Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

On some meaningful inner product for real Klein-Gordon fields with positive semi-definite norm

Frieder Kleefeld

Published Jan 1, 2006• 11 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A simple derivation of a meaningful, manifestly covariant inner product for real Klein-Gordon (KG) fields with positive semi-definite norm is provided which turns out - assuming a symmetric bilinear form - to be the real-KG-field limit of the inner product for complex KG fields reviewed by A. Mostafazadeh and F. Zamani in December, 2003, and February, 2006 (quant-ph/0312078, quant-ph/0602151, quant-ph/0602161). It is explicitly shown that the positive semi-definite norm associated with the derived inner product for real KG fields measures the number of active positive and negative energy Fourier-modes of the real KG field on the relativistic mass-shell. The very existence of an inner product with positive semi-definite norm for the considered real, i.e. neutral, KG fields shows that the metric operator entering the inner product does not contain the charge-conjugation operator. This observation sheds some additional light on the meaning of the by C.M. Bender, D.C. Brody and H.F. Jones identified C operator in the CPT inner product of PT-symmetric Quantum Mechanics.

Related papers

On some meaningful inner product for real Klein—Gordon fields with positive semi-definite norm

Frieder Kleefeld

arXiv:quant-ph/0606070•Czechoslovak Journal of Physics•Sep 1, 2006•7 citations

Quantum Mechanics of Klein-Gordon Fields I: Hilbert Space, Localized States, and Chiral Symmetry

Alí Mostafazadeh, Farhad Zamani

We derive an explicit manifestly covariant expression for the most general positivedefinite and Lorentz-invariant inner product on the space of solutions of the Klein-Gordon equation. This expression involves a one-parameter family of conserved current densities J µ a, with a ∈ (−1,1), that are analogous to the chiral current density for spin half fields. The conservation of J µ a is related to a global gauge symmetry of the Klein-Gordon fields whose gauge group is U(1) for rational a and the multiplicative group of positive real numbers for irrational a. We show that the associated gauge symmetry is responsible for the conservation of the total probability of the localization of the field in space. This provides a simple resolution of the paradoxical situation resulting from the fact that the probability current density for free scalar fields is neither covariant nor conserved. Furthermore, we discuss the implications of our approach for free real scalar fields offering a direct proof of the uniqueness of the relativistically invariant positive-definite inner product on the space of real Klein-Gordon fields. We also explore an extension of our results to scalar fields minimally coupled to an electromagnetic field.

•Jan 1, 2006•31 citations

A PHYSICAL REALIZATION OF THE GENERALIZED PT-, C-, AND CPT-SYMMETRIES AND THE POSITION OPERATOR FOR KLEIN–GORDON FIELDS

ALI MOSTAFAZADEH

Generalized parity [Formula: see text], time-reversal [Formula: see text], and charge-conjugation [Formula: see text] operators were initially defined in the study of the pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonians. We construct a concrete realization of these operators for Klein–Gordon fields and show that in this realization [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] operators respectively correspond to the ordinary time-reversal and charge-grading operations. Furthermore, we present a complete description of the quantum mechanics of Klein–Gordon fields that is based on the construction of a Hilbert space with a relativistically invariant, positive-definite, and conserved inner product. In particular we offer a natural construction of a position operator and the corresponding localized and coherent states. The restriction of this position operator to the positive-frequency fields coincides with the Newton–Wigner operator. Our approach does not rely on the conventional restriction to positive-frequency fields. Yet it provides a consistent quantum mechanical description of Klein–Gordon fields with a genuine probabilistic interpretation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0307059•International Journal of Modern Physics A•May 10, 2006•39 citations

Geometry of PT-symmetric quantum mechanics

Carl M. Bender, Dorje C. Brody, Lane P. Hughston +1 more

Recently, much research has been carried out on Hamiltonians that are not Hermitian but are symmetric under space-time reflection, that is, Hamiltonians that exhibit PT symmetry. Investigations of the Sturm-Liouville eigenvalue problem associated with such Hamiltonians have shown that in many cases the entire energy spectrum is real and positive and that the eigenfunctions form an orthogonal and complete basis. Furthermore, the quantum theories determined by such Hamiltonians have been shown to be consistent in the sense that the probabilities are positive and the dynamical trajectories are unitary. However, the geometrical structures that underlie quantum theories formulated in terms of such Hamiltonians have hitherto not been fully understood. This paper studies in detail the geometric properties of a Hilbert space endowed with a parity structure and analyses the characteristics of a PT-symmetric Hamiltonian and its eigenstates. A canonical relationship between a PT-symmetric operator and a Hermitian operator is established. It is shown that the quadratic form corresponding to the parity operator, in particular, gives rise to a natural partition of the Hilbert space into two halves corresponding to states having positive and negative PT norm. The indefiniteness of the norm can be circumvented by introducing a symmetry operator C that defines a positive definite inner product by means of a CPT conjugation operation.

