Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A Numerical Verification of the Universal Balance Index in an Open Quantum System v0.2

Lee, Byoungwoo

Published Nov 16, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

## Summary (v0.3) This record releases version v0.3 of the project **"Numerical Verification of the Universal Balance Index (UBI)"** on an open quantum many–body system. The paper implements, in full numerical detail, the protocol proposed in the companion methods paper (v0.2) and tests the SLVA/CVC prediction that the **learning rate** \( c(T) \) of an open system is controlled by a single scalar balance index\[\mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T) = \rho_s(T)\,\Delta(T),\]the product of a gap–type parameter \( \Delta(T) \) and a stiffness–type parameter \( \rho_s(T) \). The concrete testbed is a one–dimensional attractive Hubbard chain (BCS–type model) coupled to a thermal reservoir below the superconducting critical temperature \( T_c \). The work is designed as a numerical counterpart to the arithmetic Collatz Vacuum Convergence (CVC) model and the SLVA self–learning vacuum framework, providing a first quantitative bridge between number–theoretic Markov kernels and realistic open quantum systems. --- ## Overview The paper studies relaxation into a **captured superconducting phase** in a one–dimensional attractive Hubbard chain evolving under Lindblad dynamics. - **Model:** finite 1D attractive Hubbard chain with open or periodic boundary conditions.- **Bath:** local energy–dissipative Lindblad operators modeling coupling to a thermal reservoir at temperature \( T < T_c \).- **Captured vacuum \( A \):** region in state space defined by a threshold on a long–range pairing correlator, representing a macroscopically superconducting phase.- **Learning rate \( c(T) \):** exponential decay rate extracted from the tail of the first–passage distribution \( \mathbb{P}(\tau_A > t) \). The central question is whether the learning rate \( c(T) \) can be written as a simple linear function of a single scalar balance index\[\mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T) = \rho_s(T)\,\Delta(T),\]where \( \Delta(T) \) is the superconducting gap and \( \rho_s(T) \) is the superfluid stiffness. --- ## Closed results The main numerical results of v0.3 can be summarized as follows. - **Static observables (equilibrium stage).** - For each temperature \( T < T_c \), the equilibrium superconducting gap \( \Delta(T) \) is computed from the excitation spectrum. - The superfluid stiffness \( \rho_s(T) \) is extracted from the curvature of the free energy under twisted boundary conditions. - The superconducting balance index is defined by \[ \mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T) = \rho_s(T)\,\Delta(T). \] - **Dynamic observables (relaxation stage).** - Lindblad quantum trajectory simulations are run from high–temperature normal initial states. - A **captured superconducting region** \( A \) is defined via a threshold on a long–range pairing order parameter. - First–passage times \( \tau_A \) into \( A \) are measured, and empirical survival functions \[ S_T(t) = \mathbb{P}(\tau_A > t) \] are estimated for each temperature. - **Learning rate from tails.** - Over an intermediate time window, the survival functions exhibit robust exponential tails \[ S_T(t) \approx \exp\bigl(-c(T)\,t\bigr), \] allowing a learning rate \( c(T) \) to be extracted by linear fits to \( \log S_T(t) \) with controlled statistical errors. - **UBI law (main relation).** - The data are well described by a linear relation \[ c(T) \approx \kappa\,\mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T) \] with an approximately temperature–independent proportionality constant \( \kappa \). - Control plots \( c(T) \) versus \( \Delta(T) \) and \( c(T) \) versus \( \rho_s(T) \) show significantly poorer linear behaviour (visible curvature and non–zero intercepts). - **Residual analysis.** - Residuals \[ \varepsilon_k = c(T_k) - \kappa\,\mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T_k) \] are small, centered near zero, and show no systematic trend when plotted against either \( \mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T_k) \) or \( T_k/T_c \). - The residuals are comparable to the statistical uncertainties in \( c(T_k) \), supporting a genuine proportionality law rather than an accidental correlation. Taken together, these results provide strong numerical evidence that \( \mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T) \) is the natural balance index controlling the relaxation speed into the superconducting phase in this open quantum system. --- ## What is new in v0.3 Relative to the methods–oriented v0.2 paper, v0.3 adds the following closed components: - **From protocol to data.** - The abstract protocol for computing \( \Delta(T) \), \( \rho_s(T) \), \( \mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T) \), and \( c(T) \) is fully implemented. - All figures in the main text are now populated with representative numerical data instead of placeholders. - **Complete UBI verification.** - A full **UBI plot**, \( c(T_k) \) vs. \( \mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T_k) \), is presented for a set of temperatures below \( T_c \). - The best–fit line passes close to the origin and captures the entire data set with residuals at the level of statistical noise. - **Control and robustness checks.** - Control plots \( c(T_k) \) vs. \( \Delta(T_k) \) and \( c(T_k) \) vs. \( \rho_s(T_k) \) demonstrate that neither parameter alone yields an equally clean linear law. - Finite–size tests, variations of Lindblad operators, and changes in the fitting window are shown to leave the UBI proportionality intact within error bars. - **Connection back to SLVA/CVC.** - The discussion section explicitly interprets the numerical findings as a first non–arithmetic confirmation of the SLVA/CVC self–learning picture, where vacuum relaxation is governed by a single balance index. --- ## Scope \& non–toy status Although the model remains a one–dimensional superconducting chain with relatively modest Hilbert space size, v0.3 goes beyond a purely toy–model status in several respects: - The observables \( \Delta(T) \) and \( \rho_s(T) \) are standard quantities in the theory of superconductivity and superfluidity, with clear physical meaning.- The open–system dynamics uses a genuine Lindblad generator with local dissipators, rather than an ad hoc Markov chain on a finite configuration graph.- The learning rate \( c(T) \) is extracted from first–passage statistics, a standard tool in non–equilibrium and stochastic processes.- The UBI law \( c(T) \propto \mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T) \) survives nontrivial variations of model parameters and numerical protocols. For these reasons, the paper should be viewed as an early but substantial step toward establishing UBI as a **non–toy** organizing principle for real quantum many–body relaxation. --- ## Program closure and targets This work fits into a multi–stage program: 1. **SLVA/CVC theory (CVC\_SLVA v0.8 and related papers):** Proposes UBI as a universal balance index controlling self–learning dynamics, first in an arithmetic setting. 2. **Numerical protocol (Numerical UBI v0.2):** Designs a concrete simulation strategy to test the UBI hypothesis in an open superconducting chain. 3. **Numerical verification (this v0.3 paper):** Executes the protocol and finds a clear linear relation \[ c(T) \approx \kappa\,\mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T), \] with no equally simple law in terms of \( \Delta(T) \) or \( \rho_s(T) \) alone. Future targets include: - Extending the analysis to **two–dimensional** models and exploring implications for high–temperature superconductivity.- Testing UBI–type relations in other symmetry–breaking scenarios (charge–density waves, spin–density waves, and beyond).- Connecting numerical UBI measurements to experimental observables in driven–dissipative systems and ultracold–atom platforms. Together with the CVC/SLVA papers, this record supports the view that a single scalar balance index can organize both arithmetic and quantum many–body relaxation into a unified self–learning framework.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.17624182

Related papers

When Is History Truncation Safe for Quantum-Code Optimization? Projective-Unitary Path Collapse and Distribution-Robust Optimizer Reversal

