Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America

Fisher information and error complimentarity

B. Roy Frieden

Published Jan 1, 1991• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Cramer-Rao (CR) inequality e2I ≥ 1 represents complimentarity between (i) the size of mean-squares error e2 in estimation of a parameter θ from an observation y where y = θ + x, and (ii) the Fisher information I due to pdf p(x). In application to quantum mechanics, θ is the classical position of a particle, and I becomes the mean-squares momentum spread for the particle. Thus, the CR inequality becomes the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The latter is, then, but one example of a general principle of error complimentarity. As applied to optical diffraction, θ is now the unknown centroid of a diffraction pattern. Here the CR inequality becomes e2z2 ≥ (λf/4π)2, where z2 is the mean-squares photon position in the lens pupil, λ is the light wavelength, and f is the focal length. Interestingly, here the uncertainty product can be made arbitrarily small. Another use is in the case of a nonideal gas kept at a constant temperature T. The gas is inside a container of unknown drift velocity θ. If p(x) defines the probability law on velocity x for particles of the gas, the CR inequality attains a minimum for the uncertainty product e2I when p(x) is Gaussian, i.e., when p(x) is a Boltzmann law. This describes the ideal gas scenario and gives it a new significance.

DOI
10.1364/oam.1991.fl3

Related papers

Fisher Information as the basis for diffraction optics

B. Roy Frieden

An unknown probability law p(x) can be efficiently estimated using a smoothness enforcing principle I=∫dxp'(x)2/p(x) = minimum, called minimum Fisher information (MFI). An unknown diffraction pattern is an unknown probability law (on photon position x). Consider a best estimate of the centroid position in the pattern from observation of a single-photon position. It is known that the mean-square error e2 in such an estimate must exceed the Cramer-Rao bound 1II,I above. Therefore, if we demand that e2 be a maximum, we have constructed a physical rationale for the use of MFI for estimating p(x). To bring in the known refractive-index profile n(x) of the diffracting medium, demand as a constraint that the mean-square spatial phase (2π/λ)2∫dxp2(x)p(x)=ϕ2 be generally nonzero. Constructing an overall principle I — ϕ 2 = minimum, a variational problem in p(x) results. The Euler-Lagrange solution is the Helmholtz wave equation on a real amplitude function q(x), where p(x) = q(x) 2 . Thus a diffraction pattern is seen to be nature’s way of maximally smearing out spatially the probability law on position for each photon forming the pattern.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1988•1 citation

Applications to Optics and Wave Mechanics of the Criterion of Maximum Cramer-Rao Bound

B. Roy Frieden

A wide class of physical problems requires the estimation of probability laws. Diffraction patterns and quantum mechanical probability laws on position are examples. Minimum Fisher information is one approach to estimating such laws; maximum entropy is another. In this paper, we show that the minimum Fisher information approach may be derived from a prior principle of maximum Cramer-Rao bound (MCRB). The MCRB-Fisher approach is then applied to some fundamental physical problems, including diffraction theory and quantum mechanics. It is found to give the correct physical solutions, that is the Helmholtz and Schrödinger wave equations respectively. By comparison, the maximum entropy approach gives incorrect solutions to these problems, except in the special (thermodynamic) case of a harmonic oscillator potential.

Journal of Modern Optics•Aug 1, 1988•57 citations

Fisher information and the complex nature of the Schrodinger (or Helmholtz) wave equation

B. Roy Frieden

The principle of minimum Fisher information (MFI) provides a basis for deriving most of the laws of physics.1 The Fisher I is defined as (mean-squares error)-1 in the efficient determination of the classical position θ of a particle. For a one-component pdf p(x) = q2(x), the Fisher information is a one-term functional I = 4 ʃdx[q’(x)]2. Thus, I decreases as q(x) becomes smoother, or as disorder increases, consistent with the second law of thermodynamics. In the above, p(x) was specifically assumed to have a single component q2(x). Then MFI gives a real-only wave equation. Here we consider multicomponent cases p(x) = q12(x) + … + qN2(x), where the qn(x) are independent degrees of freedom. We seek the Fisher I for the case N = 2 of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics or of scalar optics. A benchmark statistical situation arises when the N components of qn(x) do not overlap. Then their informations add, and the resulting mean-squares error value is efficient, i.e. an absolute minimum.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1991•0 citations

