Quantum computing promises significant computational speed-ups that could compromise the security of current public-key cryptography. As quantum technologies advance, SCADA systems will increasingly require enhanced cybersecurity measures. Two main quantum-safe approaches exist: Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) and Quantum Key Distribution (QKD). QKD offers the unique advantage of information-theoretic security, ensuring security regardless of an adversary’s computational power. This thesis addresses two identified research gaps: protecting SCADA networks against potential quantum-computer-based attacks and identifying relevant use cases for QKD to guide further research and adoption. The objective was to assess whether QKD is a viable solution for securing SCADA communications in hydropower plants against quantum threats. The analysis included designing a QKD-based SCADA communication architecture for a hydropower network, conducting a quantum vulnerability assessment, simulating the proposed setup and evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of QKD migration. The results indicate that, at the time of writing, QKD is not a viable option for securing SCADA communications in hydropower plants, as its disadvantages outweigh its benefits. For instance, QKD cannot guarantee availability, which is a critical requirement for SCADA in many critical infrastructures, including hydropower, and it is more costly than alternative quantum-safe solutions.
Quantum computing promises significant computational speed-ups that could compromise the security of current public-key cryptography. As quantum technologies advance, SCADA systems will increasingly require enhanced cybersecurity measures. Two main quantum-safe approaches exist: Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) and Quantum Key Distribution (QKD). QKD offers the unique advantage of information-theoretic security, ensuring security regardless of an adversary’s computational power. This thesis addresses two identified research gaps: protecting SCADA networks against potential quantum-computer-based attacks and identifying relevant use cases for QKD to guide further research and adoption. The objective was to assess whether QKD is a viable solution for securing SCADA communications in hydropower plants against quantum threats. The analysis included designing a QKD-based SCADA communication architecture for a hydropower network, conducting a quantum vulnerability assessment, simulating the proposed setup and evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of QKD migration. The results indicate that, at the time of writing, QKD is not a viable option for securing SCADA communications in hydropower plants, as its disadvantages outweigh its benefits. For instance, QKD cannot guarantee availability, which is a critical requirement for SCADA in many critical infrastructures, including hydropower, and it is more costly than alternative quantum-safe solutions.
Hydropower facilities are often remotely monitored or controlled from a centralized remote control room. Additionally, major component manufacturers monitor the performance of installed components, increasingly via public communication infrastructures. While these communications enable efficiencies and increased reliability, they also expand the cyber-attack surface. Communications may use the internet to remote control a facility's control systems, or it may involve sending control commands over a network from a control room to a machine. The content could be encrypted and decrypted using a public key to protect the communicated information. These cryptographic encoding and decoding schemes become vulnerable as more advances are made in computer technologies, such as quantum computing. In contrast, quantum key distribution (QKD) and other quantum cryptographic protocols are not based upon a computational problem, and offer an alternative to symmetric cryptography in some scenarios. Although the underlying mechanism of quantum cryptogrpahic protocols such as QKD ensure that any attempt by an adversary to observe the quantum part of the protocol will result in a detectable signature as an increased error rate, potentially even preventing key generation, it serves as a warning for further investigation. In QKD, when the error rate is low enough and enough photons have been detected, a shared private key can be generated known only to the sender and receiver. We describe how this novel technology and its several modalities could benefit the critical infrastructures of dams or hydropower facilities. The presented discussions may be viewed as a precursor to a quantum cybersecurity roadmap for the identification of relevant threats and mitigation.
The supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) is a combined system of elements of hardware and software that is used for controlling industrial processes either remotely or locally. It also useful for monitoring, gathering and processing real time data, and directly interacting with different electronic as well as integrated devices such as valves, pumps, motors, and sensors. Over the years, it has become increasingly interconnected with the internet, making it vulnerable to cyber threats. In order to contain the system's internet attacks, various methods have been used, especially the encryption techniques such as symmetric and asymmetric approaches as well as the decoy SCADA method. However, with the arrival more advanced security threats such as those based on quantum computing, there is a need to introduce security measures that can neutralize such threats. One promising method is quantum cryptography, which is an encryption technique based on quantum mechanics theories. In this study, a quantum-cryptography-based algorithm is proposed. It is based on the QKD and hash-based signature scheme, which act as key generators and authenticators respectively. In order to evaluate the algorithm's performance, it is subjected to a random substitute and intercept resend attack. Using the probabilistic model checker tool, the probability of succumbing to the two attacks is checked. The results show that the algorithm would significantly improve SCADA's resistance against quantum and classical cyber threats.
Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) systems represent the cyber-physical infrastructure core of critical infrastructure, where any security violation can cause severe operational and physical repercussions. The integration of operational technology with Information Technology networks has introduced new vulnerabilities to cyber attacks, while the emergence of quantum computing poses a basic threat to classical cryptographic approaches currently in use within industrial control systems. This paper presents a novel Zero-Trust Post-Quantum Cryptographic (ZT-PQC) solution specifically tailored for resource-constrained SCADA systems. The solution combines lightweight symmetric encryption for field devices, hybrid and pure post-quantum cryptography for higher layers, and continuous Zero-Trust policy enforcement throughout the communication process. A layer-aware cryptographic offloading approach is utilized to strike a balance between quantum resilience and real-time operational requirements. The feasibility of the proposed solution is assessed using a validated synthetic SCADA dataset simulating practical communication patterns, attack models, and system constraints. Experimental results show that the solution provides quantum-resistant security with acceptable latency, minimal communication overhead, and compatibility with existing SCADA systems, thus being amenable to incremental deployment in critical infrastructure systems.
The fast integration of information technology with operational technology in cyber-physical systems (CPS) has introduced new cybersecurity risks to critical infrastructure systems including power grids. Current cryptographic systems fail to protect data because emerging quantum computing technology will break existing standard encryption methods. Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) employs principles of quantum physics to provide secure communication through an unbreakable method. This paper examines the implementation of QKD technology for CPS systems focusing on SCADA systems of the power grid infrastructure. The paper delivers an extensive evaluation of the QKD system architecture together with feature extraction and classification approaches and practical system implementations. The analysis focuses on hydroelectric systems and wide-area SCADA deployments and post-quantum cryptographic resilience. An extensive review of the existing literature helps us understand the current state, while providing essential knowledge gaps before suggesting research pathways for quantum-enhanced CPS security.
Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) systems are ubiquitous in industrial control processes, such as power grids, water supply systems, traffic control, oil and natural gas mining, space stations and nuclear plants. However, their security faces the threat of being compromised due to the increasing use of open-access networks. Furthermore, one of the research gaps involves the emergence of quantum computing, which has exposed a new type of risk to SCADA systems. Failure to secure SCADA systems can lead to catastrophic consequences. For example, a malicious attack can take control of the power supply to a city, shut down the water supply system, or cause malfunction of a nuclear reactor. The primary purpose of this paper is to identify the new type of attack based on quantum computing and design a novel security scheme to defend against traditional attacks as well as the quantum attack. The methodology of the proposed signcryption is built on the foundation of the classical Bennett and Brassard 1984 (BB84) cryptographic scheme and does not involve computationally expensive third-party validation. The proposed signcryption scheme provides both encryption and intrusion detection. In particular, it detects the man-in-the-middle attack that can lead to other types of attacks. We have simulated the proposed algorithm using the Quantum Information Toolkit in Python. Furthermore, we have validated and analyzed the proposed design through security verification tools, namely, Scyther and PRISM.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is currently being discussed as a technology to safeguard communication in a future where quantum computers compromise traditional public-key cryptosystems. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive security evaluation of QKD-based solutions, focusing on real-world use cases sourced from academic literature and industry reports. We analyze these use cases, assess their security and identify the possible advantages of deploying QKD-based solutions. We further compare QKD-based solutions with Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC), the alternative approach to achieving security when quantum computers compromise traditional public-key cryptosystems, evaluating their respective suitability for each scenario. Based on this comparative analysis, we critically discuss and comment on which use cases QKD is suited for, considering factors such as implementation complexity, scalability, and long-term security. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of the role QKD could play in future cryptographic infrastructures and offer guidance to decision-makers considering the deployment of QKD.