Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Superconductivity and normal state properties in flat bands

Kukka-Emilia Huhtinen

Published Jan 1, 2023• 136 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Bloch bands with a constant dispersion, called flat bands, have attracted great recent interest. Due to the lack of kinetic energy, even small interactions are dominant, and the formation of exotic correlated phases can be favored. Flat bands are particularly promising for superconductivity, where Bardeen-Cooper Schrieffer theory predicts that the superconducting critical temperature can be greatly enhanced compared to a dispersive band. In this dissertation, we explore the properties of flat band models in the attractive Hubbard model, with particular focus on the superconducting phase and the normal state at temperatures above the superconducting transition. The first part presents the theoretical background on superconductivity in multiband Hubbard models, including a linear response computation of the mean-field superfluid weight. In the second part, we explore the role of quantum geometry in flat band superconductivity. In the third part, we discuss the normal state in flat band models, which differs from a usual Fermi liquid. This thesis consists of four publications. In publication II, we showed that the superfluid weight in isolated flat bands is related to the minimal quantum metric, which is the integrated quantum metric with the smallest possible trace. Furthermore, by studying models with dispersive bands touching the flat bands, we showed that such band touchings can be beneficial for superconductivity. In publication III, the many-body problem was solved beyond the mean-field level in isolated flat bands models fulfilling the uniform pairing condition. This study showed that the quadratic excitation of the Cooper pair bound states is determined by the minimal quantum metric. In publication IV, we considered the relationship between quantum geometry and the real part of the optical conductivity in non-interacting flat bands. While the conductivity at non-zero inelastic scattering rate is related to the components of the quantum metric, the DC conductivity vanishes at low enough temperatures due to the localization of the particles. We also showed that a connection to the quantum metric could appear when applying the Kubo-Streda formula at exactly zero temperature in systems with (partially) flat bands, but this effect was absent when evaluating the conductivity using the Kubo-Greenwood formula. In publication I, we studied the normal state properties in the Lieb lattice flat band using dynamical mean field theory. The normal state was found to exhibit a crossover between two different types of non-Fermi liquids. At intermediate interaction strengths, a pseudogap phase with preformed pairs was found. As the interaction was lowered, the state developed insulating characteristics, which could be attributed to the localization of particles.

Related papers

Superconductivity in geometrically and topologically nontrivial lattice models

Aleksi Julku

In this thesis, superconductivity of fermions in two-dimensional Hubbard lattice models is theoretically studied. Each of the studied lattice structures features intriguing properties that provide valuable insight to understand superconductivity in general. While real condensed matter systems are too complicated to tackle with theoretical tools, the Hubbard model is one of the simplest quantum many-body models to possess a wide spectrum of physically relevant phenomena, from superconductivity to magnetism and topological order. Hubbard models are also interesting as they can be experimentally realized and accurately controlled by utilizing ultracold gases. The first part of the thesis explains the required theoretical background of superconductivity in the level of mean-field and linear response theories. Specifically, we primarily focus on the superfluid weight which implies the existence of the Meissner effect and dissipationless current, defining properties of superconductors. We further discuss how the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition, related to the loss of superconductivity due to the thermal fluctuations of the superconducting order parameter in high enough temperatures, can be accessed via the superfluid weight. In the second part, the main results are discussed. We show how the superconductivity of lattice models featuring dispersionless Bloch bands, so-called flat bands, can be large and originating from the quantum geometric properties of the Bloch states of the flat bands. This is in contrast to conventional dispersive bands where superconductivity is determined by the effective mass of the particles, i.e. by the dispersion relation of the Bloch bands alone and not by the Bloch states. This is well demonstrated in the Lieb lattice geometry, studied in Publication I, which features both a strictly flat and two dispersive Bloch bands, allowing direct comparison of superconductivity in dispersive and flat bands. We show how the superconductivity of the flat band is more robust than that of the dispersive bands and how the superfluid weight behaves non-monotonically as a function of the interaction strength. This non-monotonic behavior should be experimentally accessible. Flat band superconductivity is also the topic of Publication III, where the experimentally realized twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) is studied with local and non-local attractive interactions. We predict qualitative differences between local and non-local interaction schemes which could be distinguished experimentally and reveal the quantum geometric origin of superconductivity in TBG systems in case of both the assumed interaction schemes. Exotic Fulde-Ferrell (FF) superfluid phases, characterized by the non-zero momentum of Cooper pairs, were explored in Publication II. We show how the FF phases can be stabilized against thermal fluctuations in the presence of spin-orbit coupling (SOC) and that topologically non-trivial FF states, created with SOC and Zeeman fields, can be found at finite temperatures.; Tassa…

