Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Empirical Testing of Quantum-Like Contextuality in Mass Consciousness Structures: Analysis of ESS9 Data

Dmitry Timofeev

Published Mar 2, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This article presents a comprehensive empirical test of the applicability of quantum theory apparatus for modelling social attitudes based on data from the 9th round of the European Social Survey (ESS9 MTMM). The work implements a dual analytical design: (1) testing the Bell inequality in the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) modification to detect non-classical contextual correlations, and (2) a critical analysis of Classical Test Theory (CTT) through the lens of MTMM models. The results demonstrate that the system of political attitudes remains within the classical limit (|S| ≤ 2). A key finding is the pervasive violation of classical MTMM validity criteria across all 29 participating countries.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18830816

Related papers

The Role of Observer and Contextuality in Survey Measurement: A Quantum-Logical Model of Systematic Bias in Russian Polling Data (2018-2025)

Timofeev, Dmitry

Context This working paper is part of a larger research programme connecting quantum physics and social subjectivity through a common logical foundation (Sorkin's anhomomorphic logic). It serves as Example 1 in a conceptual framework titled "Emergent Time: From Quantum Physics to Social Subjectivity" (Timofeev, 2025). Motivation The systematic divergence between Russian state-affiliated and independent polling organizations (consistently 5-20 percentage points, peaking at 15-25 p.p. during political crises) provides a natural experiment for testing quantum-logical properties in social measurement. Unlike Western polling discrepancies attributed to sampling or methodology, the Russian case demonstrates observer-dependent collapse: the identity of the measuring organization fundamentally determines the measured outcome. Theoretical Framework Drawing on: Sorkin (1994): Anhomomorphic logic as meta-structure for contextual systems Dzhafarov & Kujala (2012): Contextuality-by-Default model Stephenson (1953) & Brown (1980): Q-methodology as operationalization of quantum logic Bourdieu (1972): Symbolic violence and habitus formation Empirical Basis Uses publicly available aggregated data from 10 verified sources (Levada Center, VCIOM, Reuters, Carnegie Endowment, Statista, etc.) covering 2018-2025, documenting systematic patterns across: 2018 Pension Reform crisis 2019 VCIOM methodology change (closed vs open questions) 2022 Ukraine invasion ("Special Military Operation") 2023-2025 stabilization period Three-Level Analysis Classical level: Political manipulation through sampling bias and question wording Non-classical level: Exploitation of fundamental contextual properties (superposition, collapse) Epistemological level: Masking constitutive measurement as "scientific discovery" Implications Methodological: Classical survey methodology inadequate for sensitive political contexts Philosophical: "Public opinion" may not exist as determinate entity prior to measurement (supporting Bourdieu's 1972 thesis "l'opinion publique n'existe pas") Political: Authoritarian regimes intuitively exploit quantum-logical properties for reality construction Empirical: Proposes falsifiable test via Bell-CHSH inequalities (requires microdata access) Limitations Based on aggregated public data, not individual-level microdata CHSH inequality test remains theoretical proposal, not conducted Culturally specific to Russian political context (generalizability requires cross-national replication) Alternative classical explanations (sampling bias, social desirability) not fully ruled out without microdata Intended Audience Quantum social science researchers Survey methodologists Political sociologists studying authoritarianism Philosophers of social science Q-methodology practitioners

•Nov 12, 2025•0 citations

Quantum contextuality in N -boson systems

Fabio Benatti, Roberto Floreanini B, Marco Genovese +1 more

Quantum contextuality in systems of identical bosonic particles is explicitly exhibited via the maximum violation of a suitable inequality of Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt type. Unlike the approaches considered so far, which make use of single-particle observables, our analysis involves collective observables constructed using multiboson operators. An exemplifying scheme to test this violation with a quantum optical setup is also discussed.

arXiv:1109.1106•Physical Review A•Sep 15, 2011•3 citations

On the applicability of Kolmogorov's theory of probability to the description of quantum phenomena. Part II: Bell inequalities

