Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Higher-dimensional quantum eraser cryptography beyond the binary encoding

Ahmed Halawani, Yahya Meshalwi Khabrani, Abdulaziz Al-Mogeeth, Zheng-Hong Li, M. Al-Amri

Published Sep 9, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Quantum eraser-based cryptographic schemes provide an alternative to conventional quantum key distribution (QKD) by encoding compatibility between preparation and measurement directly in interference, thereby eliminating the need for classical basis reconciliation. However, implementations restricted to binary encoding suffer from an intrinsic limitation: the relatively high distinguishability of two non-orthogonal states enables an eavesdropper to extract information with high success probability. Here, we show that this limitation can be mitigated by extending the quantum eraser framework to higher dimensional encoding. We introduce a ternary protocol based on three symmetrically arranged polarization states, combined with multi-photon grouping and randomized temporal ordering. Within a controlled security model based on individual attacks, we show that the maximum success probability of an undetected, faithful-resend attack drops from ≈ 85% to ≈ 54% relative to the binary case, while the binary-equivalent sifted-key rate is slightly higher (0.30 versus 0.25 bits per photon). Unlike conventional high-dimensional QKD, where the benefit of added dimensions is information-theoretic, the advantage here is physical, arising from the interplay between encoding dimensionality and interference-based indistinguishability. In this setting, higher-dimensional encoding reduces the accessibility of which-path information, leading to a suppression of information leakage at the physical level. These results identify encoding dimensionality as a resource for controlling information accessibility in interference-based cryptographic schemes and clarify the operational limits of quantum eraser-based approaches. Although the present analysis is restricted to a simplified attack model, it provides a physically transparent framework for exploring how interference and indistinguishability can be jointly engineered to influence security in quantum communication.

DOI
10.21203/rs.3.rs-10675530/v1

Related papers

Ternary Quantum Eraser Cryptography

Ahmed Halawani, Yahya Meshalwi Khabrani, Abdulaziz Al-Mogheeth +2 more

Quantum key distribution protocols based on the quantum eraser phenomenon offer an operational advantage: automatic identification of matching and mismatching encoding choices through interference, eliminating basis reconciliation. However, binary quantum eraser implementations permit an eavesdropper to recover Alice's encoded bit with $85\%$ probability. To overcome this constraint, we introduce a ternary quantum eraser protocol employing three polarization states with $120^\circ$ angular separation, transmitted in three-photon groups with randomized temporal ordering. This extension achieves enhanced security through two complementary mechanisms. First, the reduced distinguishability of symmetrically-arranged quantum states limits single-photon discrimination. Second, the combinatorial complexity of unknown photon ordering constrains multi-photon eavesdropping strategies. Security analysis against individual eavesdropping attacks within the four-dimensional path-polarization Hilbert space establishes that an eavesdropper's maximum success probability is bounded at $54\%$, substantially below the binary discrimination bound. The protocol maintains a binary-equivalent efficiency of 0.30 bits per photon, comparable to established binary QKD protocols at the sifted-rate level, while preserving the operational simplicity inherent to quantum eraser cryptography.

quant-pharXiv:2604.12577•Apr 15, 2026•0 citations

High-dimensional quantum communication

Tristan Bernhard Horst Tentrup

In this thesis, Quantum Key Distribution and quantum communication methods based on high-dimensional spatial coding of light are developed. Their security is based on the fundamental quantum nature of light and profits from the highdimensional Hilbert spaces offered intrinsically by imaging optics. An overview of classical information theory and quantum information is given to introduce the field of quantum cryptography. The advantages of larger dimensional alphabets and the security of the standard two-bases BB84 protocol is shown. The spatial states used for encoding are introduced. An analytic expression for the upper bound on the mutual information for these states is derived, including multiphoton states, detector noise and beam broadening. High-dimensional encoding of single photons is experimentally realized, reaching 10.5 bit per received photon. The dependence of the mutual information on the number of detector pixels is discussed and the experimental values are compared with the theoretical upper bound. It was shown that a standard error-correcting LDPC code is sufficient to achieve practically error-free communication. By adding a second mutually unbiased basis, a large-alphabet QKD system is experimentally realized and characterized. The security of this BB84-like protocol is analyzed in terms of intercept-resend and collective attacks. The key rate after postprocessing is analyzed under realistic circumstances, including finite key length. Finally, a new quantum communication method is demonstrated, which is based on encoding information into wavefronts decomposed over guided modes of a multimode fiber. At the end a step back is made and the similarities and differences of several quantum authentication and quantum cryptography schemes as well as Quantum Data Locking are discussed. This involves comparison of the characteristics of the classical channel, the quantum channel and the necessary dimension of the Hilbert space.

