Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Embezzling entanglement from a de Sitter observer: sharp entropy-deficit bounds on finite von Neumann algebras

Dylan Z. Liu Liu

Published Sep 28, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The type III₁ algebras of quantum field theory are universal embezzlers of entanglement, while semifinite algebras admit no embezzling state. The algebra of a de Sitter static patch with an observer is of type II₁, so gravity excludes exact embezzlement there; we determine how small the error can be. For a state ω on a finite factor and a target pure state ψ with entanglement entropy S(ψ), the smallest one-sided embezzlement error obeys δ ≥ S(ψ)/[D+ln 2D+O(1)], where D is the relative entropy of ω to the tracial state. If the density of ω is bounded by e^(Λ), then δ ≥ 2S(ψ)/[Λ+ln Λ+O(1)]. Both bounds are attained to this order, the first by an observer with uniformly distributed energy and the second by the van Dam–Hayden states. In the observer algebra of Chandrasekaran, Longo, Penington and Witten, D is the deficit of generalized entropy below that of empty de Sitter space. An observer whose energy distribution is not sharper than the de Sitter temperature T_dS therefore needs mean energy ⟨E⟩ ≳ T_dS S(ψ)/δ. If the generalized entropy is nonnegative, every state has δ ≥ S(ψ)/S_dS up to logarithmic corrections, an error of first order in Newton's constant.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23440166

Related papers

The Information Budget of the Gravitational Observer

Ram Kirpitch

In the Type II algebras of semiclassical gravity, an observer's clock with energy bounded in a band regularizes the observables of a static patch, and entropies of the resulting algebras reproduce generalized entropy. What has not been computed in that program is the mutual information budget of the observer: how many bits of clock-field correlation the observer's time-bandwidth resources permit. We prove the regularized answer: for any solution of the constraint (H_fields + H_clock)|Ψ⟩ = 0 with clock spectrum confined to bandwidth W and ticks resolved over duration T, the clock-field mutual information obeys I ≤ 2 log₂(1 + ⌊WT/2π⌋) with equality if and only if the clock is the perfect lattice clock the state that, in the de Sitter algebra of Chandrasekaran-Longo-Penington-Witten, is the maximum-entropy state describing the empty static patch. Rigidity holds: any clock with d orthogonal equally spaced ticks carries at least 2 log₂ d bits, so perfect resolution and budget saturation are the same property. Four components of the statement are measured on IBM quantum hardware: an observer ladder (the same global state read by observers of increasing resolution yields 0 → 1.7 → 3.4 → 5.2 bits, and exactly 0 for a misaligned observer); a continuous observer-frame sweep following I = 1 - h((1 + V cos θ)/2) with R² = 0.998 the ledger invariance full restoration of the correlation under the co-rotation U_A ⊗ U_B at every angle, flat to within shot noise; and the rigidity relation itself tick overlap ε and information I measured by independent circuits at seven detunings, with the forbidden region I < 2 - 2 log₂(1 + ε) empty at every point. The lift of the regularized theorem to the Type II crossed product, where empty de Sitter is conjectured to realize the perfect clock exactly, is stated as a sharp open conjecture. Statements are labelled [P] proved, [N] measured, [C] conjecture.

•Jul 17, 2026•0 citations

Multipartite Embezzlement of Entanglement

Lauritz van Luijk, Alexander Stottmeister, Henrik Wilming

Embezzlement of entanglement refers to the task of extracting entanglement from an entanglement resource via local operations and without communication while perturbing the resource arbitrarily little. Recently, the existence of embezzling states of bipartite systems of type III von Neumann algebras was shown. However, both the multipartite case and the precise relation between embezzling states and the notion of embezzling families, as originally defined by van Dam and Hayden, was left open. Here, we show that finite-dimensional approximations of multipartite embezzling states form multipartite embezzling families. In contrast, not every embezzling family converges to an embezzling state. We identify an additional consistency condition that ensures that an embezzling family converges to an embezzling state. This criterion distinguishes the embezzling family of van Dam and Hayden from the one by Leung, Toner, and Watrous. The latter generalizes to the multipartite setting. By taking a limit, we obtain a multipartite system of commuting type III 1 factors on which every state is an embezzling state. We discuss our results in the context of quantum field theory and quantum many-body physics. As open problems, we ask whether vacua of relativistic quantum fields in more than two spacetime dimensions are multipartite embezzling states and whether multipartite embezzlement allows for an operator-algebraic characterization.

