© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Communications

Dual-Protection for Free-Space Quantum Key Distribution: Enhancing Security Against Eve via Channel Randomness

Ragini Verma, Anshul Jaiswal, Anh T. Pham

Published Oct 13, 2025• 1 citation

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel quantum key distribution (QKD) set-up designed to enhance the security of a free-space optical (FSO) quantum communication system. By incorporating channel ordering information, the proposed QPSK-QKD (P-QPSK-QKD) system leverages the inherent randomness of FSO channels, providing dual protection against eavesdroppers (Eve). The first layer of security is achieved through the QPSK-QKD mechanism, while the second arises from the randomness of the FSO channels. To ensure a comprehensive investigation, the performance of P-QPSK-QKD and the existing QPSK-QKD (E-QPSK-QKD) system is analyzed using a Málaga distributed atmospheric turbulence channel model incorporating pointing errors. Novel closed-form expressions are derived for different performance metrics, including probability of sifted keys, quantum bit error rate, probability of Eve (Peve), and ergodic secret key rate (ESKR), under both perfect and imperfect feedback conditions. Intensive examination indicates that, unlike E-QPSK-QKD, wherePeveshows a water-falling trend with increasing signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) under dual thresholds, P-QPSK-QKD achieves a saturatedPeve, enhancing security. Moreover, under the single threshold,Peveof P-QPSK-QKD is twice that of E-QPSK-QKD. Additionally, due to channel randomness, the mutual information between Alice and Eve remains zero (for both single and dual thresholds), even at infinite SNR for P-QPSK-QKD, providing consistently higher ESKR than E-QPSK-QKD system under both perfect and imperfect feedback conditions.

DOI: 10.1109/tcomm.2025.3621095

Related papers

Design and Security Analysis of Quantum Key Distribution Protocol Over Free-Space Optics Using Dual-Threshold Direct-Detection Receiver

Phuc V. Trinh, Thanh V. Pham, Ngoc The Dang +3 more

This paper proposes a novel design and analyzes security performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol over free-space optics (FSO). Unlike conventional QKD protocols based on physical characteristics of quantum mechanics, the proposed QKD protocol can be implemented on standard FSO systems using subcarrier intensity modulation binary phase shift keying and direct detection with a dual-threshold receiver. Under security constraints, the design criteria for FSO transmitter and receiver, in particular, the modulation depth and the selection of dual-threshold detection, respectively, is analytically investigated. For the security analysis, quantum bit error rate, ergodic secret-key rate, and final key-creation rate are concisely derived in novel closed-form expressions in terms of finite power series, taking into account the channel loss, atmospheric turbulence-induced fading, and receiver noises. Furthermore, Monte-Carlo simulations are performed to verify analytical results and the feasibility of the proposed QKD protocol.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2018•69 citations

Design and secrecy performance of novel two-way free-space QKD protocol using standard FSO systems

Phuc V. Trinh, Anh T. Pham

This paper proposes a novel two-way free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol, which can be implemented using standard free-space optical (FSO) systems with subcarrier intensity-modulation (SIM) binary phase-shift-keying (BPSK) and direct-detection (DD) receiver. Different eavesdropping threats, including unauthorized receiver, beam-splitting, and intercept-resend attacks, are considered in the security analysis of the proposed protocol. Under the constraints on security requirements, we analytically investigate the design criteria for transmitter and receiver, in particular, the intensity modulation depth at the transmitter and the dual-threshold setting of the receiver in two-way free-space QKD systems. Quantum bit error rate (QBER), the ergodic secret-key rate, and the probability of detecting eavesdropper of the proposed system are analytically derived in closed-form expressions, considering the atmospheric loss, turbulence, and receiver noises.

International Conference on Communications•May 1, 2017•14 citations

Performance of Free-Space QKD Systems Using SIM/BPSK and Dual-Threshold/Direct-Detection

Phuc V. Trinh, Thanh V. Pham, Hung Viet Nguyen +2 more

This paper proposes a novel free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) system using subcarrier intensity-modulation (SIM) binary phase-shift-keying (BPSK) and dual-threshold/direct-detection (DT/DD) receiver with an avalanche photodiode (APD). The proposed system enables the adoption of well-developed analytical models in conventional free-space optical (FSO) communications and achieves the QKD function with a simple configuration. We analytically investigate the design criteria for transmitter and receiver, in particular, the modulation depth and the setting for dual-threshold in the context of security requirement of QKD systems. The quantum bit error rate (QBER) and the ergodic secret-key rate of the proposed system are analytically derived in closed-form expressions, considering the channel loss, atmospheric turbulence modeled by the log-normal distribution, and receiver noises. Monte-Carlo (M-C) simulations are also implemented to validate the analytical results, and numerical results confirm the feasibility of the proposed system.

