Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

World Scientific series in 20th century physics

Is Spin Coherence Like Humpty-Dumpty? I: Simplified Treatment

Berthold‐Georg Englert, Julian Schwinger, Marlan O. Scully

Published May 1, 2000• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

When Humpty-Dumpty had his great fall nobody could put him together again. A vastly more moderate challenge is to reunite the two partial beams of a Stern–Gerlach apparatus with such precision that the original spin state is recovered. Nevertheless, as we demonstrate, a substantial loss of spin coherence always occurs, unless the experimenter is able to control the magnetic field's inhomogeneity with an accuracy of at least one part in 10 5 .

DOI
10.1142/9789812795694_0029

Related papers

Spin coherence and Humpty-Dumpty. III. The effects of observation

Marlan O. Scully, Berthold‐Georg Englert, Julian Schwinger

In recent work a Stern-Gerlach interferometer (SGI) was considered in which a polarized beam of spin-(1/2 particles is split by a Stern-Gerlach apparatus into two partial beams, and then subsequent Stern-Gerlach deflecting magnets are used to reconstitute these two beams into one. In these studies it was shown that when such a coherent polarized beam passed through a SGI, some spin coherence is inevitably lost. In this regard, folk wisdom concerning irreversibility provides something of a guide to the present problem, since we all know that when Humpty-Dumpty had his great fall nobody could put him together again. In the present paper we consider the fate of our spin-(1/2 Humpty-Dumpty when a detector is present that is sensitive to the passage of particles along one trajectory, but not the other. It is not surprising that coherence is destroyed as soon as one is able to tell along which path the atom traveled. However, there seems to be no general agreement about the mechanism of coherence loss. Our conclusion is that the loss of coherence in measurements on quantum systems can always be traced to the dynamics of correlations between the measuring apparatus and the system being observed.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1989•111 citations

Is spin coherence like Humpty-Dumpty. Pt. 2. General theory

Julian Schwinger, Marlan O. Scully, Berthold‐Georg Englert

A Stern-Gerlach interferometer combines Stern-Gerlach deflecting magnets to reconstitute initially split beams, in such a way that an arbitrary initial spin state is recovered. Technical and fundamental limitations on the realizability of the device are derived.

•Nov 1, 1988•1 citation

Irreversibility of a Stern-Gerlach experiment

Gourab Das, Rangeet Bhattacharyya

The Stern-Gerlach experiment (SGE) has been known for decades, but a complete theory that explains all facets of it remains enigmatic. In its classic realization, each spin state of an atom follows a unique path or trajectory in an SGE. The enigmatic part is the final output of SGE. Feynman envisaged the outcome to be an entangled state, a superposition of $|\text{spin}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{state}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}|\text{corresponding}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{path}\ensuremath{\rangle}$. Later works described the final state of SGE as a mixed state, a weighted average of states belonging to separate beams or trajectories. Notably, Schwinger, Englert, and Scully compared the difficulty of obtaining a coherent output (a pure state) to ``putting together Humpty Dumpty'' again. Yet recent experiments using Bose-Einstein condensates indicate the emerging beams are partly coherent, favoring Feynman's description. In this work, we revisit SGE using a recent version of the quantum master equation. We show that both outcomes are probable depending on the time of flight and the timescale of the environmental fluctuations. We predict the output is initially coherent and grows gradually into a mixed state. Moreover, we also estimate how the magnetic-field gradient helps broaden the beam waist. Moreover, our treatment implies that the wave function of an atom passing through a Stern-Gerlach device does not undergo an instantaneous collapse; rather, a gradual decay of coherences results in a mixed state, resulting in an irreversible process.

