Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Conference on Computer Communications (INFOCOM)

Faking Bell Violations with Classical Light and Side-Channel Attacks

Abebu Ademe Bayleyegn, Milad Ghadimi, Muhammad Idham Habibie, Riccardo Bassoli, Frank H. P. Fitzek

Published May 18, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Bell inequality tests certify the security of entanglement-based quantum communication protocols, assuming random, hidden-variable-free basis choices and non-reproducible violations using classical sources. In practice, device imperfections and side channels enable adversaries to fake violations with classical light. Prior works focused on passive measurement selection, exploiting fixed beam splitters, detector blinding, and coincidence-time loopholes. Here, we extend this to active basis-choice systems, modeling attacks where an adversary exploits side-channel leakage from the basis-selection control path to gain partial knowledge of Alice’s and Bob’s settings, then sends tailored classical polarized light pulses programmed in timing and polarization to mimic entangled correlations. Using a discrete-event simulator, we model both genuine entangled pairs and classical faking sources in a full photonic quantum communication system. We compute the CHSH parameter S for both. Results show the classical source achieves S in the Tsirelson range $\left( {2 < S \leq 2\sqrt 2 } \right)$, closely mimicking the entangled-source case when assessed using S. Thus, mitigating side-channel leakage, especially in slow basis switching systems, is essential for securing higher-layer quantum protocols.

DOI
10.1109/infocom59046.2026.11571586

Related papers

Hacking the Bell test using classical light in energy-time entanglement–based quantum key distribution

Jonathan Jogenfors, Ashraf Mohamed El Hassan, Johan Ahrens +2 more

Photonic systems based on energy-time entanglement have been proposed to test local realism using the Bell inequality. A violation of this inequality normally also certifies security of device-independent quantum key distribution (QKD) so that an attacker cannot eavesdrop or control the system. We show how this security test can be circumvented in energy-time entangled systems when using standard avalanche photodetectors, allowing an attacker to compromise the system without leaving a trace. We reach Bell values up to 3.63 at 97.6% faked detector efficiency using tailored pulses of classical light, which exceeds even the quantum prediction. This is the first demonstration of a violation-faking source that gives both tunable violation and high faked detector efficiency. The implications are severe: the standard Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality cannot be used to show device-independent security for energy-time entanglement setups based on Franson's configuration. However, device-independent security can be reestablished, and we conclude by listing a number of improved tests and experimental setups that would protect against all current and future attacks of this type.

arXiv:1411.7222•Science Advances•Dec 4, 2015•62 citations

Randomness generation from a CHSH violation on entangled photon pairs from a continuous source without fair sampling assumptions (Conference Presentation)

Christian Kurtsiefer

Quantum physics can provide sources of randomness that can be certified as being uncorrelated to any outside process or variable, i.e. sources of private randomness, based on a violation of a Bell inequality. Initial experimental realizations of such sources of certified randomness are based on atomic or atomic-like systems, but suffer from impractically low generation rates for most applications. High efficiency infrared photodetectors and photon pair sources permitted experimental demonstrations of loophole free violation of the Bell inequality using photons. The random bit generation rate for these setups was on the order of tens per second, where the main limitation is the fixed repetition rate of the photon pair source combined with the small violation observed. In our experiment, we close the detection loophole with a system efficiency over 82%. The source of entangled photon pairs is based on continuously pumped spontaneous parametric down conversion. We estimate a collection efficiency of ≈90% into single mode fibers and detect photons with a transition edge sensors. Detection events are time-tagged and organized into time bins, for which we consider four possible outcomes: one or more detections at Alice’s side, one or more detections at Bob’s side, one or more detections at both Alice’s and Bob’s, and no detection in either channel. These events eventually lead to a CHSH-type Bell inequality that is violated for a range of time bin widths. With such an arrangement, we reach asymptotic device-indepentnet random bit generation rates on the order of 1000 bits per second.

