Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Hilbert Substrate Framework II: Accessibility and the Emergence of Spatial Locality

Benjamin August Bray

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Classical spatial structure persists in physical systems despite underlying unitary dynamics that, in principle, permit the widespread delocalization of information. In this work, we investigate whether spatial locality arises as a fundamental optimum or as a dynamical attractor. By applying a locality-biased Riemannian flow to unitary orbits, we demonstrate the existence of an accessibility phase transition. For small systems (N ≤ 3) or weak locality penalties (p ≤ 2), optimization flows easily access the global minimum corresponding to delocalized collective modes (“Harmonions”). However, beyond a critical system size (N ≥ 5) and penalty strength (p ≈ 4), the accessibility landscape undergoes a qualitative transition: the global minimum becomes kinetically inaccessible, and the system is trapped in a robust local basin corresponding to classical spatial geometry. We map the phase diagram of this transition and conclude that spatial locality emerges not because it is the simplest description of physics, but because it is the simplest accessible description for large-scale systems.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18112405

Related papers

The Hilbert Substrate Framework

Bray, Benjamin August

We present a unified framework in which classical spacetime, locality, and the familiar spatial structure of physics emerge from purely quantum-mechanical principles. Starting from a single Hilbert space H_total with unitary evolution, we impose only two information-theoretic constraints: no-signaling (locality of dynamical unitaries) and no-forgetting (global unitarity). From these axioms, we derive two complementary selection principles that together determine the structure of physical reality: Dynamical Simplicity: This principle identifies the tensor factorization of Hilbert space that minimizes the locality cost of the Hamiltonian. We prove existence and generic uniqueness of this optimal factorization and show it corresponds to a basis of collective modes we term harmonions—emergent quasiparticle degrees of freedom that decouple the dynamics. Observational Stability: This principle identifies the pointer basis that survives environmental decoherence. We demonstrate that this is generically the spatial basis—local in the interaction graph but dynamically complex. Numerical experiments confirm that these two principles select different bases: the harmonion basis minimizes Hamiltonian complexity but suffers catastrophic decoherence (97% information loss), while the spatial basis is dynamically expensive but robust (3% information loss). Physical reality emerges as the compromise: a structure sufficiently simple to have tractable dynamics and sufficiently redundant to survive observation. We conclude that space is not fundamental—it is the fixed point where dynamical simplicity and observational stability meet. The harmonion is the substrate's natural language; space is what happens when the substrate observes itself.

•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

Pre-Einsteinian Coherent Relational Dynamics A Pre-Geometric Framework for the Emergence of Quantum Theory, Gauge Structure, Probability, Matter, Spacetime, Gravitation, and Physical Constants from Stability-Selected Transport Organization

Borros Arneth

We develop a pregeometric reconstruction framework in which quantum mechanics, gauge symmetry, probabilistic structure, matter, Lorentzian spacetime geometry, gravitation, and physical constants emerge from recursively stabilized coherent relational transport organization. The framework begins from a primitive causal-relational substrate consisting only of fluctuating accessibility relations and compositional transport structure. No background spacetime manifold, metric geometry, particle ontology, or external temporal parameter is assumed fundamentally. The theory further proposes that the preconditions underlying Einsteinian physics must already exist at the pre-geometric level as deeper relational consistency principles. Lorentz invariance, causal structure, covariance, conservation laws, and gravitational equivalence are interpreted as emergent macroscopic expressions of more primitive coherent accessibility constraints. A generalized spectral transport operator governs coherent relational evolution and generates stable eigensectors corresponding to persistent physical structure. Quantum mechanics emerges from coherent compositional consistency and norm-preserving recursive transport flow. Gauge symmetry emerges as local redundancy of coherent transport representation. Classical mechanics emerges through stationary coherent transport stabilization. A reconstruction of the Born rule is proposed in which quadratic probability amplitudes arise from multiplicative persistence consistency under independent coherent composition. Lorentzian spacetime geometry emerges statistically from stabilized causal accessibility organization, while gravitation emerges thermodynamically as equilibrium relaxation of coherent accessibility geometry. The framework further proposes that physical constants correspond to frozen stability invariants selected during primordial coherent transport evolution. In particular, the fine-structure constant is interpreted as a stable surviving coherent phase-accessibility ratio associated with recursive phase closure. The theory therefore attempts not merely to reproduce known equations, but to explain why physical reality universally organizes itself through Hilbert structure, gauge redundancy, localization, Lorentzian geometry, and thermodynamic gravitational dynamics. In particular, the framework proposes that Einsteinian spacetime physics emerges from deeper pre-Einsteinian coherent relational conditions governing recursive transport accessibility before spacetime itself exists.

