Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of High Energy Physics

Critical dynamics in a real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group

Johannes V. Roth, Lorenz von Smekal

Published Oct 11, 2023• 24 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A bstract We present first calculations of critical spectral functions of the relaxational Models A, B, and C in the Halperin-Hohenberg classification using a real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group (FRG). We revisit the prediction by Son and Stephanov that the linear coupling of a conserved density to the non-conserved order parameter of Model A gives rise to critical Model-B dynamics. We formulate both 1-loop and 2-loop self-consistent expansion schemes in the 1PI vertex functions as truncations of the effective average action suitable for real-time applications, and analyze in detail how the different critical dynamics are properly incorporated in the framework of the FRG on the closed-time path. We present results for the corresponding critical spectral functions, extract the dynamic critical exponents for Models A, B, and C, in two and three spatial dimensions, respectively, and compare the resulting values with recent results from the literature.

DOI
10.1007/jhep10(2023)065

Related papers

Critical dynamics in a real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group

Johannes V. Roth, Lorenz von Smekal

We present first calculations of critical spectral functions of the relaxational Models A, B, and C in the Halperin-Hohenberg classification using a real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group (FRG). We revisit the prediction by Son and Stephanov that the linear coupling of a conserved density to the non-conserved order parameter of Model A gives rise to critical Model-B dynamics. We formulate both 1-loop and 2-loop self-consistent expansion schemes in the 1PI vertex functions as truncations of the effective average action suitable for real-time applications, and analyze in detail how the different critical dynamics are properly incorporated in the framework of the FRG on the closed-time path. We present results for the corresponding critical spectral functions, extract the dynamic critical exponents for Models A, B, and C, in two and three spatial dimensions, respectively, and compare the resulting values with recent results from the literature.

arXiv:2303.11817•Mar 21, 2023•1 citation

Real-time dynamics of the $O(4)$ scalar theory within the fRG approach

Yang-yang Tan, Yongrui Chen, Wei‐jie Fu

In this paper, the real-time dynamics of the O(4) O ( 4 ) scalar theory is studied within the functional renormalization group formulated on the Schwinger-Keldysh closed time path. The flow equations for the effective action and its n n -point correlation functions are derived in terms of the "classical'' and "quantum’’ fields, and a concise diagrammatic representation is presented. An analytic expression for the flow of the four-point vertex is obtained. Spectral functions with different values of temperature and momentum are obtained. Moreover, we calculate the dynamical critical exponent for the phase transition near the critical temperature in the O(4) O ( 4 ) scalar theory in 3+1 3 + 1 dimensions, and the value is found to be z\simeq 2.023 z ≃ 2.023 .

arXiv:2107.06482•SciPost Physics•Jan 18, 2022•22 citations

Universal scaling of transport coefficients near the liquid-gas critical point

Johannes V. Roth, Yunxin Ye, Sören Schlichting +1 more

We employ a novel real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group (FRG) to compute universal scaling functions of the thermal diffusivity and the shear viscosity in the vicinity of the liquid-gas critical point, i.e., for the dynamic universality class of Model H from the Halperin-Hohenberg classification. We map out the universal dependence of the transport coefficients on temperature, external magnetic field, and wavenumber, and provide a detailed comparison with the Kawasaki approximation, which is here obtained from a perturbative one-loop approximation to our real-time FRG flow. In contrast to the Kawasaki approximation, the non-perturbative scaling functions from the full real-time FRG flow show a mild dependence on the thermodynamic path towards the critical point. We further compare our FRG results for the universal wavenumber and temperature dependence of the thermal diffusivity with experimental data from critical fluids.

arXiv:2603.17874•Mar 18, 2026•0 citations

Critical dynamics within the real-time FRG approach

Yongrui Chen, Yang-yang Tan, Wei‐jie Fu

The Schwinger-Keldysh functional renormalization group developed by Y.-y. Tan [Real-time dynamics of the O ( 4 ) scalar theory within the fRG approach, ] is employed to investigate critical dynamics related to a second-order phase transition. The effective action of model A is expanded to the order of O ( ∂ 2 ) in the derivative expansion for the O ( N ) symmetry. By solving the fixed-point equations of effective potential and wave function, we obtain static and dynamic critical exponents for different values of the spatial dimension d and the field component number N . It is found that one has z ≥ 2 in the whole range of 2 ≤ d ≤ 4 for the case of N = 1 , while in the case of N = 4 , the dynamic critical exponent turns to z < 2 when the dimension approach towards d = 2 . Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2312.05870•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 29, 2024•8 citations

