It has been assumed that the negative divergence of all stress tensors in common use yields the same force. This work finds that this is untrue, and, in fact, can vary wildly. We demonstrate this for the hydrogen atom, the one-particle isotropic harmonic oscillator, and a particle in an infinite spherical well where the exact density, pair-density, and the first order reduced density matrix are known for ground and excited states without any approximation. The Ehrenfest stress-tensor is introduced as any stress-tensor whose negative divergence will yield the corresponding Ehrenfest force for the same system when the exact wave-function is utilized. Stress-tensors within the literature are examined to show those that are Ehrenfest stress-tensors. Those that differ are demonstrated by how they differ within an exact formulation. The proof that the negative divergence of an Ehrenfest stress-tensor yields the Ehrenfest force is summarized.
It has been assumed that the negative divergence of all stress tensors in common use yields the same force. This work finds that this is untrue, and, in fact, can vary wildly. We demonstrate this for the hydrogen atom, the one-particle isotropic harmonic oscillator, and a particle in an infinite spherical well where the exact density, pair-density, and the first order reduced density matrix are known for ground and excited states without any approximation. The Ehrenfest stress-tensor is introduced as any stress-tensor whose negative divergence will yield the corresponding Ehrenfest force for the same system when the exact wave-function is utilized. Stress-tensors within the literature are examined to show those that are Ehrenfest stress-tensors. Those that differ are demonstrated by how they differ within an exact formulation. The proof that the negative divergence of an Ehrenfest stress-tensor yields the Ehrenfest force is summarized.
There has been an enduring interest and controversy about whether or not one can define physically meaningful energy density and stress fields, e(r) and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\beta}}(\mathbf{r})$, in quantum systems. A key issue is the kinetic energy since the well-known forms, $\frac{1}{2}{|\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}|}^{2}$ and $\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}$, lead to different densities, and analogous issues arise for interaction energy terms. This paper considers the ground state of a system of many interacting particles in an external potential, and presents a resolution to the problems in steps. (1) For the kinetic energy all effects of exchange and correlation are shown to be unique functions defined at each point r; all issues of nonuniqueness are relegated to terms that involve only the density n(r) and are equivalent to an effective single-particle problem with ground state wave function s(r)=n(r)/N. (2) Interactions can be considered in two ways: in terms of potentials acting on particles or in terms of the interaction fields, e.g., the Maxwell form in terms of electric fields. In each case, the problem reduces to a mean field part that is a function of the density and a part due to correlation that is uniquely defined; however, it is different for the two cases. (3) The final results follow from the nature of energy and stress. Because the energy determines the ground state itself through the variational principle, the energy density approach leads directly to kinetic energy in the form $\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}s{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}s$ and interactions in terms of potentials acting on the particles. This leads naturally to density functional theory and provides an interpretation in which the energy density e(r) is equilibrated to minimize fluctuations with the same chemical potential at all points r. On the other hand, stress is related to forces, and the only physically acceptable expressions for the stress field involve the combination $\frac{1}{2}[s{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}s\ensuremath{-}{|\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}s|}^{2}]$, as derived by Schr\"odinger, Pauli, and others, and Coulomb interactions in terms of electric fields, not potentials. Together these results lead to well-defined formulations of energy density and stress fields that are physically motivated and based on a clear set of arguments.
Applying the concept of quantum hydrodynamics on a hydrogen atom, one can derive an equation of motion which describes the time derivative of the mass current density for the relative motion of the electron and the proton. Since this derivation can be performed with the Ehrenfest theorem, we call this equation the Ehrenfest equation of motion. As quantum hydrodynamics is consistent with Schrödinger's quantum mechanics, the stationary s-wave functions satisfy both the Schrödinger equation and the Ehrenfest equation of motion. It is the purpose of this paper to prove that the stationary s-wave functions satisfy the Ehrenfest equation of motion. From the quantum hydrodynamical point of view, this result for s-wave functions can be interpreted that the Coulomb force density that attracts the electron to the proton is compensated by a quantum force density that is related to the dispersion of the probability density.
