Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Results in Physics

Quantum entanglement of photons on free electrons

Dmitry N. Makarov

Published May 9, 2023• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The quantum entanglement of photons is one of the interesting and important manifestations of the quantum world, which is already being used in quantum technologies. The study of new methods of quantum entanglement of photons is one of the promising areas of quantum optics. In this work, it is shown that photons, in a two-mode electromagnetic field, can be quantum entangled when they interact with free electrons. It is shown that the quantum entanglement of such photons can be very large and such photons can be a good source of high quantum entanglement. In addition, it is shown that free electrons can be a beam splitter for a two-mode electromagnetic field.

DOI
10.1016/j.rinp.2023.106515

Related papers

Quantum Entanglement of Photon-Added Coherent States on a Beam Splitter

Dmitry N. Makarov

The study of new quantum states and methods for their generation is an important part of the current development of quantum technologies. One of the most important characteristics of such states is their quantum entanglement. Photon-added coherent states, which are defined as $${\text{|}}\alpha ,n\rangle = {{\mathcal{N}}_{n}}{{({{\hat {a}}^{\dag }})}^{n}}{\text{|}}\alpha \rangle $$ , where $${{\mathcal{N}}_{n}}$$ is the normalization constant, $${\text{|}}\alpha \rangle $$ is the coherent state, $${{\hat {a}}^{\dag }}$$ is the creation operator, and n is the number of added photons, have been introduced relatively recently. The quantum entanglement of such states passing through a beam splitter has been considered for the first time in this work. A simple analytical representation of the wavefunction at the outputs of the beam splitter has been found and the quantum entanglement of the resulting two-qubit states has been considered. It has been shown that new quantum states have good prospects for their use in quantum technologies.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•May 1, 2025•0 citations

High Intensity Generation of Entangled Photons in a Two‐Mode Electromagnetic Field

Dmitry N. Makarov

Abstract At present, the sources of entangled photons have a low rate of photon generation. This limitation is a key component of quantum informatics for the realization of such functions as linear quantum computation and quantum teleportation. In this paper, we propose a method for high intensity generation of entangled photons in a two‐mode electromagnetic field. On the basis of exact solutions of the Schrödinger equation, when electrons interact in an atom with a strong two‐mode electromagnetic field, it is shown that there may be large quantum entanglement between photons. The quantum entanglement is analyzed on the basis of the Schmidt parameter. It is shown that the Schmidt parameter can reach very high values depending on the choice of characteristics of the two‐mode fields. We find the Wigner function for the considered case. Violation of Bell's inequalities for continuous variables is demonstrated.

arXiv:1612.08584•Annalen der Physik•Jul 31, 2017•13 citations

Observation of quantum entanglement between free electrons and photons

Jan-Wilke Henke, Hao Jeng, Murat Sivis +1 more

Quantum entanglement is central to both the foundations of quantum mechanics and the development of new technologies in information processing, communication, and sensing. Entanglement has been realised in a variety of physical systems, spanning atoms, ions, photons, collective excitations, and hybrid combinations of particles. Remarkably, however, photons and free electrons -- the quanta of light and their most elementary sources -- have never been observed in an entangled state. Here, we demonstrate quantum entanglement between free electrons and photons. We show that entanglement is produced when an electron, prepared in a superposition of two beams, passes a nanostructure and generates transition radiation in a polarisation state tied to the electron path. By implementing quantum state tomography, we reconstruct the full density matrix of the electron-photon pair, and show that the Peres-Horodecki separability criterion is violated by more than 7 standard deviations. Based on this foundational element of emerging free-electron quantum optics, we anticipate manifold developments in enhanced electron imaging and spectroscopy beyond the standard quantum limit. More broadly, the ability to generate and measure entanglement opens electron microscopy to previously inaccessible quantum observables and correlations in solids and nanostructures.

arXiv:2504.13047•Apr 17, 2025•3 citations

Beam splitter entangler for light fields

Xun‐Li Feng, Ruxin Li, Zhizhan Xu

We propose an experimentally feasible scheme to generate various types of entangled states of light fields by using beam splitters and single-photon detectors. Two beams of light fields are incident on two beam splitters respectively with each beam being asymmetrically split into two parts in which one part is supposed to be so weak that it contains at most one photon. We let the two weak output modes interfere at a third beam splitter. A conditional joint measurement on both weak output modes may result in an entanglement between the other two output modes. The conditions for the maximal entanglement are discussed based on the concurrence. Several specific examples are also examined.

