Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

(Work in Progress) The Experiments, as the Irreducible Basis of All Science, and the Observer, as the Probability Space of All Experiments, Are Found Sufficient to Entail All Physics

Alexandre Harvey-Tremblay

Published Jan 1, 2020• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

A formal system of science is presented as a more powerful basis for fundamental physics. Rather than starting with an axiomatic theory of physics as is typically done (quantum mechanics, general relativity, classical mechanics, etc), we instead had the idea to start at the level of science by designing a formal system of science. Our goal was then to attempt, as a challenge, to derive fundamental physics from the system. This exercise turned out surprisingly productive; correcting definitions and resolving open problems spawning philosophy, mathematics, science (philosophy of) and physics. Some of our notable results include a definition of experimental data (done purely mathematically), a definition of the observer (again done purely mathematically), and a derivation of fundamental physics as the product of the scientific method (and thus, we allege, done uncontroversially). This group of results constitutes the primary items of modern theoretical physics currently missing mathematical formalization. The first part of the paper consists of constructing an experimental basis that is purely mathematical. For this we employ the set of all halting programs and we leverage modern notions of undecidability to produce a system that never runs out of new knowledge to discover, supporting a perpetual application of the scientific method. The system culminates in a definition for the observer in terms of a measure space over halting programs, such that maximizing its entropy produces a quantum-computation model of physics able to support, remarkably, up to quantum gravity. Finally, testable predictions are proposed.

DOI
10.6084/m9.figshare.11755134

Related papers

DRAFT: On the Logical Foundation of Physics (Part 2)

Alexandre Harvey-Tremblay

The aim of this work is, first, to set the basis for a formal model of science, then, it is to show that the laws of physics are its theorems. Necessarily, all theories that are the logical product of science are theorems of our model. As this includes physics, our model is, therefore, its logical foundation. Our model is an axiomatic realization of the participatory universe envisioned by John Archibald Wheeler, in which the observer's practice of science is associated with proving reality. As our model is constructive of the mathematical structure isomorphic to nature, it deprecates Karl Popper's definition of science based on falsifiability. The formal practice of science consists of constructing a message (in the sense of Shannon's theory of information) of experiments (the elements of the message) constrained by the requirement that the elements are verifiable by the statistical priors of the message. In this context, we define the priors as Nature and we qualify the message as scientific. Nature is thus understood as a general proof checker for experiments. We show that the construction of a scientific message bounds nature (the priors) to a cosmology entirely emergent from the entropy of the scientific message. Finally, we conclude that the participatory-universe is emergent from the ideal practice of science.

•Dec 1, 2018•0 citations

Constructing Physics From Measurements

Alexandre Harvey-Tremblay

We present a reformulation of fundamental physics - from an enumeration of independent axioms to the solution of a single optimization problem. Any experiment begins with an initial state preparation, involves some physical operation, and ends with a final measurement. Working from this structure, we maximize the entropy of a final measurement relative to its initial preparation subject to a measurement constraint, the later defining the domain of the theory. Since we keep the structure of an experiment entirely general, solving this optimization problem identifies the unique optimal predictive theory that holds true for all realizable experiments within the domain. We then find that using the natural constraint -- which spawns the most general domain supported by this optimization problem -- points to a unification of fundamental physics. Rather than as separate postulates, we obtain quantum mechanics, general relativity, and the Standard Model gauge symmetries within a unified theory. Notably, mathematical consistency further restricts valid solutions to 3+1 dimensions only. This reformulation reveals that the apparent complexity of modern physics, with its various forces, symmetries, and dimensional constraints, emerges as the solution an optimization problem over all realizable experiments of nature.