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Numerically Exact Study of Flat-Band Superconductivity

I. S. Tupitsyn, B. Currie, Boris V. Svistunov +2 more

Current theories of high-temperature superconductivity in flat-band systems predict a linear dependence of the transition temperature on the attractive interaction, $T_c(U) = c|U|$. However, the value of $c$ and the full nonlinear $T_c(U)$ curve---with a maximum at large $|U|$---are known beyond mean-field and quantum geometry estimates only for systems with isolated flat bands. Using a controlled diagrammatic Monte Carlo technique, we trace the onset of superfluid response in the Lieb lattice with attractive Hubbard interaction. Focusing on the half-filled flat-band case, where the ordering mechanism differs fundamentally from both BCS and BEC (preformed Cooper pair) scenarios, we find that the pairing response diverges linearly with decreasing temperature over a broad range of $U$, leading to a sharp crossover to long-range correlations at a characteristic temperature $T_*$, which provides a controlled upper bound on $T_c$. The highest $T_*$ occurs when all three bands touch at a single momentum point, potentially corresponding to high $T_c$ values.

arXiv:2604.05997•Apr 7, 2026•4 citations

Many-body superconductivity in topological flat bands

Jonah Herzog-Arbeitman, Aaron Chew, Kukka-Emilia Huhtinen +2 more

In a flat band superconductor, bosonic excitations disperse while unpaired electrons are immobile. To study this strongly interacting system, we construct a family of multi-band Hubbard models with exact eta-pairing ground states in all space groups. We analytically compute their many-body excitations and find that the Cooper pair bound states obey an effective single-boson hopping Hamiltonian written in terms of the non-interacting wavefunctions. These bound states possess a unique zero-energy excitation whose quadratic dispersion is determined by the minimal quantum metric. The rest of the bound state spectrum is classified by topological quantum chemistry, which we use to identify Cooper pairs with Weyl nodes, higher angular momentum pairing, and fragile topology. Broadening the band dispersion, we find the strongest pairing occurs at half filling and not at the highest density of states. Our analytical results prove that the elementary fermionic and bosonic excitations, corresponding respectively to pairing and coherence, are governed by distinct properties of the flat band, rigorously establishing its unique phenomenology. Superconductivity in flat bands is a central feature of quantum geometric effects, supported by mean-field theory and numerics. Here, the authors exhibit a large family of flat band Hubbard models whose ground states, Bogoliubov-de-Gennes particles, and Cooper pairs are exactly solvable with analytically calculable dispersions.

arXiv:2209.00007•Communications Physics•Jul 4, 2026•79 citations

Quantum-geometry-controlled pseudogap and non-Fermi-liquid behavior

Yu Miura, Youichi Yanase

The quantum metric plays an essential role in flat-band superconductivity, governing the superfluid weight and coherence length. While previous studies have primarily focused on mean-field superconducting properties, the role of quantum geometry in fluctuation phenomena remains largely unexplored, despite the importance of fluctuations in flat-band systems. To address this issue, we employ a multiorbital T-matrix approximation that retains the orbital structure of the Bloch wave functions. By analyzing models in which the quantum metric can be tuned independently of the band dispersion, we show that an enhanced quantum metric suppresses the fluctuation-induced pseudogap in both flat-band and dispersive-band systems. In dispersive-band systems, this suppression is accompanied by a crossover from non-Fermi-liquid to Fermi-liquid behavior. This spectral evolution suggests a quantum-metric-driven crossover from a BEC-like strong-coupling regime to a BCS-like weak-coupling regime. More broadly, our results establish the quantum metric as a control parameter of interaction-driven fluctuation phenomena beyond mean-field theory.

arXiv:2611.12168•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Pairing and non-Fermi liquid behavior in partially flat-band systems: Beyond nesting physics

