Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand

Effects of quantum mechanical identity in particle scattering: experimental observations (and lack thereof)

Niels Kjærgaard

Published Sep 1, 2021• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

ABSTRACT On the occasion of the 150th anniversary of Ernest Rutherford's birth I discuss how indistinguishabilty profoundly affects the collisions of identical particles. In the case of a Coulombic interaction this leads to a dramatic modification of Rutherford's famous scattering formula as predicted by Nevill Mott. An even more extreme example is provided by a low‐energy scattering experiment of identical fermions interacting via a short range potential. Here indistinguishability will make or break the observation of scattered particles. This fascinating phenomenon has been observed using a laser‐based collider for ultracold fermionic potassium atoms.

DOI
10.1080/03036758.2021.1969957

Related papers

How Rutherford missed discovering quantum mechanical identity

Georges M. Temmer

An interesting quirk in the energy dependence of alpha-particle scattering from helium caused Lord Rutherford to miss a major discovery—namely, the consequences of quantum mechanical identity—before their prediction by Mott a short time later.

American Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 1989•2 citations

Entanglement created in scattering processes

E. Karlsson

Abstract Quantum entanglement is a basic ingredient in the formalism of quantum mechanics and was held by Heisenberg as its most emblematic feature. But although all its consequences could be foreseen from the start, it took half a century before experiments were carried out to test its more intriguing predictions. One reason was that sufficiently sensitive tools, like lasers, were not yet available, but there was also a lack of interest and imagination among theoreticians, who did not realize its full potential. When experiments were finally realized and opened a ‘weird and ghostlike quantum world’, they were first met with surprise and doubt. In the first experiments on entanglement it was purposely created (using chain-decays or down-conversion), but entanglement is actually a ubiquitous phenomenon appearing in most physical processes, although surviving over so short time-scales that it is usually not observed. The present work deals with ‘measurement-induced entanglement’ in scattering, and starts with a process where its effects can actually be studied in the sub-femtosecond range in a time-resolved manner, the Compton scattering of neutrons. Based on results from this method, the conditions for observing similar effects in other scattering processes are discussed. First, the mechanisms for entanglement creation by a scattering particle are mentioned, then the conditions for observing measurable consequences of it on scattering cross-sections: a very limited number of scattering centers, large zero-point motions of the scatterers and no strong interaction with environment which leads to decoherence.

Physica Scripta•Dec 4, 2020•2 citations

How to distinguish identical particles

Fedor Herbut

Usually fermions and bosons behave very differently. Regarding distinguishability, they behave in one and the same way. Two-identical-particle quantum theory is discussed on the example of the deuteron and that of distant correlations, as well as on the example of the real interference and quantum erasure experiments in the Hong–Ou–Mandel two-photon interferometer (with and without polarizers and analyzers). Distinguishability and indistinguishability of two identical photons in the experiments are illustrated. It is demonstrated, using a simple formalism valid simultaneously for fermions and for bosons, that there exists an isomorphism giving theoretical foundation to distinguishing two identical particles. But the distinguishing has a limited range of exact applicability. In most cases of interest, only the indistinguishability approach has a first-principle (and universal) validity.

American Journal of Physics•Feb 1, 2001•18 citations

Classical and quantum scattering

C. A. Bertulani, Paweł Danielewicz

Figure 1.1 represents schematically a typical scattering experiment, in fact this is the sketch of E. Rutherford experiment in 1910 [ 1 ]. Projectiles (here, α -particles) from a source go through a collimator and collide with a target (gold foil in Rutherford’s experiment). Some projectiles are scattered by the target and reach the detector (here, a fluorescent screen). Rutherford expected them to go straight through with perhaps a minor deflection. Most did go straight through, but to his surprise some particles bounced directly off the gold sheet! What did this mean? Rutherford hypothesized that the positive alpha particles had hit a concentrated mass of positive particles, which he termed the nucleus. We shall describe the Rutherford scattering theoretically later in this chapter.

CRC Press eBooks•Jan 4, 2019•0 citations

Particle scattering by harmonically trapped Bose and Fermi gases

Ankita Bhattacharya, Samir Das, Shyamal Biswas

Abstract We have analytically explored the quantum phenomenon of particle scattering by harmonically trapped Bose and Fermi gases with the short ranged Fermi–Huang δ p 3 interactions (Fermi 1936 Ric. Sci. 7 13; Huang and Yang 1957 Phys. Rev. 105 767) interactions among the incident particle and the scatterers. We have predicted differential scattering cross-sections and their temperature dependence in this regard. Coherent scattering even by a single boson or fermion in the finite geometry gives rise to new tool of determining energy eigenstate of the scatterer. Our predictions on the differential scattering cross-sections can be tested within the present day experimental setups, specially, for (i) 3D harmonically trapped interacting Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC), (ii) BECs in a double well, and (iii) BECs in an optical lattice.

arXiv:1606.02804•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Feb 15, 2018•9 citations

Prediction of deviations from the Rutherford formula for low-energy Coulomb scattering of wavepackets