arXiv:quant-ph/0306027•Physical Review A•Mar 23, 2005•12 citations

Coupling Single Electrons to Single Photons and Probing their Entanglement

Jan-Wilke Henke, Hao Jeng, Claus Ropers

Electron beams are a formidable tool for probing nanophotonic systems [1]. Combining electron microscopy with external optical excitation in ultrafast transmission electron microscopes has enabled the mapping of optical near-fields [2] and the bunching of electrons in attosecond pulses [3, 4]. These developments are based on the stimulated inelastic scattering between electrons and light [5, 6], in which the electrons gain energy from or lose energy to the optical field. Recently, the underlying interaction strength of this process has been increased significantly by harnessing resonant enhancement of the optical field and velocity phase matching [7]. Such an increased interaction strength also benefits the spontaneous scattering of electrons with light, thus promising applications like generating complex quantum states of light [8]. In this presentation, we discuss a set of experiments on free electron quantum optics that investigate single-electron-single-photon interactions and probe the resulting entanglement. Specifically, we consider scenarios in which optical waveguide structures are placed inside a transmission electron microscope (TEM) facilitating the interaction. Electrons passing by, for example, an integrated photonic structure (cf. Fig. 1a) can inelastically scatter with the optical mode, leading to the emergence of electron-photon pair states [9]. The resulting correlation between energy-loss electrons and photons, illustrated in Fig. 1b, can be probed employing time- and energy-resolved detection of both particles, revealing a pronounced coincidence peak between their arrival times, schematically shown in Fig. 1c. Extending the photon detection setup by a second detector to allow for Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) measurements, the photon statistics heralded by such energy-loss electrons can be studied [10]. The observed anti-bunching behavior indicates a nonclassical optical state with single-photon properties. The inelastic electron-light scattering underlying the electron-photon pair generation is further expected to induce entanglement in the particle energies [11], however, direct observation of quantum entanglement would be exceedingly difficult given the large number of independent quantum states available in these degrees of freedom. Therefore, we propose experiments based on the quantum eraser scheme to demonstrate this free-electron-photon entanglement in different degrees of freedom [12,13]. Specifically, we consider a double-slit geometry coherently illuminated by an electron beam such that an interference pattern can be observed on a distant screen (cf. Fig. 2a). If electrons passing through the left or right (denoted |Land |R⁠, respectively) slit generate distinct marker photons with vertical (|V)or horizontal (|H) polarization, this interference pattern would disappear due to the entanglement of electron path and photon polarisation (cf. Fig. 2b). However, if this which-path information carried by the marker photon is erased, e.g. by mixing the polarisation states, the interference pattern can be recovered when detecting electrons and photons in coincidence. We describe an extension of this idea to an entanglement test, before discussing possible realistic implementations and presenting preliminary results on several experimental key aspects. In summary, we discuss the inelastic electron-light scattering at integrated photonic structures with applications ranging from coherent electron beam modulation using continuous-wave optical fields to the electron-driven generation of quantum optical states of light. Delving deeper into single electron-single photon interactions, we outline feasible experiments to generate and verify electron-photon entanglement with a potential extension to electron pairs based on entanglement swapping. All this adds to the toolbox of free electron quantum optics, potentially enabling novel sources of quantum light as well as quantum-enhanced sensing in electron microscopy. Generation of correlated electron-photon pairs. (a) Electrons pass over a photonic integrated circuit placed in the sample plane of a TEM, generating photons in the optical waveguides via inelastic scattering. Energy-loss electrons are detected and time-tagged behind an imaging spectrometer in coincidence with photons exiting the waveguide. (b) Inelastic scattering links the electron energy loss (green, right ladder) to the generation of photons (red, left ladder), creating correlations in energy and time. (c) A strong temporal correlation between the loss electrons and detected photons, indicated by the red dot, is observed relative to the uncorrelated zero-loss background electrons (blue line). Free-electron-photon quantum eraser. (a) Coherent electron illumination of a double-slit structure results in interference between the two pathways |Land |R.(b) If the electrons generate distinguishable marker photons, e.g. of orthogonal polarizations |Vand |H⁠, no interference pattern can be observed due to the electron-photon entanglement. (c) Collecting these marker photons and erasing the which-path information, e.g. using a half-wave plate (⁠λ/2⁠), the electron interference can be recovered using electron-photon coincidence detection with single-photon detectors (SPDs) placed behind a polarizing beam splitter (PBS).

