An Algebraic Diagnostic for Quantum-System Structure in Decoherent Branches
Douglas F. Watson
Abstract
Decoherence gives a criterion for when quantum histories behave as mutually exclusive alternatives with well-defined probabilities. A further question is whether such an alternative supports the internal observable structure of a finite quantum system. We formulate this representability question algebraically. If $\cA$ is the accessible observable algebra and $P$ is a branch projection, the branch-internal observable sector is $P\cA P$; an $n$-level quantum system requires this sector to support the matrix algebra $M_n(\C)$. We prove two elementary separation results. First, fixed active decoherence data can be realized by branches of arbitrary finite ranks, so the same decoherence data may correspond either to scalar sectors $\C$ or to noncommutative matrix sectors $M_n(\C)$. Second, this algebraic representability is not monotone under exact refinement: an $n$-dimensional branch supports $M_n(\C)$, while its rank-one refinements support only $\C$. These results do not challenge robust or quasi-classical accounts of branch structure. On the contrary, they clarify why such accounts need structural ingredients beyond decoherence-functional data: robust patterns, records, dynamics, locality, and subsystem decompositions are candidates for supplying the missing branch-internal algebraic structure. They identify a minimal algebraic constraint such accounts must satisfy: probability-bearing alternatives are not, by decoherence alone, finite quantum systems.