Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

How do electrons move in atoms? From the Bohr model to quantum mechanics

Shan Gao

Published Jun 19, 2021• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

It is argued that two ontological assumptions in Bohr's original atomic model are actually supported by the latter quantum mechanics. They are: (1) electrons are particles; and (2) they undergo discontinuous jumps.

Related papers

A quantum model of atoms (the energy levels of atoms)

FranÇois Rafie

In 1913, Niels Bohr developed an accurate model for the hydrogen atom. The mathematics involved and the simplicity of this model is easily understood. The intention of the paper is not to replace Bohr's model, but to find a similar model for all atoms. The model discussed, which was developed on the same basis as Bohr's model for the hydrogen atom, calculates the radii and the energies of the orbits. The wavelength of an emitted photon when an electron makes a ‘jump’ from a higher state to a lower state can also be calculated from the model. Finally, the paper demonstrates that the model obeys the de Broglie's hypothesis that the moving electron exhibits both wave and particle properties.

International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology•Mar 1, 2001•1 citation

A Quantum Mechanical Justification of Bohr Hypothesis

Sergio A. Hojman

Bohr atomic model is based on the assumption that electrons on allowed quantized orbits do not radiate. A quantum mechanical justification of this hypothesis, based on the Madelung Bohm treatment of the Schr\odinger equation is presented.

arXiv:2105.03267•May 6, 2021•0 citations

An explanation of the quantum mechanics of particles

O. Chavoya-Aceves

The ontological status of the wave function as a purely mathemat- ical artifact is clari ed. Grounds are found to reject the de Broglie- Bohm formulation of the quantum mechanics of particles. The pre-sumption by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen that quantum mechanics is not a complete theory is reinforced.

Physics Essays•Dec 11, 2015•1 citation

New Ways to Calculate

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract In June 1925 Heisenberg made the breakthrough that would lead to matrix mechanics. The theory was abstract, offered no means for visualizing the mechanics of the atom, and its application required a lot of heavy lifting. Erwin Schrödinger subsequently made the breakthrough that would lead to wave mechanics, building on Louis de Broglie’s association of a wave with an electron. In Schrödinger’s wave equation the quantum numbers of the hydrogen atom arise naturally. He argued that his ‘wavefunction’ offered a realistic description of the electron in an atom, and sought to eliminate Bohr’s discontinuous quantum jumps. But in the spring of 1926, Max Born offered an enduring alternative. The modulus-square of the wavefunction is a measure of probability in an unvisualizable microphysics. In an intense debate with Bohr, Schrödinger demanded a theory based on logical concepts free from contradictions. Bohr was left to ponder what this might mean.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations

A PARTICLE ONTOLOGICAL INTERPRETATION OF THE WAVE FUNCTION

SHAN GAO

The ontological meaning of the wave function is an important problem in the metaphysics of quantum mechanics. The conventional view is wave function realism, according to which the wave function represents a real physical field in a fundamental high-dimensional space. In this chapter, I present a new analysis of the meaning of the wave function, and the analysis suggests a particle ontological interpretation of the wave function. According to this interpretation, the wave function of a quantum system describes the state of random discontinuous motion of particles in three-dimensional space, and in particular, the modulus squared of the wave function gives the probability density that the particles appear in every possible group of positions in space. Moreover, I argue that the difference between particle ontology and field ontology may result in different predictions under certain reasonable assumption, and it is the former, not the latter, that is consistent with the predictions of quantum mechanics. Finally, I discuss similar pictures of motion of particles suggested by others. It is argued that Bell’s Everett (?) theory also implies the picture of random discontinuous motion of particles.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 1, 2023•0 citations