Byoungwoo Lee

## Overview This paper studies when a reduction of a finite quantum error-history model preserves the local direction of quantum-code optimization, and when it reverses that direction. For finite coactive spectral branches, the paper first proves a second-order local truncation-safety certificate. A strict optimizer of a truncated model persists when the full-versus-truncated effective-jet discrepancy is smaller than the coercivity margin of the truncated objective. Opposite leading jets provide a certificate of local optimizer reversal. The paper then identifies an exact boundary between genuine temporal structure and removable path redundancy. For a finite projective unitary error group, any open-loop path operator has the form $$W_\gamma=e^{i\theta_\gamma}U_{c(\gamma)},$$ where $c(\gamma)$ is the final group product. Consequently, an arbitrary temporally correlated path law is isometrically equivalent, for complete complementary leakage and for every code, to the single-shot distribution of the final projective product: $$\mathcal L_{\mathrm{path}}(V)=\mathcal L_{\pi}(V).$$ For Pauli trajectories, this remains true even when ordered errors do not commute, because different orderings can differ only by projective phases after contraction to the final channel. Thus open-loop final-channel leakage cannot identify temporal organization beyond the final projective Pauli-product distribution. Intermediate measurements, controls, syndrome extraction, or adaptive recovery are required for genuinely intervention-resolved multi-time code geometry. ## Distribution-robust optimizer reversal For an arbitrary three-location bit-flip trajectory law, let $\pi$ denote the induced final-parity distribution on $\mathbb F_2^3$, let $c=(1,1,1)$, and define $$\Lambda_\pi:=\sum_{t\in\mathbb F_2^3}\sqrt{\pi_t\pi_{t\oplus c}}.$$ For the three-qubit repetition code $$E=\operatorname{span}\{|000\rangle,|111\rangle\},$$ the complete complementary leakage is exactly $$\mathcal L_\pi(E)=\Lambda_\pi.$$ For every fixed full-support final-parity law, the intrinsic Fourier-syndrome graph coordinate $w$ satisfies $$\mathcal L_\pi(V(w))=\Lambda_\pi-2\Lambda_\pi|w|^2+o(|w|^2).$$ Hence the repetition code is a strict local maximum throughout this two-real-dimensional graph chart for every full-support final-parity distribution, independently of temporal correlations, stationarity, roundwise independence, identical error rates, or cyclic spatial symmetry. By contrast, a conditioned zero-and-one-fault truncation with positive coarse single-location weights has $$\mathcal L_{\leq 1}(E)=0$$ and strictly positive leakage at every nonzero sufficiently nearby graph code. The same reference code is therefore a strict local minimum for the truncated model and a strict local maximum for the complete process. The central conclusion is: > Exact aggregation of paths that implement the same projective physical operator preserves the entire code-optimization landscape, whereas deletion of higher-fault history fibers can reverse the local optimizer geometry. ## Scope The results concern random-unitary, open-loop finite-history models and complete complementary-channel leakage. The optimizer reversal is proved in a specified Fourier-syndrome graph chart around the three-qubit repetition code. The paper does not claim: - a full-Grassmannian classification for the three-qubit model;- a decoder or recovery-circuit construction;- a logical-error threshold;- a circuit-level hardware noise model;- collapse of an intervention-resolved process tensor;- equivalence in the presence of intermediate syndrome measurements, controls, or adaptive recovery. These intervention-resolved settings form the natural next boundary of the theory. ## Relation to the preceding research program This paper is a concluding bridge theorem paper connected to a six-paper exact finite-history QEC and spectral-minimax research line. ### 1. Compression-geometric foundation **Sharp Complementarity, Complete Attainable Region, and Metric Rigidity of Rank-Two Quantum Codes under Collective and Differential Dephasing** Version v0.5r2b DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21523950 This paper determined the complete attainable compression-defect region for rank-two codes under collective and differential two-qubit dephasing, classified the equality geometry, and established sharp metric rigidity. ### 2. Balanced finite-history minimax **Environment-Record Leakage for Finite Quantum Error Histories: Balanced Global Minimax, Complete Minimizer Geometry, and Distributional Stability** Version v0.5r2 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21560397 This paper introduced the complete environment-record leakage objective for finite error histories, solved the balanced two-step minimax problem globally over $\operatorname{Gr}(2,4)$, classified all balanced minimizers, and established distributional stability. ### 3. Bias-induced geometric selection **Bias-Induced Non-Isoclinic Optimality in Finite Quantum Error Histories: Exact Separation, Thresholdless Bifurcation, and Near-Balanced All-Code Minimax** Version v0.3r2 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21598820 This paper proved exact non-isoclinic separation, an open non-isoclinic parameter region, thresholdless loss of isoclinic optimality under arbitrarily small bias, and the leading full-Grassmannian near-balanced minimax selector. ### 4. Fourth-order overlap selection **Flat-Interior Persistence and Singular Overlap Selection in Near-Balanced Quantum Error Histories: Fourth-Order Transition Curves and Full-Grassmannian Minimax Closure** Version v0.1r3 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21622029 This sequel resolved the higher-order overlap degeneracy, established flat-interior persistence, derived singular boundary-layer transition curves, and closed the near-balanced full-Grassmannian minimax expansion through fourth order. ### 5. Abstract reflected spectral-jet framework **Reflected Spectral-Jet Realization for Degenerate Minimax Problems: Hard-Normal Selection, Flat Tangential Persistence, and Coactive Boundary Transitions** Version v0.2r1 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21636022 This paper extracted a reusable abstract framework for hard-normal isolation, soft tangential persistence, reflected active branches, and coactive boundary transitions in degenerate spectral minimax problems. ### 6. Finite-orbit generalization and first QEC truncation reversal **Beyond Reflected Pairs: Finite-Orbit Spectral Jets, Quadratic Isolation, and Multi-Branch Coactivity in Degenerate Minimax Problems** Version v0.4r1 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21644364 This paper generalized the reflected-pair theory to finite transitive orbits, developed multi-branch coactivity and representation-theoretic jet obstructions, and exhibited an exact three-location QEC realization in which restoring omitted multi-fault histories reverses the local optimizer geometry. ### 7. Present bridge theorem The present paper determines which open-loop temporal path information is exactly removable and which history reductions remain unsafe. It extends the earlier single-process reversal from independent or cyclic models to arbitrary correlated projective-unitary paths and arbitrary full-support final-parity laws. The resulting research progression is $$\text{compression geometry}\longrightarrow\text{balanced global minimax}\longrightarrow\text{bias-induced selection}\longrightarrow\text{fourth-order closure}\longrightarrow\text{reflected spectral jets}\longrightarrow\text{finite-orbit coactivity}\longrightarrow\text{projective path collapse and distribution-robust reversal}.$$ ## Reproducibility package The accompanying bundle contains: - the manuscript PDF;- the LaTeX source;- an exact symbolic verification script;- a machine-readable verification report;- a README describing the proof-artifact contract;- a SHA-256 manifest;- version and package-audit records. The verifier performs 72 exact symbolic checks, including projective Pauli phase identities, phase-covariant path compression, arbitrary-parity polar factors, translation orthogonality, Fourier-syndrome graph compressions, and coefficient bookkeeping for the distribution-robust local expansion. The verifier deliberately rejects optimized Python mode. PASS decisions do not rely on floating-point tolerances. Compactness, maximizing-direction localization, trace-norm differentiability, and uniform asymptotic assembly remain analytic parts of the manuscript proof rather than delegated computational claims.

•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations

Theoretical and Numerical Studies of the Dynamics of Open Quantum Systems

Souvik Agasti

Open quantum systems have drawn attention over decades due to its applicability in the foundation of theoretical physics, e.g. statistical mechanics, quantum mechanics and condensed matter physics. The dynamics of open quantum systems has been described as separate entities from their surrounding environment that consists of a very large number of modes, somehow coupled to the mode of the system. Even though the exact solution of the dynamical behavior of the system is impossible to calculate, we obtain a tentative solution using the crucial Markov approximation. The input-output formalism of the quantum Langevin equation (QLE) has been considered as a useful tool which provides a semi-classical description of the dynamics of the system, whereas the master equation provides a complete picture of the dynamics of the system expressed in terms of density matrix. While studying the dynamics of nonlinear system/environment coupling using QLE, we see, for a small value of external field, that the steady state system field does not change much from the steady state field obtained in the absence of nonlinear dissipation. However, in a case where a stronger external field is applied, we see that the deviation becomes substantial from the solution of linear system. We also see that the nonlinear coupling introduces significant difference in the cavity fluctuation spectrum. The description, therefore, provides a potential explanation of parametric effects in terms of nonlinear dissipation phenomena associated with the nonlinear coupling. Even though the theories developed in the context of open quantum systems have proven to be powerful tools, they do not provide a satisfactory platform to be implemented on non-linear Hamiltonians. We often approximate it by linearizing over nonlinear steady state field amplitude, and therefore, the interesting effects are often overlooked. The limitation of the analytics provokes us to simulate open quantum dynamics numerically. The numerical method consists of transformation of the environmental degrees of freedom to a one-dimensional many-body chain, and the computational technique includes numerical diagonalization and renormalization process. The time-adaptive density matrix renormalisation group (t-DMRG) is known as one of the most powerful techniques for the simulation of strongly-correlated many-body quantum systems. In this thesis, along with the theoretical modeling, we implement DMRG numerical scheme for the simulation of canonical S/B model by mapping it to one-dimensional harmonic chain with nearest neighbor interactions, and use the method to investigate the dynamics of the free dissipative system. The thermalization of open quantum systems is also studied by generating minimally entangled typical thermal states (METTS) through imaginary time evolution, and real-time evolving an empty system in the presence of the thermal bath. Further, we simulate coherently driven free dissipative Kerr nonlinear system numerically using Euler's method by solving Heisenberg equation of motion and t-DMRG algorithm, and demonstrate how the numerical results are analogous to classical bistability. By comparing with analytics, we see that the DMRG numerics is analogous to the quantum-mechanical exact solution obtained by mapping the equation of motion of the density matrix of the system to a Fokker-Plank equation. The comparison between two different numerical techniques shows that the semi-classical Euler's method determines the dynamics of the system field of one among two coherent branches, whereas DMRG numerics gives the superposition of both of them. Hence, DMRG-determined time dynamics undergoes generating non-classical states. Our approach of dealing with nonlinearity represents an important contribution in the developments of technique to study the dynamical and steady-state behavior of open quantum systems, which is a fundamental aspect of quantum physics.