Quantum Photonic Devices•Sep 18, 2018•0 citations

Bell violation with entangled photons, free of the fair-sampling assumption

Marissa Giustina, Alexandra Mech, Sven Ramelow +9 more

Summary form only given. In a Bell experiment, one prepares pairs of entangled particles and sends them to two observers, Alice and Bob, for measurement and detection [1]. For some choices of their measurement settings, Alice and Bob may observe strong correlations between their results in accordance with the predictions of quantum mechanical theory. Conversely, any physical theory that assumes no physical influence can be faster than the speed of light and that properties of physical systems are elements of reality [2] - a local realistic theory - can predict only a limited amount of correlation between Alice's and Bob's measurement outcomes. Upon observing correlations sufficient to violate Bell's inequality, Alice and Bob must abandon local realism.It is common that in an experiment, some particles emitted by the source will not be detected. Then the subset of detected particles might display correlations that violate the Bell inequality although the entire ensemble can be described by a local realistic theory [3]. To achieve a conclusive Bell violation without assuming that the detected particles are a “fair” sample, a highly efficient setup is necessary. Due to experimental limitations, fair sampling has been assumed in most Bell experiments performed to date, and it has never been possible to avoid this assumption with photons due to the absence of efficient sources and detectors. Here we report the first Bell experiment with photons that does not rely on any fair-sampling assumption. In our experiment we employ the Eberhard inequality, a Bell inequality that by construction does not rely on the fair-sampling assumption [4]. Our source of entangled photon pairs utilizes bulk-crystal spontaneous parametric downconversion in a Sagnac configuration, which has shown to be very efficient [5, 6]. For photon detection, we employ superconducting transition-edge sensors, which not only offer high efficiency but also are intrinsically free of dark counts [7]. This combination of features is imperative for an experiment in which no correction of count rates can be tolerated. We achieve uncorrected coupling efficiencies over 73% in each arm of our source, facilitating a violation of the inequality by nearly 70 standard deviations after five minutes of measurement. Since the first experimental Bell test, a satisfactory laboratory realization of the motivating gedankenexperiment has remained an outstanding challenge. The two other main assumptions include “locality” [8, 9] and “freedom of choice” [10]. Invoking any of these renders an experiment vulnerable to explanation by a local realistic theory. The realization of an experiment that is free of all three assumptions-a so-called loopholefree Bell test-remains an important outstanding goal for the physics community with strong implications for quantum technologies. We note that with our experiment, photons are the first physical system for which each of these three assumptions has been successfully addressed, albeit in different experiments. This represents promise for practical applications like one-sided device-independent quantum key distribution [11], and in an additional test, we also demonstrate that our experimental apparatus is capable of implementing this protocol on both sides.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•May 1, 2013•11 citations

Bright-light detector control emulates the local bounds of Bell-type inequalities

Shihan Sajeed, Nigar Sultana, Charles Ci Wen Lim +1 more

It is well-known that no local model-in theory-can simulate the outcome statistics of a Bell-type experiment as long as the detection efficiency is higher than a threshold value. For the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) Bell inequality this theoretical threshold value is [Formula: see text]. On the other hand, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 170404 (2011) outlined an explicit practical model that can fake the CHSH inequality for a detection efficiency of up to 0.5. In this work, we close this gap. More specifically, we propose a method to emulate a Bell inequality at the threshold detection efficiency using existing optical detector control techniques. For a Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality, it emulates the CHSH violation predicted by quantum mechanics up to [Formula: see text]. For the Garg-Mermin inequality-re-calibrated by incorporating non-detection events-our method emulates its exact local bound at any efficiency above the threshold. This confirms that attacks on secure quantum communication protocols based on Bell violation is a real threat if the detection efficiency loophole is not closed.

arXiv:1902.03197•Scientific Reports•Aug 6, 2020•4 citations

Detecting false correlations: Uncovering a faked Bell-inequality violation

M. E. Feldman, G. K. Juul, S. J. van Enk +1 more

It is possible for two parties, Alice and Bob, to establish a secure communication link by sharing an ensemble of entangled particles, and then using these particles to generate a secret key. One way to establish that the particles are indeed entangled is to verify that they violate a Bell inequality. However, it might be the case that Bob is not trustworthy and wishes Alice to believe that their communications are secure, when in fact they are not. He can do this by managing to have prior knowledge of Alice's measurement device settings and then modifying his own settings based upon this information. In this case it is possible for shared particle states that must satisfy a Bell inequality to appear to violate this inequality, which would also make the system appear secure. When Bob modifies his measurement settings, however, he produces false correlations. Here we demonstrate experimentally that Alice can detect these false correlations, and uncover Bob's trickery, by using loop-state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) tomography. More generally, we demonstrate that loop SPAM tomography can detect false correlations (correlated errors) in a two-qubit system without needing to know anything about the prepared states or the measurements, other than the dimensions of the operators that describe them.