Bohr’s atomic model and the probabilistic reality

Emory Taylor, Rajan N. Iyer

An analysis of applying the property of speed instantaneity to electronic transitions (i.e., transitions of the atomic electron that are not instantaneous), instead of quantum jumps (i.e., instantaneous transitions), during a complete oscillation for the process of Bohr’s model of the atom absorbing and emitting electromagnetic radiation (i.e., photon) reveals a discontinuity that is conserved as an emitted electromagnetic radiation (i.e., photon) discontinuity. The frequency of the oscillations of the atomic electron (i.e., electric charge) and induced magnetic field for the transitions of the atomic electron (i.e., electric charge) during the complete oscillation for the absorption and emission process (of Bohr’s atomic model) is conserved as the frequency of the oscillating electric and magnetic fields of the emitted electromagnetic radiation (i.e., photon). The conserved frequency and discontinuity (based on speed instantaneity and electronic transitions that are not instantaneous) of the atomic absorption and emission process (of Bohr’s atomic model) lead to predicting the need for Planck’s constant (i.e., quantum of action) without the use of probability. Planck claimed the interpretation of reality must change if his method of deriving the radiation law stood on a physical concept. Einstein, whom Planck credited as the first to make an advancement in the quantum field, unknowingly introduced a quantized two-dimensional discontinuum geometry that is one of the foundations on which a table of five realities used in physics was developed for making predictions. Using the table of realities, locality is redefined, and entanglement is demystified.

Physics Essays•Dec 15, 2023•5 citations
In 1913, Niels Bohr developed an accurate model for the hydrogen atom. The mathematics involved and the simplicity of this model is easily understood. The intention of the paper is not to replace Bohr's model, but to find a similar model for all atoms. The model discussed, which was developed on the same basis as Bohr's model for the hydrogen atom, calculates the radii and the energies of the orbits. The wavelength of an emitted photon when an electron makes a ‘jump’ from a higher state to a lower state can also be calculated from the model. Finally, the paper demonstrates that the model obeys the de Broglie's hypothesis that the moving electron exhibits both wave and particle properties.
Abstract In June 1925 Heisenberg made the breakthrough that would lead to matrix mechanics. The theory was abstract, offered no means for visualizing the mechanics of the atom, and its application required a lot of heavy lifting. Erwin Schrödinger subsequently made the breakthrough that would lead to wave mechanics, building on Louis de Broglie’s association of a wave with an electron. In Schrödinger’s wave equation the quantum numbers of the hydrogen atom arise naturally. He argued that his ‘wavefunction’ offered a realistic description of the electron in an atom, and sought to eliminate Bohr’s discontinuous quantum jumps. But in the spring of 1926, Max Born offered an enduring alternative. The modulus-square of the wavefunction is a measure of probability in an unvisualizable microphysics. In an intense debate with Bohr, Schrödinger demanded a theory based on logical concepts free from contradictions. Bohr was left to ponder what this might mean.
The ontological meaning of the wave function is an important problem in the metaphysics of quantum mechanics. The conventional view is wave function realism, according to which the wave function represents a real physical field in a fundamental high-dimensional space. In this chapter, I present a new analysis of the meaning of the wave function, and the analysis suggests a particle ontological interpretation of the wave function. According to this interpretation, the wave function of a quantum system describes the state of random discontinuous motion of particles in three-dimensional space, and in particular, the modulus squared of the wave function gives the probability density that the particles appear in every possible group of positions in space. Moreover, I argue that the difference between particle ontology and field ontology may result in different predictions under certain reasonable assumption, and it is the former, not the latter, that is consistent with the predictions of quantum mechanics. Finally, I discuss similar pictures of motion of particles suggested by others. It is argued that Bell’s Everett (?) theory also implies the picture of random discontinuous motion of particles.
An analysis of applying the property of speed instantaneity to electronic transitions (i.e., transitions of the atomic electron that are not instantaneous), instead of quantum jumps (i.e., instantaneous transitions), during a complete oscillation for the process of Bohr’s model of the atom absorbing and emitting electromagnetic radiation (i.e., photon) reveals a discontinuity that is conserved as an emitted electromagnetic radiation (i.e., photon) discontinuity. The frequency of the oscillations of the atomic electron (i.e., electric charge) and induced magnetic field for the transitions of the atomic electron (i.e., electric charge) during the complete oscillation for the absorption and emission process (of Bohr’s atomic model) is conserved as the frequency of the oscillating electric and magnetic fields of the emitted electromagnetic radiation (i.e., photon). The conserved frequency and discontinuity (based on speed instantaneity and electronic transitions that are not instantaneous) of the atomic absorption and emission process (of Bohr’s atomic model) lead to predicting the need for Planck’s constant (i.e., quantum of action) without the use of probability. Planck claimed the interpretation of reality must change if his method of deriving the radiation law stood on a physical concept. Einstein, whom Planck credited as the first to make an advancement in the quantum field, unknowingly introduced a quantized two-dimensional discontinuum geometry that is one of the foundations on which a table of five realities used in physics was developed for making predictions. Using the table of realities, locality is redefined, and entanglement is demystified.