Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

History of Science

Quantum Historiography and the Archive for History of Quantum Physics

J. L. Heilbron

Published Mar 1, 1968• 8 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1177/007327536800700103

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics Through Nobel: Revealing Quantum History from the Nobel Archives

Mats Larsson

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jan 12, 2026•0 citations

Kontinuum

Gerhard Grössing

Identifying »continuum« as a key concept in history, the author establishes a physicist’s view of this term, with a generally broader scope. However, when focusing on quantum physics, he produces a strong criticism both of basic theory building in quantum theory and in the historiography of this very field of scientific research. This criticism involves the fatal distinctions between the concepts of the digital and the analogue, respectively, the maintenance of a strictly reductionist, or »atomistic«, approach – as opposed to possible, more general and systemic view-points, and, consequently, the preference of research purely focussing on the particle-like rather than both the particle- and the wave-like »behaviours« on the quantum-level. It is argued that the dominant pattern of interpretation, the orthodox Kopenhagen inter- pretation, includes a highly metaphysical dimension, thereby hindering the solution of puzzles provided by quantum theory. The article pleads for a re-thinking, and re-working of the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation of quantum phenomena, which draws on a ›hidden variables‹ approach in full agreement with present experimental evidence. Furthermore, the dominance of the Kopenhagen interpretation is kept up not only by means of lobbying but also by means of historiography of science. The last chapter offers alternative viewpoints, avoiding the reductionism of the orthodox school, pleading for a more complex, multi-faceted view, and including both wave and particle aspects on an equal footing.

Österreichische Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaften•Sep 21, 2020•0 citations

The history of quantum theory

F. Hund

•Jan 1, 1974•29 citations

Revisiting the Genesis of ‘Many-Worlds'

Matthias Ackermann

It is often claimed that Wheeler insisted on a revision and consequently shortening of Everett’s PhD thesis, partly because of his anticipation to reconcile the theory with Bohr’s approach. In this paper, I want to propose a reading of the historiography that renders Wheeler’s tenacity as admittedly benevolent but ultimately condemned to failure from the start. To this end I focus on the time of the genesis of Everett’s thesis, his associated dissatisfaction with the ‘Standard’ and ‘Copenhagen’ formulation of Quantum Mechanics and Wheeler as the driving force in denying his doctoral student to be part of the debate about measurement that happened in the second half of the 1950's. If it hadn’t been for a lack of knowledge and miscommunication (philosophical failure) we would presumably find ourselves in a different ‘branch' of history.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

The history of quantum theory

Lewis Pyenson

Historia Mathematica•Aug 1, 1975•30 citations

“Mecanica cuántica acausal socialmente determinada": revisión crítica

Favio Ernesto Cala Vitery, Stefan Pohl-Valero

In his article entitled Weimar Culture; Causality and Quantum Theory, 1918- 1927: Adaptation by German Physicists to a Hostile Intellectual Environment, Paul Forman intended to depict a history of the old quantum mechanics according to which contemporary cultural influence turned out to be decisive in the introduction, acceptance and assimilation of acausality within the theory? These statements known as the Forman thesis are placed in historiographic perspective; i.e. their importance is shown using the framework provided by the characteristic tensions of historiography and philosophy of science. It is argued that the dilemma of determinism is essential in this discussion. Finally, a brief critical review of the Forman thesis is offered emphasizing some of its major weaknesses not previously discussed in the literature

instname:Universidad Jorge Tadeo Lozano•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations
Identifying »continuum« as a key concept in history, the author establishes a physicist’s view of this term, with a generally broader scope. However, when focusing on quantum physics, he produces a strong criticism both of basic theory building in quantum theory and in the historiography of this very field of scientific research. This criticism involves the fatal distinctions between the concepts of the digital and the analogue, respectively, the maintenance of a strictly reductionist, or »atomistic«, approach – as opposed to possible, more general and systemic view-points, and, consequently, the preference of research purely focussing on the particle-like rather than both the particle- and the wave-like »behaviours« on the quantum-level. It is argued that the dominant pattern of interpretation, the orthodox Kopenhagen inter- pretation, includes a highly metaphysical dimension, thereby hindering the solution of puzzles provided by quantum theory. The article pleads for a re-thinking, and re-working of the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation of quantum phenomena, which draws on a ›hidden variables‹ approach in full agreement with present experimental evidence. Furthermore, the dominance of the Kopenhagen interpretation is kept up not only by means of lobbying but also by means of historiography of science. The last chapter offers alternative viewpoints, avoiding the reductionism of the orthodox school, pleading for a more complex, multi-faceted view, and including both wave and particle aspects on an equal footing.
It is often claimed that Wheeler insisted on a revision and consequently shortening of Everett’s PhD thesis, partly because of his anticipation to reconcile the theory with Bohr’s approach. In this paper, I want to propose a reading of the historiography that renders Wheeler’s tenacity as admittedly benevolent but ultimately condemned to failure from the start. To this end I focus on the time of the genesis of Everett’s thesis, his associated dissatisfaction with the ‘Standard’ and ‘Copenhagen’ formulation of Quantum Mechanics and Wheeler as the driving force in denying his doctoral student to be part of the debate about measurement that happened in the second half of the 1950's. If it hadn’t been for a lack of knowledge and miscommunication (philosophical failure) we would presumably find ourselves in a different ‘branch' of history.
In his article entitled Weimar Culture; Causality and Quantum Theory, 1918- 1927: Adaptation by German Physicists to a Hostile Intellectual Environment, Paul Forman intended to depict a history of the old quantum mechanics according to which contemporary cultural influence turned out to be decisive in the introduction, acceptance and assimilation of acausality within the theory? These statements known as the Forman thesis are placed in historiographic perspective; i.e. their importance is shown using the framework provided by the characteristic tensions of historiography and philosophy of science. It is argued that the dilemma of determinism is essential in this discussion. Finally, a brief critical review of the Forman thesis is offered emphasizing some of its major weaknesses not previously discussed in the literature