Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Exploring Testable Quantumness of Massive Objects: Motivations, State of Play, and the Proposed Schrödinger’s Pendulum Experiment

Dipankar Home, Sougata Bhattacharyya

Published Jul 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The motivations underlying investigation of the quantum nature of massive objects stem from some of the outstanding quantum foundational issues, which include the nature of the quantum-classical boundary, and the question of using table-top experiments to test the quantumness of gravity. It is crucial to emprically verify the validity of the quantum superposition principle at the macroscopic level to probe such foundational questions. The present article begins with a brief overview of these motivations, and then proceeds to discuss the usefulness of the notion of maocrorealism for probing the fundamental quantumness of macroscopic objects, and testing its incompatibility with quantum mechanics. The article then explains the two key ingredients in this enterprise, the Leggett-Garg Inequality (LGI) and the No Disturbance Condition (NDC), followed by a snapshot of the experimental tests done so far to test the quantum mechanically predicted violations of these conditions. However, the state-of-the-art demonstrations of quantum features have reached only up to objects of masses of about 10 4 - 10 5 amu. Hence, breakthrough ideas, which can be implemented experimentally in the near future, are needed to scale up the tests of macroscopic quantumness to ever more massive objects. It is precisely this challenge which has recently been addressed by D. Das, D. Home, H. Ulbricht, S. Bose [1] through the formulation of a novel procedure for demonstrating the quantum mechanically predicted violations of these LGI/NDC conditions for an oscillating object having any large mass. We will review the salient features of this important proposed scheme which has been called the “Schrödinger Pendulum Experiment” [2] and will assess the testability of this scheme.

DOI
10.1142/9789819827572_0015

Related papers

Nonclassicality of the Harmonic-Oscillator Coherent State Persisting up to the Macroscopic Domain

Sougato Bose, Dipankar Home, Shiladitya Mal

Can the most "classical-like" of all quantum states, namely the Schrödinger coherent state of a harmonic oscillator, exhibit nonclassical behavior? We find that for an oscillating object initially in a coherent state, merely by observing at various instants which spatial region the object is in, the Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) can be violated through a genuine negative result measurement, thereby repudiating the everyday notion of macrorealism. This violation thus reveals an unnoticed nonclassicality of the very state which epitomizes classicality within the quantum description. It is found that for any given mass and oscillator frequency, a significant quantum violation of LGI can be obtained by suitably choosing the initial peak momentum of the coherent state wave packet. It thus opens up potentially the simplest way (without coupling with any ancillary quantum system or using nonlinearity) for testing whether various recently engineered and sought after macroscopic oscillators, such as feedback cooled thermal trapped nanocrystals of ∼10^{6}-10^{9} amu mass, are indeed bona fide nonclassical objects.

arXiv:1509.00196•Physical Review Letters•May 25, 2018•40 citations

Investigating the foundations of quantum physics with optomechanical setups

Marta Maria Marchese

The extraordinary success of quantum mechanics and its formalism has been established thanks to countless experiments with microscopic systems. Nevertheless, it is still not clear whether and when the quantum world ends, allowing for the emergence of classical phenomena. The extension of quantum properties to macroscopic system gives rise to paradoxes, as the well-known Schrödinger’s cat example. Among the alternatives to quantum mechanics, collapse models propose an objective modification of standard quantum theory to restore macrorealism at large scale. They predict a loss of coherence when scaling towards macroscopic systems, due to a spontaneous collapse mechanism included into the dynamics through non-linear stochastic modifications of the Schrödinger equation. Assessing and characterizing these models is a noteworthy endeavour in the exploration of the quantum-to-classical transition. The overarching goal of this Thesis is to address some of these fundamental issues, by exploring the concept of macrorealism and probing collapse models, making use of optomechanical setups. To answer the question whether a system has a quantum or classical dynamics, we will propose a theoretical test of Leggett-Garg inequalities, as tool to probe the macrorealism of an optomechanical system. We will investigate collapse models through the study of the dynamics of an optomechanical cavity, looking for signatures in the noise spectrum. Further, we will use the hypothesis testing framework and quantum metrology tools to distinguish dynamical channels encoding the presence or the lack of the collapse. Our findings show a violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities, suggesting that the demarcation line of the quantum domain can be pushed further to include larger systems. Our approaches for testing collapse models provide novel methodologies to better discriminate these effects and the results represent another step forward in the attempt of gaining a better understanding of the foundations of physics.

