Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Accounting for the factor of seven in the 1975 cold-neutron Stern–Gerlach experiment

Orrick Brian

Published Sep 5, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A recent simulation study models the 1975 cold-neutron Stern–Gerlach measurement of Hamelin, Xiromeritis and Liaud with a gradient held constant at 300 T/m, and over-predicts the published 6 mm splitting by a factor of about seven. From the primary sources, that factor divides into three. A factor 2.09 is a misattribution: the 1975 article quotes its maximum gradient as a range, 1–3 × 10⁴ G/cm, and assigns its Fig. 6 to a tapered dihedral of 5 mm entrance and 8 mm exit gap, whereas 3 × 10⁴ G/cm belongs to a 4 mm parallel gap whose own splitting is 12.6 mm. Integrating the thesis's measured field instead of a uniform gradient removes a factor 1.41. A factor 2.40 remains between our best forward calculation and the observation, unsubdivided; it contains the beam's wavelength distribution, 1–45 Å against a single 10 Å. We derive the D⁻² gradient scaling from a magnetomotive force constant to 4.2% over a factor 3.75 in gap; a forward calculation with nothing fitted returns 0.92, 1.23 and 0.77 of the observed splitting in the three stable configurations. The 1974 thesis had already identified the non-uniformity and measured λ^1.83 over six velocity settings; that measurement cannot discriminate uniform from non-uniform gradients, and its exponent lies 4.8σ below either prediction, which we leave unresolved. Classical mechanics with the unreduced neutron moment describes both datasets to about 25%; neither requires a modified deflection law, nor can exclude one at that level.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22387870

Related papers

A Numerical Experiment with the Stern-Gerlach Geometry

Riadh Al Rabeh

The Stern-Gerlach (SG) experiment reported in 1922 was an important milestone in the history of physics. The passing of a collimated neutral beam of silver atoms through a long, strong and asymmetrical magnet caused the atoms of silver out of a horizontal slit to split roughly into two separate beams forming a hollow lip figure (as seen on a plate held normal to the beam) instead of being a filled-in lip figure as suggested by some theoretical calculations. The SG results were thought to indicate that the observed phenomenon can not be explained using classical physics. Following a classical numerical approach by the author using a double-slit geometry, results are given for a 3D numerical SG type experiment showing clearly that a binary beam splitting is possible for certain conditions using an inverse square relation as the only source of forces- thus giving the possibility of a classical interpretation to the problem. For simplicity, we use what is mathematically equivalent- a dipole of charges to represent the magnetic dipole of the atom, and sets of fixed charges or potential surfaces around the path of the beam to represent the poles of a magnet. Although not exactly following the SG setup, the present results, nonetheless, are useful in showing the clear discrete behavior that can be caused by the combination of a fixed boundary, a strong field asymmetry and the highly nonlinear mapping of the inverse square law of forces coupled with the spin direction of a particle.

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Direct demonstration of the transverse Stern–Gerlach effect

J. L. Porter, R. F. Pettifer, David R Leadley

A Stern–Gerlach experiment constructed in the spirit of the original experiment is reported that demonstrates spatial quantization for a beam of silver atoms directly to the unaided eye. Splitting of the atomic beam is seen both parallel to the magnetic field direction, as in the “usual” experiment, and in a direction mutually perpendicular to the field and atomic trajectory, which is a new transverse Stern–Gerlach effect. Splitting of up to 4 mm can be recorded visually. Calculations based on the force components acting on the atomic beams reproduce the experimental results within the experimental accuracy of ±0.3 mm.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 13, 2003•3 citations

A Century Ago the Stern–Gerlach Experiment Ruled Unequivocally in Favor of Quantum Mechanics

Břetislav Friedrich

Abstract In 1921, Otto Stern conceived the idea for an experiment that would decide between a classical and a quantum description of atomic behavior, as epitomized by the Bohr–Sommerfeld–Debye model of the atom. This model entailed not only the quantization of the magnitude of the orbital electronic angular momentum but also of the projection of the angular momentum on an external magnetic field – the so‐called space quantization. Stern recognized that space quantization would have observable consequences: namely, that the magnetic dipole moment due to the orbital angular momentum would be space quantized as well, taking two opposite values for atoms whose only unpaired electron has just one quantum of orbital angular momentum. When acted upon by a suitable inhomogeneous magnetic field, a beam of such atoms would be split into two beams consisting of deflected atoms with opposite projections of the orbital angular momentum on the magnetic field. In contradistinction, if atoms behaved classically, the atomic beam would only broaden along the field gradient and have maximum intensity at zero deflection, i. e., where there would be a minimum or no intensity for a beam split due to space quantization. Stern anticipated that, although simple in principle, the experiment would be difficult to carry out – and invited Walther Gerlach to team up with him. Gerlach's realism and experimental skills together with his sometimes stubborn determination to make things work proved invaluable for the success of the Stern–Gerlach experiment (SGE). After a long struggle, Gerlach finally saw, on 8 February 1922, the splitting of a beam of silver atoms in a magnetic field. The absence of the concept of electron spin confused and confounded the interpretation of the SGE, as the silver atoms were, in fact, in a 2S state, with zero orbital and spin angular momentum. However, a key quantum feature whose existence the SGE was designed to test – namely space quantization of electronic angular momentum – was robust enough to transpire independent of whether the electronic angular momentum was orbital or due to spin. The SGE entails other key aspects of quantum mechanics such as quantum measurement, state preparation, coherence, and entanglement. Confronted with the outcome of the SGE, Stern noted: “I still have objections to the idea of beauty of quantum mechanics. But she is correct.”

