Deriving Hydrogen Spectrum Based on a Classical Electron in a Quantized Coulomb Potential with Runge–Lenz Symmetry: An Alternative to the Standard Quantum Theory
The hydrogen atom has historically played a foundational role in the development of quantum mechanics, where its discrete energy spectrum is conventionally derived from solutions of the Schrödinger wave equation. In this work we present an alternative formulation in which the hydrogen spectrum emerges without invoking the Schrödinger equation. We consider a semi-quantum framework in which the electron is treated as a classical particle governed by Poisson-bracket dynamics while interacting with a quantized electromagnetic field described using second quantization. The electron moves in the Coulomb potential generated by the proton and simultaneously couples to quantized electromagnetic modes through minimal coupling. The Coulomb system possesses a hidden dynamical symmetry characterized by the Runge–Lenz vector, which enlarges the rotational symmetry to an group for bound states. Within this framework, interactions between the classical particle and the quantized field induce an effective commutation structure in the particle’s phase space. Once this structure emerges, the algebra of the conserved quantities associated with the Runge–Lenz vector becomes identical to the operator algebra used in Pauli’s symmetry-based derivation of the hydrogen spectrum. Consequently, the discrete hydrogen energy levels arise naturally from the combined effects of Coulomb symmetry and particle–field interaction, offering a physically transparent interpretation of atomic quantization and suggesting that wave–particle duality may arise dynamically from interactions with quantized electromagnetic fields.
The hydrogen atom has historically played a foundational role in the development of quantum mechanics, where its discrete energy spectrum is conventionally derived from solutions of the Schrödinger wave equation. In this work we present an alternative formulation in which the hydrogen spectrum emerges without invoking the Schrödinger equation. We consider a semi-quantum framework in which the electron is treated as a classical particle governed by Poisson-bracket dynamics while interacting with a quantized electromagnetic field described using second quantization. The electron moves in the Coulomb potential generated by the proton and simultaneously couples to quantized electromagnetic modes through minimal coupling. The Coulomb system possesses a hidden dynamical symmetry characterized by the Runge–Lenz vector, which enlarges the rotational symmetry to an group for bound states. Within this framework, interactions between the classical particle and the quantized field induce an effective commutation structure in the particle’s phase space. Once this structure emerges, the algebra of the conserved quantities associated with the Runge–Lenz vector becomes identical to the operator algebra used in Pauli’s symmetry-based derivation of the hydrogen spectrum. Consequently, the discrete hydrogen energy levels arise naturally from the combined effects of Coulomb symmetry and particle–field interaction, offering a physically transparent interpretation of atomic quantization and suggesting that wave–particle duality may arise dynamically from interactions with quantized electromagnetic fields.
The Pauli method of quantizing the Hydrogen system using the Runge-Lenz vector is ingenious. It is well known that the energy spectrum is identical with the one obtained from the Schrödinger equation and the consistency contributed significantly to the development of Quantum Mechanics in the early days. Since the Runge-Lenz vector is a vector and it commutes with the Hamiltonian, it is natural to use it to connect energy eigenstate ∣n,l,m⟩ with other degenerate states ∣n,l±1,m′⟩. Recursive relations can be obtained and the wave functions of the whole spectrum can be obtained easily. Note that the recursive relations are consistent with those used in factorizing the Schrödinger equation. Nevertheless, the present analysis provide a better reasoning originated from the conserved vector, the Runge-Lenz vector. As in the Pauli analysis, group theory or symmetry plays a prominent role in the present analysis, while the rest of the derivations are mostly elementary.
The Pauli method of quantizing the Hydrogen system using the Runge-Lenz vector is ingenious. It is well known that the energy spectrum is identical with the one obtained from the Schrödinger equation and the consistency contributed significantly to the development of Quantum Mechanics in the early days. Since the Runge-Lenz vector is a vector and it commutes with the Hamiltonian, it is natural to use it to connect energy eigenstate with other degenerate states . Recursive relations can be obtained and the energy eigenstate wave functions of the whole spectrum can be obtained easily. Note that the recursive relations are consistent with those used in factorizing the Schrödinger equation. Nevertheless, this analysis provides a better reasoning originated from the conserved vector, the Runge-Lenz vector. As in the Pauli analysis, group theory or symmetry plays a prominent role in this analysis, while the rest of the derivations are elementary.
This paper proposes a theoretical model in which the coupling between the electron and proton inside the hydrogen atom generates a confined electromagnetic field characterized by stable resonant modes. The model assumes that this field propagates at the speed of light and forms standing-wave structures confined within the atomic system. Unlike conventional interpretations that treat the electron purely as a probabilistic quantum object, the present approach considers the possibility that quantized atomic behavior emerges from resonant electromagnetic confinement.The study introduces a resonance-based framework capable of linking atomic stability to discrete electromagnetic frequencies associated with the hydrogen atom. Specific resonant frequencies and wavelength relations are derived and compared with known spectral transitions. The model further predicts the existence of internally confined electromagnetic patterns that may explain energy quantization from a wave-resonance perspective.In addition, the proposed framework offers potential reinterpretations of atomic transitions, field localization, and energy exchange mechanisms inside simple atomic systems. The work is presented as a preliminary theoretical foundation intended for further mathematical development, analytical derivation, and experimental examination.