•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum violation of classical physics in macroscopic systems

Lucas Clemente

While quantum theory has been tested to an incredible degree on microscopic scales, quantum effects are seldom observed in our everyday macroscopic world. The curious results of applying quantum mechanics to macroscopic objects are perhaps best illustrated by Erwin Schrödinger's famous thought experiment, where a cat can be put into a superposition state of being both dead and alive. Obviously, these quantum predictions are in stark contradiction to our common experience. Even with plenty of theoretical explanations put forward to explain this discrepancy, a large number of questions about the frontier between the quantum and the classical world remain unanswered. To distinguish between classical and quantum behavior, two fundamental concepts inherent to classical physics have been established over the years: The world view of local realism limits the power of classical experiments to establish correlations over space, while the world view of macroscopic realism (or macrorealism) restricts temporal correlations. Necessary conditions for both world views have been formulated in the form of Bell and Leggett-Garg inequalities, and Bell inequalities have been shown to be violated by quantum mechanics through increasingly conclusive experiments. Furthermore, many challenging steps towards convincing violations of macrorealism have been taken in a number of recent experiments. In the first part of this thesis, conditions for macrorealism are analyzed in detail. Two necessary conditions for macrorealism, the original Leggett-Garg inequality and the recently proposed no-signaling in time condition, are presented. It is then shown that a combination of no-signaling in time conditions is not only necessary but also sufficient for the existence of a macrorealistic description. Finally, an operational formulation of no-signaling in time, in terms of positive-operator valued measurements and Hamiltonians, is derived. In the next part, we argue that these results lead to a suitable definition of classical behavior. In particular, we provide a formalism to judge the classicality of measurements and time evolutions. We then proceed to apply it to a number of exemplary measurement operators and Hamiltonians. Finally, we argue for the importance of spontaneously realized Hamiltonians in our intuition of classical behavior. Next, differences between local realism and macrorealism are analyzed. For this purpose, the probability polytopes for spatially and temporally separated experiments are compared, and a fundamental difference in the power of quantum mechanics to build both types of correlations is discovered. This result shows that Fine's theorem, which states that a set of Bell inequalities is necessary and sufficient for local realism, is not transferable to macrorealism. Thus, (Leggett-Garg) inequalities are in principle not well-suited for tests of macrorealism, as they can never form a necessary and sufficient condition, and unnecessarily restrict the violating parameter space. No-signaling in time is both better suited and more strongly motivated from the underlying physical theory. In the final part of this thesis, a concrete experimental setup for implementing quantum experiments with macroscopic objects is proposed. It consists of a superconducting micro-sphere in the Meißner state, which is levitated by magnetic fields. Through its expelled magnetic field, the sphere's center-of-mass motion couples to a superconducting quantum circuit. Properly tuned, ground state cooling can be realized, since the sphere's motion is extremely well isolated from the surrounding environment. This setup therefore is a promising candidate for the observation of quantum effects in macroscopic systems.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Testing quantum physics in space using high-mass matter-wave interferometry

Rainer Kaltenbaek

Quantum superposition is central to quantum theory but challenges our concepts of reality and spacetime when applied to macroscopic objects like Schrödinger's cat. For that reason, it has been a long-standing question whether quantum physics remains valid unmodified even for truly macroscopic objects. By now, the predictions of quantum theory have been confirmed via matter-wave interferometry for massive objects up to $10^4\,$ atomic mass units (amu). The rapid development of new technologies promises to soon allow tests of quantum theory for significantly higher test masses by using novel techniques of quantum optomechanics and high-mass matter-wave interferometry. Such experiments may yield novel insights into the foundations of quantum theory, pose stringent limits on alternative theoretical models or even uncover deviations from quantum physics. However, performing experiments of this type on Earth may soon face principal limitations due to requirements of long times of flight, ultra-low vibrations, and extremely high vacuum. Here, we present a short overview of recent developments towards the implementation of the proposed space-mission MAQRO, which promises to overcome those limitations and to perform matter-wave interferometry in a parameter regime orders of magnitude beyond state-of-the-art.