Sharareh Sayyad, Edwin W. Huang, Motoharu Kitatani +4 more

While many-body effects in flat-band systems are receiving renewed hot interest in condensed-matter physics for superconducting and topological properties as well as for magnetism, studies have primarily been restricted to multiband systems (with coexisting flat and dispersive bands). Here we focus on one-band systems where a band is ``partially flat,'' comprising flat and dispersive portions in $k$ space to reveal whether intriguing correlation effects can already arise on the simplest possible one-band level. For that, the two-dimensional repulsive Hubbard model is studied for two models having different flat areas in an intermediate-coupling regime with the dynamical mean-field theory combined with the fluctuation exchange approximation. We have a crossover from ferromagnetic to antiferromagnetic spin fluctuations as the band filling is varied and this triggers, for the model with a wider flat portion, a triplet-pair superconductivity favored over an unusually wide filling region, which is taken over by a sharply growing singlet pairing. For the model with a narrower flat portion, ${T}_{C}$ against filling exhibits an unusual double-peaked ${T}_{C}$ dome, associated with different numbers of nodes in the gap function having remarkably extended pairs in real space. We identify these as a manifestation of the physics outside the conventional nesting physics where only the pair scattering across the Fermi surface in designated (hot) spots is relevant. Another correlation effect arising from the flattened band is found in a non-Fermi-liquid behavior as detected in the momentum distribution function, frequency dependence of the self-energy, and spectral function. These indicate that unusual correlation physics can indeed occur in flat-band systems.

arXiv:1903.09888•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 6, 2020•36 citations

Designer flat bands: Topology and enhancement of superconductivity

Si Min Chan, Benoît Grémaud, G. G. Batrouni

We construct quasi-one-dimensional topological and nontopological three-band lattices with a tunable band gap and winding number of the flat band. Using full multiband mean field (MF) and exact density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculations, we show explicitly how the band gap affects pairing and superconductivity (SC) in a Hubbard model with attractive interactions. We obtain excellent agreement between MF and DMRG calculations. The SC weight ${D}_{s}$ on the gapped topological, $W\ensuremath{\ne}0$, flat band increases linearly with interaction strength $U$ for low values and with a slope that depends on the details of the compact localized state at $U=0$. As $U\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ for the gapped nontopological flat band ($W=0$), ${D}_{s}$ decays with a power law faster than quadratically but slower than exponentially. In the gapless case (flat band touching the band above it), we find at low $U$ (for both $W=0$ and $W\ensuremath{\ne}0$) that ${D}_{s}\ensuremath{\propto}{U}^{\ensuremath{\varphi}}$, with $\ensuremath{\varphi}<1$. In other words, ${D}_{s}$ increases faster than linearly for low $U$, thus favoring SC at weak interaction more than the gapped case. Our results reestablish that the BCS mean field and quantum metric alone are insufficient to characterize SC at weak coupling.

