Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Finite-size correlation length and violations of finite-size \nscaling

Sergio Caracciolo A, Andrea Gambassi, Massimiliano Gubinelli, Andrea Pelissetto C

Published Jan 1, 2001• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We address the problem of the definition of the finite-volume correlation length. First, we study the large-N limit of the N-vector model, and we show the existence of several constraints on the definition if regularity of the finite-size scaling functions and correct anomalous behaviour above the upper critical dimension are required. Then, we study in detail a model in which the zero mode is prohibited. Such. a model is a generalization of the fixed-magnetization Ising model which is equivalent to the lattice gas. Also in this case, we find that the finite-volume correlation length must satisfy appropriate constraints in order to obtain regular finite-size scaling functions, and, above the upper critical dimension, an anomalous scaling behaviour. The large-N results are confirmed by a one-loop calculation in the lattice phi (4) theory.

DOI
10.1007/bf01352587

Related papers

When correlations exceed system size: finite-size scaling in free boundary conditions above the upper critical dimension

Yulian Honchar, Bertrand Berche, Yurij V. Holovatch +1 more

We progress finite-size scaling in systems with free boundary conditions above their upper critical dimension, where in the thermodynamic limit critical scaling is described by mean-field theory. Recent works show that the correlation length is not bound by the system's physical size, a belief that long held sway. Instead, two scaling regimes can be observed — at the critical and pseudo-critical temperatures. We demonstrate that both are manifest for free boundaries. We use numerical simulations of the d = 5 Ising model to analyse the magnetization, susceptibility, magnetization Fourier modes and the partition function zeros. While some of the response functions hide the dual finite-size scaling, the precision enabled by the analysis of Lee–Yang zeros allows this be brought to the fore. In particular, finite-size scaling of leading zeros at the pseudo-critical point confirms recent predictions coming from correlations exceeding the system size. This paper is dedicated to Jaroslav Ilnytskyi on the occasion of his 60th birthday.

arXiv:2311.11721•Condensed Matter Physics•Mar 28, 2024•2 citations

Relation between bulk order-parameter correlation function and finite-size scaling

Chen, Xiaosong S., V. Dohm

We study the large-distance behavior of the bulk order-parameter correlation function for T > T c within the lattice version of the theory including lattice effects. We also study the large-L behavior of the susceptibility for T > T c of the confined lattice system of linear size L with periodic boundary conditions. We find that the structure of the large-L behavior of of the confined system is closely related to the structure of the large-distance behavior of of the bulk system. Explicit results are derived in the spherical (large-n) limit and in one-loop order for general dimensions d > 2. For the lattice model with cubic symmetry we find that finite-size scaling must be formulated in terms of the anisotropic bulk correlation length (exponential correlation length) that governs the exponential decay of for large r rather than in terms of the ordinary isotropic bulk correlation length defined via the second moment of . We show that it is the exponential bulk correlation length in the direction of the cubic axes that determines the exponential finite-size scaling behavior of lattice systems in a rectangular geometry. This result modifies a recent interpretation concerning an apparent violation of finite-size scaling in terms of the second-moment correlation length . Exact results for the one-dimensional Ising model illustrate our conclusions. Furthermore we show for general d>2 that a description of finite-size effects for finite n in the entire region requires different perturbative approaches that are applicable either to the region or , respectively. In particular we show that the exponential finite-size behavior for above T c is not captured by the standard perturbation approach that separates the homogeneous lowest mode from the inhomogeneous higher modes. Consequences for the theory of finite-size effects above four dimensions are discussed. We show that the two-variable finite-size scaling form predicts an exponential approach to the bulk critical behavior above T c whereas the reduction to a single-variable scaling form implies a power-law approach .

•Jan 1, 2000•16 citations

Finite-size scaling of the correlation length above the upper critical dimension in the five-dimensional Ising model

Jeff L. Jones, A. P. Young

We show numerically that correlation length at the critical point in the five-dimensional Ising model varies with system size $L$ as ${L}^{5∕4}$, rather than proportional to $L$, as in standard finite-size scaling (FSS) theory. Our results confirm a hypothesis that FSS expressions in dimension $d$ greater than the upper critical dimension of 4 should have $L$ replaced by ${L}^{d∕4}$ for cubic samples with periodic boundary conditions. We also investigate numerically the logarithmic corrections to FSS in $d=4$.

