Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Towards a Finite Size Analysis of Decoy-State Quantum Key Distribution with Advantage Distillation

Kleinpaß, Philipp, Treplin, Jonas, Orsucci, Davide

Published Sep 1, 2024• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) allows two legitimate parties, Alice and Bob, to share a secret key with information-theoretic security, ensuring that an eavesdropper, Eve, cannot obtain any information about the key. A QKD protocol is provably secure only when the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) is below a certain threshold and, therefore, the presence of noise inherently limits the maximum transmission distance. Advantage Distillation (AD) is a classical post-processing technique that enhances QKD protocols by increasing the maximum acceptable QBER and, thus, allows extending the communication range. AD operates by post-selecting blocks of bits and extracting fewer but highly correlated bits between Alice and Bob, which exhibit a reduced QBER, thus lowering the amount of information that has to be disclosed during the information reconciliation step. In this study, we present a new analytical expression for the secure key rate. This will enable a finite-size secure key length analysis of the decoy state version of the BB84 protocol including AD post-processing.

Related papers

Finite Size Analysis of Decoy-State BB84 with Advantage Distillation

Jonas Treplin, Philipp Kleinpaß, Davide Orsucci

Advantage Distillation (AD) is a classical post-processing technique that enhances Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols by increasing the maximum acceptable Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) and thus extending the distance at which QKD links can be securely established. AD operates by post-selecting blocks of bits and extracting fewer high-fidelity bits, exhibiting a reduced QBER and thus lowering the amount of information that has to be disclosed during the information reconciliation step. In this work we present the first comprehensive finite key-size analysis of decoy-state BB84 enhanced via AD post-processing. We demonstrate that through the use of AD the maximum acceptable QBER increases from around $9.5\%$ to around $17.3\%$ for realistic key sizes. This result shows that substantial performance enhancements can be achieved in scenarios which are constrained by the maximum tolerable QBER via improvements of the post-processing method alone.

quant-pharXiv:2511.21665•Nov 27, 2025•0 citations

Improving the performance of practical wavelength division multiplexing decoy-state quantum key distribution with advantage distillation

Bumil Kim, Jun Heo

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a promising method for sharing an information-theoretically secure secret key using the properties of quantum mechanics. Although QKD is the most practical field in quantum information science, its widespread adoption is constrained by high implementation costs. Despite the cost-effectiveness of propagating QKD with classical communication using wavelength division multiplexing (WDM), the noise generated by relatively strong classical signals degrades QKD performance. Even though several mitigation strategies exist, they often involve complexity or additional hardware. In this paper, we apply advantage distillation (AD) to enhance the performance of a practical decoy-state BB84 QKD system operating in a WDM environment. We perform finite-key analysis in both co-propagation and counter-propagation scenarios with three classical channels, and furthermore we examine the effects of varying the number of classical channels and the optical power per channel. A comparison of simulation results obtained with and without AD demonstrates that AD is robust to noise originating from classical channels. These results show that AD increases the secure key rate and transmission distance in the WDM-based QKD environment under both co-propagation and counter-propagation without requiring hardware changes. These findings suggest advantage distillation is a promising strategy for the widespread adoption of WDM-based QKD, including in challenging counter-propagation cases.

Scientific Reports•May 22, 2026•0 citations

Experimental demonstration of decoy-three-state quantum key distribution with advantage distillation

Li Gong, Chen-Peng Hao, Zhi-Jiang Chen +5 more

The advantage distillation (AD) method can significantly improve the bit error rate tolerance and transmission distance for different quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols. To enhance the transmission distance in a decoy-three-state QKD protocol, we analyze security using the AD method for the decoy-three-state QKD protocol with a weak-coherent source. The theoretical analysis results indicate that the AD method can significantly enhance the transmission distance of the decoy-three-state QKD protocol. Moreover, by applying the AD method, we experimentally realize the decoy-three-state QKD protocol with 130 km transmission distance. Our analysis results demonstrate that the AD method can significantly improve the performance of decoy-three-state QKD protocols, which can be applied in the quantum network in future research.

