Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Gauge fields and quantum theory

Stephen William Mackman

Published Jan 1, 1996• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This thesis investigates the problems within quantum mechanics for the Bohm model caused by Lorentz invariance and the existence of photons. A model describing the electromagnetic interactions of fermions is produced which does not use photons and avoids these problems. It is then shown how these techniques can be extended to linearised gravitational interactions. Finally semi-classical gravity and the possibility of gravitationally induced collapse are considered. In the first part of the thesis two modifications to the Bohm model are proposed. One takes account of Lorentz invariance, and the other is capable of describing photons. The main part of the thesis is devoted to describing interactions in a way which does not need extra gauge particles, and so is in the same spirit as the Bohm model. Electromagnetic interactions are formed using a 4-potential operator which is calculated directly, without imposing commutation relations on the 4-potential. This leads to an expression for the 4-potential in terms of the Dirac field, and results in there being no photon states. There are various ways of constructing the theory and the scattering matrix of standard QED is compared to the scattering matrix of the version which appears to be most similar. Considering only the matrix elements between fermion states, they are found to be in agreement at the order e(^2), but disagree at the order e(^4). It follows that this model, which otherwise appears to be a self consistent theory of QED, cannot agree with experiment. The same techniques can be used to quantise General Relativity when it is linearised about the Minkowski metric. The metric operator is calculated in terms of the Dirac field. The interaction is similar to that of electrodynamics, being of order 4 in the Dirac field. Finally issues relating to gravitational collapse are discussed.

Related papers

The Quantum Theory of Radiation

E R Pike frs, Sarben Sarkar

Abstract This book is unique in covering phenomena in photon- matter interactions in a unified way over a range of many orders in energy. The quantum field theoretic approach to the fully relativistic theory of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is presented together with the non- relativistic theory in both confined and unconfined geometries. The predictions of QED have been verified to a greater accuracy than any other physical theory. Moreover QED is a paradigm for other gauge theories and is presented in such a way that the generalisation to other gauge theories is natural. Gauge and Poincare symmetry properties and the non-existence of a photon wave function are thoroughly discussed. Starting from the Dirac equation the non-relativistic interaction of the electron with the electromagnetic field is derived as an effective Hamiltonian of multipole expansions. Much of quantum optics is based on the lowest order dipole approximation. From this point on the treatment of fully relativistic QED and quantum optics is done in parallel. Applications of perturbation theory such as Compton and Moller scattering and the theory photdetection are given. After the impressive successes of QED, the limitation of the theory and the necessity of electroweak theory and quantumchromodynamics are discussed. The remaining chapters are devoted to quantum optics inside cavaties. Various approaches to open systems such as master equations are discussed within the context of active systems (e.g. the laser) and passive systems. Semi- classical approximarions are shown to imply a rich non- linear dynamics including chaos for certain parameter regimes. The effect of fluctuations on such non-linear dynamics is also studied. The final chapter is devoted to highly non- classical states of the light field such as photon number, squeezed and two photon entangled states. The latter are studied for the important system of parametric down conversion and the localisation properties of photons are characterised in terms of asympotic tails in photodetection probabilities as a function of time delay. The range of the book has wider benefits. Workers in quantum optics will gain a deeper understanding of the foundations of their subject and field theorists will see concrete examples of open systems, which are beginning to impinge on fundamental theories.

