Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics

Differential Spectroscopy of Atomic Clocks for Improved Measurement Instability

Nicholas V. Nardelli, Xiaogang Zhang, Ethan Clements, May E. Kim, Youssef S. Hassan, William F. McGrew, K. Beloy, Andrew D. Ludlow, David R. Leibrandt, David B. Hume, Tara M. Fortier

Published Jan 1, 2021• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Using frequency comb mediated phase-coherent and synchronous clock comparisons we demonstrate close to a factor of 10 improvement in short-term measurement instability, σy(τ) < 2 x 10-16 @ 1s averaging, between 171Yb and 27Al+ optical clocks.
DOI
10.1364/cleo_si.2021.sth4a.4

Related papers

10-18 Optical Atomic Clock Comparisons within the Boulder Atomic Clock Network

Nicholas V. Nardelli, K. Beloy, Martha I. Bodine +35 more

We demonstrate optical frequency comparison of the 171Yb, 27Al+ and 87Sr atomic clocks with measurement uncertainties below 1 part in 1017, and discuss how phase-coherent and synchronous clock comparisons can be used to improve measurement stability.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Exploiting phase coherence for improved resolution in optical atomic frequency ratios

Tara M. Fortier

Optical atomic clocks that operate at frequencies up to 100,000 times higher than their microwave counterparts permit better resolutions and accuracies, while also providing more leeway in environmental control for out of lab applications. Many of the precision applications of these clocks, including relativistic geodesy and tests of fundamental physics rely on the intercomparison of at least two optical clocks. Relative comparisons that include single ion clocks, however, can require close to one month of continuous averaging to achieve measurement instabilities near 1 part in 1018. The long averaging times result from limits imposed on the quantum project noise as a result of signal detection from a single ion, as well as atom probe time limitations due to laser-atom decoherence. In this talk I will describe how the phase coherent properties of an optical frequency comb can be used to enable correlated and synchronous measurement of atomic clocks as a means to improve their relative measurement instability by close to a factor of 10, and nearly 100 times speed up in averaging time over conventional measurement techniques.

Optical and Quantum Sensing and Precision Metrology•Mar 4, 2021•0 citations

Optical coherence between atomic species at the second scale: improved clock comparisons via differential spectroscopy

May E. Kim, William F. McGrew, Nicholas V. Nardelli +9 more

Comparisons of high-accuracy optical atomic clocks \cite{Ludlow2015} are essential for precision tests of fundamental physics \cite{Safronova2018}, relativistic geodesy \cite{McGrew2018, Grotti2018, Delva2019}, and the anticipated redefinition of the SI second \cite{Riehle2018}. The scientific reach of these applications is restricted by the statistical precision of interspecies comparison measurements. The instability of individual clocks is limited by the finite coherence time of the optical local oscillator (OLO), which bounds the maximum atomic interrogation time. In this letter, we experimentally demonstrate differential spectroscopy \cite{Hume2016}, a comparison protocol that enables interrogating beyond the OLO coherence time. By phase-coherently linking a zero-dead-time (ZDT) \cite{Schioppo2017} Yb optical lattice clock with an Al$^+$ single-ion clock via an optical frequency comb and performing synchronised Ramsey spectroscopy, we show an improvement in comparison instability relative to our previous result \cite{network2020frequency} of nearly an order of magnitude. To our knowledge, this result represents the most stable interspecies clock comparison to date.

arXiv:2109.09540•Sep 20, 2021•3 citations

Leveraging correlated laser noise to improve optical frequency comparisons

Ethan Clements, M. Bohman, May E. Kim +14 more

Laser noise usually limits the stability of optical frequency ratio measurements, limiting the speed and precision one can compare two atomic frequency standards. In this talk I will describe two methods, correlation and differential spectroscopy, which utilize correlations in laser noise to increase the achievable interrogation time and thus increase the frequency comparison stability. Correlation spectroscopy is a technique which uses a parity measurement following a synchronized Ramsey interrogation to measure the relative frequency of two similar frequency atomic clocks. With this technique we achieve a measurement instability of (4×10^(-16))⁄√(τ⁄s) for a comparison of two single 27Al+ ion clocks. Differential spectroscopy uses an atomic clock with low projection noise, here a 171Yb lattice clock, to correct the phase noise of a second, higher frequency clock’s local oscillator thereby reducing the measurement instability to the level of the first. This can be further extended using two lattice clocks in a zero dead time configuration to correct the phase noise beyond the interrogation time reachable for a single Yb lattice clock. With these techniques we achieve measurement stabilities of (2.5×10^(-16))⁄√(τ⁄s) and (2×10^(-16))⁄√(τ⁄s) for a comparison between a single 27Al+ ion clock and a 171Yb lattice clock running as single clock and in a zero dead time configuration respectively. In addition to these techniques, I will also discuss recent progress towards characterizing the systematics of the NIST 40Ca+/27Al+ optical atomic clock.

Optical and Quantum Sensing and Precision Metrology II•Mar 9, 2022•0 citations

Enhancing optical clock stability via decoupling laser frequency noise and systematic effects

Qichao Qi, Tao Zhang, Taoyun Jin +10 more

Optical lattice clocks demonstrate advantages in metrology and frontier physics because of their high stability.Here, we present approaches to enhancing the stability by decoupling the noise related to the short-term and long-term stability.For the short-term stability, we optimize the clock laser by decoupling the frequency noise, and optimize each noise contribution individually until it is below the thermal noise limit.For the long-term stability, we introduce a method to decouple the instability caused by systematic effects.Having identified that the collision frequency shift was the main limiting factor in our systems, we thus optimized the atom number fluctuations in optical lattices.Through targeted optimization, we achieve a synchronous comparison of two clocks with an average stability of 3.2 × 10 -16 = τ p and a long-term stability of 2.4 × 10 -18 at 8000 s.This work provides an analytical framework for enhancing optical clock stability.