Microscopy and Microanalysis•Jul 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum entanglement of a harmonic oscillator with an electromagnetic field

Dmitry N. Makarov

At present, there are many methods for obtaining quantum entanglement of particles with an electromagnetic field. Most methods have a low probability of quantum entanglement and not an exact theoretical apparatus based on an approximate solution of the Schrodinger equation. There is a need for new methods for obtaining quantum-entangled particles and mathematically accurate studies of such methods. In this paper, a quantum harmonic oscillator (for example, an electron in a magnetic field) interacting with a quantized electromagnetic field is considered. Based on the exact solution of the Schrodinger equation for this system, it is shown that for certain parameters there can be a large quantum entanglement between the electron and the electromagnetic field. Quantum entanglement is analyzed on the basis of a mathematically exact expression for the Schmidt modes and the Von Neumann entropy.

arXiv:1709.04716•Scientific Reports•May 22, 2018•30 citations
The quantum entanglement of photons is one of the interesting and important manifestations of the quantum world, which is already being used in quantum technologies. The study of new methods of quantum entanglement of photons is one of the promising areas of quantum optics. In this work, it is shown that photons, in a two-mode electromagnetic field, can be quantum entangled when they interact with free electrons. It is shown that the quantum entanglement of such photons can be very large and such photons can be a good source of high quantum entanglement. In addition, it is shown that free electrons can be a beam splitter for a two-mode electromagnetic field.
The study of new quantum states and methods for their generation is an important part of the current development of quantum technologies. One of the most important characteristics of such states is their quantum entanglement. Photon-added coherent states, which are defined as |α,n⟩=Nn(a^†)n|α⟩{\text{|}}\alpha ,n\rangle = {{\mathcal{N}}_{n}}{{({{\hat {a}}^{\dag }})}^{n}}{\text{|}}\alpha \rangle |α,n⟩=Nn​(a^†)n|α⟩ , where Nn{{\mathcal{N}}_{n}}Nn​ is the normalization constant, |α⟩{\text{|}}\alpha \rangle |α⟩ is the coherent state, a^†{{\hat {a}}^{\dag }}a^† is the creation operator, and n is the number of added photons, have been introduced relatively recently. The quantum entanglement of such states passing through a beam splitter has been considered for the first time in this work. A simple analytical representation of the wavefunction at the outputs of the beam splitter has been found and the quantum entanglement of the resulting two-qubit states has been considered. It has been shown that new quantum states have good prospects for their use in quantum technologies.
Abstract At present, the sources of entangled photons have a low rate of photon generation. This limitation is a key component of quantum informatics for the realization of such functions as linear quantum computation and quantum teleportation. In this paper, we propose a method for high intensity generation of entangled photons in a two‐mode electromagnetic field. On the basis of exact solutions of the Schrödinger equation, when electrons interact in an atom with a strong two‐mode electromagnetic field, it is shown that there may be large quantum entanglement between photons. The quantum entanglement is analyzed on the basis of the Schmidt parameter. It is shown that the Schmidt parameter can reach very high values depending on the choice of characteristics of the two‐mode fields. We find the Wigner function for the considered case. Violation of Bell's inequalities for continuous variables is demonstrated.
Quantum entanglement is central to both the foundations of quantum mechanics and the development of new technologies in information processing, communication, and sensing. Entanglement has been realised in a variety of physical systems, spanning atoms, ions, photons, collective excitations, and hybrid combinations of particles. Remarkably, however, photons and free electrons -- the quanta of light and their most elementary sources -- have never been observed in an entangled state. Here, we demonstrate quantum entanglement between free electrons and photons. We show that entanglement is produced when an electron, prepared in a superposition of two beams, passes a nanostructure and generates transition radiation in a polarisation state tied to the electron path. By implementing quantum state tomography, we reconstruct the full density matrix of the electron-photon pair, and show that the Peres-Horodecki separability criterion is violated by more than 7 standard deviations. Based on this foundational element of emerging free-electron quantum optics, we anticipate manifold developments in enhanced electron imaging and spectroscopy beyond the standard quantum limit. More broadly, the ability to generate and measure entanglement opens electron microscopy to previously inaccessible quantum observables and correlations in solids and nanostructures.
We propose an experimentally feasible scheme to generate various types of entangled states of light fields by using beam splitters and single-photon detectors. Two beams of light fields are incident on two beam splitters respectively with each beam being asymmetrically split into two parts in which one part is supposed to be so weak that it contains at most one photon. We let the two weak output modes interfere at a third beam splitter. A conditional joint measurement on both weak output modes may result in an entanglement between the other two output modes. The conditions for the maximal entanglement are discussed based on the concurrence. Several specific examples are also examined.