•May 22, 2026•0 citations

Physics of Difference II: Comparison Structure and the Emergence of Topology

Yasuaki Tamura

AbstractWe investigate the minimal structural conditions under which relational accessibility organization admits a topological representation within physical description. Starting solely from the existence of distinguishable states and admissible comparison relations, we analyze how accessibility structures arise without introducing prior notions of space, geometry, metric structure, probability, or dynamics.Within the present framework, comparison between states is interpreted as a structural relation governing the accessibility of distinctions. The consistency requirements imposed on admissible comparisons induce preorder-like relational organization on the state space. We show that such comparison-induced accessibility structures admit neighborhood-like representations and may be organized in a form compatible with topological description.Importantly, the present framework does not interpret topology as a primitive geometric entity. Rather, topological structure is treated as a mathematical representation of relational accessibility induced by admissible comparison structure. In this perspective, neighborhood relations characterize accessibility coherence among distinguishable states rather than spatial proximity in a preexisting geometric manifold.We further show that equivalence structures associated with comparison naturally introduce classes of states that are indistinguishable within a given accessibility framework while remaining structurally distinct in the underlying state space. This provides a relational interpretation of local accessibility organization without invoking observer-dependent notions or externally imposed representational scales.The present work does not introduce new mathematical constructions. Instead, it identifies structural conditions under which topological representation becomes compatible with a minimal relational framework of physical description.

•May 11, 2026•0 citations

Optimal control landscape for the generation of unitary transformations

Michael Hsieh, HERSCHEL A. RABITZ

The generation of specific unitary transformations is central to a variety of quantum control problems. Given a target unitary transformation, the optimal control landscape is defined as the Hilbert-Schmidt distance between the target and controlled unitary transformation as a function of the control variables. The critical topology of the landscape is analyzed for controllable quantum systems evolving under unitary dynamics over a finite dimensional Hilbert space. It is found that the critical regions of the landscape corresponding to global optima are isolated points, and the local optima are Grassmannian submanifolds. The volumes of the critical submanifolds corresponding to suboptimal critical values asymptotically vanish in the limit of large Hilbert space dimension. Furthermore, these critical submanifolds have saddle-point topology, which cannot act as traps when searching for optimal controls. These favorable properties of the local optima suggest that the landscape topology is generally amenable to optimization. The analysis is independent of the particular structure of the system Hamiltonian, except for the assumption of full controllability, and the results are universal to the control of unitary transformations of any quantum system.

Physical Review A•Apr 7, 2008•44 citations

State Locality Theory A Phenomenological Framework for the Quantum–Classical Transition

Mikhail Bespoyasov

A phenomenological framework describing spatial manifestation and visibility decay in mesoscopic quantum systems.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Phase Primacy over Spacetime Connectivity: A Relational Alternative to Entanglement-Emergence

Cinque McFarlane - Blake

Phase-Mediated Attractor Dynamics (PMAD) advances a Phase-First Ontology in which relative phase structure, rather than spatial adjacency, constitutes the fundamental organizing principle of physical reality. Contrary to prevailing entanglement-emergence programs associated with ER=EPR, PMAD argues that metric distance, spacetime geometry, and quantum probabilities are emergent coarse-grained projections of a deeper non-equilibrium phase manifold. The fundamental relational object is the long-time phase-overlap functional\[\langle e^{i(\phi_i-\phi_j)}\rangle_T,\]from which effective geometry, correlation structure, and observer-accessible physical regularities arise. Grounded in four axioms—Phase Primacy, Attractor Determinism, Stability over Symmetry, and Ubiquitous Resonance—PMAD replaces static ontologies of objects embedded within spacetime with a driven many-body ontology organized by attractor stability. Physical proximity becomes derivative of phase synchronization, while apparent locality emerges from attractor-mediated propagation constraints. The framework further operationalizes Ontic Structural Realism by specifying the concrete dynamical relation underlying physical structure and resolves the observer ambiguity of Relational Quantum Mechanics by defining observers as embedded diagnostic probes stabilized within local attractor basins. Cross-scale applications spanning Floquet quantum hardware, solar plasma dynamics, coronal EUV variability, and astrophysical time-series analysis suggest that identical phase-organizing principles govern systems traditionally treated as ontologically distinct. The resulting picture is one in which spacetime is not the substrate of reality but an emergent bookkeeping device arising from stable phase-dynamical organization. Reality is reinterpreted not as matter occupying a pre-existing arena, but as a single driven relational process whose apparent geometry is the observable residue of attractor structure.

