Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics

Local spin and open quantum systems: clarifying misconceptions, unifying approaches

Ángel Martín Pendás, Evelio Francisco

Published Jan 1, 2021• 15 citations

Abstract

The theory of open quantum systems (OQSs) is applied to partition the squared spin operator into fragment (local spin) and interfragment (spin-coupling) contributions in a molecular system. An atomic or fragment subsystem is described by a quantum mechanical mixed density operator composed of sectors, characterized by different integer number of electrons that appear with specific probabilities. The OQS fragment spin operators coincide with those defined by Clark and Davidson in their paper on local spins (J. Chem. Phys., 2001, 115, 7382) and are fully consistent with the theory of local operators by Stollhoff and Fulde (J. Chem. Phys., 1980, 73, 4548). OQSs provide a unique way to rationalize the non-zero values of local spins found in closed-shell molecules, a fact that has led to a large number of modified definitions being proposed, which we show suffer from inconsistencies. The OQS viewpoint makes it easy to build models for localized and itinerant spins. These models are used to classify possible local spin arrangements. The role of electron correlation is also studied through the analysis of the Hubbard Hamiltonian in small chains. Local spins result from a game played differently by localized and delocalized electrons. A number of examples exemplifying the ability of the OQS local spin perspective to uncover simple chemical patterns are examined.

DOI: 10.1039/d0cp05946c

Related papers

Quantum Statistical Mechanics of Electronically Open Molecules: Reduced Density Operators

Jacob Pedersen, Bendik Støa Sannes, Ida‐Marie Høyvik

We present a reduced density operator for electronically open molecules by explicitly averaging over the environmental degrees of freedom of the composite Hamiltonian. Specifically, we include the particle-number nonconserving (particle-breaking) interactions responsible for the sharing of electrons between the molecule and the environment, which are neglected in standard formulations of quantum statistical mechanics. We propose an unambiguous definition of the partial trace operation in the composite fermionic Fock space based on composite states in a second quantization framework built from a common orthonormal set of orbitals. Thereby, we resolve the fermionic partial trace ambiguity. The common orbital basis is constructed by spatial localization of the full orbital space, in which the full composite Hamiltonian naturally partitions into a molecule Hamiltonian, an environment Hamiltonian, and an interaction Hamiltonian. The new reduced density operator is based on the approximation of commutativity between the subsystem Hamiltonians (i.e., molecule and environment Hamiltonians) and the interaction Hamiltonian, but our methodology provides a hierarchical approach for improving this approximation. The reduced density operator can be viewed as a generalization of the grand canonical density operator. We are prompted to define the generalized chemical potential, which aligns with the standard interpretation of the chemical potential, apart from the possibility of fractional rather than strictly integer electron transfer in our framework. In contrast to standard approaches, our framework enables an explicit consideration of the electron occupancy in the environment at any level of theory, irrespective of the model used to describe the molecule. Specifically, our reduced density operator is fully compatible with all possible level-of-theory treatments of the environment. The approximations that render our reduced density operator identical to the grand canonical density operator are (i) restriction of excitations to occur within the same orbitals and (ii) assumption of equal interaction with the environment for all molecule spin orbitals (i.e., the wide-band approximation).

arXiv:2505.10893Journal of Chemical Theory and ComputationOct 1, 20250 citations

Quantum Chemical Topology as a Theory of Open Quantum Systems

Ángel Martín Pendás, Evelio Francisco

Although real space regions have been widely used in theoretical chemistry, not much effort has been devoted to treat them as open quantum systems. We embrace this task here, finding closed expressions for the density operator of a quantum subsystem in real space by tracing out the degrees of freedom in its complementary region. Our results are then linked to previous knowledge. For single-determinant descriptions it is shown that the entanglement orbitals coincide with Ponec's domain natural orbitals. In general, the subsystem density operator is written as a direct sum of a fixed number of electron sectors, with weights that turn out to be equal to those found within the theory of electron distribution functions. As a computational application we show how to obtain the global first order density matrix of a subsystem and its eigensolution in a couple of toy systems. In the multideterminant wave function case, the domain natural orbitals defined through this open system approach do not coincide with those of Ponec and, contrary to the latter, have always strictly positive occupations.