•Dec 7, 1995•68 citations

Understanding of Quantum Mechanics as a Theory Based on General Relativity

Eliade N. Stefanescu

In this paper, the quantum dynamics was obtained in the framework of the general theory of relativity, where a quantum particle is described by a distribution of matter, with amplitude functions of the matter density, in the two conjugate spaces of the spatial coordinates and of the momentum, called wave functions. For a free particle, these wave functions are conjugate wave packets in the coordinate and momentum spaces, with time-dependent phases proportional to the relativistic Lagrangian, as the wave velocities in the coordinate space are equal to the distribution velocity described by the wave packet in this space. From the wave velocities of the particle wave functions, Lorentz’s force and the Maxwell equations were obtained. From the wave/group equation in the momentum space describing the Lorentz force, the expressions of the electric and magnetic fields as functions of the electric potential conjugated to time and of the vector potential conjugated to the coordinates in the particle-field Lagrangian were obtained. With these expressions, the electric and magnetic fields that satisfy the Faraday-Maxwell law of electromagnetic induction and the two Gauss-Maxwell laws of these fields were obtained. The Ampère-Maxwell law is obtained only by taking into account the physical consistency of the matter-field interaction of the equality of the propagation field velocity with the maximum relativistic velocity c. For a quantum particle in the electromagnetic field, dynamic equations in the coordinate and momentum spaces and the particle and antiparticle wave functions were obtained. It was shown that the electromagnetic potentials as functions of the coordinates describing the matter distribution of the quantum particle do not alter this distribution – under the action of an electromagnetic a quantum particle moves as a whole. The scattering or tunneling rate in an electromagnetic field, for the two possible cases, with the spin conservation, or inversion, were obtained. This description of a quantum particle as a distribution of matter with a density amplitude/wavefunction of the form of a wave packet, with the time-dependent phase proportional to the relativistic Lagrangian as a function of the metric tensor including also the gravitational field, enables the application of this theory in quantum gravity and quantum field theory in agreement with general relativity.

Book Publisher International (a part of SCIENCEDOMAIN International)•Nov 5, 2024•1 citation

Symmetries in covariant quantum mechanics

Dirk Saller

The thesis is divided in two parts. In the first part of the thesis, I present an updated version of the theory of covariant quantum mechanics and of the associated classical background. This theory has originally been proposed by Jadczyk and Modugno and further developed in cooperation with other people. It provides a geometric model for quantum mechanics of a scalar and spin particle in a curved spacetime with absolute time equipped with a given classical gravitational and electromagnetic field. Starting from minimal axioms, this model yields in a covariant way the Schrödinger equation by means of a global Lagrangian formalism and the quantum operators associated with classical quantisable functions by means of classification of distinguished quantum vector fields. In the second part of the thesis, I investigate systematically the infinitesimal symmetries of the classical and quantum geometric structures. This part deals with the main original contributions of the thesis. Some results fit well-known facts of other mathematical models of quantum mechanics, but are derived by innovative procedures. Other results are completely new. The most important original contributions can be summarized by the following two statements: The quantum symmetries constitute Lie algebras, which are naturally isomorphic to subalgebras of the new classical Lie algebra of quantisable functions. Let me stress that this algebra is not a Poisson subalgebra. On the other hand, by means of the quantum Lagrangian formalism, we can associate a conserved quantum current with any element of a distinguished classical subalgebra. These results might be the prequantum source of the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics.

•Jan 1, 2001•3 citations

Failure of Gauge Invariance or Necessity of Quantum Gravity?

Shan Gao

We analyse the gravitational Aharonov-Bohm (AB) phase within the semiclassical framework. We first review the traditional non-relativistic approximation, where a particle of rest mass \(m\) couples to the Newtonian potential via \(H_{\rm int}=m\Phi\), yielding a gauge-invariant phase analogous to the electromagnetic AB effect. We then show that this approximation fails when the particle's total energy varies between interferometer branches. A rigorous derivation from linearised general relativity reveals that in the weak-field, non-relativistic limit, gravity couples to the local energy density, not merely the rest mass. In a laser-driven atom interferometer, the two branches of the superposition differ by the location of an excitation energy \(\delta E\): either stored in the laser apparatus at \(\mathbf{x}_L\) or carried by the atom at \(\mathbf{x}_A(t)\). Under a gauge transformation $\delta h_{\mu\nu} = -\partial_\mu \xi_\nu - \partial_\nu \xi_\mu$, the gravitational AB phase acquires a residual \(\delta(\Delta \phi_{\rm grav}) = -\frac{\delta E}{\hbar c^2}[\xi_0(\mathbf{x}_L,t_f)-\xi_0(\mathbf{x}_A(t_f),t_f)]\) for a purely temporal generator, which is generically nonzero. Since experiments such as Overstreet et al. (2022) measure a stable, reproducible gravitational AB phase, we are compelled to choose between two mutually exclusive possibilities. If gauge invariance (diffeomorphism invariance) is a fundamental principle, then the semiclassical framework is incomplete and a quantum theory of gravity is necessary. If, on the other hand, gauge invariance fails, then semiclassical gravity can be a complete theory. In this case, the gravitational potentials must be understood as real physical fields, and the gauge-dependent phase is a genuine observable, consistent with experiment. These two resolutions are mutually exclusive, and their implications for the nature of gravity and gauge symmetry are profound.