arXiv:1802.02526•Feb 7, 2018•0 citations

Towards Securing Quantum Key Distribution at the Source

Amita Gnanapandithan

The importance of secure and high-rate information transmission cannot be understated in today's society. Unfortunately, a security crisis is impending due to the development of quantum computing technologies which can break current encryption schemes. A promising solution is quantum key distribution (QKD), which offers information-theoretic security. However, practical implementations of QKD do not conform to the idealized security assumptions that are made in QKD security proofs and therefore form security loopholes. The discovery of the measurement-device-independent QKD (MDI QKD) protocol presented a rapid leap in QKD research, as it effectively closes all side channels at the detection end of QKD setups, while maintaining experimental feasibility. Naturally, a major remaining obstacle in QKD research is the vulnerability of practical sources. As the clock rate of QKD systems advances into the GHz range, specific imperfections at the source arise. The goal of this PhD thesis is to conduct characterizations of source imperfections (especially those arising from GHz modulation), quantify their impact on security, and find methods to mitigate them. Specifically, this thesis presents the following studies. A) Identification and analysis of a novel side channel in sources using a Faraday mirror for temperature-stabilized polarization modulation, leading to time-dependent passive leakage of quantum states. We demonstrate that precise side-channel characterization (rather than the pessimistic approximations commonly used in the literature) can improve the estimated secret key rate by multiple orders of magnitude. B) Identification and analysis of a new class of source side channels (hidden multidimensional modulation side channels), using high-speed time-varying encoding as an illustrative case example (which we characterize using experimental and simulation-based methods). We demonstrate that hidden degrees of freedom, such as time, may be coupled to the encoding process, enabling unambiguous state discrimination attacks. In our illustrative case example, this causes the maximum secure transmission distance to be reduced by over 50%. C) Experimental and simulation-based characterization of phase correlations at GHz repetition rates when using electro-optic phase modulation for phase/polarization encoding. Our findings indicate that pattern-dependent phase deviations are on the order of 0.01pi. D) Design and experimental demonstration of a path-selection modulation source -- a source using no active phase modulation components (to mitigate the side channels arising from such components). Phase randomization is achieved through gain-switching and polarization encoding is achieved by randomly selecting between multiple paths, each path corresponding to one of the desired encoded states. Overall, by identifying and characterizing multiple source side channels, this thesis underscores the importance of avoiding unwarranted assumptions regarding the security of QKD sources. Hidden imperfections can introduce significant security vulnerabilities, and these must be continually identified and analyzed. Furthermore, this thesis highlights the value of advancing key rate analysis techniques that can accommodate a broad range of implementation flaws while producing tight security bounds, thereby enabling precise characterization of the information leakage arising from such imperfections. Finally, this thesis emphasizes that active modulators, in general, constitute a major source of potential side channels, highlighting the importance of exploring modulator-free sources. The path-selection modulation scheme presented here provides a practically feasible example of such a source.