•Jan 21, 2025•0 citations

First Elements for the Foundation of a New Paradigm in Physics

Paolo Renati

In this article I present the extracts and summary of heuristic and speculative observations on various aspects I feel are problematic in the practice of modern physics, the definitions and methods of which are the premise for the whole of Science. The illustrations will be fully developed in a later, more extensive and in-depth work in which some theoretical solutions will also be put forward; therefore in the interests of brevity all assertions will not be demonstrated fully in this article. I will initially discuss the problem with thinking of Reality as basically being made up of ontologically autonomous “parts”; I will recall how the existence of the vacuum is demonstrated through the thermodynamic experiments about heat capacities run by W. Nernst and the experiments of W. Lamb and H. Casimir (static and dynamic); the vacuum will be defined as an object that precedes matter and space, and actually illustrated as an evolving (becoming) singularity, which all existence draws from; the non-isolability of the autonomous entity will be substantiated further by the uncertainty demonstrated as intrinsically following on from phase space quantisation, and not only as an algebraic requirement of quantum formalism. Once the inconsistency of the isolable entity has been demonstrated, the ontological supremacy of relationships in a perspective close to ontic structural realism will be considered; finally, issues relating to the usual idea of “information” in the scientific domain (in thermodynamics, informatics, and telecommunications) will be discussed fairly briefly, and its inadequacy in pooling knowledge. I will then touch on what is meant by living information as the basis for Reality and how it can be discussed consistently in terms of a self-implementing subject. It should be stressed that these topics are dealt with more extensively (along with other important subjects excluded here for reasons of space) in a complete work.

World Futures•Aug 11, 2015•3 citations

Aleph Potential Theory v2

Tracy Lee Hounshell

Aleph Potential Theory v2 (APT v2) presents a unified scientific and metaphysical framework in which reality, consciousness, physics, and subjective experience emerge from traversal through an infinite abstract space of mathematical possibility known as the Aleph Potential (2). Building on the foundations introduced in APT v1, this expanded version integrates formal set‑theoretic definitions, a rigorous traversal model of consciousness, and a comprehensive reinterpretation of physics, neuroscience, and artificial intelligence. APT v2 proposes that: Potential is primary — existence arises from recursive mathematical possibility rather than matter, energy, or spacetime. Reality is traversal — a perceiver is modeled as a function Y:N→2, generating a sequence of patterns that constitute its experienced universe. Consciousness is the wake — subjective experience emerges from the coherent residue left by traversal through pattern‑space. Physics is a filtering rule — physical laws are constraints on allowable transitions within the Aleph Potential. Divinity is the total pattern — the complete self‑referential structure of all possible configurations. APT v2 introduces formal definitions, mathematical operators, and eight testable predictions spanning consciousness, quantum measurement, dreaming, near‑death states, fine‑tuning, time dilation, and quantum gravity. The document outlines a research program connecting APT to category theory, information theory, neural coherence, and AI architecture design. This version unifies the conceptual clarity of APT v1 with the cosmological and phenomenological depth of Traversing the Infinite, producing a coherent scientific model that reframes foundational questions across physics, philosophy, and cognitive science.

•Dec 23, 2025•0 citations

The Art and Science of Experimentation in Quantum Physics

Arkady Plotnitsky, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Taking its historical point of departure in Heisenberg’s work, this article offers a view of quantum mechanics as, arguably, the first truly experimental and truly mathematical physical theory, that is, a theory concerned with experimenting with nature and mathematics alike. It is truly experimental because it is not, as in classical physics, merely the independent behavior of the system considered, in other words, what happens in any event, that we track, but what kind of experiments we perform that defines what happens. By the same token, the theory is also truly mathematical because, at least in the interpretation adopted here, its mathematical formalism does not stand in the service of a mathematical description of (quantum) physical processes in space and time in the way the formalism of classical physics does, but is only used to predict the outcomes of relevant experiments. It also follows that quantum theories experiment more freely with mathematics itself, since we invent predictive mathematical schemes, rather than proceed by refining mathematically our phenomenal representations of nature, which process constrains us in classical mechanics.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations

On the missing axiom of Quantum Mechanics

Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano

The debate on the nature of quantum probabilities in relation to Quantum Non Locality has elevated Quantum Mechanics to the level of an "Operational Epistemic Theory". In such context the quantum superposition principle has an extraneous non epistemic nature. This leads us to seek purely operational foundations for Quantum Mechanics, from which to derive the current mathematical axiomatization based on Hilbert spaces. In the present work I present a set of axioms of purely operational nature, based on a general definition of "the experiment", the operational/epistemic archetype of information retrieval from reality. As we will see, this starting point logically entails a series of notions [state, conditional state, local state, pure state, faithful state, instrument, propensity (i.e. "effect"), dynamical and informational equivalence, dynamical and informational compatibility, predictability, discriminability, programmability, locality, a-causality, rank of the state, maximally chaotic state, maximally entangled state, informationally complete propensity, etc. ], along with a set of rules (addition, convex combination, partial orderings, ...), which, far from being of quantum origin as often considered, instead constitute the universal "syntactic manual" of the operational/epistemic approach. The missing ingredient is, of course, the quantum superposition axiom for probability amplitudes: for this I propose some substitute candidates of purely operational/epistemic nature.