•May 31, 2026•0 citations
Classical spatial structure persists in physical systems despite underlying unitary dynamics that, in principle, permit the widespread delocalization of information. In this work, we investigate whether spatial locality arises as a fundamental optimum or as a dynamical attractor. By applying a locality-biased Riemannian flow to unitary orbits, we demonstrate the existence of an accessibility phase transition. For small systems (N ≤ 3) or weak locality penalties (p ≤ 2), optimization flows easily access the global minimum corresponding to delocalized collective modes (“Harmonions”). However, beyond a critical system size (N ≥ 5) and penalty strength (p ≈ 4), the accessibility landscape undergoes a qualitative transition: the global minimum becomes kinetically inaccessible, and the system is trapped in a robust local basin corresponding to classical spatial geometry. We map the phase diagram of this transition and conclude that spatial locality emerges not because it is the simplest description of physics, but because it is the simplest accessible description for large-scale systems.
We present a unified framework in which classical spacetime, locality, and the familiar spatial structure of physics emerge from purely quantum-mechanical principles. Starting from a single Hilbert space H_total with unitary evolution, we impose only two information-theoretic constraints: no-signaling (locality of dynamical unitaries) and no-forgetting (global unitarity). From these axioms, we derive two complementary selection principles that together determine the structure of physical reality: Dynamical Simplicity: This principle identifies the tensor factorization of Hilbert space that minimizes the locality cost of the Hamiltonian. We prove existence and generic uniqueness of this optimal factorization and show it corresponds to a basis of collective modes we term harmonions—emergent quasiparticle degrees of freedom that decouple the dynamics. Observational Stability: This principle identifies the pointer basis that survives environmental decoherence. We demonstrate that this is generically the spatial basis—local in the interaction graph but dynamically complex. Numerical experiments confirm that these two principles select different bases: the harmonion basis minimizes Hamiltonian complexity but suffers catastrophic decoherence (97% information loss), while the spatial basis is dynamically expensive but robust (3% information loss). Physical reality emerges as the compromise: a structure sufficiently simple to have tractable dynamics and sufficiently redundant to survive observation. We conclude that space is not fundamental—it is the fixed point where dynamical simplicity and observational stability meet. The harmonion is the substrate's natural language; space is what happens when the substrate observes itself.
We develop a pregeometric reconstruction framework in which quantum mechanics, gauge symmetry, probabilistic structure, matter, Lorentzian spacetime geometry, gravitation, and physical constants emerge from recursively stabilized coherent relational transport organization. The framework begins from a primitive causal-relational substrate consisting only of fluctuating accessibility relations and compositional transport structure. No background spacetime manifold, metric geometry, particle ontology, or external temporal parameter is assumed fundamentally. The theory further proposes that the preconditions underlying Einsteinian physics must already exist at the pre-geometric level as deeper relational consistency principles. Lorentz invariance, causal structure, covariance, conservation laws, and gravitational equivalence are interpreted as emergent macroscopic expressions of more primitive coherent accessibility constraints. A generalized spectral transport operator governs coherent relational evolution and generates stable eigensectors corresponding to persistent physical structure. Quantum mechanics emerges from coherent compositional consistency and norm-preserving recursive transport flow. Gauge symmetry emerges as local redundancy of coherent transport representation. Classical mechanics emerges through stationary coherent transport stabilization. A reconstruction of the Born rule is proposed in which quadratic probability amplitudes arise from multiplicative persistence consistency under independent coherent composition. Lorentzian spacetime geometry emerges statistically from stabilized causal accessibility organization, while gravitation emerges thermodynamically as equilibrium relaxation of coherent accessibility geometry. The framework further proposes that physical constants correspond to frozen stability invariants selected during primordial coherent transport evolution. In particular, the fine-structure constant is interpreted as a stable surviving coherent phase-accessibility ratio associated with recursive phase closure. The theory therefore attempts not merely to reproduce known equations, but to explain why physical reality universally organizes itself through Hilbert structure, gauge redundancy, localization, Lorentzian geometry, and thermodynamic gravitational dynamics. In particular, the framework proposes that Einsteinian spacetime physics emerges from deeper pre-Einsteinian coherent relational conditions governing recursive transport accessibility before spacetime itself exists.