arXiv:2409.07646•Quantum•Jul 30, 2025•13 citations

Sharp embezzlement laws for quantum chains and finite Bell tests

Seth Douglas, Nidhal Mghirbi

For the finite open critical XX and Ising chains, we prove a sharp entanglement-embezzlement law from their exact discrete Schmidt spectra, including all degeneracies. For a maximally entangled target of fixed dimension d, the optimal squared local-unitary error is E_d = (ln d)^2/(4S) + O_d(S^-2), where S is the half-chain entanglement entropy. A counting criterion gives a Gaussian crossover for growing d and the same sharp law for the XXZ corner-transfer-matrix spectrum as Δ decreases to 1. We compare the optimal loss in a fixed Bell game with 243 question pairs to the Bell-pair embezzlement error with explicit constants, and prove the loss floor (3−2√2)/243 for maximally entangled states of every dimension. With a shared nine-dimensional maximally entangled register, the open XX ground state at N = 2^19 beats this floor in the original game. At N = 2^84 the chain alone suffices. A tagged test gives an exact tilted CHSH separation for the four-spin XX ground state, with classical play in the original game branch. For the infinite critical XX ground state, the half-chain factors are type III_1 and the game value is one without attainment.

•Nov 11, 2026•0 citations

Study of Von Neumann Algebras of Schwarzschild Black Holes in AdS

Ioannis Sakellariou

The definition of entanglement entropy in quantum systems relies on the factorization of the total Hilbert space into subsystems, which allows the construction of reduced density matrices through the partial trace operation. However, there exist important physical systems for which such a factorization is not available. In these cases, reduced density matrices and entanglement entropy are not well defined in the conventional sense. In this thesis, we develop an operator-algebraic framework for describing entanglement in such systems using the theory of von Neumann algebras. As a primary example, we consider eternal Schwarzschild black holes in Anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime. Starting from the dual boundary theory, we show how a suitable notion of trace can be defined, leading to a well-defined von Neumann entropy. We then reproduce the same entropy from the bulk gravitational description and demonstrate the agreement between the two calculations. Finally, we show that this quantity can be naturally interpreted as the generalized entropy.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Cosmological Entanglement Entropy from the von Neumann Algebra of Double-Scaled SYK & Its Connection with Krylov Complexity

Sergio E. Aguilar-Gutierrez

We investigate entanglement entropy between the pair of type II$_1$ algebras of the double-scaled SYK (DSSYK) model given a chord state, its holographic interpretation as generalized horizon entropy; particularly in the (anti-)de Sitter ((A)dS) space limits of the bulk dual; and its connection with Krylov complexity. The density matrices in this formalism are operators in the algebras, which are specified by the choice of global state; and there exists a trace to evaluate their von Neumann entropy since the algebras are commutants of each other, which leads to a notion of algebraic entanglement entropy. We match it in triple-scaling limits to an area computed through a Ryu-Takayanagi formula in (A)dS$_2$ space with entangling surfaces at the asymptotic timelike or spacelike boundaries respectively; providing a first-principles example of holographic entanglement entropy for (A)dS$_2$ space. This result reproduces the Bekenstein-Hawking and Gibbons-Hawking entropy formulas for specific entangling regions points, while it decreases for others. This construction does not display some of the puzzling features in dS holography. The entanglement entropy remains real-valued since the theory is unitary, and it depends on the Krylov spread complexity of the Hartle-Hawking state. At last, we discuss higher dimensional extensions.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2511.03779•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 7, 2025•6 citations

