Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entropy

Quantum Mutual Information, Fragile Systems and Emergence

Yasmín Navarrete, Sergio M. Davis

Published Nov 17, 2022• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, we present an analytical description of emergence from the density matrix framework as a state of knowledge of the system, and its generalized probability formulation. This description is based on the idea of fragile systems, wherein the observer modifies the system by the measurement (i.e., the observer effect) in order to detect possible emergent behavior. We propose the use of a descriptor, based on quantum mutual information, to calculate if subsystems of systems have inner correlations. This may contribute to a definition of emergent systems in terms of emergent information.

DOI
10.3390/e24111676

Related papers

Fragile systems: A hidden-variable Bayesian framework leading to quantum theory

Yasmín Navarrete, Sergio M. Davis

An understanding of quantum theory in terms of new, underlying descriptions capable of explaining the existence of non-classical correlations, non-commutativity of measurements and other unique and counter-intuitive phenomena remains still a challenge at the foundations of our description of physical phenomena . Among some proposals, the idea that quantum states are essentially states of knowledge in a Bayesian framework is an intriguing possibility due to its explanatory power. In this work, the formalism of quantum theory is derived from the application of Bayesian probability theory to “fragile” systems, that is, systems that are perturbed by the measurement. Complex Hilbert spaces , non-commuting operators and the trace rule for expectations all arise naturally from the use of linear algebra to solve integral equations involving classical probabilities over hidden variables. The non-fragile limit of the theory, where all measurements are commutative and the theory becomes analogous to classical statistical theory is discussed as well.

arXiv:1609.01972•Results in Physics•Apr 25, 2025•1 citation

Mutual Observability of Quantum States: A Novel Framework for Quantifying Bipartite Quantum Correlations

Jincheng Zhang

Quantum mechanics has traditionally relied on entanglement as the primary resource for describing non-classical correlations between distinct physical systems. However, entanglement fails to capture the entirety of mutual information and systemic accessibility, particularly in open, mixed, or high-dimensional environments where local states and shared correlations exhibit distinct scaling behaviors. In this paper, we introduce the concept of Mutual Observability of Quantum States (MOQ), a novel theoretical framework that quantifies how effectively one quantum system can observe or be observed by another, independently of traditional entanglement constraints. We define the mutual observability index V_AB as the ratio of the mutual information I(A:B) to the sum of the local von Neumann entropies S(A) + S(B). Through rigorous mathematical formulation, we establish its strict analytical bounds within the closed interval from 0 to 1, explore its fundamental algebraic properties, and analyze its dynamical behavior in open quantum systems. We demonstrate that MOQ dictates the strength of measurable influence and information transfer between subsystems even when quantum entanglement vanishes entirely. This framework establishes a paradigm shift in understanding quantum correlations, paving the way for advanced applications in quantum communication networks, quantum state estimation, and quantum thermodynamics.

•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

Space-time generalization of mutual information

Paolo Glorioso, Xiao-Liang Qi, Zhenbin Yang

A bstract The mutual information characterizes correlations between spatially separated regions of a system. Yet, in experiments we often measure dynamical correlations, which involve probing operators that are also separated in time. Here, we introduce a space-time generalization of mutual information which, by construction, satisfies several natural properties of the mutual information and at the same time characterizes correlations across subsystems that are separated in time. In particular, this quantity, that we call the space-time mutual information , bounds all dynamical correlations. We construct this quantity based on the idea of the quantum hypothesis testing. As a by-product, our definition provides a transparent interpretation in terms of an experimentally accessible setup. We draw connections with other notions in quantum information theory, such as quantum channel discrimination. Finally, we study the behavior of the space-time mutual information in several settings and contrast its long-time behavior in many-body localizing and thermalizing systems.

