Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Essays

Bell tests explained by classical optics without quantum entanglement

Dean L. Mamas

Published Dec 30, 2021• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A polarized photon interacts with a polarizer through the component of the photon’s electric field which is aligned with the polarizer. This component varies as the cosine of the angle through which the polarizer is rotated, explaining the cosine observed in Bell test data. Quantum mechanics is unnecessary and plays no role.
DOI
10.4006/0836-1398-34.4.582

Related papers

Comment on “Bell tests explained by classical optics without quantum entanglement” by Dean L. Mamas [Phys. Essays 34, 340 (2021)]

Richard David Gill

In a paper published in the journal [Phys. Essays 34, 340 (2021)], Mamas writes “A polarized photon interacts with a polarizer through the component of the photon's electric field which is aligned with the polarizer. This component varies as the cosine of the angle through which the polarizer is rotated, explaining the cosine observed in Bell test data. Quantum mechanics is unnecessary and plays no role”. Mamas is right that according to this physical model, one will observe a negative cosine. However, the amplitude of the cosine curve is 50%, not 100%, and it consequently does not violate any Bell-CHSH inequality. Mamas' physical model is a classic local hidden variables model. The result is illustrated with a Monte Carlo simulation.

arXiv:2211.01068•Physics Essays•Mar 13, 2023•0 citations

New Experiment for Bell’s Inequalities for Photons Using Different Polarization Angles

In quantum mechanics, quantum entanglement is a physical phenomenon in which quantum particles (such as photons, electrons...) are connected to each other despite the large distances between them.This phenomenon occurs when a pair or group of particles is created in such a way that the quantum state of a particular particle cannot be described independently of other particles, even if there is a large distance between these particles.This research dealt with a computerized theoretical study of John Bell's theory to verify quantum entanglement, which was later tested by the French scientist Alain Aspect on photons of light, and the polarization angles of light were (0.45, 22.5, 67.5)This experiment was conducted and the results were recorded from the virtual interactive quantum entanglement laboratory (VIQEL), which is highly efficient in simulating the equations of quantum mechanics and probability functions, where we obtained accurate results by increasing the number of photonic pairs involved in the experiment and then the results were compared with the results of previous research by other scientists to prove that the main variable, which is the angle of polarization, does not affect the result when its value changes, but its effect lies in the difference in angles in the experiment, which in turn enhances From the theory of quantum entanglement.

Journal of Chemical Biological and Physical Sciences•May 6, 2024•0 citations

Proposal for a new test of Bell's inequality in an optical interference experiment

Z. Y. Ou, C.K. Hong, L. Mandeļ

A new experimental test of Bell's inequality is proposed, that depends on measurements of the two-photon detection probability as a function of position in an interference experiment. Although the experiment also makes use of polarizers, the polarization angles remain fixed and only the detector positions are varied. The proposed experiment differs from most previous tests of Bell's inequality in that the measured quantities are mutually exclusive probabilities.

Optics Communications•Jul 1, 1988•23 citations

Testing Bell’s Theorem with Circular Polarization

Richard A. Hutchin

Bell tests with entangled light have been performed many times in many ways using linear polarizers, but the same tests have never been done with a circular polarizer. Until recently there has never been a true circular polarization beamsplitter—an optical component that separates light directly into left and right handed polarizations. Using a true circular polarization beamsplitter based on birefringent gratings, entangled light has been analyzed with unexpected results.

Optics and Photonics Journal•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Experiment on Bell's Inequalities Violation Would Give Same Result with Un-entangled Classical Photons

Fabien Sabinet

Experiments testing Bell's inequalities generally uses sources of entangled photons emitted in opposite direction, sent through polarizer of specific different orientation and finally correlated. But the correlation result would be the same if photons was emitted by only one source of 360° rotating polarization, separated in two flux by a semi-transparent mirror, and finally correlated as in the standard experiment. Therefore, it would demonstrate that the result is not due to any entangled state of the photons.

•Nov 1, 2020•0 citations

Photonic entanglement for fundamental tests and quantum communication

Wolfgang Tittel, Gregor Weihs

Entanglement is at the heart of fundamental tests of quantum mechanics like tests of Bell-inequalities and, as discovered lately, of quantum computation and communication. Their technological advance made entangled photons play an outstanding role in entanglement physics. We give a generalized concept of qubit entanglement and review the state of the art of photonics experiments.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107156•Quantum Information and Computation•Aug 1, 2001•158 citations
In a paper published in the journal [Phys. Essays 34, 340 (2021)], Mamas writes “A polarized photon interacts with a polarizer through the component of the photon's electric field which is aligned with the polarizer. This component varies as the cosine of the angle through which the polarizer is rotated, explaining the cosine observed in Bell test data. Quantum mechanics is unnecessary and plays no role”. Mamas is right that according to this physical model, one will observe a negative cosine. However, the amplitude of the cosine curve is 50%, not 100%, and it consequently does not violate any Bell-CHSH inequality. Mamas' physical model is a classic local hidden variables model. The result is illustrated with a Monte Carlo simulation.
In quantum mechanics, quantum entanglement is a physical phenomenon in which quantum particles (such as photons, electrons...) are connected to each other despite the large distances between them.This phenomenon occurs when a pair or group of particles is created in such a way that the quantum state of a particular particle cannot be described independently of other particles, even if there is a large distance between these particles.This research dealt with a computerized theoretical study of John Bell's theory to verify quantum entanglement, which was later tested by the French scientist Alain Aspect on photons of light, and the polarization angles of light were (0.45, 22.5, 67.5)This experiment was conducted and the results were recorded from the virtual interactive quantum entanglement laboratory (VIQEL), which is highly efficient in simulating the equations of quantum mechanics and probability functions, where we obtained accurate results by increasing the number of photonic pairs involved in the experiment and then the results were compared with the results of previous research by other scientists to prove that the main variable, which is the angle of polarization, does not affect the result when its value changes, but its effect lies in the difference in angles in the experiment, which in turn enhances From the theory of quantum entanglement.
Experiments testing Bell's inequalities generally uses sources of entangled photons emitted in opposite direction, sent through polarizer of specific different orientation and finally correlated. But the correlation result would be the same if photons was emitted by only one source of 360° rotating polarization, separated in two flux by a semi-transparent mirror, and finally correlated as in the standard experiment. Therefore, it would demonstrate that the result is not due to any entangled state of the photons.