JYU dissertations•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Dissipative Jaynes-Cummings Dynamics: A Systematic Study of Excitation Decay and Coherence Loss in the Strong-Coupling Regime

Miguel Percudani

This work presents a systematic numerical study of the dissipative Jaynes-Cummings model, consisting of a two-level system (qubit) coupled to a truncated harmonic oscillator, both subject to Markovian dissipation. The model is standard in quantum optics and open quantum systems. The master equation is solved using the Lindblad formalism with BDF integration. The study focuses on two standard observables: the qubit excited-state population P_exc(t) and the qubit Bloch vector length |r(t)|. A three-dimensional parameter scan is performed over the coupling g, the qubit dephasing rate gamma_phi, and the oscillator relaxation rate gamma_a, giving 216 cells in total. The parameters used are omega_0 = 6 Hz, omega_1 = 40 Hz, giving a detuning delta = 34 Hz, and thermal occupation n_th = 0.05. MAIN FINDINGS: The single-exponential description of the excited-state population is valid only at intermediate coupling (g approximately 4 to 8 Hz). Outside this region, the dynamics exhibits a multi-timescale structure. The decay time T is non-monotonic in g, with a minimum at g approximately 7 Hz. The location of the minimum depends only weakly on gamma_a, following a power law with exponent 0.127. At strong coupling (g greater than 15 Hz), a two-exponential model is strongly preferred by the Akaike Information Criterion in 43 out of 45 cells. The two timescales are separated by a factor of approximately 150. The fast timescale T_1 is best approximated by the Purcell formula (median ratio of numerical to theoretical value 0.68). The Fermi golden rule overestimates the decay rate by a factor of approximately 4.5. Neither the dressed-state correction nor the Bloch-Redfield calculation improves on the Purcell formula. The Bloch vector length does not follow any simple functional form (single exponential, stretched exponential, power law, or double exponential). All models have mean R-squared in the range 0.31 to 0.36. Its time derivative is, however, almost perfectly correlated with that of the population (mean correlation 0.91). The results are converged with respect to the Fock-space truncation at N_0 = 12, with identical observables for N_0 between 12 and 20. SCOPE: This is a purely numerical study of a well-defined quantum-optical model. It contains no empirical data, no claims about biological or cognitive systems, and no speculative ontology. The model, the numerical method, and the observables are standard. The results include several negative findings (the failure of perturbative formulas, the lack of a simple functional form for the Bloch vector) which are reported honestly and which identify the regime where non-perturbative methods are required. The purpose of this release is to provide reproducible numerical data and a benchmark for future analytical work on the dissipative Jaynes-Cummings model in the strong-coupling regime. CONTENTS: The LaTeX technical note (approximately 20 pages), the Python scripts for the numerical simulations, and the CSV files with the fit results, regime classification, and theoretical comparison. REFERENCES: E. T. Jaynes and F. W. Cummings, Proc. IEEE 51, 89 (1963).G. Lindblad, Commun. Math. Phys. 48, 119 (1976).H.-P. Breuer and F. Petruccione, The Theory of Open Quantum Systems, Oxford University Press (2002).C. W. Gardiner and P. Zoller, Quantum Noise, 3rd ed., Springer (2004).E. M. Purcell, Phys. Rev. 69, 681 (1946).C. Cohen-Tannoudji, J. Dupont-Roc, and G. Grynberg, Atom-Photon Interactions, Wiley (1992).W. P. Schleich, Quantum Optics in Phase Space, Wiley-VCH (2001).

•Oct 4, 2026•0 citations

Numerical approaches to isolated many-body quantum systems

Michael Kolodrubetz

Ultracold atoms have revolutionized atomic and condensed matter physics. In addition to having clean, controllable Hamiltonians, ultracold atoms are near-perfect realizations of isolated quantum systems, in which weak environmental coupling can be neglected on experimental time scales. This opens new opportunities to explore these systems not just in thermal equilibrium, but out of equilibrium as well. In this dissertation, we investigate some properties of closed quantum systems, utilizing a combination of numerical and analytical techniques. We begin by applying full configuration-interaction quantum Monte Carlo (FCIQMC) to the Fermi polaron [1], which we use as a test bed to improve the algorithm. In addition to adapting standard QMC techniques, we introduce novel controlled approximations that allow mitigation of the sign problem and simulation directly in the thermodynamic limit. We also contrast the sign problem of FCIQMC with that of more standard techniques, focusing on FCIQMC’s capacity to work in a second quantized determinant space. Next, we discuss nonequilibrium dynamics near a quantum critical point, focusing on the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising (TFI) chain. We show that the TFI dynamics exhibit critical scaling, within which the spin correlations exhibit qualitatively athermal behavior. We provide strong numerical evidence for the universality of dynamic scaling by utilizing time-dependent matrix product states to simulate a nonintegrable model in the same equilibrium universality class. As this non-integrable model has been realized experimentally [2], we investigate the robustness of our predictions against the presence of open boundary conditions and disorder. We find that the qualitatively athermal correlations remain visible, although other phenomena such as even/odd effects become relevant within the finite size scaling theory. Finally, we investigate the properties of the integrable TFI model upon varying the strength of a non-integrable perturbation, attempting to understand the finite-size scaling behavior of the eigenstate thermalization crossover. We numerically estimate iii the crossover scale of this perturbation strength using exact diagonalization, finding that the crossover scale decreases strongly with system size, and analytically provide a lower bound on the finite-size scaling of this crossover. However, we are unable to solve for the thermodynamic limit of this crossover; doing so will require larger systems and more comprehensive theory.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Thermalization and Out-of-Equilibrium Dynamics in Open Quantum Many-Body Systems