arXiv:1508.07796•Aug 31, 2015•4 citations

Mass-Independent Scheme to Test the Quantumness of a Massive Object

Debarshi Das, Dipankar Home, Hendrik Ulbricht +1 more

The search for empirical schemes to evidence the nonclassicality of large masses is a central quest of current research. However, practical schemes to witness the irreducible quantumness of an arbitrarily large mass are still lacking. To this end, we incorporate crucial modifications to the standard tools for probing the quantum violation of the pivotal classical notion of macrorealism (MR): while usual tests use the same measurement arrangement at successive times, here we use two different measurement arrangements. This yields a striking result: a mass-independent violation of MR is possible for harmonic oscillator systems. In fact, our adaptation enables probing quantum violations for literally any mass, momentum, and frequency. Moreover, coarse-grained position measurements at an accuracy much worse than the standard quantum limit, as well as knowing the relevant parameters only to this precision, without requiring them to be tuned, suffice for our proposal. These should drastically simplify the experimental effort in testing the nonclassicality of massive objects ranging from atomic ions to macroscopic mirrors in LIGO.

arXiv:2211.10318•Physical Review Letters•Jan 16, 2024•12 citations

Experimental undecidability of macroscopic quantumness

Paweł Kurzyński, Akihito Soeda, Ravishankar Ramanathan +3 more

Quantum mechanics marks a radical departure from the classical understanding of Nature, fostering an inherent randomness which forbids a deterministic description; yet the most fundamental departure arises from something different. As shown by Bell [1] and Kochen-Specker [2], quantum mechanics portrays a picture of the world in which reality loses its objectivity and is in fact created by observation. Quantum mechanics predicts phenomena which cannot be explained by any theory with objective realism, although our everyday experience supports the hypothesis that macroscopic objects, despite being made of quantum particles, exist independently of the act of observation; in this paper we identify this behavior as classical. Here we show that this seemingly obvious classical behavior of the macroscopic world cannot be experimentally tested and belongs to the realm of ontology similar to the dispute on the interpretations of quantum mechanics [3,4]. For small systems such as a single photon [5] or a pair [6], it has been experimentally proven that a classical description cannot be sustained. Recently, there have also been experiments that claim to have demonstrated quantum behavior of relatively large objects such as interference of fullerenes [7], the violation of Leggett-Garg inequality in Josephson junction [8], and interference between two condensed clouds of atoms [9], which suggest that there is no limit to the size of the system on which the quantum-versus-classical question can be tested. These behaviors, however, are not sufficient to refute classical description in the sense of objective reality. Our findings show that once we reach the regime where an Avogadro number of particles is present, the quantum-versus-classical question cannot be answered experimentally.