Logarithmic derivative operators, Cramér–Rao bounds, and Fisher information in quantum information theory

Kalyan B. Sinha, Ritabrata Sengupta

In quantum theory, there are various possibilities of defining logarithmic-derivative operators, each giving rise to a different Likelihood operator, and also to quantum Fisher information (QFI). In each case, the Cramér–Rao (CR) bound is derived from the first principles. It is also noted that if one does not make (often tacitly made) an assumption that the density operator [Formula: see text] and its derivative commute, then they lead to different QFI. Applications to one-mode coherent states (an infinite-dimensional quantum system) and to two-level quantum systems are studied.

Reviews in Mathematical Physics•Aug 25, 2025•0 citations

Fisher information as the basis for diffraction optics

B. Roy Frieden

It is shown that the Helmholtz wave equation follows from a new uncertainty principle: Given, as data, the position of a photon in an unknown diffraction pattern, the estimated position of the centroid of the pattern will suffer minimum precision. This implies a maximally spread out diffraction pattern, obeying a principle of minimum Fisher information. The minimum is constrained by knowledge of the refractive-index function n(x, y, z) of the medium through a requirement that the mean-square spatial phase gradient across the medium should be generally nonzero. Operationally the principle works directly with intensities and not complex amplitudes. As a practical matter the numerical use of the intensity-based principle might permit a widening of the known scope of solutions to diffraction problems.

Optics Letters•Feb 15, 1989•25 citations

The Fisher-information-based uncertainty relation, Cramer–Rao inequality and kinetic energy for the D -dimensional central problem

