Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Frontiers

Experimental test of the entanglement enhancement in two-photon fluorescence

Gewei Qian, Xiao Liu, Chenran Xu, Xingqi Xu, Da‐Wei Wang

Published Feb 28, 2024• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Entangled photons with time-energy correlations are predicted to have improved sensitivity compared with classical light in two-photon fluorescence, which is promising for lowering the phototoxicity in biomedical imaging. While the mechanism has been demonstrated in atoms and crystals, the effectiveness in biological molecules has been under debate. Here we report the experimental results, including both positive and negative ones, in various samples. While entanglement induced enhancement in the sum frequency generation of a nonlinear crystal was confirmed, we observe no such enhancement in the two-photon nonlinear process of various molecules. However, we observed classical two-photon fluorescence excited by nW light in rare earth element doped core-shell structure nano-crystals, which can also be used in sensitive biomedical imaging. Our results provide guidance in characterizing the effect of entanglement in two-photon processes.

DOI
10.1007/s44214-024-00052-6

Related papers

Two-Photon Fluorescence Microscopy at Extremely Low Excitation Intensity: The Power of Quantum Correlations

Oleg P. Varnavski, Theodore G. Goodson III

Quantum entanglement has been shown to imply correlations stronger than those allowed by classical models. The possibility of performing tasks that are classically impossible has made quantum entanglement a powerful resource for the development of novel methods and applications in various fields of research such as quantum computing, quantum cryptography, and quantum metrology. There is a great need for the development of next generation instrumentation and technologies utilizing entangled quantum light. Among the many applications of nonclassical states of light, nonlinear microscopy has the potential to make an impact in broad areas of science from physics to biology. Here, the microscopic image created by the fluorescence selectively excited by the process of the entangled two-photon absorption is reported. Entangled two-photon microscopy offers nonlinear imaging capabilities at an unprecedented low excitation intensity 10 7, which is 6 orders of magnitude lower than the excitation level for the classical two-photon image. The nonmonotonic dependence of the image on the femtosecond delay between the components of the entangled photon pair is demonstrated. This delay dependence is a result of specific quantum interference effects associated with the entanglement and this is not observable with classical excitation light. In combination with novel spectroscopic capabilities provided by a nonclassical light excitation, this is of critical importance for sensing and biological applications.

Journal of the American Chemical Society•Jul 9, 2020•91 citations

Limitations in Fluorescence-Detected Entangled Two-Photon-Absorption Experiments: Exploring the Low- to High-Gain Squeezing Regimes

Tiemo S. Landes, Brian J. Smith, Michael G. Raymer

We closely replicated and extended a recent experiment ("Spatial properties of entangled two-photon absorption," Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 183601, 2022) that reportedly observed enhancement of two-photon absorption rates in molecular samples by using time-frequency-entangled photon pairs, and we found that in the low-flux regime, where such enhancement is theoretically predicted in-principle, the two-photon fluorescence signal is below detection threshold using current state-of-the-art methods. The results are important in the context of efforts to enable quantum-enhanced molecular spectroscopy and imaging at ultra-low optical flux. Using an optical parametric down-conversion photon-pair source that can be varied from the low-gain spontaneous regime to the high-gain squeezing regime, we observed two-photon-induced fluorescence in the high-gain regime but in the low-gain regime any fluorescence was below detection threshold. We supplemented the molecular fluorescence experiments with a study of nonlinear-optical sum-frequency generation, for which we are able to observe the low-to-high-gain crossover, thereby verifying our theoretical models and experimental techniques. The observed rates (or lack thereof) in both experiments are consistent with theoretical predictions and with our previous experiments, and indicate that time-frequency photon entanglement does not provide a practical means to enhance in-solution molecular two-photon fluorescence spectroscopy or imaging with current techniques.