arXiv:1111.2696•Nov 11, 2011•2 citations
The motivations underlying investigation of the quantum nature of massive objects stem from some of the outstanding quantum foundational issues, which include the nature of the quantum-classical boundary, and the question of using table-top experiments to test the quantumness of gravity. It is crucial to emprically verify the validity of the quantum superposition principle at the macroscopic level to probe such foundational questions. The present article begins with a brief overview of these motivations, and then proceeds to discuss the usefulness of the notion of maocrorealism for probing the fundamental quantumness of macroscopic objects, and testing its incompatibility with quantum mechanics. The article then explains the two key ingredients in this enterprise, the Leggett-Garg Inequality (LGI) and the No Disturbance Condition (NDC), followed by a snapshot of the experimental tests done so far to test the quantum mechanically predicted violations of these conditions. However, the state-of-the-art demonstrations of quantum features have reached only up to objects of masses of about 10 4 - 10 5 amu. Hence, breakthrough ideas, which can be implemented experimentally in the near future, are needed to scale up the tests of macroscopic quantumness to ever more massive objects. It is precisely this challenge which has recently been addressed by D. Das, D. Home, H. Ulbricht, S. Bose [1] through the formulation of a novel procedure for demonstrating the quantum mechanically predicted violations of these LGI/NDC conditions for an oscillating object having any large mass. We will review the salient features of this important proposed scheme which has been called the “Schrödinger Pendulum Experiment” [2] and will assess the testability of this scheme.
Can the most "classical-like" of all quantum states, namely the Schrödinger coherent state of a harmonic oscillator, exhibit nonclassical behavior? We find that for an oscillating object initially in a coherent state, merely by observing at various instants which spatial region the object is in, the Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) can be violated through a genuine negative result measurement, thereby repudiating the everyday notion of macrorealism. This violation thus reveals an unnoticed nonclassicality of the very state which epitomizes classicality within the quantum description. It is found that for any given mass and oscillator frequency, a significant quantum violation of LGI can be obtained by suitably choosing the initial peak momentum of the coherent state wave packet. It thus opens up potentially the simplest way (without coupling with any ancillary quantum system or using nonlinearity) for testing whether various recently engineered and sought after macroscopic oscillators, such as feedback cooled thermal trapped nanocrystals of ∼10^{6}-10^{9} amu mass, are indeed bona fide nonclassical objects.
The extraordinary success of quantum mechanics and its formalism has been established thanks to countless experiments with microscopic systems. Nevertheless, it is still not clear whether and when the quantum world ends, allowing for the emergence of classical phenomena. The extension of quantum properties to macroscopic system gives rise to paradoxes, as the well-known Schrödinger’s cat example. Among the alternatives to quantum mechanics, collapse models propose an objective modification of standard quantum theory to restore macrorealism at large scale. They predict a loss of coherence when scaling towards macroscopic systems, due to a spontaneous collapse mechanism included into the dynamics through non-linear stochastic modifications of the Schrödinger equation. Assessing and characterizing these models is a noteworthy endeavour in the exploration of the quantum-to-classical transition. The overarching goal of this Thesis is to address some of these fundamental issues, by exploring the concept of macrorealism and probing collapse models, making use of optomechanical setups. To answer the question whether a system has a quantum or classical dynamics, we will propose a theoretical test of Leggett-Garg inequalities, as tool to probe the macrorealism of an optomechanical system. We will investigate collapse models through the study of the dynamics of an optomechanical cavity, looking for signatures in the noise spectrum. Further, we will use the hypothesis testing framework and quantum metrology tools to distinguish dynamical channels encoding the presence or the lack of the collapse. Our findings show a violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities, suggesting that the demarcation line of the quantum domain can be pushed further to include larger systems. Our approaches for testing collapse models provide novel methodologies to better discriminate these effects and the results represent another step forward in the attempt of gaining a better understanding of the foundations of physics.
While quantum theory has been tested to an incredible degree on microscopic scales, quantum effects are seldom observed in our everyday macroscopic world. The curious results of applying quantum mechanics to macroscopic objects are perhaps best illustrated by Erwin Schrödinger's famous thought experiment, where a cat can be put into a superposition state of being both dead and alive. Obviously, these quantum predictions are in stark contradiction to our common experience. Even with plenty of theoretical explanations put forward to explain this discrepancy, a large number of questions about the frontier between the quantum and the classical world remain unanswered. To distinguish between classical and quantum behavior, two fundamental concepts inherent to classical physics have been established over the years: The world view of local realism limits the power of classical experiments to establish correlations over space, while the world view of macroscopic realism (or macrorealism) restricts temporal correlations. Necessary conditions for both world views have been formulated in the form of Bell and Leggett-Garg inequalities, and Bell inequalities have been shown to be violated by quantum mechanics through increasingly conclusive experiments. Furthermore, many challenging steps towards convincing violations of macrorealism have been taken in a number of recent experiments. In the first part of this thesis, conditions for macrorealism are analyzed in detail. Two necessary conditions