arXiv:2401.02475•Journal of High Energy Physics•May 31, 2024•7 citations

Mutual Information: A way to quantify correlations

Marcelo Tisoc, J. Beltrán

Within the framework of Information Theory, the existence of correlations between two random variables means that we can obtain information about one of them, just by measuring or observing the other random variable. In certain cases, this kind of relationship allows obtaining information about a variable even when the other is separated by a very large distance, that is, the process of obtaining information is non-local, an example (if not the only) is the quantum entanglement. These features of correlations make it interesting and important to study, classify and quantify them. The correlations are classified into classical correlations and quantum correlations, in addition they are quantified through the mutual information. Here we will present a natural way to define classical mutual information and then we will generalize it to the quantum case. Furthermore, every term in the definitions of mutual information will be interpreted using the concepts of classical and quantum entropy.

Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Física•Jan 1, 2022•6 citations

Probability-phase mutual information

Cameron Hahn, Nishan Ranabhat, Fabio Anzà

Building on the geometric formulation of quantum mechanics, we develop a coherence theory for ensembles that exploits the probability-phase structure of the quantum state space. Standard coherence measures quantify superposition within density matrices but cannot distinguish ensembles that produce the same mixed state through different distributions of pure states. First, we introduce the probability-phase mutual information $I(P;\Phi)$, which measures statistical correlations between measurement-accessible probabilities and measurement-inaccessible phases across an ensemble. Then, we prove this satisfies the axioms of a coherence monotone, establishing it as a bona-fide measure of ensemble-level coherence. Eventually, through the definition of the \emph{coherence surplus} $\delta_{\mathcal{C}} \geq 0$, we show how ensemble coherence relates to, but exceeds, density-matrix coherence, thus quantifying structure lost in statistical averaging.

arXiv:2510.01104•Physical Review A•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Multiparty quantum mutual information: An alternative definition

Asutosh Kumar

Mutual information is the reciprocal information that is common to or shared by two or more parties. Quantum mutual information for bipartite quantum systems is non-negative, and bears the interpretation of total correlation between the two subsystems. This may, however, no longer be true for three or more party quantum systems. In this paper, we propose an alternative definition of multipartite information, taking into account the shared information between two and more parties. It is non-negative, observes monotonicity under partial trace as well as completely positive maps, and equals the multipartite information measure in literature for pure states. We then define multiparty quantum discord, and give some examples. Interestingly, we observe that quantum discord increases when a measurement is performed on a large number of subsystems. Consequently, the symmetric quantum discord, which involves a measurement on all parties, reveals the maximal quantumness. This raises a question on the interpretation of measured mutual information as a classical correlation.