Physical Review A•Dec 11, 2024•1 citation

Is spin coherence like Humpty-Dumpty? I. Simplified treatment

Berthold‐Georg Englert, Julian Schwinger, Marlan O. Scully

Foundations of Physics•Oct 1, 1988•108 citations

Is spin coherence like Humpty-Dumpty? II. General theory

Julian Schwinger, Marlan O. Scully, Berthold‐Georg Englert

Zeitschrift für Physik D Atoms Molecules and Clusters•Jun 1, 1988•103 citations

Blurred path-spin entanglement in Stern-Gerlach apparatus: interplay between magnetic inhomogeneity and Larmor precession

Nirupam Dutta, Ansuman Dey

We argue that the non-adiabatic evolution of spin states in Stern-Gerlach apparatus can blur the manifestation of path spin entanglement. This fact introduces a contradiction to the usual perception of spin measurement even in a formally ideal situation. Through quantitative calculation, we have pointed out the specific reason behind the breakdown of adiabatic evolution to be the spatial inhomogeneity of applied magnetic field. The angle $θ$ between the $z$ component of magnetic moment of the particle and applied magnetic field is also a determining factor for the category of evolution of spin states. Adiabaticity always can be restored by choosing a sufficiently small value of $θ$. Considering azimuthal inhomogeneity, we have examined the nature of path spin entanglement in the context of Stern-Gerlach experiment.

arXiv:1410.4396•Oct 16, 2014•2 citations
When Humpty-Dumpty had his great fall nobody could put him together again. A vastly more moderate challenge is to reunite the two partial beams of a Stern–Gerlach apparatus with such precision that the original spin state is recovered. Nevertheless, as we demonstrate, a substantial loss of spin coherence always occurs, unless the experimenter is able to control the magnetic field's inhomogeneity with an accuracy of at least one part in 10 5 .
In recent work a Stern-Gerlach interferometer (SGI) was considered in which a polarized beam of spin-(1/2 particles is split by a Stern-Gerlach apparatus into two partial beams, and then subsequent Stern-Gerlach deflecting magnets are used to reconstitute these two beams into one. In these studies it was shown that when such a coherent polarized beam passed through a SGI, some spin coherence is inevitably lost. In this regard, folk wisdom concerning irreversibility provides something of a guide to the present problem, since we all know that when Humpty-Dumpty had his great fall nobody could put him together again. In the present paper we consider the fate of our spin-(1/2 Humpty-Dumpty when a detector is present that is sensitive to the passage of particles along one trajectory, but not the other. It is not surprising that coherence is destroyed as soon as one is able to tell along which path the atom traveled. However, there seems to be no general agreement about the mechanism of coherence loss. Our conclusion is that the loss of coherence in measurements on quantum systems can always be traced to the dynamics of correlations between the measuring apparatus and the system being observed.
The Stern-Gerlach experiment (SGE) has been known for decades, but a complete theory that explains all facets of it remains enigmatic. In its classic realization, each spin state of an atom follows a unique path or trajectory in an SGE. The enigmatic part is the final output of SGE. Feynman envisaged the outcome to be an entangled state, a superposition of $|\text{spin}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{state}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}|\text{corresponding}\phantom{\rule{4.pt}{0ex}}\text{path}\ensuremath{\rangle}$. Later works described the final state of SGE as a mixed state, a weighted average of states belonging to separate beams or trajectories. Notably, Schwinger, Englert, and Scully compared the difficulty of obtaining a coherent output (a pure state) to ``putting together Humpty Dumpty'' again. Yet recent experiments using Bose-Einstein condensates indicate the emerging beams are partly coherent, favoring Feynman's description. In this work, we revisit SGE using a recent version of the quantum master equation. We show that both outcomes are probable depending on the time of flight and the timescale of the environmental fluctuations. We predict the output is initially coherent and grows gradually into a mixed state. Moreover, we also estimate how the magnetic-field gradient helps broaden the beam waist. Moreover, our treatment implies that the wave function of an atom passing through a Stern-Gerlach device does not undergo an instantaneous collapse; rather, a gradual decay of coherences results in a mixed state, resulting in an irreversible process.
We argue that the non-adiabatic evolution of spin states in Stern-Gerlach apparatus can blur the manifestation of path spin entanglement. This fact introduces a contradiction to the usual perception of spin measurement even in a formally ideal situation. Through quantitative calculation, we have pointed out the specific reason behind the breakdown of adiabatic evolution to be the spatial inhomogeneity of applied magnetic field. The angle θθθ between the zzz component of magnetic moment of the particle and applied magnetic field is also a determining factor for the category of evolution of spin states. Adiabaticity always can be restored by choosing a sufficiently small value of θθθ. Considering azimuthal inhomogeneity, we have examined the nature of path spin entanglement in the context of Stern-Gerlach experiment.