Michael Buchhold

Thermalization, the evolution of an interacting many-body system towards a thermal Gibbs ensemble after initialization in an arbitrary non-equilibrium state, is currently a phenomenon of great interest, both in theory and experiment. As the time evolution of a quantum system is unitary, the proposed mechanism of thermalization in quantum many-body systems corresponds to the so-called eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) and the typicality of eigenstates. Although this formally solves the contradiction of thermalizing but unitary dynamics in a closed quantum many-body system, it does neither make any statement on the dynamical process of thermalization itself nor in which way the coupling of the system to an environment can hinder or modify the relaxation dynamics. In this thesis, we address both the question whether or not a quantum system driven away from equilibrium is able to relax to a thermal state, which fulfills detailed balance, and if one can identify universal behavior in the non-equilibrium relaxation dynamics. As a first realization of driven quantum systems out of equilibrium, we investigate a system of Ising spins, interacting with the quantized radiation field in an optical cavity. For multiple cavity modes, this system forms a highly entangled and frustrated state with infinite correlation times, known as a quantum spin glass. In the presence of drive and dissipation, introduced by coupling the intra-cavity radiation field to the photon vacuum outside the cavity via lossy mirrors, the quantum glass state is modified in a universal manner. For frequencies below the photon loss rate, the dissipation takes over and the system shows the universal behavior of a dissipative spin glass, with a characteristic spectral density $\\mathcal{A}(\\omega)\\sim\\sqrt{\\omega}$. On the other hand, for frequencies above the loss rate, the system retains the universal behavior of a zero temperature, quantum spin glass. Remarkably, at the glass transition, the two subsystems of spins and photons thermalize to a joint effective temperature, even in the presence of photon loss. This thermalization is a consequence of the strong spin-photon interactions, which favor detailed balance in the system and detain photons from escaping the cavity. In the thermalized system, the features of the spin glass are mirrored onto the photon degrees of freedom, leading to an emergent photon glass phase. Exploiting the inherent photon loss of the cavity, we make predictions of possible measurements on the escaping photons, which contain detailed information of the state inside the cavity and allow for a precise, non-destructive measurement of the glass state. As a further set of non-equilibrium systems, we consider one-dimensional quantum fluids driven out of equilibrium, whose universal low energy theory is formed by the so-called Luttinger Liquid description, which, due to its large degree of universality, is of intense theoretical and experimental interest. A set of recent experiments in research groups in Vienna, Innsbruck and Munich have probed the non-equilibrium time-evolution of one-dimensional quantum fluids for different experimental realizations and are pushing into a time regime, where thermalization is expected. From a theoretical point of view, one-dimensional quantum fluids are particular interesting, as Luttinger Liquids are integrable and therefore, due to an infinite number of constants of motion, do not thermalize. The leading order correction to the quadratic theory is irrelevant in the sense of the renormalization group and does therefore not modify static correlation functions, however, it breaks integrability and will therefore, even if irrelevant, induce a completely different non-equilibrium dynamics as the quadratic Luttinger theory alone. In this thesis, we derive for the first time a kinetic equation for interacting Luttinger Liquids, which describes the time evolution of the excitation densities for arbitrary initial states. The resonant character of the interaction makes a straightforward derivation of the kinetic equation, using Fermi\'s golden rule, impossible and we have to develop non-perturbative techniques in the Keldysh framework. We derive a closed expression for the time evolution of the excitation densities in terms of self-energies and vertex corrections. Close to equilibrium, the kinetic equation describes the exponential decay of excitations, with a decay rate $\\sigma^R=\\mbox{Im}\\Sigma^R$, determined by the self-energy at equilibrium. However, for long times $\\tau$, it also reveals the presence of dynamical slow modes, which are the consequence of exactly energy conserving dynamics and lead to an algebraic decay $\\sim\\tau^{-\\eta\\sub{D}}$ with $\\eta_D=0.58$. The presence of these dynamical slow modes is not contained in the equilibrium Matsubara formalism, while they emerge naturally in the non-equilibrium formalism developed in this thesis. In order to initialize a one-dimensional quantum fluid out of equilibrium, we consider an interaction quench in a model of interacting, dispersive fermions in Chap.~\\ref{sec:Quench}. In this scenario, the fermionic interaction is suddenly changed at time $t=0$, such that for $t>0$ the system is not in an eigenstate and therefore undergoes a non-trivial time evolution. For the quadratic theory, the stationary state in the limit $t\\rightarrow\\infty$ is a non-thermal, or prethermal, state, described by a generalized Gibbs ensemble (GGE). The GGE takes into account for the conservation of all integrals of motion, formed by the eigenmodes of the Hamiltonian. On the other hand, in the presence of non-linearities, the final state for $t\\rightarrow\\infty$ is a thermal state with a finite temperature $T>0$. . The spatio-temporal, dynamical thermalization process can be decomposed into three regimes: A prequench regime on the largest distances, which is determined by the initial state, a prethermal plateau for intermediate distances, which is determined by the metastable fixed point of the quadratic theory and a thermal region on the shortest distances. The latter spreads sub-ballistically $\\sim t^{\\alpha}$ in space with $0<\\alpha<1$ depending on the quench. Until complete thermalization (i.e. for times $t<\\infty$), the thermal region contains more energy than the prethermal and prequench region, which is expressed in a larger temperature $T_{t}>T_{\\infty}$, decreasing towards its final value $T_{\\infty}$. As the system has achieved local detailed balance in the thermalized region, energy transport to the non-thermal region can only be performed by the macroscopic dynamical slow modes and the decay of the temperature $T_{t}-T_{\\infty}\\sim t^{-\\eta\\sub{D}}$ again witnesses the presence of these slow modes. The very slow spreading of thermalization is consistent with recent experiments performed in Vienna, which observe a metastable, prethermal state after a quench and only observe the onset of thermalization on much larger time scales. As an immediate indication of thermalization, we determine the time evolution of the fermionic momentum distribution after a quench from non-interacting to interacting fermions. For this quench scenario, the step in the Fermi distribution at the Fermi momentum $k\\sub{F}$ decays to zero algebraically in the absence of a non-linearity but as a stretched exponential (the exponent being proportional to the non-linearity) in the presence of a finite non-linearity. This can serve as a proof for the presence or absence of the non-linearity even on time-scales for which thermalization can not yet be observed. Finally, we consider a bosonic quantum fluid, which is driven away from equilibrium by permanent heating. The origin of the heating is atomic spontaneous emission of laser photons, which are used to create a coherent lattice potential in optical lattice experiments. This process preserves the system\'s $U(1)$-invariance, i.e. conserves the global particle number, and the corresponding long-wavelength description is a heated, interacting Luttinger Liquid, for which phonon modes are continuously populated with a momentum dependent rate $\\partial_tn_q\\sim\\gamma |q|$. In the dynamics, we identify a quasi-thermal regime for large momenta, featuring an increasing time-dependent effective temperature. In this regime, due to fast phonon-phonon scattering, detailed balance has been achieved and is expressed by a time-local, increasing temperature. The thermal region emerges locally and spreads in space sub-ballistically according to $x_t\\sim t^{4/5}$. For larger distances, the system is described by an non-equilibrium phonon distribution $n_q\\sim |q|$, which leads to a new, non-equilibrium behavior of large distance observables. For instance, the phonon decay rate scales universally as $\\gamma_q\\sim |q|^{5/3}$, with a new non-equilibrium exponent $\\eta=5/3$, which differs from equilibrium. This new, universal behavior is guaranteed by the $U(1)$ invariant dynamics of the system and is insensitive to further subleading perturbations. The non-equilibrium long-distance behavior can be determined experimentally by measuring the static and dynamic structure factor, both of which clearly indicate the exponents for phonon decay, $\\eta=5/3$ and for the spreading of thermalization $\\eta_T=4/5$. Remarkably, even in the presence of this strong external drive, the interactions and their aim to achieve detailed balance are strong enough to establish a locally emerging and spatially spreading thermal region. The physical setups in this thesis do not only reveal interesting and new dynamical features in the out-of-equilibrium time evolution of interacting systems, but they also strongly underline the high degree of universality of thermalization for the classes of models studied here. May it be a system of coupled spins and photons, where the photons are pulled away from a thermal state by Markovian photon d

•Jun 29, 2015•1 citation

Emergent supercounterfluid and quantum phase diagram of two-component interacting bosons in a one-dimensional optical lattice

Saisai He, Yang Liu, Bin Xi +3 more

Motivated by a recent experiment that realizes nearest-neighbor dipolar couplings in an optical lattice [C. Lagoin et al., Nature (London) 609, 485 (2022)], we study a one-dimensional version of the two-component extended Bose-Hubbard model via the density-matrix renormalization group method. By using the nearest-neighbor and on-site interaction parameters from the experiment, we start by mapping the quantum phase diagram in the hopping parameter ${t}_{A}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{t}_{B}$ plane with boson densities ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}={\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B}=1/2$. In addition to the density-wave phase reported in the experiment, we find several regimes of superfluidity when one or both hopping parameters are large enough, and interestingly there is a supercounterfluid phase at moderate and comparable hopping parameters. The universality classes of these phase transitions are analyzed from the correlation functions, excitation gaps, and entanglement entropy. In particular, a Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type is recognized for several gapped-to-gapless transitions. In addition, we also study the quantum phase transitions by varying ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B}$ from 0 to 1 while keeping ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}=1/2$. We identify a supersolid phase in a wide range of $1/2<{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B}<1$. Our work paves the way for realizing exotic many-body phases in cold-atom experiments upon proper tuning of experimental parameters.

arXiv:2503.18154•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 20, 2025•0 citations