arXiv:2206.10651•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 22, 2022•27 citations
Bloch bands with a constant dispersion, called flat bands, have attracted great recent interest. Due to the lack of kinetic energy, even small interactions are dominant, and the formation of exotic correlated phases can be favored. Flat bands are particularly promising for superconductivity, where Bardeen-Cooper Schrieffer theory predicts that the superconducting critical temperature can be greatly enhanced compared to a dispersive band. In this dissertation, we explore the properties of flat band models in the attractive Hubbard model, with particular focus on the superconducting phase and the normal state at temperatures above the superconducting transition. The first part presents the theoretical background on superconductivity in multiband Hubbard models, including a linear response computation of the mean-field superfluid weight. In the second part, we explore the role of quantum geometry in flat band superconductivity. In the third part, we discuss the normal state in flat band models, which differs from a usual Fermi liquid. This thesis consists of four publications. In publication II, we showed that the superfluid weight in isolated flat bands is related to the minimal quantum metric, which is the integrated quantum metric with the smallest possible trace. Furthermore, by studying models with dispersive bands touching the flat bands, we showed that such band touchings can be beneficial for superconductivity. In publication III, the many-body problem was solved beyond the mean-field level in isolated flat bands models fulfilling the uniform pairing condition. This study showed that the quadratic excitation of the Cooper pair bound states is determined by the minimal quantum metric. In publication IV, we considered the relationship between quantum geometry and the real part of the optical conductivity in non-interacting flat bands. While the conductivity at non-zero inelastic scattering rate is related to the components of the quantum metric, the DC conductivity vanishes at low enough temperatures due to the localization of the particles. We also showed that a connection to the quantum metric could appear when applying the Kubo-Streda formula at exactly zero temperature in systems with (partially) flat bands, but this effect was absent when evaluating the conductivity using the Kubo-Greenwood formula. In publication I, we studied the normal state properties in the Lieb lattice flat band using dynamical mean field theory. The normal state was found to exhibit a crossover between two different types of non-Fermi liquids. At intermediate interaction strengths, a pseudogap phase with preformed pairs was found. As the interaction was lowered, the state developed insulating characteristics, which could be attributed to the localization of particles.
In this thesis, superconductivity of fermions in two-dimensional Hubbard lattice models is theoretically studied. Each of the studied lattice structures features intriguing properties that provide valuable insight to understand superconductivity in general. While real condensed matter systems are too complicated to tackle with theoretical tools, the Hubbard model is one of the simplest quantum many-body models to possess a wide spectrum of physically relevant phenomena, from superconductivity to magnetism and topological order. Hubbard models are also interesting as they can be experimentally realized and accurately controlled by utilizing ultracold gases. The first part of the thesis explains the required theoretical background of superconductivity in the level of mean-field and linear response theories. Specifically, we primarily focus on the superfluid weight which implies the existence of the Meissner effect and dissipationless current, defining properties of superconductors. We further discuss how the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition, related to the loss of superconductivity due to the thermal fluctuations of the superconducting order parameter in high enough temperatures, can be accessed via the superfluid weight. In the second part, the main results are discussed. We show how the superconductivity of lattice models featuring dispersionless Bloch bands, so-called flat bands, can be large and originating from the quantum geometric properties of the Bloch states of the flat bands. This is in contrast to conventional dispersive bands where superconductivity is determined by the effective mass of the particles, i.e. by the dispersion relation of the Bloch bands alone and not by the Bloch states. This is well demonstrated in the Lieb lattice geometry, studied in Publication I, which features both a strictly flat and two dispersive Bloch bands, allowing direct comparison of superconductivity in dispersive and flat bands. We show how the superconductivity of the flat band is more robust than that of the dispersive bands and how the superfluid weight behaves non-monotonically as a function of the interaction strength. This non-monotonic behavior should be experimentally accessible. Flat band superconductivity is also the topic of Publication III, where the experimentally realized twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) is studied with local and non-local attractive interactions. We predict qualitative differences between local and non-local interaction schemes which could be distinguished experimentally and reveal the quantum geometric origin of superconductivity in TBG systems in case of both the assumed interaction schemes. Exotic Fulde-Ferrell (FF) superfluid phases, characterized by the non-zero momentum of Cooper pairs, were explored in Publication II. We show how the FF phases can be stabilized against thermal fluctuations in the presence of spin-orbit coupling (SOC) and that topologically non-trivial FF states, created with SOC and Zeeman fields, can be found at finite temperatures.; Tassa…