Optics Letters•Oct 10, 2025•0 citations

Further Improving the Decoy State Quantum Key Distribution Protocol with Advantage Distillation

Walter O. Krawec

In this paper, we revisit the application of classical advantage distillation (CAD) to the decoy-state BB84 protocol. Prior work has shown that CAD can greatly improve maximal distances and noise tolerances of the practical decoy state protocol. However, past work in deriving key-rate bounds for this protocol with CAD have assumed a trivial bound on the quantum entropy, whenever Alice sends a vacuum state in a CAD block (i.e., the entropy of such blocks is taken to be zero). Since such rounds contribute, negatively, to the error correction leakage, this results in a correct, though sub-optimal bound. Here, we derive a new proof of security for CAD applied to the decoy state BB84 protocol, computing a bound on Eve's uncertainty in all possible single and vacuum photon events. We use this to derive a new asymptotic key-rate bound which, we show, outperforms prior work, allowing for increased distances and noise tolerances.

quant-pharXiv:2601.02565•Jan 7, 2026•0 citations

Symmetric Extendability of Quantum States and the Extreme Limits of Quantum Key Distribution

Sumeet Khatri

We investigate QKD protocols with two-way classical post-processing that are based on the well-known six-state and BB84 signal states. In these QKD protocols, the source (Alice) sends quantum signals to the receiver (Bob), who measures them, leaving only classical data on both sides. Our goal is to find the highest value of the quantum bit-error rate (QBER) $Q$ for which two-way classical post-processing protocols on the data can distill secret keys. Using the BB84 signal states, such protocols currently exist for $Q<\\frac{1}{5}$. On the other hand, for $Q\\geq\\frac{1}{4}$ no such protocol can exist as the observed data is compatible with an intercept-resend attack. This leaves the interesting question of whether successful two-way protocols exist in the interval $\\frac{1}{5}\\leq Q<\\frac{1}{4}$. For the six-state signal states, the corresponding interval is known to be $\\frac{5-\\sqrt{5}}{10}\\leq Q<\\frac{1}{3}$. \n\t \n\tWe search for two-way protocols because it turns out that within these intervals Alice and Bob's correlations are symmetrically extendable, meaning that Bob and the eavesdropper (Eve) are completely indistinguishable from Alice's point of view, making any one-way Alice-to-Bob post-processing protocol insecure. A two-way protocol might be able to break the symmetry between Bob and Eve, and it must do so in order to distill a secret key because any two-way protocol will necessarily terminate with a one-way communication step, at which point the symmetric extendability of Alice and Bob's updated correlations must be checked again. \n \nWe first show that the search for two-way protocols breaking the symmetric extendability of Alice and Bob's correlations can be restricted to a search over post-selection protocols if all we care about is whether secret key can at all be distilled and not about the rate of distillation. We then provide strong analytical and numerical evidence to suggest that no two-way classical post-processing protocol exists within the gap when the six-state signal states are used. \n\t \n\tUnder quantum entanglement distillation protocols, it is known that secret key can be distilled right up to the intercept-resend bounds of $\\frac{1}{4}$ and $\\frac{1}{3}$ for the BB84 and six-state signal states, respectively. We therefore want to know whether classical post-processing protocols are just as good at distilling secret keys as quantum ones. Our results appear to indicate that they are not.

•Oct 13, 2016•3 citations

Enhancing distillability of secret keys with entanglement distillation and classical advantage distillation

Shin Sun, Kenneth Goodenough, Daniel Bhatti +2 more

Realizing secure communication between distant parties is one of the main goals of quantum technology. Although quantum key distribution (QKD) promises information-theoretic security for sharing a secret key, the key rate heavily depends on the level of noise in the quantum channel. To overcome the noise, both quantum and classical techniques exist, i.e., entanglement distillation and classical advantage distillation. So far, these techniques have only been used separately from each other. Herein, we present a two-stage distillation scheme concatenating entanglement distillation with classical advantage distillation. For the advantage distillation, we utilize a fixed protocol, specifically, the repetition code; in the case of entanglement distillation, we employ an enumeration algorithm to find an optimal protocol. We test our scheme for noisy entangled states and demonstrate its quantitative advantage: Our two-stage distillation scheme achieves finite key rates even in a high-noise regime where entanglement distillation or advantage distillation alone cannot afford key sharing. We also calculate the security bounds for relevant QKD protocols with our key-distillation scheme and show that they exceed the previous security bounds on the critical quantum bit error rates with only advantage distillation. Since the advantage distillation part does not introduce further requirements for quantum resources other than those required for entanglement distillation, the proposed scheme is well suited for quantum key distribution tasks with entanglement distribution networks.