IEEE Globecom Workshops (GC Wkshps)•Dec 1, 2016•10 citations

A Hybrid Noise Approach to Modelling of Free-Space Satellite Quantum Communication Channel for Continuous-Variable QKD

Mouli Chakraborty, Anshu Mukherjee, Ioannis Krikidis +2 more

This paper significantly advances the application of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) in Free- Space Optics (FSO) satellite-based quantum communication. We propose an innovative satellite quantum channel model and derive the secret quantum key distribution rate achievable through this channel. Unlike existing models that approximate the noise in quantum channels as merely Gaussian distributed, our model incorporates a hybrid noise analysis, accounting for both quantum Poissonian noise and classical Additive-White-Gaussian Noise (AWGN). This hybrid approach acknowledges the dual vulnerability of continuous variables (CV) Gaussian quantum channels to both quantum and classical noise, thereby offering a more realistic assessment of the quantum Secret Key Rate (SKR). This paper delves into the variation of SKR with the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) under various influencing parameters. We identify and analyze critical factors such as reconciliation efficiency, transmission coefficient, transmission efficiency, the quantum Poissonian noise parameter, and the satellite altitude. These parameters are pivotal in determining the SKR in FSO satellite quantum channels, highlighting the challenges of satellitebased quantum communication. Our work provides a comprehensive framework for understanding and optimizing SKR in satellite-based QKD systems, paving the way for more efficient and secure quantum communication networks.

arXiv:2410.15418•Oct 20, 2024•0 citations

Performance of free-space quantum key distribution over Malaga turbulence channel and pointing errors

Ha Duyen Trung

Abstract In this paper, we analyze the performance of free-space optical quantum key distribution (FSO-QKD) using the BB84 protocol with BPSK modulation under realistic channel conditions. The Málaga distribution is employed to model the composite atmospheric turbulence, considering pointing errors. We derive closed-form expressions for the average quantum bit error rate (QBER) and the secure key rate (SKR), incorporating both turbulence and misalignment effects. Numerical results demonstrate the impact of turbulence parameters and beam misalignment on system performance. The findings provide insights for the robust design of FSO-QKD systems under practical deployment conditions.

Journal of Optical Communications•Jun 20, 2025•3 citations

Design and Performance of Relay-Assisted Satellite Free-Space Optical Quantum Key Distribution Systems

Minh Q. Vu, Thanh V. Pham, Ngoc The Dang +1 more

This paper studies the design and performance analysis of relay-assisted satellite free-space optics (FSO) quantum key distribution (QKD) systems for secure vehicular networks. High-altitude platforms (HAPs) equipped with optical amplify-and-forward nodes are used as relay stations. Secrecy performances in terms of quantum bit error rate and ergodic secret-key rate are analytically investigated under the effects of transceiver misalignment, receiver's velocity variation, receiver noises, and atmospheric turbulence conditions. Based on the analyzed results, the design criteria for the legitimate user are determined so that the security of the considered system could be guaranteed.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2020•36 citations

This paper proposes a novel quantum key distribution (QKD) set-up designed to enhance the security of a free-space optical (FSO) quantum communication system. By incorporating channel ordering information, the proposed QPSK-QKD (P-QPSK-QKD) system leverages the inherent randomness of FSO channels, providing dual protection against eavesdroppers (Eve). The first layer of security is achieved through the QPSK-QKD mechanism, while the second arises from the randomness of the FSO channels. To ensure a comprehensive investigation, the performance of P-QPSK-QKD and the existing QPSK-QKD (E-QPSK-QKD) system is analyzed using a Málaga distributed atmospheric turbulence channel model incorporating pointing errors. Novel closed-form expressions are derived for different performance metrics, including probability of sifted keys, quantum bit error rate, probability of Eve (Peve), and ergodic secret key rate (ESKR), under both perfect and imperfect feedback conditions. Intensive examination indicates that, unlike E-QPSK-QKD, wherePeveshows a water-falling trend with increasing signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) under dual thresholds, P-QPSK-QKD achieves a saturatedPeve, enhancing security. Moreover, under the single threshold,Peveof P-QPSK-QKD is twice that of E-QPSK-QKD. Additionally, due to channel randomness, the mutual information between Alice and Eve remains zero (for both single and dual thresholds), even at infinite SNR for P-QPSK-QKD, providing consistently higher ESKR than E-QPSK-QKD system under both perfect and imperfect feedback conditions.