•Jun 15, 2018•0 citations

High-efficiency quantum key distribution without key sifting

Ping Liu, Shaobo Gao, Chunyan Li +1 more

In traditional quantum key distribution protocol, both communication parties need to reconciliate their encoding basis to realize sharing secret keys. However, the process of basis reconciliation decreases the generation efficiency of the secret key and classical information is needed to be transmitted for every raw key. Based on quantum interference, we propose a high-efficiency quantum key distribution protocol without basis reconciliation. The presented protocol can greatly improve the generating efficiency of secret keys, reaching 100% in the ideal case, and no classical information is needed. We also analyze the security of the protocol in detail, which shows that the protocol is robust against common attack strategies. Furthermore, the protocol can be implemented with current technologies and open promising possibilities for quantum cryptography.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Sep 24, 2018•0 citations

Improved Eavesdropping Detection in Quantum Key Distribution

Muhammad Mubashir Khan, Jie Xu, Almut Beige

Employing the fundamental laws of quantum physics, Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) promises the unconditionally secure distribution of cryptographic keys. However, in practical realisations, a QKD protocol is only secure, when the quantum bit error rate introduced by an eavesdropper unavoidably exceeds the system error rate. This condition guarantees that an eavesdropper cannot disguise his presence by simply replacing the original transmission line with a less faulty one. Unfortunately, this condition also limits the possible distance between the communicating parties, Alice and Bob, to a few hundred kilometers. To overcome this problem, we design a QKD protocol which allows Alice and Bob to distinguish system errors from eavesdropping errors. If they are able to identify the origin of their errors, they can detect eavesdropping even when the system error rate exceeds the eavesdropping error rate. To achieve this, the proposed protocol employs an alternative encoding of information in two-dimensional photon states. Errors manifest themselves as quantum bit and as index transmission errors with a distinct correlation between them in case of intercept-resend eavesdropping. As a result, Alice and Bob can tolerate lower eavesdropping and higher system error rates without compromising their privacy.

arXiv:1112.1110•Dec 5, 2011•3 citations

High-dimensional quantum key distribution with Qubit-like states

Lukas Scarfe, Rojan Abolhassani, Frédéric Bouchard +4 more

Quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols most often use two conjugate bases in order to verify the security of the quantum channel. In the majority of protocols, these bases are mutually unbiased to one another, which is to say they are formed from balanced superpositions of the entire set of states in the opposing basis. Here, we introduce a high-dimensional QKD protocol using qubit-like states, referred to as Fourier-qubits (or F-qubits). In our scheme, each F-qubit is a superposition of only two computational basis states with a relative phase that can take d distinct values, where d is the dimension of the computational basis. This non-mutually-unbiased approach allows us to bound the information leaked to an eavesdropper, maintaining security in high-dimensional quantum systems despite the states’ seemingly two-dimensional nature. By simplifying state preparation and measurement, our protocol offers a practical alternative for secure high-dimensional quantum communications. We experimentally demonstrate this protocol for a noisy high-dimensional QKD channel using the orbital angular momentum degree of freedom of light and discuss the potential benefits for encoding in other degrees of freedom. High dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD) systems will allow for higher key generation rate, but with added complexity for creating and detecting high dimensional quantum states. The authors demonstrate a QKD protocol using “qubit-like” qudit states, “F-qubits”, with simpler generation and detection, maintaining the benefits of high dimensional QKD protocols.