Chinese Optics Letters•Jan 1, 2025•2 citations

Synchronous Comparison of Two Thulium Optical Clocks

Artem A. Golovizin, D. Mishin, Daniil I. Provorchenko +2 more

The experimental comparison of two thulium optical lattice clocks in a time interval of up to one hour has been carried out. The synchronous comparison of a clock transition in two independent atomic ensembles using a single ultrastable laser has allowed us to eliminate fluctuations of the laser frequency from the measured frequency difference and to reach a relative measurement error of 10–16 after 500-s averaging, which corresponds to a relative instability of $$2 \times {{10}^{{ - 15}}}{\text{/}}\sqrt \tau $$ . The successful demonstration of the long-term operation of two systems using the synchronous comparison of clock transitions opens the possibility of studying systematic shifts in thulium optical clocks with an uncertainty of 10–17.

arXiv:2407.04139•Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•May 1, 2024•4 citations
Optical atomic clocks that operate at frequencies up to 100,000 times higher than their microwave counterparts permit better resolutions and accuracies, while also providing more leeway in environmental control for out of lab applications. Many of the precision applications of these clocks, including relativistic geodesy and tests of fundamental physics rely on the intercomparison of at least two optical clocks. Relative comparisons that include single ion clocks, however, can require close to one month of continuous averaging to achieve measurement instabilities near 1 part in 1018. The long averaging times result from limits imposed on the quantum project noise as a result of signal detection from a single ion, as well as atom probe time limitations due to laser-atom decoherence. In this talk I will describe how the phase coherent properties of an optical frequency comb can be used to enable correlated and synchronous measurement of atomic clocks as a means to improve their relative measurement instability by close to a factor of 10, and nearly 100 times speed up in averaging time over conventional measurement techniques.
Comparisons of high-accuracy optical atomic clocks \cite{Ludlow2015} are essential for precision tests of fundamental physics \cite{Safronova2018}, relativistic geodesy \cite{McGrew2018, Grotti2018, Delva2019}, and the anticipated redefinition of the SI second \cite{Riehle2018}. The scientific reach of these applications is restricted by the statistical precision of interspecies comparison measurements. The instability of individual clocks is limited by the finite coherence time of the optical local oscillator (OLO), which bounds the maximum atomic interrogation time. In this letter, we experimentally demonstrate differential spectroscopy \cite{Hume2016}, a comparison protocol that enables interrogating beyond the OLO coherence time. By phase-coherently linking a zero-dead-time (ZDT) \cite{Schioppo2017} Yb optical lattice clock with an Al+^++ single-ion clock via an optical frequency comb and performing synchronised Ramsey spectroscopy, we show an improvement in comparison instability relative to our previous result \cite{network2020frequency} of nearly an order of magnitude. To our knowledge, this result represents the most stable interspecies clock comparison to date.
Laser noise usually limits the stability of optical frequency ratio measurements, limiting the speed and precision one can compare two atomic frequency standards. In this talk I will describe two methods, correlation and differential spectroscopy, which utilize correlations in laser noise to increase the achievable interrogation time and thus increase the frequency comparison stability. Correlation spectroscopy is a technique which uses a parity measurement following a synchronized Ramsey interrogation to measure the relative frequency of two similar frequency atomic clocks. With this technique we achieve a measurement instability of (4×10^(-16))⁄√(τ⁄s) for a comparison of two single 27Al+ ion clocks. Differential spectroscopy uses an atomic clock with low projection noise, here a 171Yb lattice clock, to correct the phase noise of a second, higher frequency clock’s local oscillator thereby reducing the measurement instability to the level of the first. This can be further extended using two lattice clocks in a zero dead time configuration to correct the phase noise beyond the interrogation time reachable for a single Yb lattice clock. With these techniques we achieve measurement stabilities of (2.5×10^(-16))⁄√(τ⁄s) and (2×10^(-16))⁄√(τ⁄s) for a comparison between a single 27Al+ ion clock and a 171Yb lattice clock running as single clock and in a zero dead time configuration respectively. In addition to these techniques, I will also discuss recent progress towards characterizing the systematics of the NIST 40Ca+/27Al+ optical atomic clock.
Optical lattice clocks demonstrate advantages in metrology and frontier physics because of their high stability.Here, we present approaches to enhancing the stability by decoupling the noise related to the short-term and long-term stability.For the short-term stability, we optimize the clock laser by decoupling the frequency noise, and optimize each noise contribution individually until it is below the thermal noise limit.For the long-term stability, we introduce a method to decouple the instability caused by systematic effects.Having identified that the collision frequency shift was the main limiting factor in our systems, we thus optimized the atom number fluctuations in optical lattices.Through targeted optimization, we achieve a synchronous comparison of two clocks with an average stability of 3.2 × 10 -16 = τ p and a long-term stability of 2.4 × 10 -18 at 8000 s.This work provides an analytical framework for enhancing optical clock stability.
The experimental comparison of two thulium optical lattice clocks in a time interval of up to one hour has been carried out. The synchronous comparison of a clock transition in two independent atomic ensembles using a single ultrastable laser has allowed us to eliminate fluctuations of the laser frequency from the measured frequency difference and to reach a relative measurement error of 10–16 after 500-s averaging, which corresponds to a relative instability of 2×10−15/τ2 \times {{10}^{{ - 15}}}{\text{/}}\sqrt \tau 2×10−15/τ​ . The successful demonstration of the long-term operation of two systems using the synchronous comparison of clock transitions opens the possibility of studying systematic shifts in thulium optical clocks with an uncertainty of 10–17.