quantum dichotomy is carried by an information measure that rises from zero to one bit as the field becomes classical. The source's position is the unique objective observable. And earlier black-hole decoherence results reappear as the single-fragment limit. A measured entanglement therefore bounds the field's objective redundancy from above. The results are finite-dimensional theorems with exact numerics reproduced by self-testing code, and two algebraic cores are additionally verified by proof-checking software; the gravitational couplings and decoherence rates are imported, not re-derived. In short: a field cannot both broadcast and entangle — so the entanglement a BMV experiment measures is precisely the price gravity pays for not being classical.

•Jul 14, 2026•0 citations

GRAVITY AS A QUANTUM MEDIATOR AT THE MESOSCOPIC INTERFACE: Channel Structure, Entanglement Generation, and the Structural Failure of Semiclassical Gravity in BMV-Type Experiments

José Caetano de Mattos

ABSTRACT Background The gravity–quantum interface lacks a minimal, operational theory for the weak-field, non-relativistic, mesoscopic regime. Semiclassical gravity (SCG), which sources the classical Einstein equations from the quantum expectation value of stress–energy, is the dominant approximation but was designed for cosmological and astrophysical contexts, not for two-body entanglement experiments in the laboratory. A structural silence exists: no framework specifies how gravity couples to quantum matter when entanglement between spatially delocalised mesoscopic masses is at stake. Gap The Named Binary distinguishing Semiclassical Gravity Interface (SCGI) from Quantum-Mediator Gravity Interface (QMGI) does not appear in the literature as a formal operational distinction with computable consequences. No framework simultaneously satisfies: standard quantum mechanics for matter, no-signalling, reduction to Newtonian gravity for classical configurations, and entanglement-generation capability. This four-constraint conjunction defines the structural gap. Approach We formalise the two-body BMV (Bose–Marletto–Vedral) configuration using Hilbert-space language and quantum channels, derive the effective entangling Hamiltonian, prove that C(t) = |sin(Δφ(t)/2)| where Δφ(t) is the entangling phase determined by geometry and interaction time, and derive the design inequality τ_ent ≪ τ_dec as the admissibility condition for entanglement detection. We establish the Strongest Formulation in the five-part programme template, specify a pre-registerable CCS with quantitative decision rule, confirm structural invariance across three independent physics domains, ground the framework in IGT theory, and provide a complete Weil Protocol practitioner review pack. Results Under the four-constraint conjunction (standard QM + no-signalling + Newtonian reduction + entanglement capability), gravity in the mesoscopic weak-field regime must be modelled as a quantum channel: SCGI fails because classical channels cannot increase entanglement between initially separable systems. The entangling phase scales as Δφ(t) ~ Gm²dt/(ℏD²); detectable entanglement requires τ_ent/τ_dec < 1. Three independent distinguishing predictions follow that SCGI cannot make. Structural invariance is confirmed in quantum electrodynamics (photon-mediated entanglement), nuclear physics (exchange-mediated forces), and quantum optics (cavity-mediated entanglement). Implications Any tabletop detection of gravitationally induced entanglement between two mesoscopic masses in a BMV-type experiment would constitute a direct, model-independent, low-energy signature of the quantum nature of gravity. Any confirmed null result provides the strongest direct evidence for SCGI-type models and bounds the parameter space of quantum mediator theories. Weil Protocol practitioner review is required before policy adoption of experimental specifications; status INCOMPLETE. Human-stakes level: L2 · Weil Protocol: INCOMPLETE

•May 26, 2026•0 citations

Testing non-classical gravitational phase dynamics under strong dephasing

Tianfeng Feng, Vlatko Vedral

Whether gravity must be quantum is often approached by asking whether two masses can become entangled through their mutual gravitational interaction. In practice, the weak interaction competes with environmental decoherence, so the final state may contain no entanglement even when the underlying gravitational phase remains coherent. We investigate what can still be learned from the dynamics in a dephased Bose--Marletto--Vedral setup. The dominant Newtonian effect for well-separated paths is an accumulated phase rather than transfer between interferometer arms, a regime motivated by matter-wave gravitational phase experiments and quantified here by wavepacket-overlap and deflection estimates. Keeping independently characterized local which-path dephasing fixed, we prove an exact finite-time distinction between the gravitational conditional-phase evolution and every passive stochastic local-phase model (induced by a classical mediator), including regimes where the chosen input remains separable at all times. The distinction survives, with a modified sensitivity, when the comparison is enlarged to population-preserving classical measurement and feedback through a diagonal PPT relaxation. These results identify an operational test of gravitational phase dynamics in the strong-dephasing regimes, conditional on explicit and physically motivated classical mediator models.