arXiv:2410.19334•Physical Review A•Sep 11, 2025•3 citations
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) allows two legitimate parties, Alice and Bob, to share a secret key with information-theoretic security, ensuring that an eavesdropper, Eve, cannot obtain any information about the key. A QKD protocol is provably secure only when the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) is below a certain threshold and, therefore, the presence of noise inherently limits the maximum transmission distance. Advantage Distillation (AD) is a classical post-processing technique that enhances QKD protocols by increasing the maximum acceptable QBER and, thus, allows extending the communication range. AD operates by post-selecting blocks of bits and extracting fewer but highly correlated bits between Alice and Bob, which exhibit a reduced QBER, thus lowering the amount of information that has to be disclosed during the information reconciliation step. In this study, we present a new analytical expression for the secure key rate. This will enable a finite-size secure key length analysis of the decoy state version of the BB84 protocol including AD post-processing.
Advantage Distillation (AD) is a classical post-processing technique that enhances Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols by increasing the maximum acceptable Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) and thus extending the distance at which QKD links can be securely established. AD operates by post-selecting blocks of bits and extracting fewer high-fidelity bits, exhibiting a reduced QBER and thus lowering the amount of information that has to be disclosed during the information reconciliation step. In this work we present the first comprehensive finite key-size analysis of decoy-state BB84 enhanced via AD post-processing. We demonstrate that through the use of AD the maximum acceptable QBER increases from around 9.5%9.5\%9.5% to around 17.3%17.3\%17.3% for realistic key sizes. This result shows that substantial performance enhancements can be achieved in scenarios which are constrained by the maximum tolerable QBER via improvements of the post-processing method alone.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a promising method for sharing an information-theoretically secure secret key using the properties of quantum mechanics. Although QKD is the most practical field in quantum information science, its widespread adoption is constrained by high implementation costs. Despite the cost-effectiveness of propagating QKD with classical communication using wavelength division multiplexing (WDM), the noise generated by relatively strong classical signals degrades QKD performance. Even though several mitigation strategies exist, they often involve complexity or additional hardware. In this paper, we apply advantage distillation (AD) to enhance the performance of a practical decoy-state BB84 QKD system operating in a WDM environment. We perform finite-key analysis in both co-propagation and counter-propagation scenarios with three classical channels, and furthermore we examine the effects of varying the number of classical channels and the optical power per channel. A comparison of simulation results obtained with and without AD demonstrates that AD is robust to noise originating from classical channels. These results show that AD increases the secure key rate and transmission distance in the WDM-based QKD environment under both co-propagation and counter-propagation without requiring hardware changes. These findings suggest advantage distillation is a promising strategy for the widespread adoption of WDM-based QKD, including in challenging counter-propagation cases.
The advantage distillation (AD) method can significantly improve the bit error rate tolerance and transmission distance for different quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols. To enhance the transmission distance in a decoy-three-state QKD protocol, we analyze security using the AD method for the decoy-three-state QKD protocol with a weak-coherent source. The theoretical analysis results indicate that the AD method can significantly enhance the transmission distance of the decoy-three-state QKD protocol. Moreover, by applying the AD method, we experimentally realize the decoy-three-state QKD protocol with 130 km transmission distance. Our analysis results demonstrate that the AD method can significantly improve the performance of decoy-three-state QKD protocols, which can be applied in the quantum network in future research.