Comments on the entanglement spectrum of de Sitter space

Tom Banks, Patrick Draper

Abstract We argue that the Schwarzschild-de Sitter black hole entropy formula does not imply that the entanglement spectrum of the vacuum density matrix of de Sitter space is flat. Specifically, we show that the expectation value of a random projection operator of dimension d ≫ 1, on a Hilbert space of dimension D ≫ d and in a density matrix ρ = e–K with strictly positive spectrum, is $$ \frac{d}{D}\left(1+o\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{d}}\right)\right) $$ d D 1 + o 1 d , independent of the spectrum of the density matrix. In addition, for a suitable class of spectra the asymptotic estimates Tr (ρK) ~ ln D – o(1) and Tr [ρ(K – 〈K〉)2] = a〈K〉 are compatible for any order one constant a. We discuss a simple family of matrix models and projections that can replicate such modular Hamiltonians and the SdS entropy formula.

arXiv:2209.08991•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jan 24, 2023•10 citations
The type III₁ algebras of quantum field theory are universal embezzlers of entanglement, while semifinite algebras admit no embezzling state. The algebra of a de Sitter static patch with an observer is of type II₁, so gravity excludes exact embezzlement there; we determine how small the error can be. For a state ω on a finite factor and a target pure state ψ with entanglement entropy S(ψ), the smallest one-sided embezzlement error obeys δ ≥ S(ψ)/[D+ln 2D+O(1)], where D is the relative entropy of ω to the tracial state. If the density of ω is bounded by e^(Λ), then δ ≥ 2S(ψ)/[Λ+ln Λ+O(1)]. Both bounds are attained to this order, the first by an observer with uniformly distributed energy and the second by the van Dam–Hayden states. In the observer algebra of Chandrasekaran, Longo, Penington and Witten, D is the deficit of generalized entropy below that of empty de Sitter space. An observer whose energy distribution is not sharper than the de Sitter temperature T_dS therefore needs mean energy ⟨E⟩ ≳ T_dS S(ψ)/δ. If the generalized entropy is nonnegative, every state has δ ≥ S(ψ)/S_dS up to logarithmic corrections, an error of first order in Newton's constant.
In the Type II algebras of semiclassical gravity, an observer's clock with energy bounded in a band regularizes the observables of a static patch, and entropies of the resulting algebras reproduce generalized entropy. What has not been computed in that program is the mutual information budget of the observer: how many bits of clock-field correlation the observer's time-bandwidth resources permit. We prove the regularized answer: for any solution of the constraint (H_fields + H_clock)|Ψ⟩ = 0 with clock spectrum confined to bandwidth W and ticks resolved over duration T, the clock-field mutual information obeys I ≤ 2 log₂(1 + ⌊WT/2π⌋) with equality if and only if the clock is the perfect lattice clock the state that, in the de Sitter algebra of Chandrasekaran-Longo-Penington-Witten, is the maximum-entropy state describing the empty static patch. Rigidity holds: any clock with d orthogonal equally spaced ticks carries at least 2 log₂ d bits, so perfect resolution and budget saturation are the same property. Four components of the statement are measured on IBM quantum hardware: an observer ladder (the same global state read by observers of increasing resolution yields 0 → 1.7 → 3.4 → 5.2 bits, and exactly 0 for a misaligned observer); a continuous observer-frame sweep following I = 1 - h((1 + V cos θ)/2) with R² = 0.998 the ledger invariance full restoration of the correlation under the co-rotation U_A ⊗ U_B at every angle, flat to within shot noise; and the rigidity relation itself tick overlap ε and information I measured by independent circuits at seven detunings, with the forbidden region I < 2 - 2 log₂(1 + ε) empty at every point. The lift of the regularized theorem to the Type II crossed product, where empty de Sitter is conjectured to realize the perfect clock exactly, is stated as a sharp open conjecture. Statements are labelled [P] proved, [N] measured, [C] conjecture.
Embezzlement of entanglement refers to the task of extracting entanglement from an entanglement resource via local operations and without communication while perturbing the resource arbitrarily little. Recently, the existence of embezzling states of bipartite systems of type III von Neumann algebras was shown. However, both the multipartite case and the precise relation between embezzling states and the notion of embezzling families, as originally defined by van Dam and Hayden, was left open. Here, we show that finite-dimensional approximations of multipartite embezzling states form multipartite embezzling families. In contrast, not every embezzling family converges to an embezzling state. We identify an additional consistency condition that ensures that an embezzling family converges to an embezzling state. This criterion distinguishes the embezzling family of van Dam and Hayden from the one by Leung, Toner, and Watrous. The latter generalizes to the multipartite setting. By taking a limit, we obtain a multipartite system of commuting type III 1 factors on which every state is an embezzling state. We discuss our results in the context of quantum field theory and quantum many-body physics. As open problems, we ask whether vacua of relativistic quantum fields in more than two spacetime dimensions are multipartite embezzling states and whether multipartite embezzlement allows for an operator-algebraic characterization.