arXiv:cond-mat/0412150•Physical Review B•May 31, 2005•51 citations

Lattice φ4 Theory of Finite-Size Effects Above the Upper Critical Dimension

X. S. Chen, V. Dohm

We present a perturbative calculation of finite-size effects near Tc of the φ4 lattice model in a d-dimensional cubic geometry of size L with periodic boundary conditions for d>4. The structural differences between the φ4 lattice theory and the φ4 field theory found previously in the spherical limit are shown to exist also for a finite number of components of the order parameter. The two-variable finite-size scaling functions of the field theory are nonuniversal whereas those of the lattice theory are independent of the nonuniversal model parameters. One-loop results for finite-size scaling functions are derived. Their structure disagrees with the single-variable scaling form of the lowest-mode approximation for any finite ξ/L where ξ is the bulk correlation length. At Tc, the large-L behavior becomes lowest-mode like for the lattice model but not for the field-theoretic model. Characteristic temperatures close to Tc of the lattice model, such as T max (L) of the maximum of the susceptibility χ, are found to scale asymptotically as Tc-T max (L) ~L-d/2, in agreement with previous Monte Carlo (MC) data for the five-dimensional Ising model. We also predict χ max ~Ld/2 asymptotically. On a quantitative level, the asymptotic amplitudes of this large-L behavior close to Tc have not been observed in previous MC simulations at d=5 because of nonnegligible finite-size terms ~L(4-d)/2 caused by the inhomogeneous modes. These terms identify the possible origin of a significant discrepancy between the lowest-mode approximation and previous MC data. MC data of larger systems would be desirable for testing the magnitude of the L(4-d)/2 and L4-d terms predicted by our theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/9809394•International Journal of Modern Physics C•Oct 1, 1998•17 citations

Finite-size scaling of O(n) systems at the upper critical dimensionality

Jian-Ping Lv, Wanwan Xu, Yanan Sun +2 more

Abstract Logarithmic finite-size scaling of the O(n) universality class at the upper critical dimensionality (dc = 4) has a fundamental role in statistical and condensed-matter physics and important applications in various experimental systems. Here, we address this long-standing problem in the context of the n-vector model (n = 1, 2, 3) on periodic four-dimensional hypercubic lattices. We establish an explicit scaling form for the free-energy density, which simultaneously consists of a scaling term for the Gaussian fixed point and another term with multiplicative logarithmic corrections. In particular, we conjecture that the critical two-point correlation g(r, L), with L the linear size, exhibits a two-length behavior: follows $r^{2-d_c}$ governed by the Gaussian fixed point at shorter distances and enters a plateau at larger distances whose height decays as $L^{-d_c/2}({\rm ln}L)^{\hat{p}}$ with $\hat{p}=1/2$ a logarithmic correction exponent. Using extensive Monte Carlo simulations, we provide complementary evidence for the predictions through the finite-size scaling of observables, including the two-point correlation, the magnetic fluctuations at zero and nonzero Fourier modes and the Binder cumulant. Our work sheds light on the formulation of logarithmic finite-size scaling and has practical applications in experimental systems.

arXiv:1909.10347•National Science Review•Aug 26, 2020•19 citations

The Enigmatic Exponent ⫯ and the Story of Finite-Size Scaling Above the Upper Critical Dimension

