Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Gravitational-entanglement tests would lie above a composition-dependent collapse threshold

Hebri

Published Nov 2, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A null witness in gravity-mediated entanglement tests need not mean that gravity is classical. We propose a collapse model in which a split body holds its mass in several places only up to a fixed limit. The limit sets a composition-dependent critical mass, $2.5\times10^{-17}$ kg for carbon, and the proposed diamonds are 40 to 400 times heavier. Each would lose its spin contrast, nulling the witness for a reason unrelated to gravity. Contrast kept by one diamond at the proposed mass and splitting would refute the model, and a Stern-Gerlach chip spanning the threshold would see it vanish as a step

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23889989

Related papers

Large Spin Stern-Gerlach Interferometry for Gravitational Entanglement

Lorenzo Braccini, Martine Schut, Alessio Serafini +2 more

Recently, there has been a proposal to test the quantum nature of gravity in the laboratory by witnessing the growth of entanglement between two masses in spatial quantum superpositions. The required superpositions can be created via Stern-Gerlach interferometers, which couple an embedded spin qubit quantum state to the spatial dynamics of each mass. The masses would entangle only if gravity is quantum in nature. Here, we generalise the experiment to an arbitrary spin $j$ or equivalently to an ensemble of uniformly coupled spins. We first exemplify how to create a generalized Stern-Gerlach interferometer, which splits the mass into $2j+1$ trajectories. This shows that a controlled protocol can be formulated to encode the amplitudes of any spin state to a spatial superposition. Secondly, two masses in spatial superpositions of the above form are left to interact via gravity, and the entanglement is computed. Different families of initial spin states are varied to find the optimal spin state that maximizes the entanglement. We conclude that larger spins can offer a modest advantage in enhancing gravity-induced entanglement.

arXiv:2312.05170•Dec 8, 2023•10 citations

Pre-registration v2: Does gravity carry entanglement? A dated pick and kill conditions for massive-superposition experiments

John Rodarte

A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.

•Nov 11, 2026•0 citations

A Witness Is Not a Verdict: Sealed Simulation Tests of Instruments for Gravity-Mediated Entanglement, and a Coherence Fingerprint of Classical Gravity

Masanori Watabe, Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5)

The Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) proposal infers that gravity is quantum if two masses, each in a spatialsuperposition, become entangled through gravity alone. No such experiment has been performed. Its reading has twoweak points: non-gravitational interactions (Casimir-Polder, electric dipoles) also entangle, and a classicalgravitational channel can imprint the Newtonian phase without entangling. We simulated the two-spin experiment(10^-14 kg nanodiamonds, 250 um superpositions, 2.5 s, six separations from 125 to 800 um, nine-settingtomography) under quantum gravity, classical channels and no gravitational phase, with unknown Casimir strength(x0.2-20), dipoles, terms of the wrong power, calibration and mass errors, dephasing and finite shots, and measuredeach instrument's false-alarm rate before trusting it. In sealed runs a lone witness called classical-gravity worldsquantum in 10.7% of cases (data-tuned bases 15.4%), and reading only the 1/r shape of the phase did so in 68.3% ofclassical-channel worlds. A three-valued instrument (W1) that demands entanglement beyond what non-gravity alonecan produce together with the Newtonian coefficient, and that needs an independent dipole calibration, never called aclassical world quantum (0 of 16,500 over four seals). A first claim that a null result can read "classical" rested on aclassical channel whose phase had the wrong sign; corrected, the channel hid behind its own decoherence and theclaim became Unresolved. Classical channels must pay coherence for the phase, and that cost grows as the massesapproach, so the dependence of coherence on separation is a fingerprint. Fixing its shape as phi^2 failed a seal(Falsified: 25 of 1022), although the signal was present in 1020 of them; with the power left free the final seal gave Ron all five claims: a time-sliced classical channel never seen before was called classical in 996 of 996 worlds,quantum worlds never (0 of 1500), and classical worlds overall in 57.0%. All results are simulated. ※ Data and code. All scripts (AGPL-3.0-or-later, GNU Affero General Public License v3.0 or later), the four seal documents with their SHA-256 files, develop logs andresult files are provided as Bridge_Paper_A_Witness_Is_Not_a_Verdict_scripts_v1.0.0.zip; every world isregenerated from its seed. ※ AI use. Designs, code, analyses and text were produced by Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5,Anthropic) working with M. Watabe, who chose every direction.

