Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annalen der Physik

Optimal Discrimination of Two Nonorthogonal States by Continuous Probing and Feedback Operation

Peng Xu, Peng Zhao, Shengmei Zhao

Published Mar 30, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract For a quantum system prepared probabilistically on two or more non‐orthogonal states, the observer cannot discriminate the initial preparation perfectly. Kurt Jacobs [Quantum Inf. Comput. 2007, 7, 127] introduced a measurement operator that could increase the rate of information obtained using a continuous measurement scheme. However, the better effect happens at the expense of reducing the total information from the quantum system. To address this problem, an optimal operator that could yield the maximal value of mutual information for a long‐time measurement is found. Particularly, it turns out that the error probability is minimized for any measurement moment by measuring the optimal operator. Furthermore, for a given finite measurement time, a measurement scheme to maximize the obtained mutual information is presented. It is shown that while the Jacobs' operator should be used for a short‐time case, for a long‐time limit, the proposed optimal operator should be employed. For a given finite duration, the proposal could determine the optimal measurement operator that maximizes the final value of mutual information.

DOI
10.1002/andp.202100580

Related papers

Feedback control for communication with non-orthogonal states

Kurt A. Jacobs

Communicating classical information with a quantum system involves the receiver making a measurement on the system so as to distinguish as well as possible the alphabet of states used by the sender. We consider the situation in which this measurement takes an appreciable time. In this case the measurement must be described by a continuous measurement process. We consider a continuous implementation of the optimal measurement for distinguishing between two non-orthogonal states, and show that feedback control can be used during this measurement to increase the rate at which the information regarding the initial preparation is obtained. We show that while the maximum obtainable increase is modest, the effect is purely quantum mechanical in the sense that the enhancement is only possible when the initial states are non-orthogonal. We find further that the enhancement in the rate of information gain is achieved at the expense of reducing the total information which the measurement can extract in the long-time limit.

arXiv:quant-ph/0601162•Quantum Information and Computation•Jan 1, 2007•23 citations

Optimizations of quantum measurement processes for signal detection and information transmission in quantum systems

Masashi Ban, Masao Osaki, Osamu Hirota

The calculation method proposed here obtains an optimum detection process for an M-ary signal whose quantum states are linearly independent and nonorthogonal. Optimizations are carried out by minimizing the average probability of error or by maximizing the mutual information in the signal detection process. Quantum detection operators, in terms of which the signal detection process is mathematically described, are assumed to be projection operators defined on a Hilbert space H s spanned by the quantum states of the signal; that is, the best projection operators that describe the signal detection process are obtained. The optimization procedure is equivalent to finding an appropriate unitary transformation in the Hilbert space H s. For a binary quantum state signal, the optimum detection processes in which the average probability of error is minimized and in which the mutual information is maximized are obtained. It is found that the optimum detection process minimizing the average probability of error is the same as that maximizing the mutual information.

Journal of Modern Optics•Nov 1, 1996•13 citations

Feedback in the problem of distinguishing between two nonorthogonal coherent states

В. Н. Горбачев, Maria V. Chekhova

Feedback is proposed for distinguishing between two weak coherent states with phases differing by ∼π. The mutual nonorthogonality of such states gives rise to a discrimination error, which can be reduced by using feedback. An optical quantum channel is discussed where the input is classical information encoded in two weak coherent states. For a channel with feedback, the discrimination error probability is calculated, and the mutual entropy that quantifies the fidelity between input and output is evaluated. We find that the use of a feedback loop in a quantum communication channel can increase the mutual entropy when canonical position or photon number is measured.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 2011•1 citation

Maximum information measurement for qubit states

Árpád Varga, Петер Адам, János A. Bergou

We determine the optimal measurement that maximizes the average information gain about the state of a qubit system. The qubit is prepared in one of two known states with known prior probabilities. To treat the problem analytically we employ the formalism developed for the maximum confidence quantum state discrimination strategy and obtain the POVM which optimizes the information gain for the entire parameter space of the system. We show that the optimal measurement coincides exactly with the minimum-error quantum measurement only for two pure states, or when the two states have the same Bloch radius or they are on the same diagonal of the Bloch disk.

Scientific Reports•May 24, 2024•4 citations

Enhanced quantum state discrimination under general measurements with entanglement and nonorthogonality restrictions

Swati Choudhary, Aparajita Bhattacharyya, Ujjwal Sen

The minimum error probability for distinguishing between two quantum states is bounded by the Helstrom limit, derived under the assumption that measurement strategies are restricted to positive operator-valued measurements. We explore scenarios in which the error probability for discriminating two quantum states can be reduced below the Helstrom bound under some constrained access of resources, indicating the use of measurement operations that go beyond the standard positive operator-valued measurements framework. We refer to such measurements as non-positive operator-valued measurements. While existing literature often associates these measurements with initial entanglement between the system and an auxiliary, followed by joint projective measurement and discarding the auxiliary, we demonstrate that initial entanglement between system and auxiliary is not necessary for the emergence of such measurements in the context of state discrimination. Interestingly, even initial product states can give rise to effective non-positive measurements on the subsystem, and achieve sub-Helstrom discrimination error when discriminating quantum states of the subsystem.