arXiv:2404.16342•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations

Biphotons for nonlinear imaging

Ivi Afxenti

The harnessing of the nonclassical properties in photon pairs generated by the process of Spontaneous Parametric Down Conversion (SPDC) to enhance two-photon interactions has long intrigued researchers. Their use in light-matter interactions has been proven to improve efficiency either by increasing the rate of generation or by suppressing noise. Namely, the processes of Entangled Sum Frequency Generation (eSFG) and Entangled Two Photon Absorption (eTPA) have been shown to produce more photons when stimulated with entangled photons than the classical versions of the effects. This has only been effective so far at very low intensities, which, alongside the inability to reproduce previous experimental results, has caused debates about the usefulness of the effect. In the presented work, I aim to shed light on the topic by employing a carefully crafted source of entangled photon pairs to improve two-photon effects. I attempt to demonstrate, through a series of experiments, that the quantum enhancement can be observed at an order of magnitude higher than previously thought possible. To solidify the results, a direct comparison of the quantum effect was conducted by investigating the performance of the phenomenon when it is stimulated by classical radiation from a laser. Our results confirm a quantum improvement in a regime previously considered impossible, and they enabled us to examine the ramifications of the effect on imaging. By doing so, we consider real-life microscopy applications, and therefore, we can set limits to the effect.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Light-Enhanced Two-Photon Imaging of Breast Cancer Cells

Oleg P. Varnavski, Carolyn E. Gunthardt, Aasia O. Rehman +2 more

Correct biological interpretation from cell imaging can be achieved only if the observed phenomena proceed with negligible perturbation from the imaging system. Herein, we demonstrate microscopic images of breast cancer cells created by the fluorescence selectively excited in the process of entangled two-photon absorption in a scanning microscope at an excitation intensity orders of magnitude lower than that used for classical two-photon microscopy. Quantum enhanced entangled two-photon microscopy has shown cell imaging capabilities at an unprecedented low excitation intensity of ∼3.6 × 10 7 photons/s, which is a million times lower than the excitation level for the classical two-photon fluorescence image obtained in the same microscope. The extremely low light probe intensity demonstrated in entangled two-photon microscopy is of critical importance to minimize photobleaching during repetitive imaging and damage to cells in live-cell applications. This technology opens new avenues in cell investigations with light microscopy, such as enhanced selectivity and time–frequency resolution.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•Mar 23, 2022•43 citations

Ultrafast coincidence characteristics of entangled photons towards entangled two-photon absorption

Aimee Kirsten Gunther

Nonlinear optics has had extensive application into a vast array of scientific fields. One such nonlinear process, two-photon absorption (TPA), has had a wildly successful \nadoption into the field of biological imaging and microscopy. As far and as fast as this field is progressing, limitations stemming from the use of ultrafast lasers are starting to appear. \nIn this work, an alternative nonclassical light source will be motivated for the application \nof low photon-flux two-photon microscopy. The origin and properties of the chosen \nnonclassical source, spontaneous parametric downconversion (SPDC), will be discussed along with the spatial and spectral properties modelled. Nonlinear processes such as TPA and sum frequency generation (SFG) will be viewed as "ultrafast coincidence measurements" of two photons arriving at a molecule within the time window of excitation. These ultrafast coincidence measurements will be viewed in an alternative manner: in terms of the second-order coherence from a light source. This degree of second-order coherence can be subdivided into two categories arising from different combinations of correlations within and between entangled photon pairs. Of interest, the energy-time correlations within the photon pair allow for enhancements in ultrafast coincidence rates over coherent light sources. The makings of an experimental setup to demonstrate enhanced rates from ultrafast two-photon coincidences taking place in SFG in a nonlinear crystal will be discussed.