•Jun 1, 2026•0 citations
Bell inequality tests certify the security of entanglement-based quantum communication protocols, assuming random, hidden-variable-free basis choices and non-reproducible violations using classical sources. In practice, device imperfections and side channels enable adversaries to fake violations with classical light. Prior works focused on passive measurement selection, exploiting fixed beam splitters, detector blinding, and coincidence-time loopholes. Here, we extend this to active basis-choice systems, modeling attacks where an adversary exploits side-channel leakage from the basis-selection control path to gain partial knowledge of Alice’s and Bob’s settings, then sends tailored classical polarized light pulses programmed in timing and polarization to mimic entangled correlations. Using a discrete-event simulator, we model both genuine entangled pairs and classical faking sources in a full photonic quantum communication system. We compute the CHSH parameter S for both. Results show the classical source achieves S in the Tsirelson range (2<S≤22)\left( {2 < S \leq 2\sqrt 2 } \right)(2<S≤22​), closely mimicking the entangled-source case when assessed using S. Thus, mitigating side-channel leakage, especially in slow basis switching systems, is essential for securing higher-layer quantum protocols.
Photonic systems based on energy-time entanglement have been proposed to test local realism using the Bell inequality. A violation of this inequality normally also certifies security of device-independent quantum key distribution (QKD) so that an attacker cannot eavesdrop or control the system. We show how this security test can be circumvented in energy-time entangled systems when using standard avalanche photodetectors, allowing an attacker to compromise the system without leaving a trace. We reach Bell values up to 3.63 at 97.6% faked detector efficiency using tailored pulses of classical light, which exceeds even the quantum prediction. This is the first demonstration of a violation-faking source that gives both tunable violation and high faked detector efficiency. The implications are severe: the standard Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality cannot be used to show device-independent security for energy-time entanglement setups based on Franson's configuration. However, device-independent security can be reestablished, and we conclude by listing a number of improved tests and experimental setups that would protect against all current and future attacks of this type.
Quantum physics can provide sources of randomness that can be certified as being uncorrelated to any outside process or variable, i.e. sources of private randomness, based on a violation of a Bell inequality. Initial experimental realizations of such sources of certified randomness are based on atomic or atomic-like systems, but suffer from impractically low generation rates for most applications. High efficiency infrared photodetectors and photon pair sources permitted experimental demonstrations of loophole free violation of the Bell inequality using photons. The random bit generation rate for these setups was on the order of tens per second, where the main limitation is the fixed repetition rate of the photon pair source combined with the small violation observed. In our experiment, we close the detection loophole with a system efficiency over 82%. The source of entangled photon pairs is based on continuously pumped spontaneous parametric down conversion. We estimate a collection efficiency of ≈90% into single mode fibers and detect photons with a transition edge sensors. Detection events are time-tagged and organized into time bins, for which we consider four possible outcomes: one or more detections at Alice’s side, one or more detections at Bob’s side, one or more detections at both Alice’s and Bob’s, and no detection in either channel. These events eventually lead to a CHSH-type Bell inequality that is violated for a range of time bin widths. With such an arrangement, we reach asymptotic device-indepentnet random bit generation rates on the order of 1000 bits per second.
Summary form only given. In a Bell experiment, one prepares pairs of entangled particles and sends them to two observers, Alice and Bob, for measurement and detection [1]. For some choices of their measurement settings, Alice and Bob may observe strong correlations between their results in accordance with the predictions of quantum mechanical theory. Conversely, any physical theory that assumes no physical influence can be faster than the speed of light and that properties of physical systems are elements of reality [2] - a local realistic theory - can predict only a limited amount of correlation between Alice's and Bob's measurement outcomes. Upon observing correlations sufficient to violate Bell's inequality, Alice and Bob must abandon local realism.It is common that in an experiment, some particles emitted by the source will not be detected. Then the subset of detected particles might display correlations that violate the Bell inequality although the entire ensemble can be described by a local realistic theory [3]. To achieve a conclusive Bell violation without assuming that the detected particles are a “fair” sample, a highly efficient setup is necessary. Due to experimental limitations, fair sampling has been assumed in most Bell experiments performed to date, and it has never been possible to avoid this assumption with photons due to the absence of efficient sources and detectors. Here we report the first Bell experiment with photons that does not rely on any fair-sampling assumption. In our experiment we employ the Eberhard inequality, a Bell inequality that by construction does not rely on the fair-sampling assumption [4]. Our source of entangled photon pairs utilizes bulk-crystal spontaneous parametric downconversion in a Sagnac configuration, which has shown to be very efficient [5, 6]. For photon detection, we employ superconducting transition-edge sensors, which not only offer high efficiency but also are intrinsically free of dark counts [7]. This combination of features is imperative for an experiment in which no correction of count rates can be tolerated. We achieve uncorrected coupling efficiencies over 73% in each arm of our source, facilitating a violation of the inequality by nearly 70 standard deviations after five minutes of measurement. Since the first experimental Bell test, a satisfactory laboratory realization of the motivating gedankenexperiment has remained an outstanding challenge. The two other main assumptions include “locality” [8, 9] and “freedom of choice” [10]. Invoking any of these renders an experiment vulnerable to explanation by a local realistic theory. The realization of an experiment that is free of all three assumptions-a so-called loopholefree Bell test-remains an important outstanding goal for the physics community with strong implications for quantum technologies. We note that with our experiment, photons are the first physical system for which each of these three assumptions has been successfully addressed, albeit in different experiments. This represents promise for practical applications like one-sided device-independent quantum key distribution [11], and in an additional test, we also demonstrate that our experimental apparatus is capable of implementing this protocol on both sides.