•Jul 18, 2026•0 citations

Quantum estimation for gravitation and quantum information with acceleration

T. G. Downes

In this thesis we shall apply techniques from quantum information theory to the problem of measuring the structure of spacetime or equivalently measuring the gravitational field. In turn we will also look at how acceleration may effect quantum information techniques for processing and transmitting information. Measuring the structure of spacetime is a slight abuse of terminology as spacetime structure is not directly observable. We will be investigating the estimation of spacetime structure by making measurements on quantum systems which depend on the spacetime background. The structure of spacetime and the gravitational field will be treated in accordance with Einstein's general theory of relativity. This is currently the most accurately tested classical theory for gravity. It is widely believed that fundamentally, gravity should be treated within the framework of quantum mechanics, just like the other forces of nature. This is yet to be seen experimentally and a theory capable of falsifiable predictions is yet to be found. In this thesis we shall focus on the effects of gravity at the classical level, however we shall treat matter and non-gravitational energy using quantum mechanics. When looking at how gravity effects quantum information we will specifically be focusing on the simple case of acceleration, yet we shall treat it in this relativistic spacetime context. Knowing the structure of spacetime in general relativity amounts to knowing an object called the metric tensor. This object contains all the information about a spacetime. This may include local curvature, for instance around a star or black hole, gravitational radiation coming from a binary pulsar and even the large scale structure of the universe such as the rate of expansion. By performing local experiments one may attempt to extract this information. Fundamentally these experiments will be governed by quantum mechanics, hence the accuracy of the estimation will be fundamentally limited by the statistical nature of quantum theory. In this thesis we shall develop an equation which states just what accuracy one can ultimately achieve when attempting to measure the structure of spacetime. This equation will be shown to be a generalisation of known results for the accuracy to which one can ultimately measure position and momentum as well as time and energy. The result will be applied to a range of relativistic phenomena including acceleration in flat spacetime, the local curvature around a black hole, the amplitude of a gravitational wave and the expansion of the universe in a cosmological model. Following the use of quantum information theory to investigate gravity we shall look at how acceleration can effect quantum information. Firstly we shall see how quantum entanglement can be created and stored between two optical cavities when one is uniformly accelerating. This is in contrast to a number of results which predict that entanglement will be lost in the presence of acceleration. This loss of entanglement is predicted due to an as yet unobserved phenomena known as the Unruh effect. The Unruh effect states that an observer uniformly accelerating will see a thermal distribution of particles even if an inertial observer will see no particles at all. We will show how the use of optical cavities can prevent this effect from causing problems both for the storage and creation of entanglement. Finally we shall look at how a particular quantum detection scheme can be employed in the presence of acceleration. Our technique will emphasis the importance of locality, that is the localisation of physics in spacetime. We will also show how some commonly used approximations used to study the Unruh effect, can be avoided with our new formulation.

•Jan 1, 2011•2 citations

A discussion on a possibility to interpret quantum mechanics in terms of general relativity

Vu B Ho

It is shown that, with some reasonable assumptions, the theory of general relativity can be made compatible with quantum mechanics by using the field equations of general relativity to construct a Robertson-Walker metric for a quantum particle so that the line element of the particle can be transformed entirely to that of the Minkowski spacetime, which is assumed by a quantum observer, and the spacetime dynamics of the particle described by a Minkowski observer takes the form of quantum mechanics. Spacetime structure of a quantum particle may have either positive or negative curvature. However, in order to be describable using the familiar framework of quantum mechanics, the spacetime structure of a quantum particle must be "quantised" by an introduction of the imaginary number $i$. If a particle has a positive curvature then the quantisation is equivalent to turning the pseudo-Riemannian spacetime of the particle into a Riemannian spacetime. This means that it is assumed the particle is capable of measuring its temporal distance like its spatial distances. On the other hand, when a particle has a negative curvature and a negative energy density then quantising the spacetime structure of the particle is equivalent to viewing the particle as if it had a positive curvature and a positive energy density.