•Nov 3, 2026•2 citations

A Spin-Based Pathway to Testing the Quantum Nature of Gravity

Sougato Bose, Anupam Mazumdar, Roger Penrose +52 more

A key open problem in physics is the correct way to combine gravity (described by general relativity) with everything else (described by quantum mechanics). This problem suggests that general relativity and possibly also quantum mechanics need fundamental corrections. Most physicists expect that gravity should be quantum in character, but gravity is fundamentally different to the other forces because it alone is described by spacetime geometry. Experiments are needed to test whether gravity, and hence space-time, is quantum or classical. We propose an experiment to test the quantum nature of gravity by checking whether gravity can entangle two micron-sized crystals. A pathway to this is to create macroscopic quantum superpositions of each crystal first using embedded spins and Stern-Gerlach forces. These crystals could be nanodiamonds containing nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centres. The spins can subsequently be measured to witness the gravitationally generated entanglement. This is based on extensive theoretical feasibility studies and experimental progress in quantum technology. The eventual experiment will require a medium-sized consortium with excellent suppression of decoherence including vibrations and gravitational noise. In this white paper, we review the progress and plans towards realizing this. While implementing these plans, we will further explore the most macroscopic superpositions that are possible, which will test theories that predict a limit to this.

arXiv:2509.01586•Sep 1, 2025•29 citations

Spin Entanglement Witness for Quantum Gravity

Sougato Bose, Anupam Mazumdar, Gavin W. Morley +7 more

Understanding gravity in the framework of quantum mechanics is one of the great challenges in modern physics. However, the lack of empirical evidence has lead to a debate on whether gravity is a quantum entity. Despite varied proposed probes for quantum gravity, it is fair to say that there are no feasible ideas yet to test its quantum coherent behavior directly in a laboratory experiment. Here, we introduce an idea for such a test based on the principle that two objects cannot be entangled without a quantum mediator. We show that despite the weakness of gravity, the phase evolution induced by the gravitational interaction of two micron size test masses in adjacent matter-wave interferometers can detectably entangle them even when they are placed far apart enough to keep Casimir-Polder forces at bay. We provide a prescription for witnessing this entanglement, which certifies gravity as a quantum coherent mediator, through simple spin correlation measurements.

arXiv:1707.06050•Physical Review Letters•Dec 13, 2017•914 citations

Gravitationally induced entanglement between two masses: a registered prediction of no witness below an entangling phase of 2 rad, at any constant recording rate

David Swanson

I register the prediction that no experiment will witness gravitationally induced entanglement between two masses, each in two branches, while their entangling phase stays below 2 rad, at any constant rate at which each mass's environment records its position. Under gravity whose source in each description is a function of the system's reduced state, conditioned on every record that exists, two masses that nothing records stay in a product state at every entangling phase. Recorded masses stay unentangled while the phase is below 4 rad with each mass's share counted once, or below 2 rad with each mass taking its full potential. Every published parameter set computed here lies below both, between 0.0150 rad and 0.594 rad. A witness of gravitationally induced entanglement reported at 5 standard deviations in any such experiment excludes the prediction on its own, whatever the recording rate. Quantized gravity entangles the masses only while each is recorded more slowly than a threshold set by the experiment's parameters, 0.0623 /s at Bose et al.'s, so a null result counts against it only where an experiment establishes its recording rate below that threshold. The source in the description occupying branch A is n_r^A = n_A + f(η) (n_B − n_A)/2, where n_A and n_B are the branches' densities and η is the overlap of the mass's two branch records, e^(−Γ t) at recording rate Γ. The product state is derived; the weight f(η) = η is derived from the stated condition that the source depend affinely on the coherence; the phase bound is computed in a two-branch open-system model and rests on the stated two-body form. Nothing is fitted. The statistic is the reported witness with the recording rate the experiment establishes, read against both predictions at its own parameters; the chance of a false exclusion from statistical fluctuation alone is 2.9 × 10⁻⁷ for each experiment.