Current theories of high-temperature superconductivity in flat-band systems predict a linear dependence of the transition temperature on the attractive interaction, Tc(U)=c∣U∣T_c(U) = c|U|Tc​(U)=c∣U∣. However, the value of ccc and the full nonlinear Tc(U)T_c(U)Tc​(U) curve---with a maximum at large ∣U∣|U|∣U∣---are known beyond mean-field and quantum geometry estimates only for systems with isolated flat bands. Using a controlled diagrammatic Monte Carlo technique, we trace the onset of superfluid response in the Lieb lattice with attractive Hubbard interaction. Focusing on the half-filled flat-band case, where the ordering mechanism differs fundamentally from both BCS and BEC (preformed Cooper pair) scenarios, we find that the pairing response diverges linearly with decreasing temperature over a broad range of UUU, leading to a sharp crossover to long-range correlations at a characteristic temperature T∗T_*T∗​, which provides a controlled upper bound on TcT_cTc​. The highest T∗T_*T∗​ occurs when all three bands touch at a single momentum point, potentially corresponding to high TcT_cTc​ values.
In a flat band superconductor, bosonic excitations disperse while unpaired electrons are immobile. To study this strongly interacting system, we construct a family of multi-band Hubbard models with exact eta-pairing ground states in all space groups. We analytically compute their many-body excitations and find that the Cooper pair bound states obey an effective single-boson hopping Hamiltonian written in terms of the non-interacting wavefunctions. These bound states possess a unique zero-energy excitation whose quadratic dispersion is determined by the minimal quantum metric. The rest of the bound state spectrum is classified by topological quantum chemistry, which we use to identify Cooper pairs with Weyl nodes, higher angular momentum pairing, and fragile topology. Broadening the band dispersion, we find the strongest pairing occurs at half filling and not at the highest density of states. Our analytical results prove that the elementary fermionic and bosonic excitations, corresponding respectively to pairing and coherence, are governed by distinct properties of the flat band, rigorously establishing its unique phenomenology. Superconductivity in flat bands is a central feature of quantum geometric effects, supported by mean-field theory and numerics. Here, the authors exhibit a large family of flat band Hubbard models whose ground states, Bogoliubov-de-Gennes particles, and Cooper pairs are exactly solvable with analytically calculable dispersions.
The quantum metric plays an essential role in flat-band superconductivity, governing the superfluid weight and coherence length. While previous studies have primarily focused on mean-field superconducting properties, the role of quantum geometry in fluctuation phenomena remains largely unexplored, despite the importance of fluctuations in flat-band systems. To address this issue, we employ a multiorbital T-matrix approximation that retains the orbital structure of the Bloch wave functions. By analyzing models in which the quantum metric can be tuned independently of the band dispersion, we show that an enhanced quantum metric suppresses the fluctuation-induced pseudogap in both flat-band and dispersive-band systems. In dispersive-band systems, this suppression is accompanied by a crossover from non-Fermi-liquid to Fermi-liquid behavior. This spectral evolution suggests a quantum-metric-driven crossover from a BEC-like strong-coupling regime to a BCS-like weak-coupling regime. More broadly, our results establish the quantum metric as a control parameter of interaction-driven fluctuation phenomena beyond mean-field theory.
While many-body effects in flat-band systems are receiving renewed hot interest in condensed-matter physics for superconducting and topological properties as well as for magnetism, studies have primarily been restricted to multiband systems (with coexisting flat and dispersive bands). Here we focus on one-band systems where a band is ``partially flat,'' comprising flat and dispersive portions in kkk space to reveal whether intriguing correlation effects can already arise on the simplest possible one-band level. For that, the two-dimensional repulsive Hubbard model is studied for two models having different flat areas in an intermediate-coupling regime with the dynamical mean-field theory combined with the fluctuation exchange approximation. We have a crossover from ferromagnetic to antiferromagnetic spin fluctuations as the band filling is varied and this triggers, for the model with a wider flat portion, a triplet-pair superconductivity favored over an unusually wide filling region, which is taken over by a sharply growing singlet pairing. For the model with a narrower flat portion, TC{T}_{C}TC​ against filling exhibits an unusual double-peaked TC{T}_{C}TC​ dome, associated with different numbers of nodes in the gap function having remarkably extended pairs in real space. We identify these as a manifestation of the physics outside the conventional nesting physics where only the pair scattering across the Fermi surface in designated (hot) spots is relevant. Another correlation effect arising from the flattened band is found in a non-Fermi-liquid behavior as detected in the momentum distribution function, frequency dependence of the self-energy, and spectral function. These indicate that unusual correlation physics can indeed occur in flat-band systems.
We construct quasi-one-dimensional topological and nontopological three-band lattices with a tunable band gap and winding number of the flat band. Using full multiband mean field (MF) and exact density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculations, we show explicitly how the band gap affects pairing and superconductivity (SC) in a Hubbard model with attractive interactions. We obtain excellent agreement between MF and DMRG calculations. The SC weight Ds{D}_{s}Ds​ on the gapped topological, $W\ensuremath{\ne}0$, flat band increases linearly with interaction strength UUU for low values and with a slope that depends on the details of the compact localized state at U=0U=0U=0. As $U\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ for the gapped nontopological flat band (W=0W=0W=0), Ds{D}_{s}Ds​ decays with a power law faster than quadratically but slower than exponentially. In the gapless case (flat band touching the band above it), we find at low UUU (for both W=0W=0W=0 and $W\ensuremath{\ne}0$) that ${D}_{s}\ensuremath{\propto}{U}^{\ensuremath{\varphi}}$, with $\ensuremath{\varphi}<1$. In other words, Ds{D}_{s}Ds​ increases faster than linearly for low UUU, thus favoring SC at weak interaction more than the gapped case. Our results reestablish that the BCS mean field and quantum metric alone are insufficient to characterize SC at weak coupling.