quant-pharXiv:2601.19820•Jan 28, 2026•0 citations

Discriminating nonorthogonal quantum states with minimum average number of copies (Conference Presentation)

Sergei Slussarenko, Morgan M. Weston, Jungang Li +3 more

Quantum measurement and control science provides a toolkit for implementing quantum information protocols, overcoming noisy operation and minimizing the use of costly quantum resources. The importance of finding optimal measurement and control strategies is revealed in the task of quantum state discrimination, a characteristic feature of quantum mechanics and a primitive for quantum information science and technology. When a quantum system is prepared in one of two known nonorthogonal quantum states, no measurement can deterministically tell which state the system is in. Two strategies can be applied to discriminate non-orthogonal states efficiently. Unambiguous state discrimination (USD) is strategy that provides a guess which is either correct, or inconclusive [1]. Alternatively, minimum error discrimination (MED) strategy will always provide a conclusive answer, which can sometimes be incorrect [2]. Perfect nonorthogonal state discrimination is still impossible even when multiple copies of the system are available, although different strategies increase the chance of having conclusive (for USD), or correct (for MED) result. Multiple-copy measurement strategies can be either collective, when a single measurement involves all the copies of the system, or local, when each copy of the system is measured separately. The latter can be further divided into fixed, where the measurement applied to each copy is the same, or adaptive, where the measurement on each subsequent copy depends on the outcomes of the previous measurements [3,4]. A multiple-copy MED strategy is defined by its goal of minimizing the average error for fixed resources, i.e. the number of copies of the system. An alternative approach we consider, is to minimize the average resources required, while keeping errors below a given bound [5]. This approach is central for fault-tolerant quantum computing and has been applied to a number of quantum control strategies [6,7]. We call the corresponding state discrimination task the guaranteed bounded error discrimination (GBED) task. Intuitively, one may assume that the multiple-copy strategies optimal for MED would be also optimal for GBED. We experimentally apply two known local non-adaptive strategies, previously considered for the MED task, to the two-state GBED problem [5]. We then derive and experimentally demonstrate a new local strategy, designed specifically for the GBED task that outperforms other strategies. Moreover, it performs usually better than, and in the regime of small error, scales better than, the theoretical performance of the optimal adaptive strategy for the MED task. The discovered reversal in the performance of schemes when swapping the task definition from performance-maximization to resource-minimization, is similar to that previously observed in state purification [6], suggesting that this phenomenon is a generic one. [1] I. D. Ivanovic, Phys. Lett. A 123, 257 (1987). [2] C. W. Helstrom, Quantum detection and estimation theory (1976). [3] A. Acín, et al., Phys. Rev. A 71, 032338 (2005). [4] B. L. Higgins, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 220503 (2009). [5] S. Slussarenko, et al., PRL 118, 030502 (2017). [6] H. M. Wiseman and J. F. Ralph. New J. Phys. 8, 90 (2006). [7] J. Combes, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 160503 (2008).