Summary (v0.3) This record releases version v0.3 of the project "Numerical Verification of the Universal Balance Index (UBI)" on an open quantum many–body system. The paper implements, in full numerical detail, the protocol proposed in the companion methods paper (v0.2) and tests the SLVA/CVC prediction that the learning rate ( c(T) ) of an open system is controlled by a single scalar balance index[\mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T) = \rho_s(T),\Delta(T),]the product of a gap–type parameter ( \Delta(T) ) and a stiffness–type parameter ( \rho_s(T) ). The concrete testbed is a one–dimensional attractive Hubbard chain (BCS–type model) coupled to a thermal reservoir below the superconducting critical temperature ( T_c ). The work is designed as a numerical counterpart to the arithmetic Collatz Vacuum Convergence (CVC) model and the SLVA self–learning vacuum framework, providing a first quantitative bridge between number–theoretic Markov kernels and realistic open quantum systems. --- ## Overview The paper studies relaxation into a captured superconducting phase in a one–dimensional attractive Hubbard chain evolving under Lindblad dynamics. - Model: finite 1D attractive Hubbard chain with open or periodic boundary conditions.- Bath: local energy–dissipative Lindblad operators modeling coupling to a thermal reservoir at temperature ( T < T_c ).- Captured vacuum ( A ): region in state space defined by a threshold on a long–range pairing correlator, representing a macroscopically superconducting phase.- Learning rate ( c(T) ): exponential decay rate extracted from the tail of the first–passage distribution ( \mathbb{P}(\tau_A > t) ). The central question is whether the learning rate ( c(T) ) can be written as a simple linear function of a single scalar balance index[\mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T) = \rho_s(T),\Delta(T),]where ( \Delta(T) ) is the superconducting gap and ( \rho_s(T) ) is the superfluid stiffness. --- ## Closed results The main numerical results of v0.3 can be summarized as follows. - Static observables (equilibrium stage). - For each temperature ( T < T_c ), the equilibrium superconducting gap ( \Delta(T) ) is computed from the excitation spectrum. - The superfluid stiffness ( \rho_s(T) ) is extracted from the curvature of the free energy under twisted boundary conditions. - The superconducting balance index is defined by [ \mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T) = \rho_s(T),\Delta(T). ] - Dynamic observables (relaxation stage). - Lindblad quantum trajectory simulations are run from high–temperature normal initial states. - A captured superconducting region ( A ) is defined via a threshold on a long–range pairing order parameter. - First–passage times ( \tau_A ) into ( A ) are measured, and empirical survival functions [ S_T(t) = \mathbb{P}(\tau_A > t) ] are estimated for each temperature. - Learning rate from tails. - Over an intermediate time window, the survival functions exhibit robust exponential tails [ S_T(t) \approx \exp\bigl(-c(T),t\bigr), ] allowing a learning rate ( c(T) ) to be extracted by linear fits to ( \log S_T(t) ) with controlled statistical errors. - UBI law (main relation). - The data are well described by a linear relation [ c(T) \approx \kappa,\mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T) ] with an approximately temperature–independent proportionality constant ( \kappa ). - Control plots ( c(T) ) versus ( \Delta(T) ) and ( c(T) ) versus ( \rho_s(T) ) show significantly poorer linear behaviour (visible curvature and non–zero intercepts). - Residual analysis. - Residuals [ \varepsilon_k = c(T_k) - \kappa,\mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T_k) ] are small, centered near zero, and show no systematic trend when plotted against either ( \mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T_k) ) or ( T_k/T_c ). - The residuals are comparable to the statistical uncertainties in ( c(T_k) ), supporting a genuine proportionality law rather than an accidental correlation. Taken together, these results provide strong numerical evidence that ( \mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T) ) is the natural balance index controlling the relaxation speed into the superconducting phase in this open quantum system. --- ## What is new in v0.3 Relative to the methods–oriented v0.2 paper, v0.3 adds the following closed components: - From protocol to data. - The abstract protocol for computing ( \Delta(T) ), ( \rho_s(T) ), ( \mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T) ), and ( c(T) ) is fully implemented. - All figures in the main text are now populated with representative numerical data instead of placeholders. - Complete UBI verification. - A full UBI plot, ( c(T_k) ) vs. ( \mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T_k) ), is presented for a set of temperatures below ( T_c ). - The best–fit line passes close to the origin and captures the entire data set with residuals at the level of statistical noise. - Control and robustness checks. - Control plots ( c(T_k) ) vs. ( \Delta(T_k) ) and ( c(T_k) ) vs. ( \rho_s(T_k) ) demonstrate that neither parameter alone yields an equally clean linear law. - Finite–size tests, variations of Lindblad operators, and changes in the fitting window are shown to leave the UBI proportionality intact within error bars. - Connection back to SLVA/CVC. - The discussion section explicitly interprets the numerical findings as a first non–arithmetic confirmation of the SLVA/CVC self–learning picture, where vacuum relaxation is governed by a single balance index. --- ## Scope & non–toy status Although the model remains a one–dimensional superconducting chain with relatively modest Hilbert space size, v0.3 goes beyond a purely toy–model status in several respects: - The observables ( \Delta(T) ) and ( \rho_s(T) ) are standard quantities in the theory of superconductivity and superfluidity, with clear physical meaning.- The open–system dynamics uses a genuine Lindblad generator with local dissipators, rather than an ad hoc Markov chain on a finite configuration graph.- The learning rate ( c(T) ) is extracted from first–passage statistics, a standard tool in non–equilibrium and stochastic processes.- The UBI law ( c(T) \propto \mathrm{UBI}{\mathrm{SC}}(T) ) survives nontrivial variations of model parameters and numerical protocols. For these reasons, the paper should be viewed as an early but substantial step toward establishing UBI as a non–toy organizing principle for real quantum many–body relaxation. --- ## Program closure and targets This work fits into a multi–stage program: 1. SLVA/CVC theory (CVC_SLVA v0.8 and related papers): Proposes UBI as a universal balance index controlling self–learning dynamics, first in an arithmetic setting. 2. Numerical protocol (Numerical UBI v0.2): Designs a concrete simulation strategy to test the UBI hypothesis in an open superconducting chain. 3. Numerical verification (this v0.3 paper): Executes the protocol and finds a clear linear relation [ c(T) \approx \kappa,\mathrm{UBI}_{\mathrm{SC}}(T), ] with no equally simple law in terms of ( \Delta(T) ) or ( \rho_s(T) ) alone. Future targets include: - Extending the analysis to two–dimensional models and exploring implications for high–temperature superconductivity.- Testing UBI–type relations in other symmetry–breaking scenarios (charge–density waves, spin–density waves, and beyond).- Connecting numerical UBI measurements to experimental observables in driven–dissipative systems and ultracold–atom platforms. Together with the CVC/SLVA papers, this record supports the view that a single scalar balance index can organize both arithmetic and quantum many–body relaxation into a unified self–learning framework.

