Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Wiley eBooks

Worldviews: Concluding Thoughts

Richard DeWitt

Published Jun 5, 2018• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This chapter considers some implications of the discoveries explored in this book, and speculates on some of the changes that will likely be required of the worldview. Aristotelian worldview was a jigsaw puzzle-like, interlocking system of beliefs. Within the Aristotelian worldview, the usual metaphor, that is, the usual way of thinking broadly about the sort of universe we inhabited, was to think of the universe as being like an organism. The Aristotelian jigsaw puzzle was replaced with a new jigsaw puzzle, one compatible with the new discoveries. The new jigsaw puzzle, the Newtonian worldview, seemed to work well. Absolute space and time have been around, at least implicitly, for a long time, and they are explicitly found within the Newtonian framework. In contrast to relativity theory, the implications of new discoveries involving quantum theory, especially Bell's theorem and the Aspect experiments, are likely to require substantial changes in the general Newtonian picture.

DOI
10.1002/9781119119005.ch31

Related papers

Five interpretations

Alexander E. Wendt

While there is general agreement that quantum theory poses a fundamental challenge to the classical worldview, there is none on what worldview should replace it. This lack of clear positive implications is the heart of the interpretation problem in quantum theory, or understanding what the world must be like assuming the theory is true. The difficulty is twofold. First, if the theory is correct and complete then there seems to be no way to adjudicate empirically among its interpretations, forcing us to rely on metaphysics instead. Second, the classical metaphysics upon which human beings have relied in the past to interpret new theories is now itself problematic, leaving us without an interpretive backstop to anchor our thinking. Bell is surely right in expecting whatever picture of reality eventually emerges from quantum theory to “astonish us,” but by the same token it is very hard to see what that picture should be.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 20, 2015•0 citations

The Beginnings of a Modern Copernican Revolution

Richard DeWitt

The Copernican revolution of the 1500s and 1600s was in large part due to new theories and discoveries, which indicated that the general view of the universe – the more or less Aristotelian, teleological view – was no longer viable. This revolution eventually resulted in a substantially different view on the sort of universe we inhabit. New discoveries in recent years, involving Bell’s theorem, quantum theory, and the outcome of carefully designed and replicated experiments, strongly suggest that the general view of the universe we have had since the Copernican revolution is no longer viable. The main goals of this paper are (i) to present Bell’s theorem and the results of these recent experiments in a way accessible to a non-technical audience, and (ii) to explore the question of whether these new discoveries place us in a similar situation to that of our predecessors in the early years of the 1600s, or roughly, whether we are in the beginning stages of a modern Copernican revolution.

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

The Scientific Worldview

Rogene A. Buchholz

The scientific worldview is based on the assumption that the world is made up of individual elements that relate to each other through laws that can be discovered in scientific inquiry. Classical physics views the universe as composed of discrete particles that operate mechanistically and deterministically following universal laws of motion and gravity. The view of the passive scientific observer is thus challenged by a view of science as participatory. The scientific observer is involved in what is being observed as quantum theory discovered. The classical conception of matter where subatomic particles have a location at a time and a momentum at every moment of time collapses with the discovery of indeterminacy, where the particles do not have a precise location and momentum. The traditional or classical scientific worldview is alive and well in society and constitutes the way most people think about most aspects of life and the nature of existence.

Routledge eBooks•Apr 21, 2017•0 citations

A quantum perspective: an analogy for a GP worldview?

John Goldie

A DIFFERENT PARADIGM At the beginning of the 20th century many physicists felt there was little left to uncover. 1 It took the genius of Albert Einstein to challenge the prevailing Newtonian laws of motion.Einstein showed that what was thought to be inherent in phenomena was merely a manifestation of how we chose to talk about them.Relativity reveals an integrated and dynamic universe.Time, for example, is not absolute, but part of the fabric of the universe and relative to observer perspective.The faster an observer travels, the slower time passes relative to the perspective of one travelling at slower velocity.Einstein was also pivotal in the development of quantum theory, which successfully predicts the workings of subatomic particles.Quantum theory successfully explains all of chemistry and most of physics, and has enabled the development of important resources such as computers, electron microscopes, and MRI scanners.Many of quantum theory's fundamental features hint at an underlying reality that is probabilistic and not fully knowable.Wave-particle duality, for example, demonstrated that every elementary particle can be described in terms of both a particle and a wave.Another fundamental, first captured in Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, 2 demonstrated that observation of the quantum world alters its qualities.Quantum objects seem to exist in many different states at one time, only being forced to collapse and adopt definite states by the act of measurement, which is encapsulated in Schrödinger's formula.3 Both relativity and quantum theories changed how we look at the world.Both recognise that cause and effect is not always linear and our view of the world is inherently biased.They were built mathematically on thought experiments and partially confirmed by empirical findings.Gödel's incompleteness theorem, which showed that mathematical-based theory will always be incomplete, 4 and the uncertainty principle illustrate fundamental limitations to our abilities to understand and predict the universe.This is perhaps unsurprising as our brains have evolved to observe and rationalise the physical world from the perspective of living on Earth.In addition, our right brain enables us to view the world as dynamic, interconnected, and implicit, and to accept that things may never be fully known.5