•Jan 28, 2014•1 citation

Optically Excited Entangled States in Organic Molecules Illuminate the Dark

Leslie Upton, Michael R. Harpham, Özgün Süzer +3 more

We utilize quantum entangled photons to carry out nonlinear optical spectroscopy in organic molecules with an extremely small number of photons. For the first time, fluorescence is reported as a result of entangled photon absorption in organic nonlinear optical molecules. Selectivity of the entangled photon absorption process is also observed and a theoretical model of this process is provided. Through these experiments and theoretical modeling it is found that while some molecules may not have strong classical nonlinear optical properties due to their excitation pathways; these same excitation pathways may enhance the entangled photon processes. It is found that the opposite is also true. Some materials with weak classical nonlinear optical effects may exhibit strong non-classical nonlinear optical effects. Our entangled photon fluorescence results provide the first steps in realizing and demonstrating the viability of entangled two-photon microscopy, remote sensing, and optical communications.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•May 21, 2013•122 citations
Abstract Entangled photons with time-energy correlations are predicted to have improved sensitivity compared with classical light in two-photon fluorescence, which is promising for lowering the phototoxicity in biomedical imaging. While the mechanism has been demonstrated in atoms and crystals, the effectiveness in biological molecules has been under debate. Here we report the experimental results, including both positive and negative ones, in various samples. While entanglement induced enhancement in the sum frequency generation of a nonlinear crystal was confirmed, we observe no such enhancement in the two-photon nonlinear process of various molecules. However, we observed classical two-photon fluorescence excited by nW light in rare earth element doped core-shell structure nano-crystals, which can also be used in sensitive biomedical imaging. Our results provide guidance in characterizing the effect of entanglement in two-photon processes.
Quantum entanglement has been shown to imply correlations stronger than those allowed by classical models. The possibility of performing tasks that are classically impossible has made quantum entanglement a powerful resource for the development of novel methods and applications in various fields of research such as quantum computing, quantum cryptography, and quantum metrology. There is a great need for the development of next generation instrumentation and technologies utilizing entangled quantum light. Among the many applications of nonclassical states of light, nonlinear microscopy has the potential to make an impact in broad areas of science from physics to biology. Here, the microscopic image created by the fluorescence selectively excited by the process of the entangled two-photon absorption is reported. Entangled two-photon microscopy offers nonlinear imaging capabilities at an unprecedented low excitation intensity 10 7, which is 6 orders of magnitude lower than the excitation level for the classical two-photon image. The nonmonotonic dependence of the image on the femtosecond delay between the components of the entangled photon pair is demonstrated. This delay dependence is a result of specific quantum interference effects associated with the entanglement and this is not observable with classical excitation light. In combination with novel spectroscopic capabilities provided by a nonclassical light excitation, this is of critical importance for sensing and biological applications.
We closely replicated and extended a recent experiment ("Spatial properties of entangled two-photon absorption," Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 183601, 2022) that reportedly observed enhancement of two-photon absorption rates in molecular samples by using time-frequency-entangled photon pairs, and we found that in the low-flux regime, where such enhancement is theoretically predicted in-principle, the two-photon fluorescence signal is below detection threshold using current state-of-the-art methods. The results are important in the context of efforts to enable quantum-enhanced molecular spectroscopy and imaging at ultra-low optical flux. Using an optical parametric down-conversion photon-pair source that can be varied from the low-gain spontaneous regime to the high-gain squeezing regime, we observed two-photon-induced fluorescence in the high-gain regime but in the low-gain regime any fluorescence was below detection threshold. We supplemented the molecular fluorescence experiments with a study of nonlinear-optical sum-frequency generation, for which we are able to observe the low-to-high-gain crossover, thereby verifying our theoretical models and experimental techniques. The observed rates (or lack thereof) in both experiments are consistent with theoretical predictions and with our previous experiments, and indicate that time-frequency photon entanglement does not provide a practical means to enhance in-solution molecular two-photon fluorescence spectroscopy or imaging with current techniques.
