Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

Dispersive Spectrometry At Terahertz Frequencies for Probing the Quality of NbTiN Superconducting Films

Andrey V. Khudchenko, Bram Lap, Kirill I. Rudakov, Ronald Hesper, V. P. Koshelets, Pavel N. Dmitriev, Artem M. Chekushkin, Fedor V. Khan, Elena S. Zhukova, Lenar S. Kadyrov, Boris P. Gorshunov, Andrey M. Baryshev

Published Feb 1, 2022• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present the quality measurements of thick (thicker than London penetration depth) NbTiN superconducting films at Terahertz frequencies using a Dispersive Fourier Transform Spectrometer (DFTS). The reflected RF signal from the tested film was measured in time domain, allowing us to separate it from other reflections. The complex conductivity of the film depends on frequency and determines the reflection coefficient. By comparing the film reflection in superconducting state (film temperature below$Tc$) with that of the normal state (film temperature above$Tc$), we characterized the film quality at terahertz frequencies, and directly probed the energy of the superconducting gap of the tested film. The experimental results were fitted using the extended Mattis-Bardeen theory and th obtained film parameters show a good agreement with the literature. In addition to the DFTS, we have also measured the properties of NbTiN film using Time Domain Spectroscopy (TDS). It is shown that both TDS and DFTS provide similar results, and both techniques can be used for the quality control of thick NbTiN films. The superconducting gap determined from the measurements by both DFTS and TDS are in good agreement for both solid and meshed films showing that there is no remarkable degradation in the film quality due to technological processes of lift-off or ion etching.

DOI
10.1109/tasc.2022.3147736

Related papers

Characterization of NbTiN Films for Superconducting Terahertz Circuitry

Yoshinori Uzawa, Kazumasa Makise, Shingo Saito +7 more

We have investigated superconducting properties of niobium titanium nitride (NbTiN) films to be used for the lower and upper electrodes of a microstrip line with a SiO2insulator on a quartz substrate at Terahertz frequencies. NbTiN films were prepared on a 1-mm thick quartz substrate directly (assumed to be the lower electrode of the microstrip line) and on an about 150-nm thick SiO2layer sputtered on a quartz substrate (assumed to be the upper electrode) by reactive dc magnetron sputtering at ambient temperature. The complex conductivity measurement by Terahertz time- domain spectroscopy revealed that both films have similar superconducting properties with critical temperatures of about 14 K and gap frequencies of about 1.2 THz at 5 K. This indicates that all-NbTiN microstrip lines may work well as extremely low-loss transmission lines at Terahertz frequencies.

IEEE International Superconductive Electronics Conference (ISEC)•Jul 1, 2015•1 citation

Impact of the Buffer Layers and Anodization on Properties of NbTiN Films for THz Receivers

Elena S. Zhukova, Boris P. Gorshunov, Lenar S. Kadyrov +7 more

In this paper, we present the results of the research aimed at improving the fabrication process of a SIS-mixer for operation at frequencies close to 1 THz. We study the impact of buffer aluminum oxide layer and anodization effects on the properties of superconducting NbTiN films which form the electrodes of the transmission lines in THz-range devices. These layers are traditionally used in technological processes. The measurements of THz response are performed using terahertz time-domain spectrometer at frequencies from 0.3 to 2.0 THz. It was found that the critical temperature, normal-state conductivity just above the transition temperature, superconducting gap value and London penetration depth of the NbTiN film sputtered on aluminum oxide buffer layer are almost the same as of the film sputtered directly onto the substrate. The difference between the parameters is comparable to the measurement uncertainty for NbTiN films with and without additional surface layers of aluminum and anodization.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jan 16, 2024•2 citations

Contactless terahertz mapping of wafer-scale superconducting NbTiN thin films

Yayi Lin, Marc Neis, Marcello P. Guardascione +9 more

For large-scale superconducting quantum technology, e.g. quantum computing, the homogeneity of wafer-scale superconducting thin films is vital for consistent performance of the fabricated devices. Terahertz (THz) spectroscopy as a contactless and non-destructive measurement technique is a powerful tool to characterize the superconducting films. In this work, a set of niobium titanium nitride (NbTiN) thin films on 4-inch and 6-inch silicon wafers, grown via plasma-enhanced magnetron sputtering, are investigated via THz spectroscopy: full wafers are mapped at room temperatures and exemplary segments are characterized at cryogenic temperatures. The deviations in observed sheet resistance depend on the used deposition device and the film thickness. While the deviations in superconducting sheet kinetic inductance match those of the normal-state sheet resistance, the critical temperature and energy gap exhibit little variation. This THz mapping technique demonstrates the feasibility of evaluating wafer-scale superconducting thin films before lithography, facilitating preparation of the thin films for reproducible device fabrication.