British Journal of General Practice•Apr 27, 2017•1 citation

Introduction

Hans Halvorson

No scientific theory has caused more puzzlement and confusion than quantum theory. Beginning in 1900, the theory developed in fits and starts and found a consistent mathematical framing only when John von Neumann published his Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik in 1932 [12]. But even today, we struggle to understand the world as pictured by quantum theory. Physics is supposed to help us to understand the world, and yet quantum theory makes it seem a very strange place. One might be tempted to push aside our puzzlement as the result of our clinging to a primitive worldview. But our puzzlement is not merely a psychological obstacle; it is also an obstacle to the development of physics itself. This obstacle is encountered primarily in our attempts to unify quantum theory and the general theory of relativity. As argued persuasively by Chris Isham (who is represented in this volume), Lee Smolin [10], and others, the primary obstacle between us and future physics is our own failure to understand the conceptual foundations of current physical theories. How, then, are we to make conceptual progress? What is the process by which we find a new perspective, a perspective in which previously puzzling phenomena find a place in an intelligible—and perhaps beautiful—structure? I do not wish to make prescriptions or to claim that conceptual progress can be achieved in only one way. But this book begins with the Ansatz that conceptual progress might be achieved through free creations of the human intellect.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 18, 2011•0 citations

Bell's Theorem and Its Consequences

In this chapter we shall show that some simple results about correlations turn out to have very profound and puzzling consequences about the nature of the world, as it is described by quantum mechanics. Certain ideas that seem natural, and indeed almost inevitable, from the point of view of special relativity have consequences that are contradicted by quantum mechanics. The starting point of the investigation was an argument by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in 1935, but it was not pursued until 30 years later, by J. S. Bell, who obtained much more significant results that had not been anticipated in any previous work. Bell's work has led to an interesting series of experiments, which have confirmed the numerical correctness of the predictions of QM, but have not made the implications of the results seem any less strange.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Sep 8, 2014•0 citations
This chapter considers some implications of the discoveries explored in this book, and speculates on some of the changes that will likely be required of the worldview. Aristotelian worldview was a jigsaw puzzle-like, interlocking system of beliefs. Within the Aristotelian worldview, the usual metaphor, that is, the usual way of thinking broadly about the sort of universe we inhabited, was to think of the universe as being like an organism. The Aristotelian jigsaw puzzle was replaced with a new jigsaw puzzle, one compatible with the new discoveries. The new jigsaw puzzle, the Newtonian worldview, seemed to work well. Absolute space and time have been around, at least implicitly, for a long time, and they are explicitly found within the Newtonian framework. In contrast to relativity theory, the implications of new discoveries involving quantum theory, especially Bell's theorem and the Aspect experiments, are likely to require substantial changes in the general Newtonian picture.
While there is general agreement that quantum theory poses a fundamental challenge to the classical worldview, there is none on what worldview should replace it. This lack of clear positive implications is the heart of the interpretation problem in quantum theory, or understanding what the world must be like assuming the theory is true. The difficulty is twofold. First, if the theory is correct and complete then there seems to be no way to adjudicate empirically among its interpretations, forcing us to rely on metaphysics instead. Second, the classical metaphysics upon which human beings have relied in the past to interpret new theories is now itself problematic, leaving us without an interpretive backstop to anchor our thinking. Bell is surely right in expecting whatever picture of reality eventually emerges from quantum theory to “astonish us,” but by the same token it is very hard to see what that picture should be.
The Copernican revolution of the 1500s and 1600s was in large part due to new theories and discoveries, which indicated that the general view of the universe – the more or less Aristotelian, teleological view – was no longer viable. This revolution eventually resulted in a substantially different view on the sort of universe we inhabit. New discoveries in recent years, involving Bell’s theorem, quantum theory, and the outcome of carefully designed and replicated experiments, strongly suggest that the general view of the universe we have had since the Copernican revolution is no longer viable. The main goals of this paper are (i) to present Bell’s theorem and the results of these recent experiments in a way accessible to a non-technical audience, and (ii) to explore the question of whether these new discoveries place us in a similar situation to that of our predecessors in the early years of the 1600s, or roughly, whether we are in the beginning stages of a modern Copernican revolution.