for macrorealism, the original Leggett-Garg inequality and the recently proposed no-signaling in time condition, are presented. It is then shown that a combination of no-signaling in time conditions is not only necessary but also sufficient for the existence of a macrorealistic description. Finally, an operational formulation of no-signaling in time, in terms of positive-operator valued measurements and Hamiltonians, is derived. In the next part, we argue that these results lead to a suitable definition of classical behavior. In particular, we provide a formalism to judge the classicality of measurements and time evolutions. We then proceed to apply it to a number of exemplary measurement operators and Hamiltonians. Finally, we argue for the importance of spontaneously realized Hamiltonians in our intuition of classical behavior. Next, differences between local realism and macrorealism are analyzed. For this purpose, the probability polytopes for spatially and temporally separated experiments are compared, and a fundamental difference in the power of quantum mechanics to build both types of correlations is discovered. This result shows that Fine's theorem, which states that a set of Bell inequalities is necessary and sufficient for local realism, is not transferable to macrorealism. Thus, (Leggett-Garg) inequalities are in principle not well-suited for tests of macrorealism, as they can never form a necessary and sufficient condition, and unnecessarily restrict the violating parameter space. No-signaling in time is both better suited and more strongly motivated from the underlying physical theory. In the final part of this thesis, a concrete experimental setup for implementing quantum experiments with macroscopic objects is proposed. It consists of a superconducting micro-sphere in the Meißner state, which is levitated by magnetic fields. Through its expelled magnetic field, the sphere's center-of-mass motion couples to a superconducting quantum circuit. Properly tuned, ground state cooling can be realized, since the sphere's motion is extremely well isolated from the surrounding environment. This setup therefore is a promising candidate for the observation of quantum effects in macroscopic systems.
Quantum superposition is central to quantum theory but challenges our concepts of reality and spacetime when applied to macroscopic objects like Schrödinger's cat. For that reason, it has been a long-standing question whether quantum physics remains valid unmodified even for truly macroscopic objects. By now, the predictions of quantum theory have been confirmed via matter-wave interferometry for massive objects up to 104 10^4\,104 atomic mass units (amu). The rapid development of new technologies promises to soon allow tests of quantum theory for significantly higher test masses by using novel techniques of quantum optomechanics and high-mass matter-wave interferometry. Such experiments may yield novel insights into the foundations of quantum theory, pose stringent limits on alternative theoretical models or even uncover deviations from quantum physics. However, performing experiments of this type on Earth may soon face principal limitations due to requirements of long times of flight, ultra-low vibrations, and extremely high vacuum. Here, we present a short overview of recent developments towards the implementation of the proposed space-mission MAQRO, which promises to overcome those limitations and to perform matter-wave interferometry in a parameter regime orders of magnitude beyond state-of-the-art.
The search for empirical schemes to evidence the nonclassicality of large masses is a central quest of current research. However, practical schemes to witness the irreducible quantumness of an arbitrarily large mass are still lacking. To this end, we incorporate crucial modifications to the standard tools for probing the quantum violation of the pivotal classical notion of macrorealism (MR): while usual tests use the same measurement arrangement at successive times, here we use two different measurement arrangements. This yields a striking result: a mass-independent violation of MR is possible for harmonic oscillator systems. In fact, our adaptation enables probing quantum violations for literally any mass, momentum, and frequency. Moreover, coarse-grained position measurements at an accuracy much worse than the standard quantum limit, as well as knowing the relevant parameters only to this precision, without requiring them to be tuned, suffice for our proposal. These should drastically simplify the experimental effort in testing the nonclassicality of massive objects ranging from atomic ions to macroscopic mirrors in LIGO.
Quantum mechanics marks a radical departure from the classical understanding of Nature, fostering an inherent randomness which forbids a deterministic description; yet the most fundamental departure arises from something different. As shown by Bell [1] and Kochen-Specker [2], quantum mechanics portrays a picture of the world in which reality loses its objectivity and is in fact created by observation. Quantum mechanics predicts phenomena which cannot be explained by any theory with objective realism, although our everyday experience supports the hypothesis that macroscopic objects, despite being made of quantum particles, exist independently of the act of observation; in this paper we identify this behavior as classical. Here we show that this seemingly obvious classical behavior of the macroscopic world cannot be experimentally tested and belongs to the realm of ontology similar to the dispute on the interpretations of quantum mechanics [3,4]. For small systems such as a single photon [5] or a pair [6], it has been experimentally proven that a classical description cannot be sustained. Recently, there have also been experiments that claim to have demonstrated quantum behavior of relatively large objects such as interference of fullerenes [7], the violation of Leggett-Garg inequality in Josephson junction [8], and interference between two condensed clouds of atoms [9], which suggest that there is no limit to the size of the system on which the quantum-versus-classical question can be tested. These behaviors, however, are not sufficient to refute classical description in the sense of objective reality. Our findings show that once we reach the regime where an Avogadro number of particles is present, the quantum-versus-classical question cannot be answered experimentally.