Scott E. Hoffmann

Abstract We calculate the nonrelativistic scattering of a wavepacket from a Coulomb potential and find deviations from the Rutherford formula in all cases. These generally occur only at low scattering angles, where they would be obscured by the part of the incident beam that emerges essentially unscattered. For a model experiment, the scattering of helium nuclei from a thin gold foil, we find the deviation region is magnified for low incident energies (in the keV range), so that a large shadow zone of low probability around the forward direction is expected to be measurable. From a theoretical perspective, the use of wavepackets makes partial wave analysis applicable to this infinite-range potential. It allows us to calculate the everywhere finite probability for a wavepacket to wavepacket transition and to relate this to the differential cross section. Time delays and advancements in the detection probabilities can be calculated. We investigate the optical theorem as applied to this special case.

arXiv:1704.04305•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Sep 19, 2017•3 citations
ABSTRACT On the occasion of the 150th anniversary of Ernest Rutherford's birth I discuss how indistinguishabilty profoundly affects the collisions of identical particles. In the case of a Coulombic interaction this leads to a dramatic modification of Rutherford's famous scattering formula as predicted by Nevill Mott. An even more extreme example is provided by a low‐energy scattering experiment of identical fermions interacting via a short range potential. Here indistinguishability will make or break the observation of scattered particles. This fascinating phenomenon has been observed using a laser‐based collider for ultracold fermionic potassium atoms.
Abstract Quantum entanglement is a basic ingredient in the formalism of quantum mechanics and was held by Heisenberg as its most emblematic feature. But although all its consequences could be foreseen from the start, it took half a century before experiments were carried out to test its more intriguing predictions. One reason was that sufficiently sensitive tools, like lasers, were not yet available, but there was also a lack of interest and imagination among theoreticians, who did not realize its full potential. When experiments were finally realized and opened a ‘weird and ghostlike quantum world’, they were first met with surprise and doubt. In the first experiments on entanglement it was purposely created (using chain-decays or down-conversion), but entanglement is actually a ubiquitous phenomenon appearing in most physical processes, although surviving over so short time-scales that it is usually not observed. The present work deals with ‘measurement-induced entanglement’ in scattering, and starts with a process where its effects can actually be studied in the sub-femtosecond range in a time-resolved manner, the Compton scattering of neutrons. Based on results from this method, the conditions for observing similar effects in other scattering processes are discussed. First, the mechanisms for entanglement creation by a scattering particle are mentioned, then the conditions for observing measurable consequences of it on scattering cross-sections: a very limited number of scattering centers, large zero-point motions of the scatterers and no strong interaction with environment which leads to decoherence.
Usually fermions and bosons behave very differently. Regarding distinguishability, they behave in one and the same way. Two-identical-particle quantum theory is discussed on the example of the deuteron and that of distant correlations, as well as on the example of the real interference and quantum erasure experiments in the Hong–Ou–Mandel two-photon interferometer (with and without polarizers and analyzers). Distinguishability and indistinguishability of two identical photons in the experiments are illustrated. It is demonstrated, using a simple formalism valid simultaneously for fermions and for bosons, that there exists an isomorphism giving theoretical foundation to distinguishing two identical particles. But the distinguishing has a limited range of exact applicability. In most cases of interest, only the indistinguishability approach has a first-principle (and universal) validity.
Figure 1.1 represents schematically a typical scattering experiment, in fact this is the sketch of E. Rutherford experiment in 1910 [ 1 ]. Projectiles (here, α -particles) from a source go through a collimator and collide with a target (gold foil in Rutherford’s experiment). Some projectiles are scattered by the target and reach the detector (here, a fluorescent screen). Rutherford expected them to go straight through with perhaps a minor deflection. Most did go straight through, but to his surprise some particles bounced directly off the gold sheet! What did this mean? Rutherford hypothesized that the positive alpha particles had hit a concentrated mass of positive particles, which he termed the nucleus. We shall describe the Rutherford scattering theoretically later in this chapter.
Abstract We have analytically explored the quantum phenomenon of particle scattering by harmonically trapped Bose and Fermi gases with the short ranged Fermi–Huang δ p 3 interactions (Fermi 1936 Ric. Sci. 7 13; Huang and Yang 1957 Phys. Rev. 105 767) interactions among the incident particle and the scatterers. We have predicted differential scattering cross-sections and their temperature dependence in this regard. Coherent scattering even by a single boson or fermion in the finite geometry gives rise to new tool of determining energy eigenstate of the scatterer. Our predictions on the differential scattering cross-sections can be tested within the present day experimental setups, specially, for (i) 3D harmonically trapped interacting Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC), (ii) BECs in a double well, and (iii) BECs in an optical lattice.
Abstract We calculate the nonrelativistic scattering of a wavepacket from a Coulomb potential and find deviations from the Rutherford formula in all cases. These generally occur only at low scattering angles, where they would be obscured by the part of the incident beam that emerges essentially unscattered. For a model experiment, the scattering of helium nuclei from a thin gold foil, we find the deviation region is magnified for low incident energies (in the keV range), so that a large shadow zone of low probability around the forward direction is expected to be measurable. From a theoretical perspective, the use of wavepackets makes partial wave analysis applicable to this infinite-range potential. It allows us to calculate the everywhere finite probability for a wavepacket to wavepacket transition and to relate this to the differential cross section. Time delays and advancements in the detection probabilities can be calculated. We investigate the optical theorem as applied to this special case.