Ralph Kenna B, Bertrand Berche

Scaling, hyperscaling and finite-size scaling were long considered problematic in theories of critical phenomena in high dimensions. The scaling relations themselves form a model-independent structure that any model-specific theory must adhere to, and they are accounted for by the simple principle of homogeneity. Finite-size scaling is similarly founded on the fundamental idea that only two length scales enter the game — namely system length and correlation length. While all scaling relations are quite satisfactory for multitudes of physical systems in low dimensions, one fails in high dimensions. The aberrant scaling relation is called hyperscaling and involves dimensionality itself. Finite-size scaling also appears to fail in high dimensions. Developed in the 1930s, Landau mean-field theory is valid in such high-dimensional systems. However, it too does not accord with hyperscaling and finite-size scaling there. The advent of renormalization-group theory in the 1970s brought deeper fundamental insights into critical phenomena, allowing systems to be viewed at different scales. Above a critical dimensionality, higher-order Renormalization Group (RG) eigenvalues become irrelevant and scaling is governed by the Gaussian fixed point. Although obeying all scaling relations including hyperscaling, and although it appears to successfully explain scaling in the correlation sector, the Gaussian fixed point fails to capture the free energy and derivatives, even in infinite volume. In the 1980s, to fix this for the magnetisation, specific heat and susceptibility, Fisher introduced the notion of dangerous irrelevant variables. Since the correlation sector did not appear to be broken, no attempt was made to repair it and Fisher’s modified RG formalism worked quite well in the thermodynamic limit of infinite volume. However, finite-size scaling fails. Also in the 1980’s, Binder, Nauenberg, Privman and Young extended Fisher’s concept to the free energy itself and to finite-size systems. While putting Fisher’s ideas on a more fundamental footing, the failure of finite-size scaling there still presented a problem. This appeared to be resolved by the introduction of “thermodynamic length” to replace correlation length as the length scale that controls Finite-Size Scaling (FSS). Thus hyperscaling and FSS were both sacrificed in favour of the RG patched together by ad hoc solutions. In the 1990’s, Luijten and Blöte went a long way to resolving the dilemma by adding corrections to scaling to the above considerations. It was clear that both of these played a role. However, as with previous authors, and adhering to the principle of not fixing that appears not to be broken, they did not address correlation length directly. Here we report on developments over the past decade which went a long way to addressing these long-standing problems The key to unlocking these, and extending their validity to the high-dimensional regime, was to relax assumptions that the correlation length has to be bounded by the physical length of bounded systems. This allowed and necessitated the extension of Fisher’s concept of dangerous irrelevant variables to the correlation sector.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 15, 2024•0 citations
We address the problem of the definition of the finite-volume correlation length. First, we study the large-N limit of the N-vector model, and we show the existence of several constraints on the definition if regularity of the finite-size scaling functions and correct anomalous behaviour above the upper critical dimension are required. Then, we study in detail a model in which the zero mode is prohibited. Such. a model is a generalization of the fixed-magnetization Ising model which is equivalent to the lattice gas. Also in this case, we find that the finite-volume correlation length must satisfy appropriate constraints in order to obtain regular finite-size scaling functions, and, above the upper critical dimension, an anomalous scaling behaviour. The large-N results are confirmed by a one-loop calculation in the lattice phi (4) theory.
We progress finite-size scaling in systems with free boundary conditions above their upper critical dimension, where in the thermodynamic limit critical scaling is described by mean-field theory. Recent works show that the correlation length is not bound by the system's physical size, a belief that long held sway. Instead, two scaling regimes can be observed — at the critical and pseudo-critical temperatures. We demonstrate that both are manifest for free boundaries. We use numerical simulations of the d = 5 Ising model to analyse the magnetization, susceptibility, magnetization Fourier modes and the partition function zeros. While some of the response functions hide the dual finite-size scaling, the precision enabled by the analysis of Lee–Yang zeros allows this be brought to the fore. In particular, finite-size scaling of leading zeros at the pseudo-critical point confirms recent predictions coming from correlations exceeding the system size. This paper is dedicated to Jaroslav Ilnytskyi on the occasion of his 60th birthday.
We study the large-distance behavior of the bulk order-parameter correlation function for T > T c within the lattice version of the theory including lattice effects. We also study the large-L behavior of the susceptibility for T > T c of the confined lattice system of linear size L with periodic boundary conditions. We find that the structure of the large-L behavior of of the confined system is closely related to the structure of the large-distance behavior of of the bulk system. Explicit results are derived in the spherical (large-n) limit and in one-loop order for general dimensions d > 2. For the lattice model with cubic symmetry we find that finite-size scaling must be formulated in terms of the anisotropic bulk correlation length (exponential correlation length) that governs the exponential decay of for large r rather than in terms of the ordinary isotropic bulk correlation length defined via the second moment of . We show that it is the exponential bulk correlation length in the direction of the cubic axes that determines the exponential finite-size scaling behavior of lattice systems in a rectangular geometry. This result modifies a recent interpretation concerning an apparent violation of finite-size scaling in terms of the second-moment correlation length . Exact results for the one-dimensional Ising model illustrate our conclusions. Furthermore we show for general d>2 that a description of finite-size effects for finite n in the entire region requires different perturbative approaches that are applicable either to the region or , respectively. In particular we show that the exponential finite-size behavior for above T c is not captured by the standard perturbation approach that separates the homogeneous lowest mode from the inhomogeneous higher modes. Consequences for the theory of finite-size effects above four dimensions are discussed. We show that the two-variable finite-size scaling form predicts an exponential approach to the bulk critical behavior above T c whereas the reduction to a single-variable scaling form implies a power-law approach .