arXiv:2607.15757•Jul 17, 2026•0 citations

Superconducting resonator circuits at frequencies above the gap frequency

Gert J. de Lange, J. J. Kuipers, T. M. Klapwijk +3 more

The frequency response of three superconductive niobium resonating circuits, formed by a Nb microstrip and a Nb tunnel junction, is measured and analyzed at frequencies above the superconducting gap frequency. The circuits are placed in a waveguide system and the frequency response is determined with a Fourier transform spectrometer. The calculated and measured resonance frequencies and bandwidths are in good agreement with the extreme anomalous limit of the Mattis–Bardeen theory on the anomalous skin effect in superconductors [D.C. Mattis and J. Bardeen, Phys. Rev. 111, 412 (1958)]. The observed loss is higher than predicted by this theory, in agreement with previous observations on Nb films. The use of other materials for striplines as tuning circuits for heterodyne superconducting tunnel junction mixers is analyzed.

Journal of Applied Physics•Feb 15, 1995•24 citations

Design of Terahertz SIS Mixers Using Nb/AlN/Nb Junctions Integrated With All-NbTiN Tuning Circuits

Yoshinori Uzawa, M. Kroug, Takafumi Kojima +7 more

We have designed superconductor-insulator-superconductor (SIS) mixers using Nb/AlN/Nb tunnel junctions integrated with NbTiN/SiO2/NbTiN microstrip tuning circuits for the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) Band 10 (0.78-0.95 THz). In order to design the tuning circuits, we used terahertz time domain spectroscopy to experimentally derive the complex conductivity of relatively thick NbTiN films deposited on quartz substrate directly as a ground plane and on RF-sputtered SiO2as a microstrip. Results showed that the conductivities of both films can be described by a modified Mattis-Bardeen theory. We also investigated the junction heating effects originating from quasi-particle trapping in the Nb electrodes embedded in NbTiN circuits by varying the volume of the electrodes. It was confirmed that current-voltage curves of Nb/AlN/Nb tunnel junctions with thick (~200 nm) counter electrodes contacting NbTiN wirings showed higher gap voltages as well as reduced back-bending than those with thin (~50 nm) electrodes. Making use of these findings, our designed SIS mixers employing Nb/AlN/Nb junctions with a current density of 15 kA/cm2and all-NbTiN tuning circuits may cover the Band 10 with good sensitivity.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Nov 28, 2016•12 citations

Evaluation of niobium transmission lines up to the superconducting gap frequency

M. M. T. M. Dierichs, B. Johan Feenstra, Anders J. Skalare +4 more

The frequency dependence of the coupling of niobium superconducting transmission lines is measured for frequencies up to and above the superconducting gap frequency. For this purpose superconducting microstrips are integrated in log-periodic planar antennas and the spectral response is measured by means of a Fourier transform spectrometer with 1 μm2 Nb/Al2O3/Nb SIS junctions as detectors. Resonances of microstrips are observed up to 650 GHz, the superconducting gap frequency of niobium, but above that frequency no resonances have been detected. The measured resonance frequencies are in good agreement with a dispersive model for superconducting transmission lines based on the Mattis–Bardeen theory. The radiation coupling is lower than calculated, indicating significant dielectric losses.