For the finite open critical XX and Ising chains, we prove a sharp entanglement-embezzlement law from their exact discrete Schmidt spectra, including all degeneracies. For a maximally entangled target of fixed dimension d, the optimal squared local-unitary error is E_d = (ln d)^2/(4S) + O_d(S^-2), where S is the half-chain entanglement entropy. A counting criterion gives a Gaussian crossover for growing d and the same sharp law for the XXZ corner-transfer-matrix spectrum as Δ decreases to 1. We compare the optimal loss in a fixed Bell game with 243 question pairs to the Bell-pair embezzlement error with explicit constants, and prove the loss floor (3−2√2)/243 for maximally entangled states of every dimension. With a shared nine-dimensional maximally entangled register, the open XX ground state at N = 2^19 beats this floor in the original game. At N = 2^84 the chain alone suffices. A tagged test gives an exact tilted CHSH separation for the four-spin XX ground state, with classical play in the original game branch. For the infinite critical XX ground state, the half-chain factors are type III_1 and the game value is one without attainment.
The definition of entanglement entropy in quantum systems relies on the factorization of the total Hilbert space into subsystems, which allows the construction of reduced density matrices through the partial trace operation. However, there exist important physical systems for which such a factorization is not available. In these cases, reduced density matrices and entanglement entropy are not well defined in the conventional sense. In this thesis, we develop an operator-algebraic framework for describing entanglement in such systems using the theory of von Neumann algebras. As a primary example, we consider eternal Schwarzschild black holes in Anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime. Starting from the dual boundary theory, we show how a suitable notion of trace can be defined, leading to a well-defined von Neumann entropy. We then reproduce the same entropy from the bulk gravitational description and demonstrate the agreement between the two calculations. Finally, we show that this quantity can be naturally interpreted as the generalized entropy.
We investigate entanglement entropy between the pair of type II1_11​ algebras of the double-scaled SYK (DSSYK) model given a chord state, its holographic interpretation as generalized horizon entropy; particularly in the (anti-)de Sitter ((A)dS) space limits of the bulk dual; and its connection with Krylov complexity. The density matrices in this formalism are operators in the algebras, which are specified by the choice of global state; and there exists a trace to evaluate their von Neumann entropy since the algebras are commutants of each other, which leads to a notion of algebraic entanglement entropy. We match it in triple-scaling limits to an area computed through a Ryu-Takayanagi formula in (A)dS2_22​ space with entangling surfaces at the asymptotic timelike or spacelike boundaries respectively; providing a first-principles example of holographic entanglement entropy for (A)dS2_22​ space. This result reproduces the Bekenstein-Hawking and Gibbons-Hawking entropy formulas for specific entangling regions points, while it decreases for others. This construction does not display some of the puzzling features in dS holography. The entanglement entropy remains real-valued since the theory is unitary, and it depends on the Krylov spread complexity of the Hartle-Hawking state. At last, we discuss higher dimensional extensions.
Abstract We argue that the Schwarzschild-de Sitter black hole entropy formula does not imply that the entanglement spectrum of the vacuum density matrix of de Sitter space is flat. Specifically, we show that the expectation value of a random projection operator of dimension d ≫ 1, on a Hilbert space of dimension D ≫ d and in a density matrix ρ = e–K with strictly positive spectrum, is dD(1+o(1d)) \frac{d}{D}\left(1+o\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{d}}\right)\right) Dd​(1+o(d​1​)) d D 1 + o 1 d , independent of the spectrum of the density matrix. In addition, for a suitable class of spectra the asymptotic estimates Tr (ρK) ~ ln D – o(1) and Tr [ρ(K – 〈K〉)2] = a〈K〉 are compatible for any order one constant a. We discuss a simple family of matrix models and projections that can replicate such modular Hamiltonians and the SdS entropy formula.