A comparative study of authentication schemes in IoDN: From traditional cryptography to post-quantum innovations
Deepakshi Dabas, Pawan Singh Mehra
The rapid proliferation of Internet of Drones Networks (IoDN) in mission-critical applications such as surveillance, logistics, precision agriculture, and disaster response has intensified the demand for robust, scalable authentication mechanisms that ensure data confidentiality and integrity in dynamic, resource-constrained environments. Traditional cryptographic authentication schemes—such as RSA and ECC—are increasingly vulnerable to the computational power of quantum adversaries, particularly due to Shor's and Grover's algorithms, which compromise their long-term viability. This study conducts a systematic and comparative evaluation of over 50 authentication schemes spanning classical, lightweight, blockchain-augmented, and post-quantum cryptographic (PQC) domains. The analysis benchmarks protocols against multidimensional metrics including quantum resistance, computational and memory overhead, key generation cost, and deployment feasibility in UAV swarms. Notably, PQC primitives such as lattice-based CRYSTALS-Dilithium and hash-based SPHINCS+ exhibit superior quantum robustness but introduce latency and footprint challenges, impeding real-time IoDN operations. In contrast, optimized Ring-LWE and NTRU variants demonstrate 25–40% reductions in energy consumption on embedded drone platform, while preserving NIST-compliant security levels. Hybrid architectures integrating blockchain for decentralized trust and PQC primitives for key encapsulation show promise in balancing performance and fault tolerance, addressing key distribution bottlenecks without undermining scalability. However, interoperability gaps with IoT-centric protocols (e.g., LoRaWAN, MQTT) highlight standardization challenges. This study advocates for the co-design of quantum-resilient, lightweight authentication frameworks tailored to the spatio-temporal constraints of IoDN and outlines strategic directions for cross-sectoral collaboration to accelerate secure transition into the post-quantum era.
CRC Press eBooks•Nov 6, 2025•0 citations