Superposed Spacetimes: A Proposal for Reconciling Relativity and Quantum Theory

Wang, Xiaoqiang

We propose a novel semiclassical mechanism to unify quantum mechanics and general relativity, where wave function collapse in a superposition state induces a rapid change in the energy-momentum tensor, triggering spacetime dynamics that propagate at the speed of light. Unlike models assuming superposed spacetimes, we posit that the superposition yields a single, continuous classical spacetime driven by the expectation value of the energy-momentum tensor. Upon collapse, the abrupt shift modifies the spacetime metric via Einstein's field equations, respecting causality. We explore this for a particle in a spatial superposition, propose detailed experimental designs with numerical simulations of gravitational perturbations, address potential theoretical challenges, and discuss implications for existing quantum-gravity theories. This framework offers a pathway to reconcile quantum and gravitational dynamics without quantizing spacetime, with testable signatures in future experiments.

Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker, Thomas Görnitz, Holger Lyre

V. Vilasini, Lin-Qing Chen, Liuhang Ye +2 more

The notions of events and their localisation fundamentally differ between quantum theory and general relativity, reconciling them becomes even more important and challenging in the context of quantum gravity where a classical spacetime background can no longer be assumed. We therefore propose an operational approach drawing from quantum information, to define events and their localisation relative to a Lab, which in particular includes a choice of physical degree of freedom (the reference) providing a generalised notion of "location". We define a property of the reference, relative measurability, that is sensitive to correlations between the Lab's reference and objects of study. Applying this proposal to analyse the quantum switch (QS), a process widely associated with indefinite causal order, we uncover differences between classical and quantum spacetime realisations of QS, rooted in the relative measurability of the associated references and possibilities for agents' interventions. Our analysis also clarifies a longstanding debate on the interpretation of QS experiments, demonstrating how different conclusions stem from distinct assumptions on the Labs. This provides a foundation for a more unified view of events, localisation, and causality across quantum and relativistic domains.

Gleb Wataghin

Léon Brillouin

V. Vilasini, Lin-Qing Chen, Liuhang Ye +1 more

The notions of events and their localisation fundamentally differ between quantum theory and general relativity, reconciling them becomes even more important and challenging in the context of quantum gravity where a classical spacetime background can no longer be assumed. We therefore propose an operational approach drawing from quantum information, to define events and their localisation relative to a Lab, which in particular includes a choice of physical degree of freedom (the reference) providing a generalised notion of "location". We define a property of the reference, relative measurability, that is sensitive to correlations between the Lab's reference and objects of study. Applying this proposal to analyse the quantum switch (QS), a process widely associated with indefinite causal order, we uncover differences between classical and quantum spacetime realisations of QS, rooted in the relative measurability of the associated references and possibilities for agents' interventions. Our analysis also clarifies a longstanding debate on the interpretation of QS experiments, demonstrating how different conclusions stem from distinct assumptions on the Labs. This provides a foundation for a more unified view of events, localisation, and causality across quantum and relativistic domains.