arXiv:quant-ph/0506034•Jun 3, 2005•6 citations
A formal system of science is presented as a more powerful basis for fundamental physics. Rather than starting with an axiomatic theory of physics as is typically done (quantum mechanics, general relativity, classical mechanics, etc), we instead had the idea to start at the level of science by designing a formal system of science. Our goal was then to attempt, as a challenge, to derive fundamental physics from the system. This exercise turned out surprisingly productive; correcting definitions and resolving open problems spawning philosophy, mathematics, science (philosophy of) and physics. Some of our notable results include a definition of experimental data (done purely mathematically), a definition of the observer (again done purely mathematically), and a derivation of fundamental physics as the product of the scientific method (and thus, we allege, done uncontroversially). This group of results constitutes the primary items of modern theoretical physics currently missing mathematical formalization. The first part of the paper consists of constructing an experimental basis that is purely mathematical. For this we employ the set of all halting programs and we leverage modern notions of undecidability to produce a system that never runs out of new knowledge to discover, supporting a perpetual application of the scientific method. The system culminates in a definition for the observer in terms of a measure space over halting programs, such that maximizing its entropy produces a quantum-computation model of physics able to support, remarkably, up to quantum gravity. Finally, testable predictions are proposed.
The aim of this work is, first, to set the basis for a formal model of science, then, it is to show that the laws of physics are its theorems. Necessarily, all theories that are the logical product of science are theorems of our model. As this includes physics, our model is, therefore, its logical foundation. Our model is an axiomatic realization of the participatory universe envisioned by John Archibald Wheeler, in which the observer's practice of science is associated with proving reality. As our model is constructive of the mathematical structure isomorphic to nature, it deprecates Karl Popper's definition of science based on falsifiability. The formal practice of science consists of constructing a message (in the sense of Shannon's theory of information) of experiments (the elements of the message) constrained by the requirement that the elements are verifiable by the statistical priors of the message. In this context, we define the priors as Nature and we qualify the message as scientific. Nature is thus understood as a general proof checker for experiments. We show that the construction of a scientific message bounds nature (the priors) to a cosmology entirely emergent from the entropy of the scientific message. Finally, we conclude that the participatory-universe is emergent from the ideal practice of science.
We present a reformulation of fundamental physics - from an enumeration of independent axioms to the solution of a single optimization problem. Any experiment begins with an initial state preparation, involves some physical operation, and ends with a final measurement. Working from this structure, we maximize the entropy of a final measurement relative to its initial preparation subject to a measurement constraint, the later defining the domain of the theory. Since we keep the structure of an experiment entirely general, solving this optimization problem identifies the unique optimal predictive theory that holds true for all realizable experiments within the domain. We then find that using the natural constraint -- which spawns the most general domain supported by this optimization problem -- points to a unification of fundamental physics. Rather than as separate postulates, we obtain quantum mechanics, general relativity, and the Standard Model gauge symmetries within a unified theory. Notably, mathematical consistency further restricts valid solutions to 3+1 dimensions only. This reformulation reveals that the apparent complexity of modern physics, with its various forces, symmetries, and dimensional constraints, emerges as the solution an optimization problem over all realizable experiments of nature.
In this article I present the extracts and summary of heuristic and speculative observations on various aspects I feel are problematic in the practice of modern physics, the definitions and methods of which are the premise for the whole of Science. The illustrations will be fully developed in a later, more extensive and in-depth work in which some theoretical solutions will also be put forward; therefore in the interests of brevity all assertions will not be demonstrated fully in this article. I will initially discuss the problem with thinking of Reality as basically being made up of ontologically autonomous “parts”; I will recall how the existence of the vacuum is demonstrated through the thermodynamic experiments about heat capacities run by W. Nernst and the experiments of W. Lamb and H. Casimir (static and dynamic); the vacuum will be defined as an object that precedes matter and space, and actually illustrated as an evolving (becoming) singularity, which all existence draws from; the non-isolability of the