Critical dynamics: a field-theoretical approach

R. Folk, G. Moser

We review the progress made in dynamic bulk critical behaviour in equilibrium in the last 25 years since the review of Halperin and Hohenberg. We unify the presentation of the theoretical background by restricting ourselves to the field-theoretic renormalization group method. The main results obtained in the different universality classes are presented. This contains the critical dynamics near the gas–liquid transition in pure fluids (model H), the plait point and consolute point in mixtures (model H � ), the superfluid transition in 4 He (model F) and 4 He– 3 He mixtures (model F � ), the Curie point (model J) and Neel point (model G) in Heisenberg magnets and the superconducting transition. In comparison with experimental results, it became clear that in most cases one has to consider apart from the universal asymptotic critical behaviour also the non-universal effective behaviour. Either because it turned out to be inevitable due to a small dynamical transient exponent inhibiting the system to reach the asymptotics (e.g., at the superfluid transition) or because one is interested in the region further away from the phase transition like in pure fluids and mixtures at their gas–liquid or demixing transition. The calculation of the critical dynamics is adequate in most cases only in two-loop order. We review these results and present the solution to unreasonable features found for some models. Thus, we consider model C where relaxational and diffusive dynamics are coupled and the scaling properties and the limit to a purely relaxational model (model A) have not been understood. In general for models where the order parameter couples to other conserved densities time scale ratios between the kinetic coefficients of the order parameter and the conserved densities play an important role. Their fixed-point values and the approach to the fixed point are changed considerably in two-loop order compared to their values in one-loop order. These considerations are relevant for the explanation of the dynamical critical shape functions of systems such as superfluid helium (model F) and the isotropic antiferromagnet (model G). As far as possible, the comparison of results obtained by the renormalization group theory with numerical simulations has been made.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 31, 2006•150 citations

Real-time methods for spectral functions

Johannes V. Roth, Dominik Schweitzer, Leon J. Sieke +1 more

In this paper we develop and compare different real-time methods to calculate spectral functions. These include classical-statistical simulations, the Gaussian state approximation (GSA), and the functional renormalization group (FRG) formulated on the Keldysh closed-time path. Our test-bed system is the quartic anharmonic oscillator, a single self-interacting bosonic degree of freedom, coupled to an external heat bath providing dissipation analogous to the Caldeira-Leggett model. As our benchmark we use the spectral function from exact diagonalization with constant Ohmic damping. To extend the GSA for the open system, we solve the corresponding Heisenberg-Langevin equations in the Gaussian approximation. For the real-time FRG, we introduce a novel general prescription to construct causal regulators based on introducing scale-dependent fictitious heat baths. Our results explicitly demonstrate how the discrete transition lines of the quantum system gradually build up the broad continuous structures in the classical spectral function as temperature increases. At sufficiently high temperatures, classical, GSA, and exact-diagonalization results all coincide. The real-time FRG is able to reproduce the effective thermal mass, but it overestimates broadening and only qualitatively describes higher excitations, at the present order of our combined vertex and loop expansion. As temperature is lowered, the GSA follows the ensemble average of the exact solution better than the classical spectral function. In the low-temperature strong-coupling regime, the qualitative features of the exact result are best captured by our real-time FRG calculation, with quantitative improvements to be expected at higher truncation orders.

Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jun 22, 2022•21 citations
A bstract We present first calculations of critical spectral functions of the relaxational Models A, B, and C in the Halperin-Hohenberg classification using a real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group (FRG). We revisit the prediction by Son and Stephanov that the linear coupling of a conserved density to the non-conserved order parameter of Model A gives rise to critical Model-B dynamics. We formulate both 1-loop and 2-loop self-consistent expansion schemes in the 1PI vertex functions as truncations of the effective average action suitable for real-time applications, and analyze in detail how the different critical dynamics are properly incorporated in the framework of the FRG on the closed-time path. We present results for the corresponding critical spectral functions, extract the dynamic critical exponents for Models A, B, and C, in two and three spatial dimensions, respectively, and compare the resulting values with recent results from the literature.
We present first calculations of critical spectral functions of the relaxational Models A, B, and C in the Halperin-Hohenberg classification using a real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group (FRG). We revisit the prediction by Son and Stephanov that the linear coupling of a conserved density to the non-conserved order parameter of Model A gives rise to critical Model-B dynamics. We formulate both 1-loop and 2-loop self-consistent expansion schemes in the 1PI vertex functions as truncations of the effective average action suitable for real-time applications, and analyze in detail how the different critical dynamics are properly incorporated in the framework of the FRG on the closed-time path. We present results for the corresponding critical spectral functions, extract the dynamic critical exponents for Models A, B, and C, in two and three spatial dimensions, respectively, and compare the resulting values with recent results from the literature.
Real-time dynamics of the O(4)O(4)O(4) scalar theory within the fRG approach
In this paper, the real-time dynamics of the O(4) O ( 4 ) scalar theory is studied within the functional renormalization group formulated on the Schwinger-Keldysh closed time path. The flow equations for the effective action and its n n -point correlation functions are derived in terms of the "classical'' and "quantum’’ fields, and a concise diagrammatic representation is presented. An analytic expression for the flow of the four-point vertex is obtained. Spectral functions with different values of temperature and momentum are obtained. Moreover, we calculate the dynamical critical exponent for the phase transition near the critical temperature in the O(4) O ( 4 ) scalar theory in 3+1 3 + 1 dimensions, and the value is found to be z\simeq 2.023 z ≃ 2.023 .
We employ a novel real-time formulation of the functional renormalization group (FRG) to compute universal scaling functions of the thermal diffusivity and the shear viscosity in the vicinity of the liquid-gas critical point, i.e., for the dynamic universality class of Model H from the Halperin-Hohenberg classification. We map out the universal dependence of the transport coefficients on temperature, external magnetic field, and wavenumber, and provide a detailed comparison with the Kawasaki approximation, which is here obtained from a perturbative one-loop approximation to our real-time FRG flow. In contrast to the Kawasaki approximation, the non-perturbative scaling functions from the full real-time FRG flow show a mild dependence on the thermodynamic path towards the critical point. We further compare our FRG results for the universal wavenumber and temperature dependence of the thermal diffusivity with experimental data from critical fluids.
The Schwinger-Keldysh functional renormalization group developed by Y.-y. Tan [Real-time dynamics of the O ( 4 ) scalar theory within the fRG approach, ] is employed to investigate critical dynamics related to a second-order phase transition. The effective action of model A is expanded to the order of O ( ∂ 2 ) in the derivative expansion for the O ( N ) symmetry. By solving the fixed-point equations of effective potential and wave function, we obtain static and dynamic critical exponents for different values of the spatial dimension d and the field component number N . It is found that one has z ≥ 2 in the whole range of 2 ≤ d ≤ 4 for the case of N = 1 , while in the case of N = 4 , the dynamic critical exponent turns to z < 2 when the dimension approach towards d = 2 . Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We review the progress made in dynamic bulk critical behaviour in equilibrium in the last 25 years since the review of Halperin and Hohenberg. We unify the presentation of the theoretical background by restricting ourselves to the field-theoretic renormalization group method. The main results obtained in the different universality classes are presented. This contains the critical dynamics near the gas–liquid transition in pure fluids (model H), the plait point and consolute point in mixtures (model H � ), the superfluid transition in 4 He (model F) and 4 He– 3 He mixtures (model F � ), the Curie point (model J) and Neel point (model G) in Heisenberg magnets and the superconducting transition. In comparison with experimental results, it became clear that in most cases one has to consider apart from the universal asymptotic critical behaviour also the non-universal effective behaviour. Either because it turned out to be inevitable due to a small dynamical transient exponent inhibiting the system to reach the asymptotics (e.g., at the superfluid transition) or because one is interested in the region further away from the phase transition like in pure fluids and mixtures at their gas–liquid or demixing transition. The calculation of the critical dynamics is adequate in most cases only in two-loop order. We review these results and present the solution to unreasonable features found for some models. Thus, we consider model C where relaxational and diffusive dynamics are coupled and the scaling properties and the limit to a purely relaxational model (model A) have not been understood. In general for models where the order parameter couples to other conserved densities time scale ratios between the kinetic coefficients of the order parameter and the conserved densities play an important role. Their fixed-point values and the approach to the fixed point are changed considerably in two-loop order compared to their values in one-loop order. These considerations are relevant for the explanation of the dynamical critical shape functions of systems such as superfluid helium (model F) and the isotropic antiferromagnet (model G). As far as possible, the comparison of results obtained by the renormalization group theory with numerical simulations has been made.
In this paper we develop and compare different real-time methods to calculate spectral functions. These include classical-statistical simulations, the Gaussian state approximation (GSA), and the functional renormalization group (FRG) formulated on the Keldysh closed-time path. Our test-bed system is the quartic anharmonic oscillator, a single self-interacting bosonic degree of freedom, coupled to an external heat bath providing dissipation analogous to the Caldeira-Leggett model. As our benchmark we use the spectral function from exact diagonalization with constant Ohmic damping. To extend the GSA for the open system, we solve the corresponding Heisenberg-Langevin equations in the Gaussian approximation. For the real-time FRG, we introduce a novel general prescription to construct causal regulators based on introducing scale-dependent fictitious heat baths. Our results explicitly demonstrate how the discrete transition lines of the quantum system gradually build up the broad continuous structures in the classical spectral function as temperature increases. At sufficiently high temperatures, classical, GSA, and exact-diagonalization results all coincide. The real-time FRG is able to reproduce the effective thermal mass, but it overestimates broadening and only qualitatively describes higher excitations, at the present order of our combined vertex and loop expansion. As temperature is lowered, the GSA follows the ensemble average of the exact solution better than the classical spectral function. In the low-temperature strong-coupling regime, the qualitative features of the exact result are best captured by our real-time FRG calculation, with quantitative improvements to be expected at higher truncation orders.