SPIE Quantum Information Science and Technology•Oct 11, 2018•0 citations
Abstract For a quantum system prepared probabilistically on two or more non‐orthogonal states, the observer cannot discriminate the initial preparation perfectly. Kurt Jacobs [Quantum Inf. Comput. 2007, 7, 127] introduced a measurement operator that could increase the rate of information obtained using a continuous measurement scheme. However, the better effect happens at the expense of reducing the total information from the quantum system. To address this problem, an optimal operator that could yield the maximal value of mutual information for a long‐time measurement is found. Particularly, it turns out that the error probability is minimized for any measurement moment by measuring the optimal operator. Furthermore, for a given finite measurement time, a measurement scheme to maximize the obtained mutual information is presented. It is shown that while the Jacobs' operator should be used for a short‐time case, for a long‐time limit, the proposed optimal operator should be employed. For a given finite duration, the proposal could determine the optimal measurement operator that maximizes the final value of mutual information.
Communicating classical information with a quantum system involves the receiver making a measurement on the system so as to distinguish as well as possible the alphabet of states used by the sender. We consider the situation in which this measurement takes an appreciable time. In this case the measurement must be described by a continuous measurement process. We consider a continuous implementation of the optimal measurement for distinguishing between two non-orthogonal states, and show that feedback control can be used during this measurement to increase the rate at which the information regarding the initial preparation is obtained. We show that while the maximum obtainable increase is modest, the effect is purely quantum mechanical in the sense that the enhancement is only possible when the initial states are non-orthogonal. We find further that the enhancement in the rate of information gain is achieved at the expense of reducing the total information which the measurement can extract in the long-time limit.
The calculation method proposed here obtains an optimum detection process for an M-ary signal whose quantum states are linearly independent and nonorthogonal. Optimizations are carried out by minimizing the average probability of error or by maximizing the mutual information in the signal detection process. Quantum detection operators, in terms of which the signal detection process is mathematically described, are assumed to be projection operators defined on a Hilbert space H s spanned by the quantum states of the signal; that is, the best projection operators that describe the signal detection process are obtained. The optimization procedure is equivalent to finding an appropriate unitary transformation in the Hilbert space H s. For a binary quantum state signal, the optimum detection processes in which the average probability of error is minimized and in which the mutual information is maximized are obtained. It is found that the optimum detection process minimizing the average probability of error is the same as that maximizing the mutual information.
Feedback is proposed for distinguishing between two weak coherent states with phases differing by ∼π. The mutual nonorthogonality of such states gives rise to a discrimination error, which can be reduced by using feedback. An optical quantum channel is discussed where the input is classical information encoded in two weak coherent states. For a channel with feedback, the discrimination error probability is calculated, and the mutual entropy that quantifies the fidelity between input and output is evaluated. We find that the use of a feedback loop in a quantum communication channel can increase the mutual entropy when canonical position or photon number is measured.
We determine the optimal measurement that maximizes the average information gain about the state of a qubit system. The qubit is prepared in one of two known states with known prior probabilities. To treat the problem analytically we employ the formalism developed for the maximum confidence quantum state discrimination strategy and obtain the POVM which optimizes the information gain for the entire parameter space of the system. We show that the optimal measurement coincides exactly with the minimum-error quantum measurement only for two pure states, or when the two states have the same Bloch radius or they are on the same diagonal of the Bloch disk.
The minimum error probability for distinguishing between two quantum states is bounded by the Helstrom limit, derived under the assumption that measurement strategies are restricted to positive operator-valued measurements. We explore scenarios in which the error probability for discriminating two quantum states can be reduced below the Helstrom bound under some constrained access of resources, indicating the use of measurement operations that go beyond the standard positive operator-valued measurements framework. We refer to such measurements as non-positive operator-valued measurements. While existing literature often associates these measurements with initial entanglement between the system and an auxiliary, followed by joint projective measurement and discarding the auxiliary, we demonstrate that initial entanglement between system and auxiliary is not necessary for the emergence of such measurements in the context of state discrimination. Interestingly, even initial product states can give rise to effective non-positive measurements on the subsystem, and achieve sub-Helstrom discrimination error when discriminating quantum states of the subsystem.
Quantum measurement and control science provides a toolkit for implementing quantum information protocols, overcoming noisy operation and minimizing the use of costly quantum resources. The importance of finding optimal measurement and control strategies is revealed in the task of quantum state discrimination, a characteristic feature of quantum mechanics and a primitive for quantum information science and technology. When a quantum system is prepared in one of two known nonorthogonal quantum states, no measurement can deterministically tell which state the system is in. Two strategies can be applied to discriminate non-orthogonal states efficiently. Unambiguous state discrimination (USD) is strategy that provides a guess which is either correct, or inconclusive [1]. Alternatively, minimum error discrimination (MED) strategy will always provide a conclusive answer, which can sometimes be incorrect [2]. Perfect nonorthogonal state discrimination is still impossible even when multiple copies of the system are available, although different strategies increase the chance of having conclusive (for USD), or correct (for MED) result. Multiple-copy measurement strategies can be either collective, when a single measurement involves all the copies of the system, or local, when each copy of the system is measured separately. The latter can be further divided into fixed, where the measurement applied to each copy is the same, or adaptive, where the measurement on each subsequent copy depends on the outcomes of the previous measurements [3,4]. A multiple-copy MED strategy is defined by its goal of minimizing the average error for fixed resources, i.e. the number of copies of the system. An alternative approach we consider, is to minimize the average resources required, while keeping errors below a given bound [5]. This approach is central for fault-tolerant quantum computing and has been applied to a number of quantum control strategies [6,7]. We call the corresponding state discrimination task the guaranteed bounded error discrimination (GBED) task. Intuitively, one may assume that the multiple-copy strategies optimal for MED would be also optimal for GBED. We experimentally apply two known local non-adaptive strategies, previously considered for the MED task, to the two-state GBED problem [5]. We then derive and experimentally demonstrate a new local strategy, designed specifically for the GBED task that outperforms other strategies. Moreover, it performs usually better than, and in the regime of small error, scales better than, the theoretical performance of the optimal adaptive strategy for the MED task. The discovered reversal in the performance of schemes when swapping the task definition from performance-maximization to resource-minimization, is similar to that previously observed in state purification [6], suggesting that this phenomenon is a generic one. [1] I. D. Ivanovic, Phys. Lett. A 123, 257 (1987). [2] C. W. Helstrom, Quantum detection and estimation theory (1976). [3] A. Acín, et al., Phys. Rev. A 71, 032338 (2005). [4] B. L. Higgins, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 220503 (2009). [5] S. Slussarenko, et al., PRL 118, 030502 (2017). [6] H. M. Wiseman and J. F. Ralph. New J. Phys. 8, 90 (2006). [7] J. Combes, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 160503 (2008).