arXiv:2504.03893•Communications Physics•Nov 25, 2025•7 citations

Two high-dimensional cartesian bases for quantum key distribution

Tristan Bernhard Horst Tentrup, Willemijn M. Luiten, Peter Hooijschuur +2 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides a secure way of generating shared cryptographic keys between a sender (Alice) and a receiver (Bob). The original BB84 protocol uses a two-dimensional polarization basis, limiting the information content of a single photon to 1 bit. Using the transverse position of single photons as one basis and the Fourier space as a second basis, one can construct a pair of mutually unbiased higher-dimensional bases. This improves not only the security of the protocol, but also the key generation rate. We present experimental results with a Spatial-Light-Modulator-based encoding scheme employing two nearly orthogonal alphabets with on the order of 103symbols each and an information content of about 10 bit.

Workshop on Information Optics•Jul 1, 2017•1 citation
Abstract Quantum eraser-based cryptographic schemes provide an alternative to conventional quantum key distribution (QKD) by encoding compatibility between preparation and measurement directly in interference, thereby eliminating the need for classical basis reconciliation. However, implementations restricted to binary encoding suffer from an intrinsic limitation: the relatively high distinguishability of two non-orthogonal states enables an eavesdropper to extract information with high success probability. Here, we show that this limitation can be mitigated by extending the quantum eraser framework to higher dimensional encoding. We introduce a ternary protocol based on three symmetrically arranged polarization states, combined with multi-photon grouping and randomized temporal ordering. Within a controlled security model based on individual attacks, we show that the maximum success probability of an undetected, faithful-resend attack drops from ≈ 85% to ≈ 54% relative to the binary case, while the binary-equivalent sifted-key rate is slightly higher (0.30 versus 0.25 bits per photon). Unlike conventional high-dimensional QKD, where the benefit of added dimensions is information-theoretic, the advantage here is physical, arising from the interplay between encoding dimensionality and interference-based indistinguishability. In this setting, higher-dimensional encoding reduces the accessibility of which-path information, leading to a suppression of information leakage at the physical level. These results identify encoding dimensionality as a resource for controlling information accessibility in interference-based cryptographic schemes and clarify the operational limits of quantum eraser-based approaches. Although the present analysis is restricted to a simplified attack model, it provides a physically transparent framework for exploring how interference and indistinguishability can be jointly engineered to influence security in quantum communication.
Quantum key distribution protocols based on the quantum eraser phenomenon offer an operational advantage: automatic identification of matching and mismatching encoding choices through interference, eliminating basis reconciliation. However, binary quantum eraser implementations permit an eavesdropper to recover Alice's encoded bit with 85%85\%85% probability. To overcome this constraint, we introduce a ternary quantum eraser protocol employing three polarization states with 120∘120^\circ120∘ angular separation, transmitted in three-photon groups with randomized temporal ordering. This extension achieves enhanced security through two complementary mechanisms. First, the reduced distinguishability of symmetrically-arranged quantum states limits single-photon discrimination. Second, the combinatorial complexity of unknown photon ordering constrains multi-photon eavesdropping strategies. Security analysis against individual eavesdropping attacks within the four-dimensional path-polarization Hilbert space establishes that an eavesdropper's maximum success probability is bounded at 54%54\%54%, substantially below the binary discrimination bound. The protocol maintains a binary-equivalent efficiency of 0.30 bits per photon, comparable to established binary QKD protocols at the sifted-rate level, while preserving the operational simplicity inherent to quantum eraser cryptography.
In this thesis, Quantum Key Distribution and quantum communication methods based on high-dimensional spatial coding of light are developed. Their security is based on the fundamental quantum nature of light and profits from the highdimensional Hilbert spaces offered intrinsically by imaging optics. An overview of classical information theory and quantum information is given to introduce the field of quantum cryptography. The advantages of larger dimensional alphabets and the security of the standard two-bases BB84 protocol is shown. The spatial states used for encoding are introduced. An analytic expression for the upper bound on the mutual information for these states is derived, including multiphoton states, detector noise and beam broadening. High-dimensional encoding of single photons is experimentally realized, reaching 10.5 bit per received photon. The dependence of the mutual information on the number of detector pixels is discussed and the experimental values are compared with the theoretical upper bound. It was shown that a standard error-correcting