Progress Towards a Cryogenic Single-ion Clock

Takahiro Tow

Published Jun 1, 2026• 0 citations

Abstract

The accuracy of state-of-the-art optical atomic clocks has surpassed that of microwave clocks by more than two orders of magnitude. This revolution in accuracy has prompted international dialogue concerning the redefinition of the SI second away from the current cesium standard. Optical clocks employing a single trapped ion are promising candidates for realizing this redefinition as they offer exceptional fractional frequency uncertainty. However, there is still room for improvement: the leading contributions to the uncertainty of most single-ion clocks, such as the 88Sr+ clock operated by the National Research Council of Canada (NRC), are the blackbody radiation shifts and collisional frequency shifts. The uncancelled blackbody radiation shift dominates both the total shift and uncertainty of the existing room temperature strontium ion clocks. To address these sources of inaccuracy, I contributed to developing a strontium ion trap for operation at 4 K. Operating at cryogenic temperatures suppresses the blackbody radiation shift by eight orders of magnitude and collisional shifts by at least two orders of magnitude, enabling substantial improvements to the performance of single-ion clocks. The proposed cryogenic clock is capable of achieving fractional frequency uncertainty below 10−19. This thesis describes the design, construction, and evaluation of the cryogenic ion trap towards realizing a more accurate atomic clock.

Related papers

Progress towards a strontium single-ion optical clock with mHz uncertainty

P. Dubé, Bin Jian, Alan A. Madej

The strontium ion clock developed at the National Research Council of Canada has reached an uncertainty level of 5 mHz in recent years. This low level of uncertainty was achieved in great part by using methods that harness specific properties of the clock transition that allow either a very high level of cancellation or a strong suppression of frequency shifts that would otherwise dominate the uncertainty budget. The shifts controlled by these methods are the electric quadrupole shift, the tensor Stark shifts, and the micromotion shifts. With these methods in place, the main limitation to the accuracy of the clock transition frequency is the uncertainty in the evaluation of blackbody radiation (BBR) field. In this paper, we review the methods used to control the shifts to the 5 mHz level and present our plans for the evaluation of the BBR field that is expected to reduce the total uncertainty to the mHz level.

European Frequency and Time ForumApr 1, 20160 citations

Ticking near the Zero-Point Energy: Towards 1 x 10^-18 Accuracy in Al^+ Optical Clocks

Jwo-Sy Chen

The advancement of optical atomic clocks in the past two decades has motivated many potential applications in navigation, communication, and science. Accurate optical clocks that outperform the current cesium time standard also trigger a discussion about a possible redefinition of the SI second. The 27Al+ quantum logic clocks developed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) were the first to achieve the clock fractional frequency uncertainty below 10-17 in 2010. To date, a few research groups around the world have demonstrated optical clocks based on various atomic transitions with fractional frequency uncertainty in the 10-18 range. The accuracy of the previous 27Al+ clocks was limited by the second order Doppler (time dilation) shift and the blackbody shift. Since 2010, the third 27Al+ optical clock is being developed at NIST to achieve a higher accuracy. The frequency uncertainties dominant in the previous clocks are controlled and reduced in the current optical clock. The new design of the ion trap system has reduced significantly both the blackbody radiation shift uncertainty and the time dilation shift uncertainty due to micromotion, while the time dilation shift uncertainty due to the secular motion has been reduced by more than an order of magnitude by operating the optical clock near the three dimensional zero-point energy. Despite those previously dominant uncertainties, several other systematic effects are being evaluated and some other efforts are being made to achieve a total uncertainty towards 1.0 x 10-18. In this thesis, I will document the detail of the construction and evaluation of the current 27Al+ optical clock developed at NIST.

Jan 1, 20172 citations

Advances in the uncertainty evaluation of a 88Sr+ single ion optical clock

P. Dubé, Bin Jian, Amar C. Vutha

We report on recent progress in the evaluation and reduction of the systematic shifts of the strontium ion clock, addressing effects such as the collisional frequency shift, the servo tracking errors, and the blackbody radiation (BBR) shift. The total uncertainty is currently dominated by the BBR field evaluation. All the other known contributions are at least one order of magnitude smaller. Experiments are underway to improve the BBR field evaluation using thermal imaging of a dummy ion trap.

European Frequency and Time ForumApr 1, 20182 citations

Optimization of a RF Single Ion Paul Trap for a 88Sr+ Ion Optical Clock Comparison

Maria Tibbo

As part of the ongoing world-wide effort in improving time and frequency references, a high accuracy optical frequency standard was developed using the electric quadrupole allowed clock transition at 445 THz (674 nm) in a trapped and laser cooled 88Sr+ion. An ion trap system of the endcap design has been recently evaluated with a fractional frequency uncertainty which surpasses the accuracy of the current realization of the SI second. This thesis seeks to further evaluate the limiting systematic shifts of the device by optimizing a second ion trap reference based on a rf Paul trap design, which was then compared with the endcap trap reference frequency. The comparison of the two ion traps' reference frequencies confirmed an overall offset of -0.36 pm 0.08 Hz at the 445 THz reference frequency corresponding to a fractional frequency offset of 8 x 10^-16.