Journal of Chemical Theory and ComputationDec 21, 201823 citations

A review of progress in the physics of open quantum systems: theory and experiment

I. Rotter, F. Bird

This report on progress explores recent advances in our theoretical and experimental understanding of the physics of open quantum systems (OQSs). The study of such systems represents a core problem in modern physics that has evolved to assume an unprecedented interdisciplinary character. OQSs consist of some localized, microscopic, region that is coupled to an external environment by means of an appropriate interaction. Examples of such systems may be found in numerous areas of physics, including atomic and nuclear physics, photonics, biophysics, and mesoscopic physics. It is the latter area that provides the main focus of this review, an emphasis that is driven by the capacity that exists to subject mesoscopic devices to unprecedented control. We thus provide a detailed discussion of the behavior of mesoscopic devices (and other OQSs) in terms of the projection-operator formalism, according to which the system under study is considered to be comprised of a localized region (Q), embedded into a well-defined environment (P) of scattering wavefunctions (with Q + P = 1). The Q subspace must be treated using the concepts of non-Hermitian physics, and of particular interest here is: the capacity of the environment to mediate a coupling between the different states of Q; the role played by the presence of exceptional points (EPs) in the spectra of OQSs; the influence of EPs on the rigidity of the wavefunction phases, and; the ability of EPs to initiate a dynamical phase transition (DPT). EPs are singular points in the continuum, at which two resonance states coalesce, that is where they exhibit a non-avoided crossing. DPTs occur when the quantum dynamics of the open system causes transitions between non-analytically connected states, as a function of some external control parameter. Much like conventional phase transitions, the behavior of the system on one side of the DPT does not serve as a reliable indicator of that on the other. In addition to discussing experiments on mesoscopic quantum point contacts that provide evidence of the environmentally-mediated coupling of quantum states, we also review manifestations of DPTs in mesoscopic devices and other systems. These experiments include observations of resonance-trapping behavior in microwave cavities and open quantum dots, phase lapses in tunneling through single-electron transistors, and spin swapping in atomic ensembles. Other possible manifestations of this phenomenon are presented, including various superradiant phenomena in low-dimensional semiconductors. From these discussions a generic picture of OQSs emerges in which the environmentally-mediated coupling between different quantum states plays a critical role in governing the system behavior. The ability to control or manipulate this interaction may even lead to new applications in photonics and electronics.

arXiv:1507.08478Reports on Progress in PhysicsOct 28, 2015257 citations

Interacting Subsystems and Their Molecular Ensembles

Roman F. Nalewajski

The molecular density-partition problem is reexamined and the information-theoretic (IT) justification of the stockholder division rule is summarized. The ensemble representations of the promolecular and molecular mixed states of constituent atoms are identified and the electron probabilities in the isoelectronic stockholder atoms-in-molecules (AIM) are used to define the molecular-orbital ensembles for the bonded Hirshfeld atoms. In the pure quantum state of the whole molecular system its interacting (entangled) fragments are described by the subsystem density operators, with the subsystem physical properties being generated by the partial traces involving the fragment density matrices.

Academic Journal of ChemistryApr 25, 20207 citations

Entanglement coupled cluster theory: Exact spin-adaptation

Sarai Dery Folkestad, Bendik Støa Sannes, Henrik Koch A

We present a novel framework for spin-adapted coupled cluster theory. The approach exploits the entanglement of an open-shell molecule with electrons in a non-interacting bath. Together, the molecule and the bath form a closed-shell system, and electron correlation can be included using the standard spin-adapted closed-shell coupled cluster formalism. A projection operator, which enforces conditions on the electrons in the bath, is used to obtain the desired state of the molecule. This entanglement coupled cluster theory is outlined, and proof-of-concept calculations for doublet states are reported. The approach is further extendable to open-shell systems with other values of the total spin.

arXiv:2301.12228The Journal of Chemical PhysicsJun 12, 20236 citations

Locally coupled open subsystems: A formalism for affordable electronic structure calculations featuring fractional charges and size consistency

Martín A. Mosquera, Mark A. Ratner, George Chappell Schatz

This manuscript introduces a methodology (within the Born-Oppenheimer picture) to compute electronic ground-state properties of molecules and solids/surfaces with fractionally occupied components. Given a user-defined division of the molecule into subsystems, our theory uses an auxiliary global Hamiltonian that is defined as the sum of subsystem Hamiltonians, plus the spatial integral of a second-quantized local operator that allows the electrons to be transferred between subsystems. This electron transfer operator depends on a local potential that can be determined using density functional approximations and/or other techniques such as machine learning. The present framework employs superpositions of tensor-product wave functions, which can satisfy size consistency and avoid spurious fractional charges at large bond distances. The electronic population of each subsystem is in general a positive real number and is obtained from wave-function amplitudes, which are calculated by means of ground-state matrix diagonalization (or matrix propagation in the time-dependent case). Our method can provide pathways to explore charge-transfer effects in environments where dividing the molecule into subsystems is convenient and to develop computationally affordable electronic structure algorithms.

The Journal of Chemical PhysicsJul 19, 20186 citations