It is well-known that no local model-in theory-can simulate the outcome statistics of a Bell-type experiment as long as the detection efficiency is higher than a threshold value. For the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) Bell inequality this theoretical threshold value is [Formula: see text]. On the other hand, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 170404 (2011) outlined an explicit practical model that can fake the CHSH inequality for a detection efficiency of up to 0.5. In this work, we close this gap. More specifically, we propose a method to emulate a Bell inequality at the threshold detection efficiency using existing optical detector control techniques. For a Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality, it emulates the CHSH violation predicted by quantum mechanics up to [Formula: see text]. For the Garg-Mermin inequality-re-calibrated by incorporating non-detection events-our method emulates its exact local bound at any efficiency above the threshold. This confirms that attacks on secure quantum communication protocols based on Bell violation is a real threat if the detection efficiency loophole is not closed.
It is possible for two parties, Alice and Bob, to establish a secure communication link by sharing an ensemble of entangled particles, and then using these particles to generate a secret key. One way to establish that the particles are indeed entangled is to verify that they violate a Bell inequality. However, it might be the case that Bob is not trustworthy and wishes Alice to believe that their communications are secure, when in fact they are not. He can do this by managing to have prior knowledge of Alice's measurement device settings and then modifying his own settings based upon this information. In this case it is possible for shared particle states that must satisfy a Bell inequality to appear to violate this inequality, which would also make the system appear secure. When Bob modifies his measurement settings, however, he produces false correlations. Here we demonstrate experimentally that Alice can detect these false correlations, and uncover Bob's trickery, by using loop-state-preparation-and-measurement (SPAM) tomography. More generally, we demonstrate that loop SPAM tomography can detect false correlations (correlated errors) in a two-qubit system without needing to know anything about the prepared states or the measurements, other than the dimensions of the operators that describe them.
The importance of secure and high-rate information transmission cannot be understated in today's society. Unfortunately, a security crisis is impending due to the development of quantum computing technologies which can break current encryption schemes. A promising solution is quantum key distribution (QKD), which offers information-theoretic security. However, practical implementations of QKD do not conform to the idealized security assumptions that are made in QKD security proofs and therefore form security loopholes. The discovery of the measurement-device-independent QKD (MDI QKD) protocol presented a rapid leap in QKD research, as it effectively closes all side channels at the detection end of QKD setups, while maintaining experimental feasibility. Naturally, a major remaining obstacle in QKD research is the vulnerability of practical sources. As the clock rate of QKD systems advances into the GHz range, specific imperfections at the source arise. The goal of this PhD thesis is to conduct characterizations of source imperfections (especially those arising from GHz modulation), quantify their impact on security, and find methods to mitigate them. Specifically, this thesis presents the following studies. A) Identification and analysis of a novel side channel in sources using a Faraday mirror for temperature-stabilized polarization modulation, leading to time-dependent passive leakage of quantum states. We demonstrate that precise side-channel characterization (rather than the pessimistic approximations commonly used in the literature) can improve the estimated secret key rate by multiple orders of magnitude. B) Identification and analysis of a new class of source side channels (hidden multidimensional modulation side channels), using high-speed time-varying encoding as an illustrative case example (which we characterize using experimental and simulation-based methods). We demonstrate that hidden degrees of freedom, such as time, may be coupled to the encoding process, enabling unambiguous state discrimination attacks. In our illustrative case example, this causes the maximum secure transmission distance to be reduced by over 50%. C) Experimental and simulation-based characterization of phase correlations at GHz repetition rates when using electro-optic phase modulation for phase/polarization encoding. Our findings indicate that pattern-dependent phase deviations are on the order of 0.01pi. D) Design and experimental demonstration of a path-selection modulation source -- a source using no active phase modulation components (to mitigate the side channels arising from such components). Phase randomization is achieved through gain-switching and polarization encoding is achieved by randomly selecting between multiple paths, each path corresponding to one of the desired encoded states. Overall, by identifying and characterizing multiple source side channels, this thesis underscores the importance of avoiding unwarranted assumptions regarding the security of QKD sources. Hidden imperfections can introduce significant security vulnerabilities, and these must be continually identified and analyzed. Furthermore, this thesis highlights the value of advancing key rate analysis techniques that can accommodate a broad range of implementation flaws while producing tight security bounds, thereby enabling precise characterization of the information leakage arising from such imperfections. Finally, this thesis emphasizes that active modulators, in general, constitute a major source of potential side channels, highlighting the importance of exploring modulator-free sources. The path-selection modulation scheme presented here provides a practically feasible example of such a source.