'In the past few years quantum computers have seen considerable interest from fields which have problems which are computationally expensive to solve with classical computers. One area that has been a major of source of this interest is the simulation of chemical systems. Materials are one type of system that is important to a variety of industries such as renewable energy and medicine. Among the obstacles faced in simulating materials, materials can have properties which are challenging to calculate on classical computers. The promise of quantum computing for improving the exactness of chemical calculations has been shown with a number of methods for a variety of systems. One such method which has previously been used for materials is the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE). However work doing this is still fairly scarce and also typically uses closed source/paid software or does not publish detailed code. The goal of this research is to implement VQE for materials using the python package Tangelo. This implementation will then be used to perform calculations on simple systems to compare this implementation with existing results.
'In the past few years quantum computers have seen considerable interest from fields which have problems which are computationally expensive to solve with classical computers. One area that has been a major of source of this interest is the simulation of chemical systems. Materials are one type of system that is important to a variety of industries such as renewable energy and medicine. Among the obstacles faced in simulating materials, materials can have properties which are challenging to calculate on classical computers. The promise of quantum computing for improving the exactness of chemical calculations has been shown with a number of methods for a variety of systems. One such method which has previously been used for materials is the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE). However work doing this is still fairly scarce and also typically uses closed source/paid software or does not publish detailed code. The goal of this research is to implement VQE for materials using the python package Tangelo. This implementation will then be used to perform calculations on simple systems to compare this implementation with existing results.
Abstract Material discovery is a phenomenon practiced since the evolution of the world. The discovery of materials has led to significant development in varied fields such as Science, Engineering and Technology. Computationally simulating molecules has been an area of interest in the industry as well as academia. However, simulating large molecules can be computationally expensive in terms of computing power and complexity. Quantum computing is a recent development that can improve the efficiency in predicting properties of atoms and molecules which will be useful for material design. The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is one such quantum algorithm used to calculate the ground state energy of molecules or ions. In this study, we have done a comparative analysis of the parameters that constitute the VQE algorithm. This includes components such as basis, qubit mapping, ansatz, and optimizers used. We have also developed a database consisting of 79 single atoms and their variations of oxidation states and 33 molecules with the data of their Hamiltonian and ground state energy and dipole moment.
The advancements in classical computational components such as CPUs and GPUs have had a reverberating impact on the democratization of computational power available, with the field of computational chemistry reaping significant benefits from the propulsion of the limits of systems studied. The accurate prediction of chemical properties and reaction dynamics through computational simulation is now a centerpiece of modern chemical research, significantly accelerating discoveries research areas of materials science and drug development, as well as industrially relevant processes such as the emission of aldehydes from soft foams, flame retardants and pyrolysis and the carbonylation of epoxides. These achievements of computational chemistry still are overshadowed in the face of fundamental bottlenecks where classical methods remain constrained by the exponential scaling when treating large and/or strongly correlated quantum many-body systems. This innate computational complexity often constitutes chemically accurate calculations based on first principles impractical, or plain impossible, for systems beyond modest sizes. Quantum computing offers a potential pathway around these limitations, originally formally formulated by David Deutsch as a tool for simulating quantum systems, with the first quantum algorithms indicating speed-ups compared to classical counterparts arising from Peter Shor and Lov Grover for the prime factorization of an integer number and unstructured search respectively. Relying on fundamental theorems by Claude Shannon, it has been demonstrated that through the use of error-correcting codes fault-tolerant quantum computers are able to safeguard information against noise and decoherence, strongly indicating towards exponential speedups in solving central computational chemistry problems, such as determining ground state energies or reaction pathways of chemical systems. Substantial strides in experimental quantum computing over the past decade, including proof-of-principle demonstrations of quantum error correction, mean to bring full-scale fault-tolerant quantum computing within the grasp of humanity. The breakthroughs needed to attain scalable, error-corrected quantum computation with capabilities exceeding those of classical methods in real-world scenarios is likely still some years away. While striving to address the engineering challenges standing in the way of achieving fault tolerant quantum computing, substantial effort has been focused toward developing and benchmarking hybrid algorithms tailored for the Noisy Intermediate- Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices, available now to researchers. These hybrid quantum-classical algorithms, with the most notable being the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), allow the probing of quantum computing’s utility in computational chemistry even in the face of significant hardware noise and limited coherence times. The work presented in this thesis introduces several key additions the VQE framework, geared especially towards to NISQ hardware, where the mindful use of available resources is imperative. First, the implementation of the Conjugate Model Search optimizer is described, an optimization method that integrates simple models that are surrogate to the original function, combined with conjugate gradient optimization to navigate effectively parameter landscapes typical of variational algorithms, prone to noise. Second, this thesis contains the proposal and extensive study of a hyperparameter tuning procedure employing genetic algorithms, allowing for comprehensive simulation benchmarks that augment the robustness and efficiency of VQE implementations with respect to convergence time through real wall-time models of quantum processors. Continuing, a bridge is presented between quantum simulation and quantum chemistry, through qubit-to-fermion mappings of existing quantum gates, further enabling the direct and accurate modeling of chemical systems on trapped atom quantum hardware with the added arsenal provided by techniques designed for qubit architectures. Additionally, experimental data contained in this thesis include detailed benchmarking data collected from state-of-the-art trapped ion quantum processors available at the Johannes Gutenberg Universität Mainz, demonstrating the actual viability and performance of various methodologies for extracting results. Lastly, the state of VQE is examined, as it served as a springboard for a plethora of advancements in the development of quantum computing hardware, as well as the direction the field of simulation of computational quantum chemistry via quantum devices is headed towards in the coming years.