We show numerically that correlation length at the critical point in the five-dimensional Ising model varies with system size LLL as L5∕4{L}^{5∕4}L5∕4, rather than proportional to LLL, as in standard finite-size scaling (FSS) theory. Our results confirm a hypothesis that FSS expressions in dimension ddd greater than the upper critical dimension of 4 should have LLL replaced by Ld∕4{L}^{d∕4}Ld∕4 for cubic samples with periodic boundary conditions. We also investigate numerically the logarithmic corrections to FSS in d=4d=4d=4.
We present a perturbative calculation of finite-size effects near Tc of the φ4 lattice model in a d-dimensional cubic geometry of size L with periodic boundary conditions for d>4. The structural differences between the φ4 lattice theory and the φ4 field theory found previously in the spherical limit are shown to exist also for a finite number of components of the order parameter. The two-variable finite-size scaling functions of the field theory are nonuniversal whereas those of the lattice theory are independent of the nonuniversal model parameters. One-loop results for finite-size scaling functions are derived. Their structure disagrees with the single-variable scaling form of the lowest-mode approximation for any finite ξ/L where ξ is the bulk correlation length. At Tc, the large-L behavior becomes lowest-mode like for the lattice model but not for the field-theoretic model. Characteristic temperatures close to Tc of the lattice model, such as T max (L) of the maximum of the susceptibility χ, are found to scale asymptotically as Tc-T max (L) ~L-d/2, in agreement with previous Monte Carlo (MC) data for the five-dimensional Ising model. We also predict χ max ~Ld/2 asymptotically. On a quantitative level, the asymptotic amplitudes of this large-L behavior close to Tc have not been observed in previous MC simulations at d=5 because of nonnegligible finite-size terms ~L(4-d)/2 caused by the inhomogeneous modes. These terms identify the possible origin of a significant discrepancy between the lowest-mode approximation and previous MC data. MC data of larger systems would be desirable for testing the magnitude of the L(4-d)/2 and L4-d terms predicted by our theory.
Abstract Logarithmic finite-size scaling of the O(n) universality class at the upper critical dimensionality (dc = 4) has a fundamental role in statistical and condensed-matter physics and important applications in various experimental systems. Here, we address this long-standing problem in the context of the n-vector model (n = 1, 2, 3) on periodic four-dimensional hypercubic lattices. We establish an explicit scaling form for the free-energy density, which simultaneously consists of a scaling term for the Gaussian fixed point and another term with multiplicative logarithmic corrections. In particular, we conjecture that the critical two-point correlation g(r, L), with L the linear size, exhibits a two-length behavior: follows r2−dcr^{2-d_c}r2−dc​ governed by the Gaussian fixed point at shorter distances and enters a plateau at larger distances whose height decays as L−dc/2(lnL)p^L^{-d_c/2}({\rm ln}L)^{\hat{p}}L−dc​/2(lnL)p^​ with p^=1/2\hat{p}=1/2p^​=1/2 a logarithmic correction exponent. Using extensive Monte Carlo simulations, we provide complementary evidence for the predictions through the finite-size scaling of observables, including the two-point correlation, the magnetic fluctuations at zero and nonzero Fourier modes and the Binder cumulant. Our work sheds light on the formulation of logarithmic finite-size scaling and has practical applications in experimental systems.
Scaling, hyperscaling and finite-size scaling were long considered problematic in theories of critical phenomena in high dimensions. The scaling relations themselves form a model-independent structure that any model-specific theory must adhere to, and they are accounted for by the simple principle of homogeneity. Finite-size scaling is similarly founded on the fundamental idea that only two length scales enter the game — namely system length and correlation length. While all scaling relations are quite satisfactory for multitudes of physical systems in low dimensions, one fails in high dimensions. The aberrant scaling relation is called hyperscaling and involves dimensionality itself. Finite-size scaling also appears to fail in high dimensions. Developed in the 1930s, Landau mean-field theory is valid in such high-dimensional systems. However, it too does not accord with hyperscaling and finite-size scaling there. The advent of renormalization-group theory in the 1970s brought deeper fundamental insights into critical phenomena, allowing systems to be viewed at different scales. Above a critical dimensionality, higher-order Renormalization Group (RG) eigenvalues become irrelevant and scaling is governed by the Gaussian fixed point. Although obeying all scaling relations including hyperscaling, and although it appears to successfully explain scaling in the correlation sector, the Gaussian fixed point fails to capture the free energy and derivatives, even in infinite volume. In the 1980s, to fix this for the magnetisation, specific heat and susceptibility, Fisher introduced the notion of dangerous irrelevant variables. Since the correlation sector did not appear to be broken, no attempt was made to repair it and Fisher’s modified RG formalism worked quite well in the thermodynamic limit of infinite volume. However, finite-size scaling fails. Also in the 1980’s, Binder, Nauenberg, Privman and Young extended Fisher’s concept to the free energy itself and to finite-size systems. While putting Fisher’s ideas on a more fundamental footing, the failure of finite-size scaling there still presented a problem. This appeared to be resolved by the introduction of “thermodynamic length” to replace correlation length as the length scale that controls Finite-Size Scaling (FSS). Thus hyperscaling and FSS were both sacrificed in favour of the RG patched together by ad hoc solutions. In the 1990’s, Luijten and Blöte went a long way to resolving the dilemma by adding corrections to scaling to the above considerations. It was clear that both of these played a role. However, as with previous authors, and adhering to the principle of not fixing that appears not to be broken, they did not address correlation length directly. Here we report on developments over the past decade which went a long way to addressing these long-standing problems The key to unlocking these, and extending their validity to the high-dimensional regime, was to relax assumptions that the correlation length has to be bounded by the physical length of bounded systems. This allowed and necessitated the extension of Fisher’s concept of dangerous irrelevant variables to the correlation sector.