arXiv:hep-th/9507069•Jul 12, 1995•0 citations
This thesis investigates the problems within quantum mechanics for the Bohm model caused by Lorentz invariance and the existence of photons. A model describing the electromagnetic interactions of fermions is produced which does not use photons and avoids these problems. It is then shown how these techniques can be extended to linearised gravitational interactions. Finally semi-classical gravity and the possibility of gravitationally induced collapse are considered. In the first part of the thesis two modifications to the Bohm model are proposed. One takes account of Lorentz invariance, and the other is capable of describing photons. The main part of the thesis is devoted to describing interactions in a way which does not need extra gauge particles, and so is in the same spirit as the Bohm model. Electromagnetic interactions are formed using a 4-potential operator which is calculated directly, without imposing commutation relations on the 4-potential. This leads to an expression for the 4-potential in terms of the Dirac field, and results in there being no photon states. There are various ways of constructing the theory and the scattering matrix of standard QED is compared to the scattering matrix of the version which appears to be most similar. Considering only the matrix elements between fermion states, they are found to be in agreement at the order e(^2), but disagree at the order e(^4). It follows that this model, which otherwise appears to be a self consistent theory of QED, cannot agree with experiment. The same techniques can be used to quantise General Relativity when it is linearised about the Minkowski metric. The metric operator is calculated in terms of the Dirac field. The interaction is similar to that of electrodynamics, being of order 4 in the Dirac field. Finally issues relating to gravitational collapse are discussed.
Abstract This book is unique in covering phenomena in photon- matter interactions in a unified way over a range of many orders in energy. The quantum field theoretic approach to the fully relativistic theory of quantum electrodynamics (QED) is presented together with the non- relativistic theory in both confined and unconfined geometries. The predictions of QED have been verified to a greater accuracy than any other physical theory. Moreover QED is a paradigm for other gauge theories and is presented in such a way that the generalisation to other gauge theories is natural. Gauge and Poincare symmetry properties and the non-existence of a photon wave function are thoroughly discussed. Starting from the Dirac equation the non-relativistic interaction of the electron with the electromagnetic field is derived as an effective Hamiltonian of multipole expansions. Much of quantum optics is based on the lowest order dipole approximation. From this point on the treatment of fully relativistic QED and quantum optics is done in parallel. Applications of perturbation theory such as Compton and Moller scattering and the theory photdetection are given. After the impressive successes of QED, the limitation of the theory and the necessity of electroweak theory and quantumchromodynamics are discussed. The remaining chapters are devoted to quantum optics inside cavaties. Various approaches to open systems such as master equations are discussed within the context of active systems (e.g. the laser) and passive systems. Semi- classical approximarions are shown to imply a rich non- linear dynamics including chaos for certain parameter regimes. The effect of fluctuations on such non-linear dynamics is also studied. The final chapter is devoted to highly non- classical states of the light field such as photon number, squeezed and two photon entangled states. The latter are studied for the important system of parametric down conversion and the localisation properties of photons are characterised in terms of asympotic tails in photodetection probabilities as a function of time delay. The range of the book has wider benefits. Workers in quantum optics will gain a deeper understanding of the foundations of their subject and field theorists will see concrete examples of open systems, which are beginning to impinge on fundamental theories.
In this paper, the quantum dynamics was obtained in the framework of the general theory of relativity, where a quantum particle is described by a distribution of matter, with amplitude functions of the matter density, in the two conjugate spaces of the spatial coordinates and of the momentum, called wave functions. For a free particle, these wave functions are conjugate wave packets in the coordinate and momentum spaces, with time-dependent phases proportional to the relativistic Lagrangian, as the wave velocities in the coordinate space are equal to the distribution velocity described by the wave packet in this space. From the wave velocities of the particle wave functions, Lorentz’s force and the Maxwell equations were obtained. From the wave/group equation in the momentum space describing the Lorentz force, the expressions of the electric and magnetic fields as functions of the electric potential conjugated to