"We study the issues of average forces and the Ehrenfest theorem for a particle restricted to a semi-infinite interval by an impenetrable wall. We consider and discuss two specific cases: (i) a free particle in an infinite step potential, and (ii) a free particle on a half-line. In each situation, we show that the mean values of the position, momentum and force, as functions of time, verify the Ehrenfest theorem (the state of the particle being a general wave packet that is a continuous superposition of the energy eigenstates for the Hamiltonian). However, the involved force is not the same in each case. In fact, we have the usual external classical force in the first case and a type of nonlocal boundary quantum force in the second case. In spite of these different forces, the corresponding mean values of these quantities give the same results. Accordingly, the Ehrenfest equations in the two situations are equivalent. We believe that a careful and clear consideration of how the two cases differ but, in the end, agree, is pertinent, and has not been included in the literature."
Within the density-functional theory of Hohenberg, Kohn and Sham, a comprehensive stress tensor is defined for a many-electron polyatomic system. This consists of contributions from kinetic energy, Coulomb energy and exchange correlation energy. The covariant derivative of the stress tensor yields the 'local' force density in three-dimensional space, which vanishes for static stationary states due to the balance between classical and quantum force densities. Some interesting implications of the zero force density are discussed. In particular, this turns out to be a special case of the Euler equation or the Navier-Stokes equation in fluid dynamics. The fluid-dynamical interpretation of the stress tensor is discussed and the viscosity coefficients are derived. The present work is likely to provide a basis for 'classical' interpretations of many molecular and solid-state phenomena.
The concept of a stress tensor is fundamental in classical continuum mechanics, encapsulating internal forces per unit area that a material can sustain. In quantum many‑body systems, however, the notion of pressure and stress has traditionally been limited to scalar or local quantities derived from the equation of state or from density functional approximations. In this work we introduce a fully tensorial representation of electronic internal forces that arises naturally from the quantum mechanical description of electrons in condensed matter systems. We define the Electron Quantum Stress Tensor (EQST) as a second‑rank tensor operator constructed from the kinetic and interaction contributions to the many‑electron Hamiltonian. By deriving explicit expressions for the EQST in terms of the electron density, its gradients, and the exchange–correlation potential, we establish a direct link between the microscopic wavefunction and macroscopic mechanical observables. The EQST framework provides a new lens for interpreting phenomena in two‑dimensional electron gases, quantum Hall fluids, and other strongly correlated electronic materials, offering a potential route toward uncovering novel mechanical properties of electrons that could have implications for future Nobel‑level discoveries.
The goal of Quantum Mechanics I, A Problem Text, is to enable students to solve problems appropriate to their first course in quantum mechanics. Significantly detailed solutions to traditionally posed problems dominate. Theory and rationale are addressed in prescript and postscript narratives and/or within the solved problems to guide students; and clarify vocabulary, symbology, and terminology. Applications of the postulates are presented initially using arguments from linear algebra appropriate to discrete systems with low-dimensional vectors and matrix operators, introducing orthogonality, orthonormality, Hermiticity, eigenvectors, eigenvalues, probability, expectation value, and degeneracy. These arguments blend into infinite-dimensional vectors and operators, and calculus-based arguments for continuous systems where delta functions, theta functions, and Fourier transforms are initially discussed. Dirac notation is fully developed within these first five chapters. Chapter six discusses Ehrenfest’s theorem, the Heisenberg uncertainty relations, and Gaussian wave functions and wave packets. Increasingly sophisticated potential energy functions are then treated to include the free particle, the infinite square well, the one-dimensional scattering state, the simple harmonic oscillator, the finite square well, orbital angular momentum, and the hydrogen atom. Ladder operators are featured in the developments of the simple harmonic oscillator and orbital angular momentum. The diversity of narratives and detailed solutions intend