Applied Physics Letters•Jul 12, 1993•10 citations
We present the quality measurements of thick (thicker than London penetration depth) NbTiN superconducting films at Terahertz frequencies using a Dispersive Fourier Transform Spectrometer (DFTS). The reflected RF signal from the tested film was measured in time domain, allowing us to separate it from other reflections. The complex conductivity of the film depends on frequency and determines the reflection coefficient. By comparing the film reflection in superconducting state (film temperature belowTcTcTc) with that of the normal state (film temperature aboveTcTcTc), we characterized the film quality at terahertz frequencies, and directly probed the energy of the superconducting gap of the tested film. The experimental results were fitted using the extended Mattis-Bardeen theory and th obtained film parameters show a good agreement with the literature. In addition to the DFTS, we have also measured the properties of NbTiN film using Time Domain Spectroscopy (TDS). It is shown that both TDS and DFTS provide similar results, and both techniques can be used for the quality control of thick NbTiN films. The superconducting gap determined from the measurements by both DFTS and TDS are in good agreement for both solid and meshed films showing that there is no remarkable degradation in the film quality due to technological processes of lift-off or ion etching.
We have investigated superconducting properties of niobium titanium nitride (NbTiN) films to be used for the lower and upper electrodes of a microstrip line with a SiO2insulator on a quartz substrate at Terahertz frequencies. NbTiN films were prepared on a 1-mm thick quartz substrate directly (assumed to be the lower electrode of the microstrip line) and on an about 150-nm thick SiO2layer sputtered on a quartz substrate (assumed to be the upper electrode) by reactive dc magnetron sputtering at ambient temperature. The complex conductivity measurement by Terahertz time- domain spectroscopy revealed that both films have similar superconducting properties with critical temperatures of about 14 K and gap frequencies of about 1.2 THz at 5 K. This indicates that all-NbTiN microstrip lines may work well as extremely low-loss transmission lines at Terahertz frequencies.
In this paper, we present the results of the research aimed at improving the fabrication process of a SIS-mixer for operation at frequencies close to 1 THz. We study the impact of buffer aluminum oxide layer and anodization effects on the properties of superconducting NbTiN films which form the electrodes of the transmission lines in THz-range devices. These layers are traditionally used in technological processes. The measurements of THz response are performed using terahertz time-domain spectrometer at frequencies from 0.3 to 2.0 THz. It was found that the critical temperature, normal-state conductivity just above the transition temperature, superconducting gap value and London penetration depth of the NbTiN film sputtered on aluminum oxide buffer layer are almost the same as of the film sputtered directly onto the substrate. The difference between the parameters is comparable to the measurement uncertainty for NbTiN films with and without additional surface layers of aluminum and anodization.
For large-scale superconducting quantum technology, e.g. quantum computing, the homogeneity of wafer-scale superconducting thin films is vital for consistent performance of the fabricated devices. Terahertz (THz) spectroscopy as a contactless and non-destructive measurement technique is a powerful tool to characterize the superconducting films. In this work, a set of niobium titanium nitride (NbTiN) thin films on 4-inch and 6-inch silicon wafers, grown via plasma-enhanced magnetron sputtering, are investigated via THz spectroscopy: full wafers are mapped at room temperatures and exemplary segments are characterized at cryogenic temperatures. The deviations in observed sheet resistance depend on the used deposition device and the film thickness. While the deviations in superconducting sheet kinetic inductance match those of the normal-state sheet resistance, the critical temperature and energy gap exhibit little variation. This THz mapping technique demonstrates the feasibility of evaluating wafer-scale superconducting thin films before lithography, facilitating preparation of the thin films for reproducible device fabrication.
The frequency response of three superconductive niobium resonating circuits, formed by a Nb microstrip and a Nb tunnel junction, is measured and analyzed at frequencies above the superconducting gap frequency. The circuits are placed in a waveguide system and the frequency response is determined with a Fourier transform spectrometer. The calculated and measured resonance frequencies and bandwidths are in good agreement with the extreme anomalous limit of the Mattis–Bardeen theory on the anomalous skin effect in superconductors [D.C. Mattis and J. Bardeen, Phys. Rev. 111, 412 (1958)]. The observed loss is higher than predicted by this theory, in agreement with previous observations on Nb films. The use of other materials for striplines as tuning circuits for heterodyne superconducting tunnel junction mixers is analyzed.
We have designed superconductor-insulator-superconductor (SIS) mixers using Nb/AlN/Nb tunnel junctions integrated with NbTiN/SiO2/NbTiN microstrip tuning circuits for the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) Band 10 (0.78-0.95 THz). In order to design the tuning circuits, we used terahertz time domain spectroscopy to experimentally derive the complex conductivity of relatively thick NbTiN films deposited on quartz substrate directly as a ground plane and on RF-sputtered SiO2as a microstrip. Results showed that the conductivities of both films can be described by a modified Mattis-Bardeen theory. We also investigated the junction heating effects originating from quasi-particle trapping in the Nb electrodes embedded in NbTiN circuits by varying the volume of the electrodes. It was confirmed that current-voltage curves of Nb/AlN/Nb tunnel junctions with thick (~200 nm) counter electrodes contacting NbTiN wirings showed higher gap voltages as well as reduced back-bending than those with thin (~50 nm) electrodes. Making use of these findings, our designed SIS mixers employing Nb/AlN/Nb junctions with a current density of 15 kA/cm2and all-NbTiN tuning circuits may cover the Band 10 with good sensitivity.
The frequency dependence of the coupling of niobium superconducting transmission lines is measured for frequencies up to and above the superconducting gap frequency. For this purpose superconducting microstrips are integrated in log-periodic planar antennas and the spectral response is measured by means of a Fourier transform spectrometer with 1 μm2 Nb/Al2O3/Nb SIS junctions as detectors. Resonances of microstrips are observed up to 650 GHz, the superconducting gap frequency of niobium, but above that frequency no resonances have been detected. The measured resonance frequencies are in good agreement with a dispersive model for superconducting transmission lines based on the Mattis–Bardeen theory. The radiation coupling is lower than calculated, indicating significant dielectric losses.