time and of the vector potential conjugated to the coordinates in the particle-field Lagrangian were obtained. With these expressions, the electric and magnetic fields that satisfy the Faraday-Maxwell law of electromagnetic induction and the two Gauss-Maxwell laws of these fields were obtained. The Ampère-Maxwell law is obtained only by taking into account the physical consistency of the matter-field interaction of the equality of the propagation field velocity with the maximum relativistic velocity c. For a quantum particle in the electromagnetic field, dynamic equations in the coordinate and momentum spaces and the particle and antiparticle wave functions were obtained. It was shown that the electromagnetic potentials as functions of the coordinates describing the matter distribution of the quantum particle do not alter this distribution – under the action of an electromagnetic a quantum particle moves as a whole. The scattering or tunneling rate in an electromagnetic field, for the two possible cases, with the spin conservation, or inversion, were obtained. This description of a quantum particle as a distribution of matter with a density amplitude/wavefunction of the form of a wave packet, with the time-dependent phase proportional to the relativistic Lagrangian as a function of the metric tensor including also the gravitational field, enables the application of this theory in quantum gravity and quantum field theory in agreement with general relativity.
The thesis is divided in two parts. In the first part of the thesis, I present an updated version of the theory of covariant quantum mechanics and of the associated classical background. This theory has originally been proposed by Jadczyk and Modugno and further developed in cooperation with other people. It provides a geometric model for quantum mechanics of a scalar and spin particle in a curved spacetime with absolute time equipped with a given classical gravitational and electromagnetic field. Starting from minimal axioms, this model yields in a covariant way the Schrödinger equation by means of a global Lagrangian formalism and the quantum operators associated with classical quantisable functions by means of classification of distinguished quantum vector fields. In the second part of the thesis, I investigate systematically the infinitesimal symmetries of the classical and quantum geometric structures. This part deals with the main original contributions of the thesis. Some results fit well-known facts of other mathematical models of quantum mechanics, but are derived by innovative procedures. Other results are completely new. The most important original contributions can be summarized by the following two statements: The quantum symmetries constitute Lie algebras, which are naturally isomorphic to subalgebras of the new classical Lie algebra of quantisable functions. Let me stress that this algebra is not a Poisson subalgebra. On the other hand, by means of the quantum Lagrangian formalism, we can associate a conserved quantum current with any element of a distinguished classical subalgebra. These results might be the prequantum source of the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics.
We analyse the gravitational Aharonov-Bohm (AB) phase within the semiclassical framework. We first review the traditional non-relativistic approximation, where a particle of rest mass mmm couples to the Newtonian potential via Hint=mΦH_{\rm int}=m\PhiHint​=mΦ, yielding a gauge-invariant phase analogous to the electromagnetic AB effect. We then show that this approximation fails when the particle's total energy varies between interferometer branches. A rigorous derivation from linearised general relativity reveals that in the weak-field, non-relativistic limit, gravity couples to the local energy density, not merely the rest mass. In a laser-driven atom interferometer, the two branches of the superposition differ by the location of an excitation energy δE\delta EδE: either stored in the laser apparatus at xL\mathbf{x}_LxL​ or carried by the atom at xA(t)\mathbf{x}_A(t)xA​(t). Under a gauge transformation δhμν=−∂μξν−∂νξμ\delta h_{\mu\nu} = -\partial_\mu \xi_\nu - \partial_\nu \xi_\muδhμν​=−∂μ​ξν​−∂ν​ξμ​, the gravitational AB phase acquires a residual δ(Δϕgrav)=−δEℏc2[ξ0(xL,tf)−ξ0(xA(tf),tf)]\delta(\Delta \phi_{\rm grav}) = -\frac{\delta E}{\hbar c^2}[\xi_0(\mathbf{x}_L,t_f)-\xi_0(\mathbf{x}_A(t_f),t_f)]δ(Δϕgrav​)=−ℏc2δE​[ξ0​(xL​,tf​)−ξ0​(xA​(tf​),tf​)] for a purely temporal generator, which is generically nonzero. Since experiments such as Overstreet et al. (2022) measure a stable, reproducible gravitational AB phase, we are compelled to choose between two mutually exclusive possibilities. If gauge invariance (diffeomorphism invariance) is a fundamental principle, then the semiclassical framework is incomplete and a quantum theory of gravity is necessary. If, on the other hand, gauge invariance fails, then semiclassical gravity can be a complete theory. In this case, the gravitational potentials must be understood as real physical fields, and the gauge-dependent phase is a genuine observable, consistent with experiment. These two resolutions are mutually exclusive, and their implications for the nature of gravity and gauge symmetry are profound.