The scientific worldview is based on the assumption that the world is made up of individual elements that relate to each other through laws that can be discovered in scientific inquiry. Classical physics views the universe as composed of discrete particles that operate mechanistically and deterministically following universal laws of motion and gravity. The view of the passive scientific observer is thus challenged by a view of science as participatory. The scientific observer is involved in what is being observed as quantum theory discovered. The classical conception of matter where subatomic particles have a location at a time and a momentum at every moment of time collapses with the discovery of indeterminacy, where the particles do not have a precise location and momentum. The traditional or classical scientific worldview is alive and well in society and constitutes the way most people think about most aspects of life and the nature of existence.
A DIFFERENT PARADIGM At the beginning of the 20th century many physicists felt there was little left to uncover. 1 It took the genius of Albert Einstein to challenge the prevailing Newtonian laws of motion.Einstein showed that what was thought to be inherent in phenomena was merely a manifestation of how we chose to talk about them.Relativity reveals an integrated and dynamic universe.Time, for example, is not absolute, but part of the fabric of the universe and relative to observer perspective.The faster an observer travels, the slower time passes relative to the perspective of one travelling at slower velocity.Einstein was also pivotal in the development of quantum theory, which successfully predicts the workings of subatomic particles.Quantum theory successfully explains all of chemistry and most of physics, and has enabled the development of important resources such as computers, electron microscopes, and MRI scanners.Many of quantum theory's fundamental features hint at an underlying reality that is probabilistic and not fully knowable.Wave-particle duality, for example, demonstrated that every elementary particle can be described in terms of both a particle and a wave.Another fundamental, first captured in Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, 2 demonstrated that observation of the quantum world alters its qualities.Quantum objects seem to exist in many different states at one time, only being forced to collapse and adopt definite states by the act of measurement, which is encapsulated in Schrödinger's formula.3 Both relativity and quantum theories changed how we look at the world.Both recognise that cause and effect is not always linear and our view of the world is inherently biased.They were built mathematically on thought experiments and partially confirmed by empirical findings.Gödel's incompleteness theorem, which showed that mathematical-based theory will always be incomplete, 4 and the uncertainty principle illustrate fundamental limitations to our abilities to understand and predict the universe.This is perhaps unsurprising as our brains have evolved to observe and rationalise the physical world from the perspective of living on Earth.In addition, our right brain enables us to view the world as dynamic, interconnected, and implicit, and to accept that things may never be fully known.5
No scientific theory has caused more puzzlement and confusion than quantum theory. Beginning in 1900, the theory developed in fits and starts and found a consistent mathematical framing only when John von Neumann published his Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik in 1932 [12]. But even today, we struggle to understand the world as pictured by quantum theory. Physics is supposed to help us to understand the world, and yet quantum theory makes it seem a very strange place. One might be tempted to push aside our puzzlement as the result of our clinging to a primitive worldview. But our puzzlement is not merely a psychological obstacle; it is also an obstacle to the development of physics itself. This obstacle is encountered primarily in our attempts to unify quantum theory and the general theory of relativity. As argued persuasively by Chris Isham (who is represented in this volume), Lee Smolin [10], and others, the primary obstacle between us and future physics is our own failure to understand the conceptual foundations of current physical theories. How, then, are we to make conceptual progress? What is the process by which we find a new perspective, a perspective in which previously puzzling phenomena find a place in an intelligible—and perhaps beautiful—structure? I do not wish to make prescriptions or to claim that conceptual progress can be achieved in only one way. But this book begins with the Ansatz that conceptual progress might be achieved through free creations of the human intellect.
In this chapter we shall show that some simple results about correlations turn out to have very profound and puzzling consequences about the nature of the world, as it is described by quantum mechanics. Certain ideas that seem natural, and indeed almost inevitable, from the point of view of special relativity have consequences that are contradicted by quantum mechanics. The starting point of the investigation was an argument by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in 1935, but it was not pursued until 30 years later, by J. S. Bell, who obtained much more significant results that had not been anticipated in any previous work. Bell's work has led to an interesting series of experiments, which have confirmed the numerical correctness of the predictions of QM, but have not made the implications of the results seem any less strange.