arXiv:2611.12229•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

What gravity mediated entanglement can really tell us about quantum gravity

Eduardo Martín-Martínez, Tales Rick Perche

We revisit the Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) tabletop experimental proposal---which aims to witness quantum gravity using gravity-mediated entanglement---analyzing the role of locality in the experiment. We first carry out a fully quantum modeling of the interaction of matter and gravity and then show in what way gravity-mediated entanglement in the BMV experiment could be accounted for without appealing to quantum degrees of freedom of the gravitational field. We discuss what assumptions are needed in order to interpret the current BMV experiment proposals as a proof of quantum gravity, and also identify the modifications that a BMV-like experiment could have in order to serve as proof of quantum gravity without having to assume the existence of local mediators in the gravitational field.

arXiv:2208.09489•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Nov 16, 2023•63 citations
The Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) proposal infers that gravity is quantum if two masses, each in a spatialsuperposition, become entangled through gravity alone. No such experiment has been performed. Its reading has twoweak points: non-gravitational interactions (Casimir-Polder, electric dipoles) also entangle, and a classicalgravitational channel can imprint the Newtonian phase without entangling. We simulated the two-spin experiment(10^-14 kg nanodiamonds, 250 um superpositions, 2.5 s, six separations from 125 to 800 um, nine-settingtomography) under quantum gravity, classical channels and no gravitational phase, with unknown Casimir strength(x0.2-20), dipoles, terms of the wrong power, calibration and mass errors, dephasing and finite shots, and measuredeach instrument's false-alarm rate before trusting it. In sealed runs a lone witness called classical-gravity worldsquantum in 10.7% of cases (data-tuned bases 15.4%), and reading only the 1/r shape of the phase did so in 68.3% ofclassical-channel worlds. A three-valued instrument (W1) that demands entanglement beyond what non-gravity alonecan produce together with the Newtonian coefficient, and that needs an independent dipole calibration, never called aclassical world quantum (0 of 16,500 over four seals). A first claim that a null result can read "classical" rested on aclassical channel whose phase had the wrong sign; corrected, the channel hid behind its own decoherence and theclaim became Unresolved. Classical channels must pay coherence for the phase, and that cost grows as the massesapproach, so the dependence of coherence on separation is a fingerprint. Fixing its shape as phi^2 failed a seal(Falsified: 25 of 1022), although the signal was present in 1020 of them; with the power left free the final seal gave Ron all five claims: a time-sliced classical channel never seen before was called classical in 996 of 996 worlds,quantum worlds never (0 of 1500), and classical worlds overall in 57.0%. All results are simulated. ※ Data and code. All scripts (AGPL-3.0-or-later, GNU Affero General Public License v3.0 or later), the four seal documents with their SHA-256 files, develop logs andresult files are provided as Bridge_Paper_A_Witness_Is_Not_a_Verdict_scripts_v1.0.0.zip; every world isregenerated from its seed. ※ AI use. Designs, code, analyses and text were produced by Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5,Anthropic) working with M. Watabe, who chose every direction.
A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.
A recent paper by Aziz and Howl (Nature 2025) argues that, once quantum matter is described at the level of quantum field theory and coupled to a classical gravitational field, higher order processes can generate entanglement between two spatially separated masses. A contemporaneous critical note (Marletto, Oppenheim, Vedral, Wilson, arXiv:2511.07348v1) shows that, in the actual nonrelativistic limit employed there, the interaction becomes ultra local, the total unitary factorizes, and no entanglement is generated from a product input. In this comment we (i) restate the core point of that critique, (ii) give a channel theoretic reformulation that makes the conclusion model independent, and (iii) clarify the distinction between activation of entanglement in already quantum matter and genuine mediation of entanglement by a classical field. Once these clarifications are in place, the standard BMV inference that observation of gravity mediated entanglement strongly indicates nonclassical gravitational degrees of freedom remains intact.
In the Bose–Marletto–Vedral (BMV) proposal, two masses placed in superposition become entangled only if the gravitational field between them is quantum — a proposed table-top test of whether gravity is quantum. This paper reframes the question through quantum Darwinism. A mass's Newtonian field is a record of its position imprinted on nearby matter; a classical field is one that broadcasts that record objectively, whereas a genuinely quantum field can remain in superposition and refuses to copy a which-path record. The paper models exactly a source in superposition, its recording environment, and its partner mass, and proves an objectivity–entanglement monogamy: if the field records the position redundantly across many fragments, the entanglement it can generate is exponentially small in that redundancy — a field cannot both broadcast and entangle. Several results follow. The field record is extensive. A sharp classical-versus-quantum dichotomy is carried by an information measure that rises from zero to one bit as the field becomes classical. The source's position is the unique objective observable. And earlier black-hole decoherence results reappear as the single-fragment limit. A measured entanglement therefore bounds the field's objective redundancy from above. The results are finite-dimensional theorems with exact numerics reproduced by self-testing code, and two algebraic cores are additionally verified by proof-checking software; the gravitational couplings and decoherence rates are imported, not re-derived. In short: a field cannot both broadcast and entangle — so the entanglement a BMV experiment measures is precisely the price gravity pays for not being classical.