Jan 1, 20130 citations

Development of an Apparatus for a Strontium Optical Lattice Optical Frequency Standard

Ian R. Hill

Accurate time keeping is critical to the function and advancement of many human endeavours. Atomic clocks based on a microwave transition in atomic Cs have served as primary frequency standards to realise the SI second since their formal adoption in 1967. State-of-the-art, laser cooled, Cs fountains now routinely operate with fractional frequency uncertainties below the 10⁻¹⁵ level in laboratories throughout the world. Over the last decade, efforts to build frequency standards based on optical transitions have come to fruition and potential inaccuracies below the 10⁻¹⁷ level have been demonstrated. Such standards point to the future of time keeping and much development is being pursued to realise the potential of these 'next generation' optical clocks. One such approach, on which this work focusses, relies on a 'magic' wavelength optical lattice trap to provide (almost) Doppler- and recoil-free confinement of atoms during clock interrogation. At this 'magic' wavelength, light induced perturbation of the clock states is equal and so cancels precisely. This thesis describes the design and implementation of an optical lattice frequency standard apparatus based on 88Sr held in a 1D optical lattice. A review of the development of atomic frequency metrology is given from a historical viewpoint and the technology and limitations of current methods discussed. To tackle the blackbody radiation shift, which currently presents the greatest limitation to the Sr lattice clock, imposing at the 10⁻¹⁶ level, a scheme to measure the blackbody radiation shift coefficient at the 10⁻¹⁷ level is developed. Techniques to laser cool and trap atomic strontium are described and the implementation detailed. All laser systems required for clock operation are described including the design and implementation of extended-cavity diode lasers for precision spectroscopy. Details relevant to the eventual operation of the apparatus are discussed.

Jun 1, 20123 citations

A dual species optical atomic clock

Martin Steinel

Frequency standards based on optical transitions between electronic states of trapped ions have reached uncertainties below 10−18 [1]. The Stark shift caused by room-temperature blackbody radiation (BBR) causes the largest correction for most high-performance optical clock. The systematic uncertainty of 171Yb+ clocks based on the 2S1/2 (F = 0) → 2D3/2 (F = 2) electric quadrupole (E2) and 2S1/2 (F = 0) → 2F7/2 (F = 3) electric octupole (E3) transitions is currently limited to 28×10−18 and 1.5×10−18, respectively, by the fractional accuracy of the differential polarizability Δαdc of approximately 2% [2]. In the scope of this thesis, a dual species clock based on 171Yb+ and 88Sr+ ions was set up, operated and evaluated, to overcome this barrier. Since Δαdc is known with a smaller fractional uncertainty of 0.04% for the 2S1/2 → 2D5/2 E2 transition of 88Sr+ [3], this allows for a transfer of Δαdc from 88Sr+ to 171Yb+ following a method proposed in [4]. The optical intensity of a laser is calibrated with the Stark shift it causes on the 88Sr+ clock transition, allowing for the determination of Δαdc of the 171Yb+ clock transitions. This allows for a reduction of the fractional uncertainty of Δαdc for both 171Yb+ clock transitions below 0.4% and clock operation on the E2 and E3 transition with a fractional BBR shift uncertainty of 0.84×10−18 and 0.24×10−18 is enabled, respectively. However the value of Δαdc determined in this thesis does not agree with [2], a fractional offset of approximately 14% is observed. To investigate this discrepancy further, Δαdc is measured in the same manner as in [2] for the 88Sr+ clock transition. The same offset of approximately 14% is found, calling the accuracy of at least one of these methods into question. Finally, the first optical frequency ratio ℛ between the 88Sr+ clock transition and the 171Yb+ E3 transition is measured. The fractional uncertainty of ℛ is 23×10−18. ℛ in combination with the absolute frequency of the E3 transition allows for the determination of the 88Sr+ absolute frequency νSr+ with an uncertainty limited by the caesium references. The value of νSr+ falls outside of the recommended range, but is corroborated by measurements of the same quantity by other institutes [5, 6]. [1] M. Marshall et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 033201 (2025) [2] N. Huntemann et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 063001 (2016) [3] T. Lindvall et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 043402 (2025) [4] M. D. Barrett et al., Phys. Rev. A 100, 043418 (2019) [5] C. Marceau et al., Metrologia 62.4, 045001 (2025) [6] T. Lindvall et al., Phys. Rev. Appl. 24, 044082 (2025)

Dec 16, 20250 citations