Security of Hybrid Key Encapsulation.

Nina Bindel, Jacqueline Brendel, Marc Fischlin +2 more

Jinrong Chen, Wei Peng, Yi Wang +1 more

TLS 1.3 is a crucial protocol for securing modern internet communications. To facilitate a smooth transition to post-quantum security, hybrid key exchange, which combines classical key exchange algorithms with post-quantum key encapsulation mechanisms (KEMs), is proposed to enhance the security of the current TLS 1.3 handshake. However, existing drafts and implementations of hybrid key exchange for TLS 1.3 primarily rely on CCA-secure KEMs (i.e., secure against chosen-ciphertext attacks) based on the Fujisaki-Okamoto (FO) transform. The re-encryption step in their decapsulation algorithms not only introduces additional performance overhead but also raises the risk of side-channel attacks. Although Huguenin-Dumittan and Vaudenay (Eurocrypt 2022) and Zhou et al. (Asiacrypt 2024) demonstrated that the weaker CPA-secure KEMs (i.e., secure against chosen-plaintext attacks) suffice for constructing a secure TLS 1.3 handshake, their analyses were limited to single-KEM settings and did not consider the hybrid key exchange scenario. This work challenges the necessity of CCA security by proving that CPA-secure KEMs are sufficient for the TLS 1.3 handshake even in the hybrid key exchange setting. We provide the first formal security proofs for this claim, covering both the classical random oracle model (ROM) and the quantum random oracle model (QROM), thereby ensuring security against quantum adversaries. To validate the practical benefits, we conduct an extensive performance evaluation based on the latest OpenSSL implementation. Our results show that using CPA-secure KEMs yields up to 44.8% performance improvement at the key exchange layer and up to approximately 9% acceleration for the full TLS 1.3 handshake. Beyond performance gains, this approach reduces the codebase's attack surface by eliminating the re-encryption step, thereby mitigating a class of side-channel vulnerabilities. Our work positions CPA-secure KEMs as a secure, efficient, and practical alternative for standardizing and deploying post-quantum TLS 1.3 even with hybrid key exchange.

Maki Yoshida, Toru Fujiwara

Setareh Sharifian, Reihaneh Safavi–Naini

A hybrid encryption scheme consists of a public-key part called the key encapsulation mechanism (KEM), that is used to generate and establish a shared secret key between two parties, and a (symmetric) secret-key part called the data encapsulation mechanism (DEM) that encrypts the data using the shared key. Hybrid encryption schemes are widely used for securing Internet communication. In this paper, we initiate the study of hybrid encryption in preprocessing model which assumes access to initial correlated variables by all parties (including the eavesdropper), and define information-theoretic KEM (iKEM) that together with a (computationally) secure DEM, results in a hybrid encryption scheme in preprocessing model. We define security of each building block, and prove a composition theorem that guarantees (computational) q-chosen-plaintext attack (CPA) security of the hybrid encryption system if the iKEM and the DEM satisfy q-chosen-encapsulation attack security and one-time security, respectively. We show that an iKEM can be realized by an information-theoretic one-way secret key agreement (OW-SKA) protocol where a single message is transmitted from Alice to Bob, with a new security definition that allows$q$queries to Alice. Using a OW-SKA that satisfies this new definition of security, effectively allows the established secret key to be used with a onetime symmetric key encryption system that can be implemented, for example, by XORing the output of a (computationally) secure pseudorandom generator with the message, to provide secure encryption of$q$arbitrary messages (polynomially bounded length). We discuss our results and directions for future work.

Sandro Coretti, Ueli M. Maurer, Björn Tackmann

Setareh Sharifian, Reihaneh Safavi–Naini

A hybrid encryption scheme is a public-key encryption system that consists of a public-key part called the key encapsulation mechanism (KEM), and a (symmetric) secret-key part called data encapsulation mechanism (DEM): the public-key part is used to generate a shared secret key between two parties, and the symmetric key part is used to encrypt the message using the generated key. Hybrid encryption schemes are widely used for secure communication over the Internet. In this paper, we initiate the study of hybrid encryption in preprocessing model which assumes access to initial correlated variables by all parties (including the eavesdropper). We define information-theoretic KEM (iKEM) that, together with a (computationally) secure DEM, results in a hybrid encryption scheme in preprocessing model. We define the security of each building block, and prove a composition theorem that guarantees (computational) qe-chosen plaintext (CPA) security of the hybrid encryption system if the iKEM and the DEM satisfy qe-chosen encapculation attack and one-time security, respectively. We show that iKEM can be realized by a one-way SKA (OW-SKA) protocol with a revised security definition. Using an OW-SKA that satisfies this revised definition of security effectively allows the secret key that is generated by the OW-SKA to be used with a one-time symmetric key encryption system such as XORing a pseudorandom string with the message, and provide qe-CPA security for the hybrid encryption system.We discuss our results and directions for future work.