Israel Journal of Chemistry•Jun 28, 2023•7 citations

Classical Justification of the Stern-Gerlach Experiment

Hamid V. Ansari

It is shown that contrary to what is thought the classical physics does not predict a uniform distribution for the magnetic dipoles (silver atoms) in a nonuniform magnetic field in the Stern-Gerlach experiment. Its prediction for a concentrated beam is obtained in the form of a circular surface such that the density of the dipoles is much more near the edge than near the center. Some experiments are proposed for testing the contents of the article.

•Aug 1, 2009•0 citations

Eddy currents in the Stern–Gerlach experiment

Sue Sulcs, Barry C. Gilbert

We calculate the effects of Larmor precession in the two-state Stern–Gerlach experiment performed with silver atoms. We compare the time constants and Q factors for an oscillating magnetic-dipole moment in free space and in close proximity to an iron magnet. Numerical modelling suggests that the original Stern–Gerlach experiment was too dissipative to have eliminated classical explanations. A recent experiment, also admitting a classical interpretation, is discussed briefly. A new experiment is proposed that should be able to confirm quantum mechanics unequivocally. PACS Nos.: 03.65Bz, 41.20Gz, 32.10Dk

Canadian Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 2002•2 citations

Investigation of splitting of a beam of potassium atoms in the classical Stern-Gerlach experiment at varying inhomogeneity of the magnetic field

Asel' Akhmetova

The splitting of a beam of potassium atoms in the classical Stern-Gerlach scheme under varying inhomogeneity of the magnetic field is experimentally investigated in this work. First, the basic shape of the beam in the absence of an effective field is recorded, which makes it possible to introduce and calibrate the geometrical parameters of the channel. Then, when the current in the magnet windings increases and the field gradient grows, a systematic shift of the beam density maxima is observed, described by the model function F(u), which includes the parameter q, which characterizes the strength of interaction of atoms with the field. Theoretical calculations based on this function showed good agreement with the experimental results, including the asymmetry of the distribution due to the nonideal symmetry of the magnetic system. The obtained dependences of the position of the intensity maxima on ∇B confirmed the validity of both linear and asymptotic approximation for different modes of magnet operation. These conclusions have both fundamental importance for understanding the quantum mechanical aspects of beam splitting and applied significance in the development of methods for precise control of spin-polarized atomic beams in spectroscopy and spintronics.