## Overview This paper studies when a reduction of a finite quantum error-history model preserves the local direction of quantum-code optimization, and when it reverses that direction. For finite coactive spectral branches, the paper first proves a second-order local truncation-safety certificate. A strict optimizer of a truncated model persists when the full-versus-truncated effective-jet discrepancy is smaller than the coercivity margin of the truncated objective. Opposite leading jets provide a certificate of local optimizer reversal. The paper then identifies an exact boundary between genuine temporal structure and removable path redundancy. For a finite projective unitary error group, any open-loop path operator has the form Wγ=eiθγUc(γ),W_\gamma=e^{i\theta_\gamma}U_{c(\gamma)},Wγ​=eiθγ​Uc(γ)​, where c(γ)c(\gamma)c(γ) is the final group product. Consequently, an arbitrary temporally correlated path law is isometrically equivalent, for complete complementary leakage and for every code, to the single-shot distribution of the final projective product: Lpath(V)=Lπ(V).\mathcal L_{\mathrm{path}}(V)=\mathcal L_{\pi}(V).Lpath​(V)=Lπ​(V). For Pauli trajectories, this remains true even when ordered errors do not commute, because different orderings can differ only by projective phases after contraction to the final channel. Thus open-loop final-channel leakage cannot identify temporal organization beyond the final projective Pauli-product distribution. Intermediate measurements, controls, syndrome extraction, or adaptive recovery are required for genuinely intervention-resolved multi-time code geometry. ## Distribution-robust optimizer reversal For an arbitrary three-location bit-flip trajectory law, let π\piπ denote the induced final-parity distribution on F23\mathbb F_2^3F23​, let c=(1,1,1)c=(1,1,1)c=(1,1,1), and define Λπ:=∑t∈F23πtπt⊕c.\Lambda_\pi:=\sum_{t\in\mathbb F_2^3}\sqrt{\pi_t\pi_{t\oplus c}}.Λπ​:=∑t∈F23​​πt​πt⊕c​​. For the three-qubit repetition code E=span⁡{∣000⟩,∣111⟩},E=\operatorname{span}\{|000\rangle,|111\rangle\},E=span{∣000⟩,∣111⟩}, the complete complementary leakage is exactly Lπ(E)=Λπ.\mathcal L_\pi(E)=\Lambda_\pi.Lπ​(E)=Λπ​. For every fixed full-support final-parity law, the intrinsic Fourier-syndrome graph coordinate www satisfies Lπ(V(w))=Λπ−2Λπ∣w∣2+o(∣w∣2).\mathcal L_\pi(V(w))=\Lambda_\pi-2\Lambda_\pi|w|^2+o(|w|^2).Lπ​(V(w))=Λπ​−2Λπ​∣w∣2+o(∣w∣2). Hence the repetition code is a strict local maximum throughout this two-real-dimensional graph chart for every full-support final-parity distribution, independently of temporal correlations, stationarity, roundwise independence, identical error rates, or cyclic spatial symmetry. By contrast, a conditioned zero-and-one-fault truncation with positive coarse single-location weights has L≤1(E)=0\mathcal L_{\leq 1}(E)=0L≤1​(E)=0 and strictly positive leakage at every nonzero sufficiently nearby graph code. The same reference code is therefore a strict local minimum for the truncated model and a strict local maximum for the complete process. The central conclusion is: > Exact aggregation of paths that implement the same projective physical operator preserves the entire code-optimization landscape, whereas deletion of higher-fault history fibers can reverse the local optimizer geometry. ## Scope The results concern random-unitary, open-loop finite-history models and complete complementary-channel leakage. The optimizer reversal is proved in a specified Fourier-syndrome graph chart around the three-qubit repetition code. The paper does not claim: - a full-Grassmannian classification for the three-qubit model;- a decoder or recovery-circuit construction;- a logical-error threshold;- a circuit-level hardware noise model;- collapse of an intervention-resolved process tensor;- equivalence in the presence of intermediate syndrome measurements, controls, or adaptive recovery. These intervention-resolved settings form the natural next boundary of the theory. ## Relation to the preceding research program This paper is a concluding bridge theorem paper connected to a six-paper exact finite-history QEC and spectral-minimax research line. ### 1. Compression-geometric foundation **Sharp Complementarity, Complete Attainable Region, and Metric Rigidity of Rank-Two Quantum Codes under Collective and Differential Dephasing** Version v0.5r2b DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21523950 This paper determined the complete attainable compression-defect region for rank-two codes under collective and differential two-qubit dephasing, classified the equality geometry, and established sharp metric rigidity. ### 2. Balanced finite-history minimax **Environment-Record Leakage for Finite Quantum Error Histories: Balanced Global Minimax, Complete Minimizer Geometry, and Distributional Stability** Version v0.5r2 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21560397 This paper introduced the complete environment-record leakage objective for finite error histories, solved the balanced two-step minimax problem globally over Gr⁡(2,4)\operatorname{Gr}(2,4)Gr(2,4), classified all balanced minimizers, and established distributional stability. ### 3. Bias-induced geometric selection **Bias-Induced Non-Isoclinic Optimality in Finite Quantum Error Histories: Exact Separation, Thresholdless Bifurcation, and Near-Balanced All-Code Minimax** Version v0.3r2 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21598820 This paper proved exact non-isoclinic separation, an open non-isoclinic parameter region, thresholdless loss of isoclinic optimality under arbitrarily small bias, and the leading full-Grassmannian near-balanced minimax selector. ### 4. Fourth-order overlap selection **Flat-Interior Persistence and Singular Overlap Selection in Near-Balanced Quantum Error Histories: Fourth-Order Transition Curves and Full-Grassmannian Minimax Closure** Version v0.1r3 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21622029 This sequel resolved the higher-order overlap degeneracy, established flat-interior persistence, derived singular boundary-layer transition curves, and closed the near-balanced full-Grassmannian minimax expansion through fourth order. ### 5. Abstract reflected spectral-jet framework **Reflected Spectral-Jet Realization for Degenerate Minimax Problems: Hard-Normal Selection, Flat Tangential Persistence, and Coactive Boundary Transitions** Version v0.2r1 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21636022 This paper extracted a reusable abstract framework for hard-normal isolation, soft tangential persistence, reflected active branches, and coactive boundary transitions in degenerate spectral minimax problems. ### 6. Finite-orbit generalization and first QEC truncation reversal **Beyond Reflected Pairs: Finite-Orbit Spectral Jets, Quadratic Isolation, and Multi-Branch Coactivity in Degenerate Minimax Problems** Version v0.4r1 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21644364 This paper generalized the reflected-pair theory to finite transitive orbits, developed multi-branch coactivity and representation-theoretic jet obstructions, and exhibited an exact three-location QEC realization in which restoring omitted multi-fault histories reverses the local optimizer geometry. ### 7. Present bridge theorem The present paper determines which open-loop temporal path information is exactly removable and which history reductions remain unsafe. It extends the earlier single-process reversal from independent or cyclic models to arbitrary correlated projective-unitary paths and arbitrary full-support final-parity laws. The resulting research progression is compression geometry⟶balanced global minimax⟶bias-induced selection⟶fourth-order closure⟶reflected spectral jets⟶finite-orbit coactivity⟶projective path collapse and distribution-robust reversal.\text{compression geometry}\longrightarrow\text{balanced global minimax}\longrightarrow\text{bias-induced selection}\longrightarrow\text{fourth-order closure}\longrightarrow\text{reflected spectral jets}\longrightarrow\text{finite-orbit coactivity}\longrightarrow\text{projective path collapse and distribution-robust reversal}.compression geometry⟶balanced global minimax⟶bias-induced selection⟶fourth-order closure⟶reflected spectral jets⟶finite-orbit coactivity⟶projective path collapse and distribution-robust reversal. ## Reproducibility package The accompanying bundle contains: - the manuscript PDF;- the LaTeX source;- an exact symbolic verification script;- a machine-readable verification report;- a README describing the proof-artifact contract;- a SHA-256 manifest;- version and package-audit records. The verifier performs 72 exact symbolic checks, including projective Pauli phase identities, phase-covariant path compression, arbitrary-parity polar factors, translation orthogonality, Fourier-syndrome graph compressions, and coefficient bookkeeping for the distribution-robust local expansion. The verifier deliberately rejects optimized Python mode. PASS decisions do not rely on floating-point tolerances. Compactness, maximizing-direction localization, trace-norm differentiability, and uniform asymptotic assembly remain analytic parts of the manuscript proof rather than delegated computational claims.