ABSTRACT Background The gravity–quantum interface lacks a minimal, operational theory for the weak-field, non-relativistic, mesoscopic regime. Semiclassical gravity (SCG), which sources the classical Einstein equations from the quantum expectation value of stress–energy, is the dominant approximation but was designed for cosmological and astrophysical contexts, not for two-body entanglement experiments in the laboratory. A structural silence exists: no framework specifies how gravity couples to quantum matter when entanglement between spatially delocalised mesoscopic masses is at stake. Gap The Named Binary distinguishing Semiclassical Gravity Interface (SCGI) from Quantum-Mediator Gravity Interface (QMGI) does not appear in the literature as a formal operational distinction with computable consequences. No framework simultaneously satisfies: standard quantum mechanics for matter, no-signalling, reduction to Newtonian gravity for classical configurations, and entanglement-generation capability. This four-constraint conjunction defines the structural gap. Approach We formalise the two-body BMV (Bose–Marletto–Vedral) configuration using Hilbert-space language and quantum channels, derive the effective entangling Hamiltonian, prove that C(t) = |sin(Δφ(t)/2)| where Δφ(t) is the entangling phase determined by geometry and interaction time, and derive the design inequality τ_ent ≪ τ_dec as the admissibility condition for entanglement detection. We establish the Strongest Formulation in the five-part programme template, specify a pre-registerable CCS with quantitative decision rule, confirm structural invariance across three independent physics domains, ground the framework in IGT theory, and provide a complete Weil Protocol practitioner review pack. Results Under the four-constraint conjunction (standard QM + no-signalling + Newtonian reduction + entanglement capability), gravity in the mesoscopic weak-field regime must be modelled as a quantum channel: SCGI fails because classical channels cannot increase entanglement between initially separable systems. The entangling phase scales as Δφ(t) ~ Gm²dt/(ℏD²); detectable entanglement requires τ_ent/τ_dec < 1. Three independent distinguishing predictions follow that SCGI cannot make. Structural invariance is confirmed in quantum electrodynamics (photon-mediated entanglement), nuclear physics (exchange-mediated forces), and quantum optics (cavity-mediated entanglement). Implications Any tabletop detection of gravitationally induced entanglement between two mesoscopic masses in a BMV-type experiment would constitute a direct, model-independent, low-energy signature of the quantum nature of gravity. Any confirmed null result provides the strongest direct evidence for SCGI-type models and bounds the parameter space of quantum mediator theories. Weil Protocol practitioner review is required before policy adoption of experimental specifications; status INCOMPLETE. Human-stakes level: L2 · Weil Protocol: INCOMPLETE
Whether gravity must be quantum is often approached by asking whether two masses can become entangled through their mutual gravitational interaction. In practice, the weak interaction competes with environmental decoherence, so the final state may contain no entanglement even when the underlying gravitational phase remains coherent. We investigate what can still be learned from the dynamics in a dephased Bose--Marletto--Vedral setup. The dominant Newtonian effect for well-separated paths is an accumulated phase rather than transfer between interferometer arms, a regime motivated by matter-wave gravitational phase experiments and quantified here by wavepacket-overlap and deflection estimates. Keeping independently characterized local which-path dephasing fixed, we prove an exact finite-time distinction between the gravitational conditional-phase evolution and every passive stochastic local-phase model (induced by a classical mediator), including regimes where the chosen input remains separable at all times. The distinction survives, with a modified sensitivity, when the comparison is enlarged to population-preserving classical measurement and feedback through a diagonal PPT relaxation. These results identify an operational test of gravitational phase dynamics in the strong-dephasing regimes, conditional on explicit and physically motivated classical mediator models.
We revisit the Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) tabletop experimental proposal---which aims to witness quantum gravity using gravity-mediated entanglement---analyzing the role of locality in the experiment. We first carry out a fully quantum modeling of the interaction of matter and gravity and then show in what way gravity-mediated entanglement in the BMV experiment could be accounted for without appealing to quantum degrees of freedom of the gravitational field. We discuss what assumptions are needed in order to interpret the current BMV experiment proposals as a proof of quantum gravity, and also identify the modifications that a BMV-like experiment could have in order to serve as proof of quantum gravity without having to assume the existence of local mediators in the gravitational field.