Quantum simulation of quantum chemistry is one of the most compelling applications of quantum computing. It is of particular importance in areas ranging from materials science, biochemistry, and condensed matter physics. Here, we propose a full quantum eigensolver (FQE) algorithm to calculate the molecular ground energies and electronic structures using quantum gradient descent. Compared to existing classical-quantum hybrid methods such as variational quantum eigensolver (VQE), our method removes the classical optimizer and performs all the calculations on a quantum computer with faster convergence. The gradient descent iteration depth has a favorable complexity that is logarithmically dependent on the system size and inverse of the precision. Moreover, the FQE can be further simplified by exploiting a perturbation theory for the calculations of intermediate matrix elements and obtaining results with a precision that satisfies the requirement of chemistry application. The full quantum eigensolver can be implemented on a near-term quantum computer. With the rapid development of quantum computing hardware, the FQE provides an efficient and powerful tool to solve quantum chemistry problems.
Quantum mechanics has introduced a new theoretical framework for the study of molecules, enabling the prediction of properties and dynamics through the solution of the Schrödinger equation applied to these systems. However, solving this equation is computationally expensive, which has led to the development of various mathematical frameworks and computational methods designed to balance the available resources with the desired level of accuracy. In particular, quantum computers have emerged as a promising technology with the potential to address these problems more efficiently in the coming decades, whether through reductions in memory, time, and energy consumption, i. e., reductions in computational complexity or by enhancing precision. This research field is known as Quantum Simulation. Given the current technological limitations of quantum computers, Variational Quantum Algorithms (VQAs), especially the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), stand out as a feasible approach to demonstrating advantages over classical methods in the near term. This feasibility arises from their lower demand for quantum gates and the reduced depth of the circuits required for their implementation. In this work, we present the application of quantum mechanics to the study of molecules, provide an introduction to the fundamentals of quantum computing, and explore the integration of these fields by employing the VQE in molecular simulations. Finally, we discuss the spatial and temporal complexity associated with the algorithm, highlighting its implications and challenges.
The variational quantum eigensolver (or VQE), first developed by Peruzzo et al. (2014), has received significant attention from the research community in recent years. It uses the variational principle to compute the ground state energy of a Hamiltonian, a problem that is central to quantum chemistry and condensed matter physics. Conventional computing methods are constrained in their accuracy due to the computational limits facing exact modeling of the exponentially growing electronic wavefunction for these many-electron systems. The VQE may be used to model these complex wavefunctions in polynomial time, making it one of the most promising near-term applications for quantum computing. One important advantage is that variational algorithms have been shown to present some degree of resilience to the noise in the quantum hardware. Finding a path to navigate the relevant literature has rapidly become an overwhelming task, with many methods promising to improve different parts of the algorithm, but without clear descriptions of how the diverse parts fit together. The potential practical advantages of the algorithm are also widely discussed in the literature, but with varying conclusions. Despite strong theoretical underpinnings suggesting excellent scaling of individual VQE components, studies have pointed out that their various pre-factors could be too large to reach a quantum computing advantage over conventional methods. This review aims at disentangling the relevant literature to provide a comprehensive overview of the progress that has been made on the different parts of the algorithm, and to discuss future areas of research that are fundamental for the VQE to deliver on its promises. All the different components of the algorithm are reviewed in detail. These include the representation of Hamiltonians and wavefunctions on a quantum computer, the optimization process to find ground state energies, the post processing mitigation of quantum errors, and suggested best practices. We identify four main areas of future research: (1) optimal measurement schemes for reduction of circuit repetitions required; (2) large scale parallelization across many quantum computers; (3) ways to overcome the potential appearance of vanishing gradients in the optimization process for large systems, and how the number of iterations required for the optimization scales with system size; (4) the extent to which VQE suffers for quantum noise, and whether this noise can be mitigated in a tractable manner. The answers to these open research questions will determine the routes for the VQE to achieve quantum advantage as the quantum computing hardware scales up and as the noise levels are reduced.
New approaches into computational quantum chemistry can be developed through the use of quantum computing. While universal, fault-tolerant quantum computers are still not available, and we want to utilize today's noisy quantum processors. One of their flagship applications is the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE)-an algorithm for calculating the minimum energy of a physical Hamiltonian. In this study, we investigate how various types of errors affect the VQE and how to efficiently use the available resources to produce precise computational results. We utilize a simulator of a noisy quantum device, an exact statevector simulator, and physical quantum hardware to study the VQE algorithm for molecular hydrogen. We find that the optimal method of running the hybrid classical-quantum optimization is to: (i) allow some noise in intermediate energy evaluations, using fewer shots per step and fewer optimization iterations, but ensure a high final readout precision; (ii) emphasize efficient problem encoding and ansatz parametrization; and (iii) run all experiments within a short time-frame, avoiding parameter drift with time. Nevertheless, current publicly available quantum resources are still very noisy and scarce/expensive, and even when using them efficiently, it is quite difficult to perform trustworthy calculations of molecular energies.