Maik Reddiger

Among the various "no-go theorems" in the foundations of quantum mechanics, Bell inequalities are among the few, which do not implicitly rely on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics. Instead, Bell inequalities are commonly understood to rest on Kolmogorov's theory of probability and a "locality" assumption. Physical evidence supporting their violation is hence taken as evidence against at least one of these two assumptions. This work provides a comprehensive analysis of the physical debate on Bell inequalities from the point of view of Kolmogorov's theory of probability, focusing on the Bell-Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequality (BCHSH inequality). The central contribution is the motivation and mathematical study of the notion of contextuality in Bell experiments: in so-called contextual Bell models the detectors themselves behave randomly and the distribution of the random detector parameters depends on the chosen detector settings. It is shown how even "classical" Bell experiments motivate such a description. The need to account for contextuality was pointed out before by de la Peña, Cetto, Brody, Lochak, Bohm, Hiley and others. A broad class of contextual models is proven to satisfy the BCHSH inequality, thereby generalizing a previous result by Gill and Lambare. Nonetheless, even under strong locality requirements, contextual Bell models may violate the BCHSH inequality: based on work by Popescu and Rohrlich, we consider a "proof of concept" example exhibiting the maximum possible violation. Contrary to the much debated "loopholes" in empirical tests of Bell inequalities, contextuality thus reveals a conceptual misunderstanding in the physical conclusions commonly drawn from Bell inequality violations.

quant-pharXiv:2609.31075•Sep 28, 2026•0 citations

Violation of Leggett–Garg Inequality in Perceiving Cup-like Objects and Cognitive Contextuality

Likan Zhan, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Yingce Zhu

This paper is devoted to an experimental investigation of cognitive contextuality inspired by quantum contextuality research. This contextuality is related to, but not identical to context-sensitivity which is well-studied in cognitive psychology and decision making. This paper is a part of quantum-like modeling, i.e., exploring the methodology of quantum theory outside of physics. We examined the bistable perception of cup-like objects, which strongly depends on experimental contexts. Our experimental data confirmed the existence of cognitive hysteresis, the important role of memory, and the non-commutative structure of cognitive observables. In physics, quantum contextuality is assessed using Bell-CHSH inequalities, and their violation is incorrectly believed to imply the nonlocality of Nature. The violation of Bell-type inequalities in cognitive and social science strongly indicates that the metaphysical implications of these inequalities are quite limited. In our experiments, modified Leggett-Garg inequalities were also significantly violated, but this only means that experimental data from experiments performed in different contexts cannot be modeled by a unique set of noncontextual, jointly distributed random variables. In our experiments, we know the empirical probability distributions measured in different contexts; thus, we can obtain much more detailed and reliable information about contextuality in human cognition by performing nonparametric compatibility tests.

Entropy•Nov 5, 2024•0 citations

Tests for quantum contextuality in terms of Q-entropies

Alexey E. Rastegin

The information-theoretic approach to Bell's theorem is developed with use of the conditional $q$-entropies. The $q$-entropic measures fulfill many similar properties to the standard Shannon entropy. In general, both the locality and noncontextuality notions are usually treated with use of the so-called marginal scenarios. These hypotheses lead to the existence of a joint probability distribution, which marginalizes to all particular ones. Assuming the existence of such a joint probability distribution, we derive the family of inequalities of Bell's type in terms of conditional $q$-entropies for all $q\geq1$. Quantum violations of the new inequalities are exemplified within the Clauser--Horne--Shimony--Holt (CHSH) and Klyachko--Can--Binicio\v{g}lu--Shumovsky (KCBS) scenarios. An extension to the case of $n$-cycle scenario is briefly mentioned. The new inequalities with conditional $q$-entropies allow to expand a class of probability distributions, for which the nonlocality or contextuality can be detected within entropic formulation. The $q$-entropic inequalities can also be useful in analyzing cases with detection inefficiencies. Using two models of such a kind, we consider some potential advantages of the $q$-entropic formulation.

arXiv:1210.6742•Quantum Information and Computation•Sep 1, 2014•18 citations

Is there contextuality in behavioural and social systems?