J. S. Dehesa, Rosario González‐Férez, Pablo Sánchez-Moreno

The inequality , with L being the grand orbital quantum number, and its conjugate relation for (⟨ r 2 ⟩, ⟨ p −2 ⟩) are shown to be fulfilled in the D -dimensional central problem. Their use has allowed us to improve the Fisher-information-based uncertainty relation ( I ρ I γ ⩾ const) and the Cramer–Rao inequalities (⟨ r 2 ⟩ I ρ ⩾ D 2 ; ⟨ p 2 ⟩ I γ ⩾ D 2 ). In addition, the kinetic energy and the radial expectation value ⟨ r 2 ⟩ are shown to be bounded from below by the Fisher information in position and momentum spaces, denoted by I ρ and I γ , respectively.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 6, 2007•88 citations
The Cramer-Rao (CR) inequality e2I ≥ 1 represents complimentarity between (i) the size of mean-squares error e2 in estimation of a parameter θ from an observation y where y = θ + x, and (ii) the Fisher information I due to pdf p(x). In application to quantum mechanics, θ is the classical position of a particle, and I becomes the mean-squares momentum spread for the particle. Thus, the CR inequality becomes the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The latter is, then, but one example of a general principle of error complimentarity. As applied to optical diffraction, θ is now the unknown centroid of a diffraction pattern. Here the CR inequality becomes e2z2 ≥ (λf/4π)2, where z2 is the mean-squares photon position in the lens pupil, λ is the light wavelength, and f is the focal length. Interestingly, here the uncertainty product can be made arbitrarily small. Another use is in the case of a nonideal gas kept at a constant temperature T. The gas is inside a container of unknown drift velocity θ. If p(x) defines the probability law on velocity x for particles of the gas, the CR inequality attains a minimum for the uncertainty product e2I when p(x) is Gaussian, i.e., when p(x) is a Boltzmann law. This describes the ideal gas scenario and gives it a new significance.
An unknown probability law p(x) can be efficiently estimated using a smoothness enforcing principle I=∫dxp'(x)2/p(x) = minimum, called minimum Fisher information (MFI). An unknown diffraction pattern is an unknown probability law (on photon position x). Consider a best estimate of the centroid position in the pattern from observation of a single-photon position. It is known that the mean-square error e2 in such an estimate must exceed the Cramer-Rao bound 1II,I above. Therefore, if we demand that e2 be a maximum, we have constructed a physical rationale for the use of MFI for estimating p(x). To bring in the known refractive-index profile n(x) of the diffracting medium, demand as a constraint that the mean-square spatial phase (2π/λ)2∫dxp2(x)p(x)=ϕ2 be generally nonzero. Constructing an overall principle I — ϕ 2 = minimum, a variational problem in p(x) results. The Euler-Lagrange solution is the Helmholtz wave equation on a real amplitude function q(x), where p(x) = q(x) 2 . Thus a diffraction pattern is seen to be nature’s way of maximally smearing out spatially the probability law on position for each photon forming the pattern.
A wide class of physical problems requires the estimation of probability laws. Diffraction patterns and quantum mechanical probability laws on position are examples. Minimum Fisher information is one approach to estimating such laws; maximum entropy is another. In this paper, we show that the minimum Fisher information approach may be derived from a prior principle of maximum Cramer-Rao bound (MCRB). The MCRB-Fisher approach is then applied to some fundamental physical problems, including diffraction theory and quantum mechanics. It is found to give the correct physical solutions, that is the Helmholtz and Schrödinger wave equations respectively. By comparison, the maximum entropy approach gives incorrect solutions to these problems, except in the special (thermodynamic) case of a harmonic oscillator potential.
The principle of minimum Fisher information (MFI) provides a basis for deriving most of the laws of physics.1 The Fisher I is defined as (mean-squares error)-1 in the efficient determination of the classical position θ of a particle. For a one-component pdf p(x) = q2(x), the Fisher information is a one-term functional I = 4 ʃdx[q’(x)]2. Thus, I decreases as q(x) becomes smoother, or as disorder increases, consistent with the second law of thermodynamics. In the above, p(x) was specifically assumed to have a single component q2(x). Then MFI gives a real-only wave equation. Here we consider multicomponent cases p(x) = q12(x) + … + qN2(x), where the qn(x) are independent degrees of freedom. We seek the Fisher I for the case N = 2 of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics or of scalar optics. A benchmark statistical situation arises when the N components of qn(x) do not overlap. Then their informations add, and the resulting mean-squares error value is efficient, i.e. an absolute minimum.
In quantum theory, there are various possibilities of defining logarithmic-derivative operators, each giving rise to a different Likelihood operator, and also to quantum Fisher information (QFI). In each case, the Cramér–Rao (CR) bound is derived from the first principles. It is also noted that if one does not make (often tacitly made) an assumption that the density operator [Formula: see text] and its derivative commute, then they lead to different QFI. Applications to one-mode coherent states (an infinite-dimensional quantum system) and to two-level quantum systems are studied.
It is shown that the Helmholtz wave equation follows from a new uncertainty principle: Given, as data, the position of a photon in an unknown diffraction pattern, the estimated position of the centroid of the pattern will suffer minimum precision. This implies a maximally spread out diffraction pattern, obeying a principle of minimum Fisher information. The minimum is constrained by knowledge of the refractive-index function n(x, y, z) of the medium through a requirement that the mean-square spatial phase gradient across the medium should be generally nonzero. Operationally the principle works directly with intensities and not complex amplitudes. As a practical matter the numerical use of the intensity-based principle might permit a widening of the known scope of solutions to diffraction problems.
The inequality , with L being the grand orbital quantum number, and its conjugate relation for (⟨ r 2 ⟩, ⟨ p −2 ⟩) are shown to be fulfilled in the D -dimensional central problem. Their use has allowed us to improve the Fisher-information-based uncertainty relation ( I ρ I γ ⩾ const) and the Cramer–Rao inequalities (⟨ r 2 ⟩ I ρ ⩾ D 2 ; ⟨ p 2 ⟩ I γ ⩾ D 2 ). In addition, the kinetic energy and the radial expectation value ⟨ r 2 ⟩ are shown to be bounded from below by the Fisher information in position and momentum spaces, denoted by I ρ and I γ , respectively.