autonomous entity will be substantiated further by the uncertainty demonstrated as intrinsically following on from phase space quantisation, and not only as an algebraic requirement of quantum formalism. Once the inconsistency of the isolable entity has been demonstrated, the ontological supremacy of relationships in a perspective close to ontic structural realism will be considered; finally, issues relating to the usual idea of “information” in the scientific domain (in thermodynamics, informatics, and telecommunications) will be discussed fairly briefly, and its inadequacy in pooling knowledge. I will then touch on what is meant by living information as the basis for Reality and how it can be discussed consistently in terms of a self-implementing subject. It should be stressed that these topics are dealt with more extensively (along with other important subjects excluded here for reasons of space) in a complete work.
Aleph Potential Theory v2 (APT v2) presents a unified scientific and metaphysical framework in which reality, consciousness, physics, and subjective experience emerge from traversal through an infinite abstract space of mathematical possibility known as the Aleph Potential (2). Building on the foundations introduced in APT v1, this expanded version integrates formal set‑theoretic definitions, a rigorous traversal model of consciousness, and a comprehensive reinterpretation of physics, neuroscience, and artificial intelligence. APT v2 proposes that: Potential is primary — existence arises from recursive mathematical possibility rather than matter, energy, or spacetime. Reality is traversal — a perceiver is modeled as a function Y:N→2, generating a sequence of patterns that constitute its experienced universe. Consciousness is the wake — subjective experience emerges from the coherent residue left by traversal through pattern‑space. Physics is a filtering rule — physical laws are constraints on allowable transitions within the Aleph Potential. Divinity is the total pattern — the complete self‑referential structure of all possible configurations. APT v2 introduces formal definitions, mathematical operators, and eight testable predictions spanning consciousness, quantum measurement, dreaming, near‑death states, fine‑tuning, time dilation, and quantum gravity. The document outlines a research program connecting APT to category theory, information theory, neural coherence, and AI architecture design. This version unifies the conceptual clarity of APT v1 with the cosmological and phenomenological depth of Traversing the Infinite, producing a coherent scientific model that reframes foundational questions across physics, philosophy, and cognitive science.
Taking its historical point of departure in Heisenberg’s work, this article offers a view of quantum mechanics as, arguably, the first truly experimental and truly mathematical physical theory, that is, a theory concerned with experimenting with nature and mathematics alike. It is truly experimental because it is not, as in classical physics, merely the independent behavior of the system considered, in other words, what happens in any event, that we track, but what kind of experiments we perform that defines what happens. By the same token, the theory is also truly mathematical because, at least in the interpretation adopted here, its mathematical formalism does not stand in the service of a mathematical description of (quantum) physical processes in space and time in the way the formalism of classical physics does, but is only used to predict the outcomes of relevant experiments. It also follows that quantum theories experiment more freely with mathematics itself, since we invent predictive mathematical schemes, rather than proceed by refining mathematically our phenomenal representations of nature, which process constrains us in classical mechanics.
The debate on the nature of quantum probabilities in relation to Quantum Non Locality has elevated Quantum Mechanics to the level of an "Operational Epistemic Theory". In such context the quantum superposition principle has an extraneous non epistemic nature. This leads us to seek purely operational foundations for Quantum Mechanics, from which to derive the current mathematical axiomatization based on Hilbert spaces. In the present work I present a set of axioms of purely operational nature, based on a general definition of "the experiment", the operational/epistemic archetype of information retrieval from reality. As we will see, this starting point logically entails a series of notions [state, conditional state, local state, pure state, faithful state, instrument, propensity (i.e. "effect"), dynamical and informational equivalence, dynamical and informational compatibility, predictability, discriminability, programmability, locality, a-causality, rank of the state, maximally chaotic state, maximally entangled state, informationally complete propensity, etc. ], along with a set of rules (addition, convex combination, partial orderings, ...), which, far from being of quantum origin as often considered, instead constitute the universal "syntactic manual" of the operational/epistemic approach. The missing ingredient is, of course, the quantum superposition axiom for probability amplitudes: for this I propose some substitute candidates of purely operational/epistemic nature.