Electron beams are a formidable tool for probing nanophotonic systems [1]. Combining electron microscopy with external optical excitation in ultrafast transmission electron microscopes has enabled the mapping of optical near-fields [2] and the bunching of electrons in attosecond pulses [3, 4]. These developments are based on the stimulated inelastic scattering between electrons and light [5, 6], in which the electrons gain energy from or lose energy to the optical field. Recently, the underlying interaction strength of this process has been increased significantly by harnessing resonant enhancement of the optical field and velocity phase matching [7]. Such an increased interaction strength also benefits the spontaneous scattering of electrons with light, thus promising applications like generating complex quantum states of light [8]. In this presentation, we discuss a set of experiments on free electron quantum optics that investigate single-electron-single-photon interactions and probe the resulting entanglement. Specifically, we consider scenarios in which optical waveguide structures are placed inside a transmission electron microscope (TEM) facilitating the interaction. Electrons passing by, for example, an integrated photonic structure (cf. Fig. 1a) can inelastically scatter with the optical mode, leading to the emergence of electron-photon pair states [9]. The resulting correlation between energy-loss electrons and photons, illustrated in Fig. 1b, can be probed employing time- and energy-resolved detection of both particles, revealing a pronounced coincidence peak between their arrival times, schematically shown in Fig. 1c. Extending the photon detection setup by a second detector to allow for Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) measurements, the photon statistics heralded by such energy-loss electrons can be studied [10]. The observed anti-bunching behavior indicates a nonclassical optical state with single-photon properties. The inelastic electron-light scattering underlying the electron-photon pair generation is further expected to induce entanglement in the particle energies [11], however, direct observation of quantum entanglement would be exceedingly difficult given the large number of independent quantum states available in these degrees of freedom. Therefore, we propose experiments based on the quantum eraser scheme to demonstrate this free-electron-photon entanglement in different degrees of freedom [12,13]. Specifically, we consider a double-slit geometry coherently illuminated by an electron beam such that an interference pattern can be observed on a distant screen (cf. Fig. 2a). If electrons passing through the left or right (denoted |Land |R⁠, respectively) slit generate distinct marker photons with vertical (|V)or horizontal (|H) polarization, this interference pattern would disappear due to the entanglement of electron path and photon polarisation (cf. Fig. 2b). However, if this which-path information carried by the marker photon is erased, e.g. by mixing the polarisation states, the interference pattern can be recovered when detecting electrons and photons in coincidence. We describe an extension of this idea to an entanglement test, before discussing possible realistic implementations and presenting preliminary results on several experimental key aspects. In summary, we discuss the inelastic electron-light scattering at integrated photonic structures with applications ranging from coherent electron beam modulation using continuous-wave optical fields to the electron-driven generation of quantum optical states of light. Delving deeper into single electron-single photon interactions, we outline feasible experiments to generate and verify electron-photon entanglement with a potential extension to electron pairs based on entanglement swapping. All this adds to the toolbox of free electron quantum optics, potentially enabling novel sources of quantum light as well as quantum-enhanced sensing in electron microscopy. Generation of correlated electron-photon pairs. (a) Electrons pass over a photonic integrated circuit placed in the sample plane of a TEM, generating photons in the optical waveguides via inelastic scattering. Energy-loss electrons are detected and time-tagged behind an imaging spectrometer in coincidence with photons exiting the waveguide. (b) Inelastic scattering links the electron energy loss (green, right ladder) to the generation of photons (red, left ladder), creating correlations in energy and time. (c) A strong temporal correlation between the loss electrons and detected photons, indicated by the red dot, is observed relative to the uncorrelated zero-loss background electrons (blue line). Free-electron-photon quantum eraser. (a) Coherent electron illumination of a double-slit structure results in interference between the two pathways |Land |R.(b) If the electrons generate distinguishable marker photons, e.g. of orthogonal polarizations |Vand |H⁠, no interference pattern can be observed due to the electron-photon entanglement. (c) Collecting these marker photons and erasing the which-path information, e.g. using a half-wave plate (⁠λ/2⁠), the electron interference can be recovered using electron-photon coincidence detection with single-photon detectors (SPDs) placed behind a polarizing beam splitter (PBS).
At present, there are many methods for obtaining quantum entanglement of particles with an electromagnetic field. Most methods have a low probability of quantum entanglement and not an exact theoretical apparatus based on an approximate solution of the Schrodinger equation. There is a need for new methods for obtaining quantum-entangled particles and mathematically accurate studies of such methods. In this paper, a quantum harmonic oscillator (for example, an electron in a magnetic field) interacting with a quantized electromagnetic field is considered. Based on the exact solution of the Schrodinger equation for this system, it is shown that for certain parameters there can be a large quantum entanglement between the electron and the electromagnetic field. Quantum entanglement is analyzed on the basis of a mathematically exact expression for the Schmidt modes and the Von Neumann entropy.