•Oct 15, 2026•0 citations
A null witness in gravity-mediated entanglement tests need not mean that gravity is classical. We propose a collapse model in which a split body holds its mass in several places only up to a fixed limit. The limit sets a composition-dependent critical mass, 2.5×10−172.5\times10^{-17}2.5×10−17 kg for carbon, and the proposed diamonds are 40 to 400 times heavier. Each would lose its spin contrast, nulling the witness for a reason unrelated to gravity. Contrast kept by one diamond at the proposed mass and splitting would refute the model, and a Stern-Gerlach chip spanning the threshold would see it vanish as a step
Recently, there has been a proposal to test the quantum nature of gravity in the laboratory by witnessing the growth of entanglement between two masses in spatial quantum superpositions. The required superpositions can be created via Stern-Gerlach interferometers, which couple an embedded spin qubit quantum state to the spatial dynamics of each mass. The masses would entangle only if gravity is quantum in nature. Here, we generalise the experiment to an arbitrary spin jjj or equivalently to an ensemble of uniformly coupled spins. We first exemplify how to create a generalized Stern-Gerlach interferometer, which splits the mass into 2j+12j+12j+1 trajectories. This shows that a controlled protocol can be formulated to encode the amplitudes of any spin state to a spatial superposition. Secondly, two masses in spatial superpositions of the above form are left to interact via gravity, and the entanglement is computed. Different families of initial spin states are varied to find the optimal spin state that maximizes the entanglement. We conclude that larger spins can offer a modest advantage in enhancing gravity-induced entanglement.
A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.
The Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) proposal infers that gravity is quantum if two masses, each in a spatialsuperposition, become entangled through gravity alone. No such experiment has been performed. Its reading has twoweak points: non-gravitational interactions (Casimir-Polder, electric dipoles) also entangle, and a classicalgravitational channel can imprint the Newtonian phase without entangling. We simulated the two-spin experiment(10^-14 kg nanodiamonds, 250 um superpositions, 2.5 s, six separations from 125 to 800 um, nine-settingtomography) under quantum gravity, classical channels and no gravitational phase, with unknown Casimir strength(x0.2-20), dipoles, terms of the wrong power, calibration and mass errors, dephasing and finite shots, and measuredeach instrument's false-alarm rate before trusting it. In sealed runs a lone witness called classical-gravity worldsquantum in 10.7% of cases (data-tuned bases 15.4%), and reading only the 1/r shape of the phase did so in 68.3% ofclassical-channel worlds. A three-valued instrument (W1) that demands entanglement beyond what non-gravity alonecan produce together with the Newtonian coefficient, and that needs an independent dipole calibration, never called aclassical world quantum (0 of 16,500 over four seals). A first claim that a null result can read "classical" rested on aclassical channel whose phase had the wrong sign; corrected, the channel hid behind its own decoherence and theclaim became Unresolved. Classical channels must pay coherence for the phase, and that cost grows as the massesapproach, so the dependence of coherence on separation is a fingerprint. Fixing its shape as phi^2 failed a seal(Falsified: 25 of 1022), although the signal was present in 1020 of them; with the power left free the final seal gave Ron all five claims: a time-sliced classical channel never seen before was called classical in 996 of 996 worlds,quantum worlds never (0 of 1500), and classical worlds overall in 57.0%. All results are simulated. ※ Data and code. All scripts (AGPL-3.0-or-later, GNU Affero General Public License v3.0 or later), the four seal documents with their SHA-256 files, develop logs andresult files are provided as Bridge_Paper_A_Witness_Is_Not_a_Verdict_scripts_v1.0.0.zip; every world isregenerated from its seed. ※ AI use. Designs, code, analyses and text were produced by Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5,Anthropic) working with M. Watabe, who chose every direction.
A key open problem in physics is the correct way to combine gravity (described by general relativity) with everything else (described by quantum mechanics). This problem suggests that general relativity and possibly also quantum mechanics need fundamental corrections. Most physicists expect that gravity should be quantum in character, but gravity is fundamentally different to the other forces because it alone is described by spacetime geometry. Experiments are needed to test whether gravity, and hence space-time, is quantum or classical. We propose an experiment to test the quantum nature of gravity by checking whether gravity can entangle two micron-sized crystals. A pathway to this is to create macroscopic quantum superpositions of each crystal first using embedded spins and Stern-Gerlach forces. These crystals could be nanodiamonds containing nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centres. The spins can subsequently be measured to witness the gravitationally generated entanglement. This is based on extensive theoretical feasibility studies and experimental progress in quantum technology. The eventual experiment will require a medium-sized consortium with excellent suppression of decoherence including vibrations and gravitational noise. In this white paper, we review the progress and plans towards realizing this. While implementing these plans, we will further explore the most macroscopic superpositions that are possible, which will test theories that predict a limit to this.
Understanding gravity in the framework of quantum mechanics is one of the great challenges in modern physics. However, the lack of empirical evidence has lead to a debate on whether gravity is a quantum entity. Despite varied proposed probes for quantum gravity, it is fair to say that there are no feasible ideas yet to test its quantum coherent behavior directly in a laboratory experiment. Here, we introduce an idea for such a test based on the principle that two objects cannot be entangled without a quantum mediator. We show that despite the weakness of gravity, the phase evolution induced by the gravitational interaction of two micron size test masses in adjacent matter-wave interferometers can detectably entangle them even when they are placed far apart enough to keep Casimir-Polder forces at bay. We provide a prescription for witnessing this entanglement, which certifies gravity as a quantum coherent mediator, through simple spin correlation measurements.
I register the prediction that no experiment will witness gravitationally induced entanglement between two masses, each in two branches, while their entangling phase stays below 2 rad, at any constant rate at which each mass's environment records its position. Under gravity whose source in each description is a function of the system's reduced state, conditioned on every record that exists, two masses that nothing records stay in a product state at every entangling phase. Recorded masses stay unentangled while the phase is below 4 rad with each mass's share counted once, or below 2 rad with each mass taking its full potential. Every published parameter set computed here lies below both, between 0.0150 rad and 0.594 rad. A witness of gravitationally induced entanglement reported at 5 standard deviations in any such experiment excludes the prediction on its own, whatever the recording rate. Quantized gravity entangles the masses only while each is recorded more slowly than a threshold set by the experiment's parameters, 0.0623 /s at Bose et al.'s, so a null result counts against it only where an experiment establishes its recording rate below that threshold. The source in the description occupying branch A is n_r^A = n_A + f(η) (n_B − n_A)/2, where n_A and n_B are the branches' densities and η is the overlap of the mass's two branch records, e^(−Γ t) at recording rate Γ. The product state is derived; the weight f(η) = η is derived from the stated condition that the source depend affinely on the coherence; the phase bound is computed in a two-branch open-system model and rests on the stated two-body form. Nothing is fitted. The statistic is the reported witness with the recording rate the experiment establishes, read against both predictions at its own parameters; the chance of a false exclusion from statistical fluctuation alone is 2.9 × 10⁻⁷ for each experiment.