In this thesis we shall apply techniques from quantum information theory to the problem of measuring the structure of spacetime or equivalently measuring the gravitational field. In turn we will also look at how acceleration may effect quantum information techniques for processing and transmitting information. Measuring the structure of spacetime is a slight abuse of terminology as spacetime structure is not directly observable. We will be investigating the estimation of spacetime structure by making measurements on quantum systems which depend on the spacetime background. The structure of spacetime and the gravitational field will be treated in accordance with Einstein's general theory of relativity. This is currently the most accurately tested classical theory for gravity. It is widely believed that fundamentally, gravity should be treated within the framework of quantum mechanics, just like the other forces of nature. This is yet to be seen experimentally and a theory capable of falsifiable predictions is yet to be found. In this thesis we shall focus on the effects of gravity at the classical level, however we shall treat matter and non-gravitational energy using quantum mechanics. When looking at how gravity effects quantum information we will specifically be focusing on the simple case of acceleration, yet we shall treat it in this relativistic spacetime context. Knowing the structure of spacetime in general relativity amounts to knowing an object called the metric tensor. This object contains all the information about a spacetime. This may include local curvature, for instance around a star or black hole, gravitational radiation coming from a binary pulsar and even the large scale structure of the universe such as the rate of expansion. By performing local experiments one may attempt to extract this information. Fundamentally these experiments will be governed by quantum mechanics, hence the accuracy of the estimation will be fundamentally limited by the statistical nature of quantum theory. In this thesis we shall develop an equation which states just what accuracy one can ultimately achieve when attempting to measure the structure of spacetime. This equation will be shown to be a generalisation of known results for the accuracy to which one can ultimately measure position and momentum as well as time and energy. The result will be applied to a range of relativistic phenomena including acceleration in flat spacetime, the local curvature around a black hole, the amplitude of a gravitational wave and the expansion of the universe in a cosmological model. Following the use of quantum information theory to investigate gravity we shall look at how acceleration can effect quantum information. Firstly we shall see how quantum entanglement can be created and stored between two optical cavities when one is uniformly accelerating. This is in contrast to a number of results which predict that entanglement will be lost in the presence of acceleration. This loss of entanglement is predicted due to an as yet unobserved phenomena known as the Unruh effect. The Unruh effect states that an observer uniformly accelerating will see a thermal distribution of particles even if an inertial observer will see no particles at all. We will show how the use of optical cavities can prevent this effect from causing problems both for the storage and creation of entanglement. Finally we shall look at how a particular quantum detection scheme can be employed in the presence of acceleration. Our technique will emphasis the importance of locality, that is the localisation of physics in spacetime. We will also show how some commonly used approximations used to study the Unruh effect, can be avoided with our new formulation.
It is shown that, with some reasonable assumptions, the theory of general relativity can be made compatible with quantum mechanics by using the field equations of general relativity to construct a Robertson-Walker metric for a quantum particle so that the line element of the particle can be transformed entirely to that of the Minkowski spacetime, which is assumed by a quantum observer, and the spacetime dynamics of the particle described by a Minkowski observer takes the form of quantum mechanics. Spacetime structure of a quantum particle may have either positive or negative curvature. However, in order to be describable using the familiar framework of quantum mechanics, the spacetime structure of a quantum particle must be "quantised" by an introduction of the imaginary number iii. If a particle has a positive curvature then the quantisation is equivalent to turning the pseudo-Riemannian spacetime of the particle into a Riemannian spacetime. This means that it is assumed the particle is capable of measuring its temporal distance like its spatial distances. On the other hand, when a particle has a negative curvature and a negative energy density then quantising the spacetime structure of the particle is equivalent to viewing the particle as if it had a positive curvature and a positive energy density.