Open quantum systems have drawn attention over decades due to its applicability in the foundation of theoretical physics, e.g. statistical mechanics, quantum mechanics and condensed matter physics. The dynamics of open quantum systems has been described as separate entities from their surrounding environment that consists of a very large number of modes, somehow coupled to the mode of the system. Even though the exact solution of the dynamical behavior of the system is impossible to calculate, we obtain a tentative solution using the crucial Markov approximation. The input-output formalism of the quantum Langevin equation (QLE) has been considered as a useful tool which provides a semi-classical description of the dynamics of the system, whereas the master equation provides a complete picture of the dynamics of the system expressed in terms of density matrix. While studying the dynamics of nonlinear system/environment coupling using QLE, we see, for a small value of external field, that the steady state system field does not change much from the steady state field obtained in the absence of nonlinear dissipation. However, in a case where a stronger external field is applied, we see that the deviation becomes substantial from the solution of linear system. We also see that the nonlinear coupling introduces significant difference in the cavity fluctuation spectrum. The description, therefore, provides a potential explanation of parametric effects in terms of nonlinear dissipation phenomena associated with the nonlinear coupling. Even though the theories developed in the context of open quantum systems have proven to be powerful tools, they do not provide a satisfactory platform to be implemented on non-linear Hamiltonians. We often approximate it by linearizing over nonlinear steady state field amplitude, and therefore, the interesting effects are often overlooked. The limitation of the analytics provokes us to simulate open quantum dynamics numerically. The numerical method consists of transformation of the environmental degrees of freedom to a one-dimensional many-body chain, and the computational technique includes numerical diagonalization and renormalization process. The time-adaptive density matrix renormalisation group (t-DMRG) is known as one of the most powerful techniques for the simulation of strongly-correlated many-body quantum systems. In this thesis, along with the theoretical modeling, we implement DMRG numerical scheme for the simulation of canonical S/B model by mapping it to one-dimensional harmonic chain with nearest neighbor interactions, and use the method to investigate the dynamics of the free dissipative system. The thermalization of open quantum systems is also studied by generating minimally entangled typical thermal states (METTS) through imaginary time evolution, and real-time evolving an empty system in the presence of the thermal bath. Further, we simulate coherently driven free dissipative Kerr nonlinear system numerically using Euler's method by solving Heisenberg equation of motion and t-DMRG algorithm, and demonstrate how the numerical results are analogous to classical bistability. By comparing with analytics, we see that the DMRG numerics is analogous to the quantum-mechanical exact solution obtained by mapping the equation of motion of the density matrix of the system to a Fokker-Plank equation. The comparison between two different numerical techniques shows that the semi-classical Euler's method determines the dynamics of the system field of one among two coherent branches, whereas DMRG numerics gives the superposition of both of them. Hence, DMRG-determined time dynamics undergoes generating non-classical states. Our approach of dealing with nonlinearity represents an important contribution in the developments of technique to study the dynamical and steady-state behavior of open quantum systems, which is a fundamental aspect of quantum physics.
This work presents a systematic numerical study of the dissipative Jaynes-Cummings model, consisting of a two-level system (qubit) coupled to a truncated harmonic oscillator, both subject to Markovian dissipation. The model is standard in quantum optics and open quantum systems. The master equation is solved using the Lindblad formalism with BDF integration. The study focuses on two standard observables: the qubit excited-state population P_exc(t) and the qubit Bloch vector length |r(t)|. A three-dimensional parameter scan is performed over the coupling g, the qubit dephasing rate gamma_phi, and the oscillator relaxation rate gamma_a, giving 216 cells in total. The parameters used are omega_0 = 6 Hz, omega_1 = 40 Hz, giving a detuning delta = 34 Hz, and thermal occupation n_th = 0.05. MAIN FINDINGS: The single-exponential description of the excited-state population is valid only at intermediate coupling (g approximately 4 to 8 Hz). Outside this region, the dynamics exhibits a multi-timescale structure. The decay time T is non-monotonic in g, with a minimum at g approximately 7 Hz. The location of the minimum depends only weakly on gamma_a, following a power law with exponent 0.127. At strong coupling (g greater than 15 Hz), a two-exponential model is strongly preferred by the Akaike Information Criterion in 43 out of 45 cells. The two timescales are separated by a factor of approximately 150. The fast timescale T_1 is best approximated by the Purcell formula (median ratio of numerical to theoretical value 0.68). The Fermi golden rule overestimates the decay rate by a factor of approximately 4.5. Neither the dressed-state correction nor the Bloch-Redfield calculation improves on the Purcell formula. The Bloch vector length does not follow any simple functional form (single exponential, stretched exponential, power law, or double exponential). All models have mean R-squared in the range 0.31 to 0.36. Its time derivative is, however, almost perfectly correlated with that of the population (mean correlation 0.91). The results are converged with respect to the Fock-space truncation at N_0 = 12, with identical observables for N_0 between 12 and 20. SCOPE: This is a purely numerical study of a well-defined quantum-optical model. It contains no empirical data, no claims about biological or cognitive systems, and no speculative ontology. The model, the numerical method, and the observables are standard. The results include several negative findings (the failure of perturbative formulas, the lack of a simple functional form for the Bloch vector) which are reported honestly and which identify the regime where non-perturbative methods are required. The purpose of this release is to provide reproducible numerical data and a benchmark for future analytical work on the dissipative Jaynes-Cummings model in the strong-coupling regime. CONTENTS: The LaTeX technical note (approximately 20 pages), the Python scripts for the numerical simulations, and the CSV files with the fit results, regime classification, and theoretical comparison. REFERENCES: E. T. Jaynes and F. W. Cummings, Proc. IEEE 51, 89 (1963).G. Lindblad, Commun. Math. Phys. 48, 119 (1976).H.-P. Breuer and F. Petruccione, The Theory of Open Quantum Systems, Oxford University Press (2002).C. W. Gardiner and P. Zoller, Quantum Noise, 3rd ed., Springer (2004).E. M. Purcell, Phys. Rev. 69, 681 (1946).C. Cohen-Tannoudji, J. Dupont-Roc, and G. Grynberg, Atom-Photon Interactions, Wiley (1992).W. P. Schleich, Quantum Optics in Phase Space, Wiley-VCH (2001).
Ultracold atoms have revolutionized atomic and condensed matter physics. In addition to having clean, controllable Hamiltonians, ultracold atoms are near-perfect realizations of isolated quantum systems, in which weak environmental coupling can be neglected on experimental time scales. This opens new opportunities to explore these systems not just in thermal equilibrium, but out of equilibrium as well. In this dissertation, we investigate some properties of closed quantum systems, utilizing a combination of numerical and analytical techniques. We begin by applying full configuration-interaction quantum Monte Carlo (FCIQMC) to the Fermi polaron [1], which we use as a test bed to improve the algorithm. In addition to adapting standard QMC techniques, we introduce novel controlled approximations that allow mitigation of the sign problem and simulation directly in the thermodynamic limit. We also contrast the sign problem of FCIQMC with that of more standard techniques, focusing on FCIQMC’s capacity to work in a second quantized determinant space. Next, we discuss nonequilibrium dynamics near a quantum critical point, focusing on the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising (TFI) chain. We show that the TFI dynamics exhibit critical scaling, within which the spin correlations exhibit qualitatively athermal behavior. We provide strong numerical evidence for the universality of dynamic scaling by utilizing time-dependent matrix product states to simulate a nonintegrable model in the same equilibrium universality class. As this non-integrable model has been realized experimentally [2], we investigate the robustness of our predictions against the presence of open boundary conditions and disorder. We find that the qualitatively athermal correlations remain visible, although other phenomena such as even/odd effects become relevant within the finite size scaling theory. Finally, we investigate the properties of the integrable TFI model upon varying the strength of a non-integrable perturbation, attempting to understand the finite-size scaling behavior of the eigenstate thermalization crossover. We numerically estimate iii the crossover scale of this perturbation strength using exact diagonalization, finding that the crossover scale decreases strongly with system size, and analytically provide a lower bound on the finite-size scaling of this crossover. However, we are unable to solve for the thermodynamic limit of this crossover; doing so will require larger systems and more comprehensive theory.
Thermalization, the evolution of an interacting many-body system towards a thermal Gibbs ensemble after initialization in an arbitrary non-equilibrium state, is currently a phenomenon of great interest, both in theory and experiment. As the time evolution of a quantum system is unitary, the proposed mechanism of thermalization in quantum many-body systems corresponds to the so-called eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) and the typicality of eigenstates. Although this formally solves the contradiction of thermalizing but unitary dynamics in a closed quantum many-body system, it does neither make any statement on the dynamical process of thermalization itself nor in which way the coupling of the system to an environment can hinder or modify the relaxation dynamics. In this thesis, we address both the question whether or not a quantum system driven away from equilibrium is able to relax to a thermal state, which fulfills detailed balance, and if one can identify universal behavior in the non-equilibrium relaxation dynamics. As a first realization of driven quantum systems out of equilibrium, we investigate a system of Ising spins, interacting with the quantized radiation field in an optical cavity. For multiple cavity modes, this system forms a highly entangled and frustrated state with infinite correlation times, known as a quantum spin glass. In the presence of drive and dissipation, introduced by coupling the intra-cavity radiation field to the photon vacuum outside the cavity via lossy mirrors, the quantum glass state is modified in a universal manner. For frequencies below the photon loss rate, the