E. N. Dzhafarov, Ru Zhang, Janne V. Kujala

Most behavioural and social experiments aimed at revealing contextuality are confined to cyclic systems with binary outcomes. In quantum physics, this broad class of systems includes as special cases Klyachko-Can-Binicioglu-Shumovsky-type, Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bell-type and Suppes-Zanotti-Leggett-Garg-type systems. The theory of contextuality known as contextuality-by-default allows one to define and measure contextuality in all such systems, even if there are context-dependent errors in measurements, or if something in the contexts directly interacts with the measurements. This makes the theory especially suitable for behavioural and social systems, where direct interactions of 'everything with everything' are ubiquitous. For cyclic systems with binary outcomes, the theory provides necessary and sufficient conditions for non-contextuality, and these conditions are known to be breached in certain quantum systems. We review several behavioural and social datasets (from polls of public opinion to visual illusions to conjoint choices to word combinations to psychophysical matching), and none of these data provides any evidence for contextuality. Our working hypothesis is that this may be a broadly applicable rule: behavioural and social systems are non-contextual, i.e. all 'contextual effects' in them result from the ubiquitous dependence of response distributions on the elements of contexts other than the ones to which the response is presumably or normatively directed.

arXiv:1504.07422•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 30, 2015•89 citations
This article presents a comprehensive empirical test of the applicability of quantum theory apparatus for modelling social attitudes based on data from the 9th round of the European Social Survey (ESS9 MTMM). The work implements a dual analytical design: (1) testing the Bell inequality in the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) modification to detect non-classical contextual correlations, and (2) a critical analysis of Classical Test Theory (CTT) through the lens of MTMM models. The results demonstrate that the system of political attitudes remains within the classical limit (|S| ≤ 2). A key finding is the pervasive violation of classical MTMM validity criteria across all 29 participating countries.
Context This working paper is part of a larger research programme connecting quantum physics and social subjectivity through a common logical foundation (Sorkin's anhomomorphic logic). It serves as Example 1 in a conceptual framework titled "Emergent Time: From Quantum Physics to Social Subjectivity" (Timofeev, 2025). Motivation The systematic divergence between Russian state-affiliated and independent polling organizations (consistently 5-20 percentage points, peaking at 15-25 p.p. during political crises) provides a natural experiment for testing quantum-logical properties in social measurement. Unlike Western polling discrepancies attributed to sampling or methodology, the Russian case demonstrates observer-dependent collapse: the identity of the measuring organization fundamentally determines the measured outcome. Theoretical Framework Drawing on: Sorkin (1994): Anhomomorphic logic as meta-structure for contextual systems Dzhafarov & Kujala (2012): Contextuality-by-Default model Stephenson (1953) & Brown (1980): Q-methodology as operationalization of quantum logic Bourdieu (1972): Symbolic violence and habitus formation Empirical Basis Uses publicly available aggregated data from 10 verified sources (Levada Center, VCIOM, Reuters, Carnegie Endowment, Statista, etc.) covering 2018-2025, documenting systematic patterns across: 2018 Pension Reform crisis 2019 VCIOM methodology change (closed vs open questions) 2022 Ukraine invasion ("Special Military Operation") 2023-2025 stabilization period Three-Level Analysis Classical level: Political manipulation through sampling bias and question wording Non-classical level: Exploitation of fundamental contextual properties (superposition, collapse) Epistemological level: Masking constitutive measurement as "scientific discovery" Implications Methodological: Classical survey methodology inadequate for sensitive political contexts Philosophical: "Public opinion" may not exist as determinate entity prior to measurement (supporting Bourdieu's 1972 thesis "l'opinion publique n'existe pas") Political: Authoritarian regimes intuitively exploit quantum-logical properties for reality construction Empirical: Proposes falsifiable test via Bell-CHSH inequalities (requires microdata access) Limitations Based on aggregated public data, not individual-level microdata CHSH inequality test remains theoretical proposal, not conducted Culturally specific to Russian political context (generalizability requires cross-national replication) Alternative classical explanations (sampling bias, social desirability) not fully ruled out without microdata Intended Audience Quantum social science researchers Survey methodologists Political sociologists studying authoritarianism Philosophers of social science Q-methodology practitioners