In this paper, we revisit the application of classical advantage distillation (CAD) to the decoy-state BB84 protocol. Prior work has shown that CAD can greatly improve maximal distances and noise tolerances of the practical decoy state protocol. However, past work in deriving key-rate bounds for this protocol with CAD have assumed a trivial bound on the quantum entropy, whenever Alice sends a vacuum state in a CAD block (i.e., the entropy of such blocks is taken to be zero). Since such rounds contribute, negatively, to the error correction leakage, this results in a correct, though sub-optimal bound. Here, we derive a new proof of security for CAD applied to the decoy state BB84 protocol, computing a bound on Eve's uncertainty in all possible single and vacuum photon events. We use this to derive a new asymptotic key-rate bound which, we show, outperforms prior work, allowing for increased distances and noise tolerances.
We investigate QKD protocols with two-way classical post-processing that are based on the well-known six-state and BB84 signal states. In these QKD protocols, the source (Alice) sends quantum signals to the receiver (Bob), who measures them, leaving only classical data on both sides. Our goal is to find the highest value of the quantum bit-error rate (QBER) QQQ for which two-way classical post-processing protocols on the data can distill secret keys. Using the BB84 signal states, such protocols currently exist for Q<frac15Q<\\frac{1}{5}Q<frac15. On the other hand, for Qgeqfrac14Q\\geq\\frac{1}{4}Qgeqfrac14 no such protocol can exist as the observed data is compatible with an intercept-resend attack. This leaves the interesting question of whether successful two-way protocols exist in the interval frac15leqQ<frac14\\frac{1}{5}\\leq Q<\\frac{1}{4}frac15leqQ<frac14. For the six-state signal states, the corresponding interval is known to be frac5−sqrt510leqQ<frac13\\frac{5-\\sqrt{5}}{10}\\leq Q<\\frac{1}{3}frac5−sqrt510leqQ<frac13. \n\t \n\tWe search for two-way protocols because it turns out that within these intervals Alice and Bob's correlations are symmetrically extendable, meaning that Bob and the eavesdropper (Eve) are completely indistinguishable from Alice's point of view, making any one-way Alice-to-Bob post-processing protocol insecure. A two-way protocol might be able to break the symmetry between Bob and Eve, and it must do so in order to distill a secret key because any two-way protocol will necessarily terminate with a one-way communication step, at which point the symmetric extendability of Alice and Bob's updated correlations must be checked again. \n \nWe first show that the search for two-way protocols breaking the symmetric extendability of Alice and Bob's correlations can be restricted to a search over post-selection protocols if all we care about is whether secret key can at all be distilled and not about the rate of distillation. We then provide strong analytical and numerical evidence to suggest that no two-way classical post-processing protocol exists within the gap when the six-state signal states are used. \n\t \n\tUnder quantum entanglement distillation protocols, it is known that secret key can be distilled right up to the intercept-resend bounds of frac14\\frac{1}{4}frac14 and frac13\\frac{1}{3}frac13 for the BB84 and six-state signal states, respectively. We therefore want to know whether classical post-processing protocols are just as good at distilling secret keys as quantum ones. Our results appear to indicate that they are not.
Realizing secure communication between distant parties is one of the main goals of quantum technology. Although quantum key distribution (QKD) promises information-theoretic security for sharing a secret key, the key rate heavily depends on the level of noise in the quantum channel. To overcome the noise, both quantum and classical techniques exist, i.e., entanglement distillation and classical advantage distillation. So far, these techniques have only been used separately from each other. Herein, we present a two-stage distillation scheme concatenating entanglement distillation with classical advantage distillation. For the advantage distillation, we utilize a fixed protocol, specifically, the repetition code; in the case of entanglement distillation, we employ an enumeration algorithm to find an optimal protocol. We test our scheme for noisy entangled states and demonstrate its quantitative advantage: Our two-stage distillation scheme achieves finite key rates even in a high-noise regime where entanglement distillation or advantage distillation alone cannot afford key sharing. We also calculate the security bounds for relevant QKD protocols with our key-distillation scheme and show that they exceed the previous security bounds on the critical quantum bit error rates with only advantage distillation. Since the advantage distillation part does not introduce further requirements for quantum resources other than those required for entanglement distillation, the proposed scheme is well suited for quantum key distribution tasks with entanglement distribution networks.