LDPC code is sufficient to achieve practically error-free communication. By adding a second mutually unbiased basis, a large-alphabet QKD system is experimentally realized and characterized. The security of this BB84-like protocol is analyzed in terms of intercept-resend and collective attacks. The key rate after postprocessing is analyzed under realistic circumstances, including finite key length. Finally, a new quantum communication method is demonstrated, which is based on encoding information into wavefronts decomposed over guided modes of a multimode fiber. At the end a step back is made and the similarities and differences of several quantum authentication and quantum cryptography schemes as well as Quantum Data Locking are discussed. This involves comparison of the characteristics of the classical channel, the quantum channel and the necessary dimension of the Hilbert space.
In traditional quantum key distribution protocol, both communication parties need to reconciliate their encoding basis to realize sharing secret keys. However, the process of basis reconciliation decreases the generation efficiency of the secret key and classical information is needed to be transmitted for every raw key. Based on quantum interference, we propose a high-efficiency quantum key distribution protocol without basis reconciliation. The presented protocol can greatly improve the generating efficiency of secret keys, reaching 100% in the ideal case, and no classical information is needed. We also analyze the security of the protocol in detail, which shows that the protocol is robust against common attack strategies. Furthermore, the protocol can be implemented with current technologies and open promising possibilities for quantum cryptography.
Employing the fundamental laws of quantum physics, Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) promises the unconditionally secure distribution of cryptographic keys. However, in practical realisations, a QKD protocol is only secure, when the quantum bit error rate introduced by an eavesdropper unavoidably exceeds the system error rate. This condition guarantees that an eavesdropper cannot disguise his presence by simply replacing the original transmission line with a less faulty one. Unfortunately, this condition also limits the possible distance between the communicating parties, Alice and Bob, to a few hundred kilometers. To overcome this problem, we design a QKD protocol which allows Alice and Bob to distinguish system errors from eavesdropping errors. If they are able to identify the origin of their errors, they can detect eavesdropping even when the system error rate exceeds the eavesdropping error rate. To achieve this, the proposed protocol employs an alternative encoding of information in two-dimensional photon states. Errors manifest themselves as quantum bit and as index transmission errors with a distinct correlation between them in case of intercept-resend eavesdropping. As a result, Alice and Bob can tolerate lower eavesdropping and higher system error rates without compromising their privacy.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols most often use two conjugate bases in order to verify the security of the quantum channel. In the majority of protocols, these bases are mutually unbiased to one another, which is to say they are formed from balanced superpositions of the entire set of states in the opposing basis. Here, we introduce a high-dimensional QKD protocol using qubit-like states, referred to as Fourier-qubits (or F-qubits). In our scheme, each F-qubit is a superposition of only two computational basis states with a relative phase that can take d distinct values, where d is the dimension of the computational basis. This non-mutually-unbiased approach allows us to bound the information leaked to an eavesdropper, maintaining security in high-dimensional quantum systems despite the states’ seemingly two-dimensional nature. By simplifying state preparation and measurement, our protocol offers a practical alternative for secure high-dimensional quantum communications. We experimentally demonstrate this protocol for a noisy high-dimensional QKD channel using the orbital angular momentum degree of freedom of light and discuss the potential benefits for encoding in other degrees of freedom. High dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD) systems will allow for higher key generation rate, but with added complexity for creating and detecting high dimensional quantum states. The authors demonstrate a QKD protocol using “qubit-like” qudit states, “F-qubits”, with simpler generation and detection, maintaining the benefits of high dimensional QKD protocols.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides a secure way of generating shared cryptographic keys between a sender (Alice) and a receiver (Bob). The original BB84 protocol uses a two-dimensional polarization basis, limiting the information content of a single photon to 1 bit. Using the transverse position of single photons as one basis and the Fourier space as a second basis, one can construct a pair of mutually unbiased higher-dimensional bases. This improves not only the security of the protocol, but also the key generation rate. We present experimental results with a Spatial-Light-Modulator-based encoding scheme employing two nearly orthogonal alphabets with on the order of 103symbols each and an information content of about 10 bit.