Among the various "no-go theorems" in the foundations of quantum mechanics, Bell inequalities are among the few, which do not implicitly rely on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics. Instead, Bell inequalities are commonly understood to rest on Kolmogorov's theory of probability and a "locality" assumption. Physical evidence supporting their violation is hence taken as evidence against at least one of these two assumptions. This work provides a comprehensive analysis of the physical debate on Bell inequalities from the point of view of Kolmogorov's theory of probability, focusing on the Bell-Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequality (BCHSH inequality). The central contribution is the motivation and mathematical study of the notion of contextuality in Bell experiments: in so-called contextual Bell models the detectors themselves behave randomly and the distribution of the random detector parameters depends on the chosen detector settings. It is shown how even "classical" Bell experiments motivate such a description. The need to account for contextuality was pointed out before by de la Peña, Cetto, Brody, Lochak, Bohm, Hiley and others. A broad class of contextual models is proven to satisfy the BCHSH inequality, thereby generalizing a previous result by Gill and Lambare. Nonetheless, even under strong locality requirements, contextual Bell models may violate the BCHSH inequality: based on work by Popescu and Rohrlich, we consider a "proof of concept" example exhibiting the maximum possible violation. Contrary to the much debated "loopholes" in empirical tests of Bell inequalities, contextuality thus reveals a conceptual misunderstanding in the physical conclusions commonly drawn from Bell inequality violations.
This paper is devoted to an experimental investigation of cognitive contextuality inspired by quantum contextuality research. This contextuality is related to, but not identical to context-sensitivity which is well-studied in cognitive psychology and decision making. This paper is a part of quantum-like modeling, i.e., exploring the methodology of quantum theory outside of physics. We examined the bistable perception of cup-like objects, which strongly depends on experimental contexts. Our experimental data confirmed the existence of cognitive hysteresis, the important role of memory, and the non-commutative structure of cognitive observables. In physics, quantum contextuality is assessed using Bell-CHSH inequalities, and their violation is incorrectly believed to imply the nonlocality of Nature. The violation of Bell-type inequalities in cognitive and social science strongly indicates that the metaphysical implications of these inequalities are quite limited. In our experiments, modified Leggett-Garg inequalities were also significantly violated, but this only means that experimental data from experiments performed in different contexts cannot be modeled by a unique set of noncontextual, jointly distributed random variables. In our experiments, we know the empirical probability distributions measured in different contexts; thus, we can obtain much more detailed and reliable information about contextuality in human cognition by performing nonparametric compatibility tests.
The information-theoretic approach to Bell's theorem is developed with use of the conditional qqq-entropies. The qqq-entropic measures fulfill many similar properties to the standard Shannon entropy. In general, both the locality and noncontextuality notions are usually treated with use of the so-called marginal scenarios. These hypotheses lead to the existence of a joint probability distribution, which marginalizes to all particular ones. Assuming the existence of such a joint probability distribution, we derive the family of inequalities of Bell's type in terms of conditional qqq-entropies for all q≥1q\geq1q≥1. Quantum violations of the new inequalities are exemplified within the Clauser--Horne--Shimony--Holt (CHSH) and Klyachko--Can--Binicio\v{g}lu--Shumovsky (KCBS) scenarios. An extension to the case of nnn-cycle scenario is briefly mentioned. The new inequalities with conditional qqq-entropies allow to expand a class of probability distributions, for which the nonlocality or contextuality can be detected within entropic formulation. The qqq-entropic inequalities can also be useful in analyzing cases with detection inefficiencies. Using two models of such a kind, we consider some potential advantages of the qqq-entropic formulation.
Most behavioural and social experiments aimed at revealing contextuality are confined to cyclic systems with binary outcomes. In quantum physics, this broad class of systems includes as special cases Klyachko-Can-Binicioglu-Shumovsky-type, Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bell-type and Suppes-Zanotti-Leggett-Garg-type systems. The theory of contextuality known as contextuality-by-default allows one to define and measure contextuality in all such systems, even if there are context-dependent errors in measurements, or if something in the contexts directly interacts with the measurements. This makes the theory especially suitable for behavioural and social systems, where direct interactions of 'everything with everything' are ubiquitous. For cyclic systems with binary outcomes, the theory provides necessary and sufficient conditions for non-contextuality, and these conditions are known to be breached in certain quantum systems. We review several behavioural and social datasets (from polls of public opinion to visual illusions to conjoint choices to word combinations to psychophysical matching), and none of these data provides any evidence for contextuality. Our working hypothesis is that this may be a broadly applicable rule: behavioural and social systems are non-contextual, i.e. all 'contextual effects' in them result from the ubiquitous dependence of response distributions on the elements of contexts other than the ones to which the response is presumably or normatively directed.