The harnessing of the nonclassical properties in photon pairs generated by the process of Spontaneous Parametric Down Conversion (SPDC) to enhance two-photon interactions has long intrigued researchers. Their use in light-matter interactions has been proven to improve efficiency either by increasing the rate of generation or by suppressing noise. Namely, the processes of Entangled Sum Frequency Generation (eSFG) and Entangled Two Photon Absorption (eTPA) have been shown to produce more photons when stimulated with entangled photons than the classical versions of the effects. This has only been effective so far at very low intensities, which, alongside the inability to reproduce previous experimental results, has caused debates about the usefulness of the effect. In the presented work, I aim to shed light on the topic by employing a carefully crafted source of entangled photon pairs to improve two-photon effects. I attempt to demonstrate, through a series of experiments, that the quantum enhancement can be observed at an order of magnitude higher than previously thought possible. To solidify the results, a direct comparison of the quantum effect was conducted by investigating the performance of the phenomenon when it is stimulated by classical radiation from a laser. Our results confirm a quantum improvement in a regime previously considered impossible, and they enabled us to examine the ramifications of the effect on imaging. By doing so, we consider real-life microscopy applications, and therefore, we can set limits to the effect.
Correct biological interpretation from cell imaging can be achieved only if the observed phenomena proceed with negligible perturbation from the imaging system. Herein, we demonstrate microscopic images of breast cancer cells created by the fluorescence selectively excited in the process of entangled two-photon absorption in a scanning microscope at an excitation intensity orders of magnitude lower than that used for classical two-photon microscopy. Quantum enhanced entangled two-photon microscopy has shown cell imaging capabilities at an unprecedented low excitation intensity of ∼3.6 × 10 7 photons/s, which is a million times lower than the excitation level for the classical two-photon fluorescence image obtained in the same microscope. The extremely low light probe intensity demonstrated in entangled two-photon microscopy is of critical importance to minimize photobleaching during repetitive imaging and damage to cells in live-cell applications. This technology opens new avenues in cell investigations with light microscopy, such as enhanced selectivity and time–frequency resolution.
Nonlinear optics has had extensive application into a vast array of scientific fields. One such nonlinear process, two-photon absorption (TPA), has had a wildly successful \nadoption into the field of biological imaging and microscopy. As far and as fast as this field is progressing, limitations stemming from the use of ultrafast lasers are starting to appear. \nIn this work, an alternative nonclassical light source will be motivated for the application \nof low photon-flux two-photon microscopy. The origin and properties of the chosen \nnonclassical source, spontaneous parametric downconversion (SPDC), will be discussed along with the spatial and spectral properties modelled. Nonlinear processes such as TPA and sum frequency generation (SFG) will be viewed as "ultrafast coincidence measurements" of two photons arriving at a molecule within the time window of excitation. These ultrafast coincidence measurements will be viewed in an alternative manner: in terms of the second-order coherence from a light source. This degree of second-order coherence can be subdivided into two categories arising from different combinations of correlations within and between entangled photon pairs. Of interest, the energy-time correlations within the photon pair allow for enhancements in ultrafast coincidence rates over coherent light sources. The makings of an experimental setup to demonstrate enhanced rates from ultrafast two-photon coincidences taking place in SFG in a nonlinear crystal will be discussed.
We utilize quantum entangled photons to carry out nonlinear optical spectroscopy in organic molecules with an extremely small number of photons. For the first time, fluorescence is reported as a result of entangled photon absorption in organic nonlinear optical molecules. Selectivity of the entangled photon absorption process is also observed and a theoretical model of this process is provided. Through these experiments and theoretical modeling it is found that while some molecules may not have strong classical nonlinear optical properties due to their excitation pathways; these same excitation pathways may enhance the entangled photon processes. It is found that the opposite is also true. Some materials with weak classical nonlinear optical effects may exhibit strong non-classical nonlinear optical effects. Our entangled photon fluorescence results provide the first steps in realizing and demonstrating the viability of entangled two-photon microscopy, remote sensing, and optical communications.