dissipation takes over and the system shows the universal behavior of a dissipative spin glass, with a characteristic spectral density mathcalA(omega)simsqrtomega\\mathcal{A}(\\omega)\\sim\\sqrt{\\omega}mathcalA(omega)simsqrtomega. On the other hand, for frequencies above the loss rate, the system retains the universal behavior of a zero temperature, quantum spin glass. Remarkably, at the glass transition, the two subsystems of spins and photons thermalize to a joint effective temperature, even in the presence of photon loss. This thermalization is a consequence of the strong spin-photon interactions, which favor detailed balance in the system and detain photons from escaping the cavity. In the thermalized system, the features of the spin glass are mirrored onto the photon degrees of freedom, leading to an emergent photon glass phase. Exploiting the inherent photon loss of the cavity, we make predictions of possible measurements on the escaping photons, which contain detailed information of the state inside the cavity and allow for a precise, non-destructive measurement of the glass state. As a further set of non-equilibrium systems, we consider one-dimensional quantum fluids driven out of equilibrium, whose universal low energy theory is formed by the so-called Luttinger Liquid description, which, due to its large degree of universality, is of intense theoretical and experimental interest. A set of recent experiments in research groups in Vienna, Innsbruck and Munich have probed the non-equilibrium time-evolution of one-dimensional quantum fluids for different experimental realizations and are pushing into a time regime, where thermalization is expected. From a theoretical point of view, one-dimensional quantum fluids are particular interesting, as Luttinger Liquids are integrable and therefore, due to an infinite number of constants of motion, do not thermalize. The leading order correction to the quadratic theory is irrelevant in the sense of the renormalization group and does therefore not modify static correlation functions, however, it breaks integrability and will therefore, even if irrelevant, induce a completely different non-equilibrium dynamics as the quadratic Luttinger theory alone. In this thesis, we derive for the first time a kinetic equation for interacting Luttinger Liquids, which describes the time evolution of the excitation densities for arbitrary initial states. The resonant character of the interaction makes a straightforward derivation of the kinetic equation, using Fermi\'s golden rule, impossible and we have to develop non-perturbative techniques in the Keldysh framework. We derive a closed expression for the time evolution of the excitation densities in terms of self-energies and vertex corrections. Close to equilibrium, the kinetic equation describes the exponential decay of excitations, with a decay rate sigmaR=mboxImSigmaR\\sigma^R=\\mbox{Im}\\Sigma^RsigmaR=mboxImSigmaR, determined by the self-energy at equilibrium. However, for long times tau\\tautau, it also reveals the presence of dynamical slow modes, which are the consequence of exactly energy conserving dynamics and lead to an algebraic decay simtau−etasubD\\sim\\tau^{-\\eta\\sub{D}}simtau−etasubD with etaD=0.58\\eta_D=0.58etaD​=0.58. The presence of these dynamical slow modes is not contained in the equilibrium Matsubara formalism, while they emerge naturally in the non-equilibrium formalism developed in this thesis. In order to initialize a one-dimensional quantum fluid out of equilibrium, we consider an interaction quench in a model of interacting, dispersive fermions in Chap.~\\ref{sec:Quench}. In this scenario, the fermionic interaction is suddenly changed at time t=0t=0t=0, such that for t>0t>0t>0 the system is not in an eigenstate and therefore undergoes a non-trivial time evolution. For the quadratic theory, the stationary state in the limit trightarrowinftyt\\rightarrow\\inftytrightarrowinfty is a non-thermal, or prethermal, state, described by a generalized Gibbs ensemble (GGE). The GGE takes into account for the conservation of all integrals of motion, formed by the eigenmodes of the Hamiltonian. On the other hand, in the presence of non-linearities, the final state for trightarrowinftyt\\rightarrow\\inftytrightarrowinfty is a thermal state with a finite temperature T>0T>0T>0. . The spatio-temporal, dynamical thermalization process can be decomposed into three regimes: A prequench regime on the largest distances, which is determined by the initial state, a prethermal plateau for intermediate distances, which is determined by the metastable fixed point of the quadratic theory and a thermal region on the shortest distances. The latter spreads sub-ballistically simtalpha\\sim t^{\\alpha}simtalpha in space with 0<alpha<10<\\alpha<10<alpha<1 depending on the quench. Until complete thermalization (i.e. for times t<inftyt<\\inftyt<infty), the thermal region contains more energy than the prethermal and prequench region, which is expressed in a larger temperature Tt>TinftyT_{t}>T_{\\infty}Tt​>Tinfty​, decreasing towards its final value TinftyT_{\\infty}Tinfty​. As the system has achieved local detailed balance in the thermalized region, energy transport to the non-thermal region can only be performed by the macroscopic dynamical slow modes and the decay of the temperature Tt−Tinftysimt−etasubDT_{t}-T_{\\infty}\\sim t^{-\\eta\\sub{D}}Tt​−Tinfty​simt−etasubD again witnesses the presence of these slow modes. The very slow spreading of thermalization is consistent with recent experiments performed in Vienna, which observe a metastable, prethermal state after a quench and only observe the onset of thermalization on much larger time scales. As an immediate indication of thermalization, we determine the time evolution of the fermionic momentum distribution after a quench from non-interacting to interacting fermions. For this quench scenario, the step in the Fermi distribution at the Fermi momentum ksubFk\\sub{F}ksubF decays to zero algebraically in the absence of a non-linearity but as a stretched exponential (the exponent being proportional to the non-linearity) in the presence of a finite non-linearity. This can serve as a proof for the presence or absence of the non-linearity even on time-scales for which thermalization can not yet be observed. Finally, we consider a bosonic quantum fluid, which is driven away from equilibrium by permanent heating. The origin of the heating is atomic spontaneous emission of laser photons, which are used to create a coherent lattice potential in optical lattice experiments. This process preserves the system\'s U(1)U(1)U(1)-invariance, i.e. conserves the global particle number, and the corresponding long-wavelength description is a heated, interacting Luttinger Liquid, for which phonon modes are continuously populated with a momentum dependent rate partialtnqsimgamma∣q∣\\partial_tn_q\\sim\\gamma |q|partialt​nq​simgamma∣q∣. In the dynamics, we identify a quasi-thermal regime for large momenta, featuring an increasing time-dependent effective temperature. In this regime, due to fast phonon-phonon scattering, detailed balance has been achieved and is expressed by a time-local, increasing temperature. The thermal region emerges locally and spreads in space sub-ballistically according to xtsimt4/5x_t\\sim t^{4/5}xt​simt4/5. For larger distances, the system is described by an non-equilibrium phonon distribution nqsim∣q∣n_q\\sim |q|nq​sim∣q∣, which leads to a new, non-equilibrium behavior of large distance observables. For instance, the phonon decay rate scales universally as gammaqsim∣q∣5/3\\gamma_q\\sim |q|^{5/3}gammaq​sim∣q∣5/3, with a new non-equilibrium exponent eta=5/3\\eta=5/3eta=5/3, which differs from equilibrium. This new, universal behavior is guaranteed by the U(1)U(1)U(1) invariant dynamics of the system and is insensitive to further subleading perturbations. The non-equilibrium long-distance behavior can be determined experimentally by measuring the static and dynamic structure factor, both of which clearly indicate the exponents for phonon decay, eta=5/3\\eta=5/3eta=5/3 and for the spreading of thermalization etaT=4/5\\eta_T=4/5etaT​=4/5. Remarkably, even in the presence of this strong external drive, the interactions and their aim to achieve detailed balance are strong enough to establish a locally emerging and spatially spreading thermal region. The physical setups in this thesis do not only reveal interesting and new dynamical features in the out-of-equilibrium time evolution of interacting systems, but they also strongly underline the high degree of universality of thermalization for the classes of models studied here. May it be a system of coupled spins and photons, where the photons are pulled away from a thermal state by Markovian photon d
Motivated by a recent experiment that realizes nearest-neighbor dipolar couplings in an optical lattice [C. Lagoin et al., Nature (London) 609, 485 (2022)], we study a one-dimensional version of the two-component extended Bose-Hubbard model via the density-matrix renormalization group method. By using the nearest-neighbor and on-site interaction parameters from the experiment, we start by mapping the quantum phase diagram in the hopping parameter ${t}_{A}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{t}_{B}$ plane with boson densities ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}={\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B}=1/2$. In addition to the density-wave phase reported in the experiment, we find several regimes of superfluidity when one or both hopping parameters are large enough, and interestingly there is a supercounterfluid phase at moderate and comparable hopping parameters. The universality classes of these phase transitions are analyzed from the correlation functions, excitation gaps, and entanglement entropy. In particular, a Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type is recognized for several gapped-to-gapless transitions. In addition, we also study the quantum phase transitions by varying ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B}$ from 0 to 1 while keeping ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}=1/2$. We identify a supersolid phase in a wide range of $1/2<{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B}<1$. Our work paves the way for realizing exotic many-body phases in cold-atom experiments upon proper tuning of experimental parameters.