AbstractWe investigate the minimal structural conditions under which relational accessibility organization admits a topological representation within physical description. Starting solely from the existence of distinguishable states and admissible comparison relations, we analyze how accessibility structures arise without introducing prior notions of space, geometry, metric structure, probability, or dynamics.Within the present framework, comparison between states is interpreted as a structural relation governing the accessibility of distinctions. The consistency requirements imposed on admissible comparisons induce preorder-like relational organization on the state space. We show that such comparison-induced accessibility structures admit neighborhood-like representations and may be organized in a form compatible with topological description.Importantly, the present framework does not interpret topology as a primitive geometric entity. Rather, topological structure is treated as a mathematical representation of relational accessibility induced by admissible comparison structure. In this perspective, neighborhood relations characterize accessibility coherence among distinguishable states rather than spatial proximity in a preexisting geometric manifold.We further show that equivalence structures associated with comparison naturally introduce classes of states that are indistinguishable within a given accessibility framework while remaining structurally distinct in the underlying state space. This provides a relational interpretation of local accessibility organization without invoking observer-dependent notions or externally imposed representational scales.The present work does not introduce new mathematical constructions. Instead, it identifies structural conditions under which topological representation becomes compatible with a minimal relational framework of physical description.
The generation of specific unitary transformations is central to a variety of quantum control problems. Given a target unitary transformation, the optimal control landscape is defined as the Hilbert-Schmidt distance between the target and controlled unitary transformation as a function of the control variables. The critical topology of the landscape is analyzed for controllable quantum systems evolving under unitary dynamics over a finite dimensional Hilbert space. It is found that the critical regions of the landscape corresponding to global optima are isolated points, and the local optima are Grassmannian submanifolds. The volumes of the critical submanifolds corresponding to suboptimal critical values asymptotically vanish in the limit of large Hilbert space dimension. Furthermore, these critical submanifolds have saddle-point topology, which cannot act as traps when searching for optimal controls. These favorable properties of the local optima suggest that the landscape topology is generally amenable to optimization. The analysis is independent of the particular structure of the system Hamiltonian, except for the assumption of full controllability, and the results are universal to the control of unitary transformations of any quantum system.
Phase-Mediated Attractor Dynamics (PMAD) advances a Phase-First Ontology in which relative phase structure, rather than spatial adjacency, constitutes the fundamental organizing principle of physical reality. Contrary to prevailing entanglement-emergence programs associated with ER=EPR, PMAD argues that metric distance, spacetime geometry, and quantum probabilities are emergent coarse-grained projections of a deeper non-equilibrium phase manifold. The fundamental relational object is the long-time phase-overlap functional⟨ei(ϕi−ϕj)⟩T,\langle e^{i(\phi_i-\phi_j)}\rangle_T,⟨ei(ϕi​−ϕj​)⟩T​,from which effective geometry, correlation structure, and observer-accessible physical regularities arise. Grounded in four axioms—Phase Primacy, Attractor Determinism, Stability over Symmetry, and Ubiquitous Resonance—PMAD replaces static ontologies of objects embedded within spacetime with a driven many-body ontology organized by attractor stability. Physical proximity becomes derivative of phase synchronization, while apparent locality emerges from attractor-mediated propagation constraints. The framework further operationalizes Ontic Structural Realism by specifying the concrete dynamical relation underlying physical structure and resolves the observer ambiguity of Relational Quantum Mechanics by defining observers as embedded diagnostic probes stabilized within local attractor basins. Cross-scale applications spanning Floquet quantum hardware, solar plasma dynamics, coronal EUV variability, and astrophysical time-series analysis suggest that identical phase-organizing principles govern systems traditionally treated as ontologically distinct. The resulting picture is one in which spacetime is not the substrate of reality but an emergent bookkeeping device arising from stable phase-dynamical organization. Reality is reinterpreted not as matter occupying a pre-existing arena, but as a single driven relational process whose apparent geometry is the observable residue of attractor structure.