Technobius physics.•Dec 29, 2024•0 citations
A recent simulation study models the 1975 cold-neutron Stern–Gerlach measurement of Hamelin, Xiromeritis and Liaud with a gradient held constant at 300 T/m, and over-predicts the published 6 mm splitting by a factor of about seven. From the primary sources, that factor divides into three. A factor 2.09 is a misattribution: the 1975 article quotes its maximum gradient as a range, 1–3 × 10⁴ G/cm, and assigns its Fig. 6 to a tapered dihedral of 5 mm entrance and 8 mm exit gap, whereas 3 × 10⁴ G/cm belongs to a 4 mm parallel gap whose own splitting is 12.6 mm. Integrating the thesis's measured field instead of a uniform gradient removes a factor 1.41. A factor 2.40 remains between our best forward calculation and the observation, unsubdivided; it contains the beam's wavelength distribution, 1–45 Å against a single 10 Å. We derive the D⁻² gradient scaling from a magnetomotive force constant to 4.2% over a factor 3.75 in gap; a forward calculation with nothing fitted returns 0.92, 1.23 and 0.77 of the observed splitting in the three stable configurations. The 1974 thesis had already identified the non-uniformity and measured λ^1.83 over six velocity settings; that measurement cannot discriminate uniform from non-uniform gradients, and its exponent lies 4.8σ below either prediction, which we leave unresolved. Classical mechanics with the unreduced neutron moment describes both datasets to about 25%; neither requires a modified deflection law, nor can exclude one at that level.
The Stern-Gerlach (SG) experiment reported in 1922 was an important milestone in the history of physics. The passing of a collimated neutral beam of silver atoms through a long, strong and asymmetrical magnet caused the atoms of silver out of a horizontal slit to split roughly into two separate beams forming a hollow lip figure (as seen on a plate held normal to the beam) instead of being a filled-in lip figure as suggested by some theoretical calculations. The SG results were thought to indicate that the observed phenomenon can not be explained using classical physics. Following a classical numerical approach by the author using a double-slit geometry, results are given for a 3D numerical SG type experiment showing clearly that a binary beam splitting is possible for certain conditions using an inverse square relation as the only source of forces- thus giving the possibility of a classical interpretation to the problem. For simplicity, we use what is mathematically equivalent- a dipole of charges to represent the magnetic dipole of the atom, and sets of fixed charges or potential surfaces around the path of the beam to represent the poles of a magnet. Although not exactly following the SG setup, the present results, nonetheless, are useful in showing the clear discrete behavior that can be caused by the combination of a fixed boundary, a strong field asymmetry and the highly nonlinear mapping of the inverse square law of forces coupled with the spin direction of a particle.
A Stern–Gerlach experiment constructed in the spirit of the original experiment is reported that demonstrates spatial quantization for a beam of silver atoms directly to the unaided eye. Splitting of the atomic beam is seen both parallel to the magnetic field direction, as in the “usual” experiment, and in a direction mutually perpendicular to the field and atomic trajectory, which is a new transverse Stern–Gerlach effect. Splitting of up to 4 mm can be recorded visually. Calculations based on the force components acting on the atomic beams reproduce the experimental results within the experimental accuracy of ±0.3 mm.
Abstract In 1921, Otto Stern conceived the idea for an experiment that would decide between a classical and a quantum description of atomic behavior, as epitomized by the Bohr–Sommerfeld–Debye model of the atom. This model entailed not only the quantization of the magnitude of the orbital electronic angular momentum but also of the projection of the angular momentum on an external magnetic field – the so‐called space quantization. Stern recognized that space quantization would have observable consequences: namely, that the magnetic dipole moment due to the orbital angular momentum would be space quantized as well, taking two opposite values for atoms whose only unpaired electron has just one quantum of orbital angular momentum. When acted upon by a suitable inhomogeneous magnetic field, a beam of such atoms would be split into two beams consisting of deflected atoms with opposite projections of the orbital angular momentum on the magnetic field. In contradistinction, if atoms behaved classically, the atomic beam would only broaden along the field gradient and have maximum intensity at zero deflection, i. e., where there would be a minimum or no intensity for a beam split due to space quantization. Stern anticipated that, although simple in principle, the experiment would be difficult to carry out – and invited Walther Gerlach to team up with him. Gerlach's realism and experimental skills together with his sometimes stubborn determination to make things work proved invaluable for the success of the Stern–Gerlach experiment (SGE). After a long struggle, Gerlach finally saw, on 8 February 1922, the splitting of a beam of silver atoms in a magnetic field. The absence of the concept of electron spin confused and confounded the interpretation of the SGE, as the silver atoms were, in fact, in a 2S state, with zero orbital and spin angular momentum. However, a key quantum feature whose existence the SGE was designed to test – namely space quantization of electronic angular momentum – was robust enough to transpire independent of whether the electronic angular momentum was orbital or due to spin. The SGE entails other key aspects of quantum mechanics such as quantum measurement, state preparation, coherence, and entanglement. Confronted with the outcome of the SGE, Stern noted: “I still have objections to the idea of beauty of quantum mechanics. But she is correct.”
We calculate the effects of Larmor precession in the two-state Stern–Gerlach experiment performed with silver atoms. We compare the time constants and Q factors for an oscillating magnetic-dipole moment in free space and in close proximity to an iron magnet. Numerical modelling suggests that the original Stern–Gerlach experiment was too dissipative to have eliminated classical explanations. A recent experiment, also admitting a classical interpretation, is discussed briefly. A new experiment is proposed that should be able to confirm quantum mechanics unequivocally. PACS Nos.: 03.65Bz, 41.20Gz, 32.10Dk
The splitting of a beam of potassium atoms in the classical Stern-Gerlach scheme under varying inhomogeneity of the magnetic field is experimentally investigated in this work. First, the basic shape of the beam in the absence of an effective field is recorded, which makes it possible to introduce and calibrate the geometrical parameters of the channel. Then, when the current in the magnet windings increases and the field gradient grows, a systematic shift of the beam density maxima is observed, described by the model function F(u), which includes the parameter q, which characterizes the strength of interaction of atoms with the field. Theoretical calculations based on this function showed good agreement with the experimental results, including the asymmetry of the distribution due to the nonideal symmetry of the magnetic system. The obtained dependences of the position of the intensity maxima on ∇B confirmed the validity of both linear and asymptotic approximation for different modes of magnet operation. These conclusions have both fundamental importance for understanding the quantum mechanical aspects of beam splitting and applied significance in the development of methods for precise control of spin-polarized atomic beams in spectroscopy and spintronics.