This paper proposes a novel design and analyzes security performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol over free-space optics (FSO). Unlike conventional QKD protocols based on physical characteristics of quantum mechanics, the proposed QKD protocol can be implemented on standard FSO systems using subcarrier intensity modulation binary phase shift keying and direct detection with a dual-threshold receiver. Under security constraints, the design criteria for FSO transmitter and receiver, in particular, the modulation depth and the selection of dual-threshold detection, respectively, is analytically investigated. For the security analysis, quantum bit error rate, ergodic secret-key rate, and final key-creation rate are concisely derived in novel closed-form expressions in terms of finite power series, taking into account the channel loss, atmospheric turbulence-induced fading, and receiver noises. Furthermore, Monte-Carlo simulations are performed to verify analytical results and the feasibility of the proposed QKD protocol.

This paper proposes a novel two-way free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol, which can be implemented using standard free-space optical (FSO) systems with subcarrier intensity-modulation (SIM) binary phase-shift-keying (BPSK) and direct-detection (DD) receiver. Different eavesdropping threats, including unauthorized receiver, beam-splitting, and intercept-resend attacks, are considered in the security analysis of the proposed protocol. Under the constraints on security requirements, we analytically investigate the design criteria for transmitter and receiver, in particular, the intensity modulation depth at the transmitter and the dual-threshold setting of the receiver in two-way free-space QKD systems. Quantum bit error rate (QBER), the ergodic secret-key rate, and the probability of detecting eavesdropper of the proposed system are analytically derived in closed-form expressions, considering the atmospheric loss, turbulence, and receiver noises.

This paper proposes a novel free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) system using subcarrier intensity-modulation (SIM) binary phase-shift-keying (BPSK) and dual-threshold/direct-detection (DT/DD) receiver with an avalanche photodiode (APD). The proposed system enables the adoption of well-developed analytical models in conventional free-space optical (FSO) communications and achieves the QKD function with a simple configuration. We analytically investigate the design criteria for transmitter and receiver, in particular, the modulation depth and the setting for dual-threshold in the context of security requirement of QKD systems. The quantum bit error rate (QBER) and the ergodic secret-key rate of the proposed system are analytically derived in closed-form expressions, considering the channel loss, atmospheric turbulence modeled by the log-normal distribution, and receiver noises. Monte-Carlo (M-C) simulations are also implemented to validate the analytical results, and numerical results confirm the feasibility of the proposed system.

This paper significantly advances the application of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) in Free- Space Optics (FSO) satellite-based quantum communication. We propose an innovative satellite quantum channel model and derive the secret quantum key distribution rate achievable through this channel. Unlike existing models that approximate the noise in quantum channels as merely Gaussian distributed, our model incorporates a hybrid noise analysis, accounting for both quantum Poissonian noise and classical Additive-White-Gaussian Noise (AWGN). This hybrid approach acknowledges the dual vulnerability of continuous variables (CV) Gaussian quantum channels to both quantum and classical noise, thereby offering a more realistic assessment of the quantum Secret Key Rate (SKR). This paper delves into the variation of SKR with the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) under various influencing parameters. We identify and analyze critical factors such as reconciliation efficiency, transmission coefficient, transmission efficiency, the quantum Poissonian noise parameter, and the satellite altitude. These parameters are pivotal in determining the SKR in FSO satellite quantum channels, highlighting the challenges of satellitebased quantum communication. Our work provides a comprehensive framework for understanding and optimizing SKR in satellite-based QKD systems, paving the way for more efficient and secure quantum communication networks.

Abstract In this paper, we analyze the performance of free-space optical quantum key distribution (FSO-QKD) using the BB84 protocol with BPSK modulation under realistic channel conditions. The Málaga distribution is employed to model the composite atmospheric turbulence, considering pointing errors. We derive closed-form expressions for the average quantum bit error rate (QBER) and the secure key rate (SKR), incorporating both turbulence and misalignment effects. Numerical results demonstrate the impact of turbulence parameters and beam misalignment on system performance. The findings provide insights for the robust design of FSO-QKD systems under practical deployment conditions.

This paper studies the design and performance analysis of relay-assisted satellite free-space optics (FSO) quantum key distribution (QKD) systems for secure vehicular networks. High-altitude platforms (HAPs) equipped with optical amplify-and-forward nodes are used as relay stations. Secrecy performances in terms of quantum bit error rate and ergodic secret-key rate are analytically investigated under the effects of transceiver misalignment, receiver's velocity variation, receiver noises, and atmospheric turbulence conditions. Based on the analyzed results, the design criteria for the legitimate user are determined so that the security of the considered system could be guaranteed.