arXiv:1504.07176•Physical Review A•Jul 27, 2017•33 citations
In this paper, we present an analytical description of emergence from the density matrix framework as a state of knowledge of the system, and its generalized probability formulation. This description is based on the idea of fragile systems, wherein the observer modifies the system by the measurement (i.e., the observer effect) in order to detect possible emergent behavior. We propose the use of a descriptor, based on quantum mutual information, to calculate if subsystems of systems have inner correlations. This may contribute to a definition of emergent systems in terms of emergent information.
An understanding of quantum theory in terms of new, underlying descriptions capable of explaining the existence of non-classical correlations, non-commutativity of measurements and other unique and counter-intuitive phenomena remains still a challenge at the foundations of our description of physical phenomena . Among some proposals, the idea that quantum states are essentially states of knowledge in a Bayesian framework is an intriguing possibility due to its explanatory power. In this work, the formalism of quantum theory is derived from the application of Bayesian probability theory to “fragile” systems, that is, systems that are perturbed by the measurement. Complex Hilbert spaces , non-commuting operators and the trace rule for expectations all arise naturally from the use of linear algebra to solve integral equations involving classical probabilities over hidden variables. The non-fragile limit of the theory, where all measurements are commutative and the theory becomes analogous to classical statistical theory is discussed as well.
Quantum mechanics has traditionally relied on entanglement as the primary resource for describing non-classical correlations between distinct physical systems. However, entanglement fails to capture the entirety of mutual information and systemic accessibility, particularly in open, mixed, or high-dimensional environments where local states and shared correlations exhibit distinct scaling behaviors. In this paper, we introduce the concept of Mutual Observability of Quantum States (MOQ), a novel theoretical framework that quantifies how effectively one quantum system can observe or be observed by another, independently of traditional entanglement constraints. We define the mutual observability index V_AB as the ratio of the mutual information I(A:B) to the sum of the local von Neumann entropies S(A) + S(B). Through rigorous mathematical formulation, we establish its strict analytical bounds within the closed interval from 0 to 1, explore its fundamental algebraic properties, and analyze its dynamical behavior in open quantum systems. We demonstrate that MOQ dictates the strength of measurable influence and information transfer between subsystems even when quantum entanglement vanishes entirely. This framework establishes a paradigm shift in understanding quantum correlations, paving the way for advanced applications in quantum communication networks, quantum state estimation, and quantum thermodynamics.
A bstract The mutual information characterizes correlations between spatially separated regions of a system. Yet, in experiments we often measure dynamical correlations, which involve probing operators that are also separated in time. Here, we introduce a space-time generalization of mutual information which, by construction, satisfies several natural properties of the mutual information and at the same time characterizes correlations across subsystems that are separated in time. In particular, this quantity, that we call the space-time mutual information , bounds all dynamical correlations. We construct this quantity based on the idea of the quantum hypothesis testing. As a by-product, our definition provides a transparent interpretation in terms of an experimentally accessible setup. We draw connections with other notions in quantum information theory, such as quantum channel discrimination. Finally, we study the behavior of the space-time mutual information in several settings and contrast its long-time behavior in many-body localizing and thermalizing systems.
Within the framework of Information Theory, the existence of correlations between two random variables means that we can obtain information about one of them, just by measuring or observing the other random variable. In certain cases, this kind of relationship allows obtaining information about a variable even when the other is separated by a very large distance, that is, the process of obtaining information is non-local, an example (if not the only) is the quantum entanglement. These features of correlations make it interesting and important to study, classify and quantify them. The correlations are classified into classical correlations and quantum correlations, in addition they are quantified through the mutual information. Here we will present a natural way to define classical mutual information and then we will generalize it to the quantum case. Furthermore, every term in the definitions of mutual information will be interpreted using the concepts of classical and quantum entropy.
Building on the geometric formulation of quantum mechanics, we develop a coherence theory for ensembles that exploits the probability-phase structure of the quantum state space. Standard coherence measures quantify superposition within density matrices but cannot distinguish ensembles that produce the same mixed state through different distributions of pure states. First, we introduce the probability-phase mutual information I(P;Φ)I(P;\Phi)I(P;Φ), which measures statistical correlations between measurement-accessible probabilities and measurement-inaccessible phases across an ensemble. Then, we prove this satisfies the axioms of a coherence monotone, establishing it as a bona-fide measure of ensemble-level coherence. Eventually, through the definition of the \emph{coherence surplus} δC≥0\delta_{\mathcal{C}} \geq 0δC​≥0, we show how ensemble coherence relates to, but exceeds, density-matrix coherence, thus quantifying structure lost in statistical averaging.
Mutual information is the reciprocal information that is common to or shared by two or more parties. Quantum mutual information for bipartite quantum systems is non-negative, and bears the interpretation of total correlation between the two subsystems. This may, however, no longer be true for three or more party quantum systems. In this paper, we propose an alternative definition of multipartite information, taking into account the shared information between two and more parties. It is non-negative, observes monotonicity under partial trace as well as completely positive maps, and equals the multipartite information measure in literature for pure states. We then define multiparty quantum discord, and give some examples. Interestingly, we observe that quantum discord increases when a measurement is performed on a large number of subsystems. Consequently, the symmetric quantum discord, which involves a measurement on all parties, reveals the maximal quantumness. This raises a question on the interpretation of measured mutual information as a classical correlation.