Pauli first noticed the hidden SO(4) symmetry for the Hydrogen atom in the early stages of quantum mechanics [1]. Departing from that symmetry, one can recover the spectrum of a spinless hydrogen atom and the degeneracy of its states without explicitly solving Schrodinger's equation [2]. In this paper, we derive that SO(4) symmetry and spectrum using a computer algebra system (CAS). While this problem is well known [3, 4], its solution involves several steps of manipulating expressions with tensorial quantum operators, simplifying them by taking into account a combination of commutator rules and Einstein's sum rule for repeated indices. Therefore, it is an excellent model to test the current status of CAS concerning this kind of quantum-and-tensor-algebra computations. Generally speaking, when capable, CAS can significantly help with manipulations that, like non-commutative tensor calculus subject to algebra rules, are tedious, time-consuming and error-prone. The presentation also shows a pattern of computer algebra operations that can be useful for systematically tackling more complicated symbolic problems of this kind.
This paper presents a quantum-field-theoretic formulation of the hydrogen 2p → 1s Lyman-α transition, replacing the semiclassical Bohr–Maxwell description with the modern framework of quantum electrodynamics. The initial and final bound-electron states are described by the Dirac equation in the proton’s Coulomb field, with the Schrödinger equation recovered as the leading nonrelativistic limit. The electromagnetic radiation field is quantized, and photon emission is generated by the QED interaction Hamiltonian. The transition amplitude is evaluated from the atomic current and quantized electromagnetic field, leading through Fermi’s golden rule to the spontaneous-emission rate and Einstein coefficient A₂₁. Energy and momentum conservation require the emitted photon to carry the atomic transition energy, including the small correction associated with proton recoil. At leading order, the Lyman-α photon has ΔE ≈ 10.2 eV, ν ≈ 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz, and λ ≈ 121.6 nm. In the electric-dipole approximation, the field-theoretic calculation reduces to the standard matrix element of the interaction Hamiltonian H_int = −μ·E, thereby connecting QED directly to the transition dipole moment, oscillator strength, Einstein A coefficient, and radiative lifetime. The calculation reproduces the accepted numerical results for hydrogen while identifying their origin in the coupling between the quantized electron field and the quantized electromagnetic field. The paper also explains how classical electrodynamics is recovered from QED. Maxwell’s equations govern the expectation values of the electromagnetic-field operators in the appropriate classical-field limit, particularly for coherent states containing many photons. A single spontaneously emitted Lyman-α photon, however, remains a genuinely quantum excitation rather than a classical electromagnetic wave. Leading corrections beyond the nonrelativistic Coulomb approximation are then considered, including relativistic fine structure, the Lamb shift, and atomic recoil. The resulting treatment provides a rigorous bridge from the historical Bohr model and Schrödinger wave mechanics to Dirac theory and full QED, verifying the Lyman-α energy, frequency, wavelength, transition probability, and radiative decay structure within a unified quantum-field framework.
This paper develops and verifies a physics-first description of the hydrogen-atom transition from the L shell (n = 2) to the K shell (n = 1) by combining the historical Bohr model of atomic structure with classical Maxwell electrodynamics. Beginning with the Coulomb force, centripetal dynamics, and Bohr’s angular-momentum quantization condition, the analysis derives the allowed orbital radii, electron velocities, angular momenta, kinetic energies, electrostatic potential energies, and total bound-state energies of the hydrogen atom. For the n = 2 → n = 1 transition, the calculated energy difference is approximately 10.2 eV, corresponding through the Planck–Einstein relation ΔE = hν to a frequency of approximately 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz and a wavelength near 121.6 nm, consistent with the hydrogen Lyman-α transition. The emitted radiation is then examined through Maxwell’s equations and the vacuum constitutive relations. The resulting electromagnetic-wave description yields the transverse electric and magnetic fields together with the associated electromagnetic energy density, Poynting energy flux, momentum density, radiation pressure, and Maxwell stress tensor. In this way, the atomic energy difference obtained from the Bohr model is connected quantitatively to the classical propagation properties of the outgoing electromagnetic radiation. The derivation is mathematically consistent as a historical Bohr–Maxwell reconstruction, but it does not constitute a closed dynamical theory of spontaneous emission. The essential bridge between discrete atomic energy levels and the continuous Maxwell field is supplied by the quantum frequency condition ΔE = hν. Neither classical Maxwell electrodynamics nor Newtonian orbital mechanics independently derives this relation, and classical Maxwell theory does not by itself quantize the emitted radiation energy into individual photons. A complete treatment of spontaneous emission, transition probabilities, radiative lifetimes, and photon-field quantization requires quantum mechanics and ultimately quantum electrodynamics. Accordingly, the framework is presented as a verified correspondence between established limiting descriptions rather than as a replacement for Schrödinger wave mechanics, Dirac theory, or quantum electrodynamics. By clearly separating the atomic bound-state calculation, the quantum energy-frequency bridge, and the classical electromagnetic propagation problem, the analysis provides a rigorous conceptual and mathematical foundation for subsequent Maxwell–Schrödinger, Dirac–Maxwell, quantum-electrodynamic, Maxwell–Scretching, and Scretching Quantum Chain formulations of hydrogenic radiative transitions.