arXiv:0704.2959•Apr 23, 2007•2 citations

Quantum Physics, Relativity, and Complex Spacetime: Towards a New Synthesis

Gerald Kaiser

The positivity of the energy in relativistic quantum mechanics implies that wave functions can be continued analytically to the forward tube T in complex spacetime. For Klein-Gordon particles, we interpret T as an extended (8D) classical phase space containing all 6D classical phase spaces as symplectic submanifolds. The evaluation maps $e_z: f\to f(z)$ of wave functions on T are relativistic coherent states reducing to the Gaussian coherent states in the nonrelativistic limit. It is known that no covariant probability interpretation exists for Klein-Gordon particles in real spacetime because the time component of the conserved "probability current" can attain negative values even for positive-energy solutions. We show that this problem is solved very naturally in complex spacetime, where $|f(x-iy)|^2$ is interpreted as a probability density on all 6D phase spaces in T which, when integrated over the "momentum" variables y, gives a conserved spacetime probability current whose time component is a positive regularization of the usual one. Similar results are obtained for Dirac particles, where the evaluation maps $e_z$ are spinor-valued relativistic coherent states. For free quantized Klein-Gordon and Dirac fields, the above formalism extends to n-particle/antiparticle coherent states whose scalar products are Wightman functions. The 2-point function plays the role of a reproducing kernel for the one-particle and antiparticle subspaces.

arXiv:0910.0352•Oct 2, 2009•7 citations

Generalized PT-, C-, and CPT-Symmetries, Position Operators, and Localized States of Klein-Gordon Fields

Mostafazadeh, A

We construct a concrete realization of the generalized parity (P), time-reversal (T), and charge-conjugation (C) operators, that were initially defined in the study of the PT-symmetric and pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonians, for Klein-Gordon fields. We show that PT and C operators, that signify certain symmetries of the system, correspond to the ordinary time-reversal and charge-conjugation transformations, respectively. Furthermore, we construct a positive-definite and relativistically invariant inner product on the space of Klein-Gordon fields and show that the generator h of time-translations viewed as acting in the Hilbert space ${cal H}$ defined by this inner product is Hermitian. The quantum system having ${cal H}$ as its Hilbert space and h as its Hamiltonian is unitarily equivalent to the one defined by a Hermitian Hamiltonian acting in the Hilbert space $L^2(R^3)oplus L^2(R^3)$. We give the explicit form of the corresponding unitary transformation and use it to construct position operators, localized and coherent states, and a set of wave functions for the Klein-Gordon fields. Our approach provides a consistent quantum mechanical description of the Klein-Gordon fields that admits a genuine probabilistic interpretation.

•Jul 8, 2003•2 citations
A simple derivation of a meaningful, manifestly covariant inner product for real Klein-Gordon (KG) fields with positive semi-definite norm is provided which turns out - assuming a symmetric bilinear form - to be the real-KG-field limit of the inner product for complex KG fields reviewed by A. Mostafazadeh and F. Zamani in December, 2003, and February, 2006 (quant-ph/0312078, quant-ph/0602151, quant-ph/0602161). It is explicitly shown that the positive semi-definite norm associated with the derived inner product for real KG fields measures the number of active positive and negative energy Fourier-modes of the real KG field on the relativistic mass-shell. The very existence of an inner product with positive semi-definite norm for the considered real, i.e. neutral, KG fields shows that the metric operator entering the inner product does not contain the charge-conjugation operator. This observation sheds some additional light on the meaning of the by C.M. Bender, D.C. Brody and H.F. Jones identified C operator in the CPT inner product of PT-symmetric Quantum Mechanics.
We derive an explicit manifestly covariant expression for the most general positivedefinite and Lorentz-invariant inner product on the space of solutions of the Klein-Gordon equation. This expression involves a one-parameter family of conserved current densities J µ a, with a ∈ (−1,1), that are analogous to the chiral current density for spin half fields. The conservation of J µ a is related to a global gauge symmetry of the Klein-Gordon fields whose gauge group is U(1) for rational a and the multiplicative group of positive real numbers for irrational a. We show that the associated gauge symmetry is responsible for the conservation of the total probability of the localization of the field in space. This provides a simple resolution of the paradoxical situation resulting from the fact that the probability current density for free scalar fields is neither covariant nor conserved. Furthermore, we discuss the implications of our approach for free real scalar fields offering a direct proof of the uniqueness of the relativistically invariant positive-definite inner product on the space of real Klein-Gordon fields. We also explore an extension of our results to scalar fields minimally coupled to an electromagnetic field.
Generalized parity [Formula: see text], time-reversal [Formula: see text], and charge-conjugation [Formula: see text] operators were initially defined in the study of the pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonians. We construct a concrete realization of these operators for Klein–Gordon fields and show that in this realization [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] operators respectively correspond to the ordinary time-reversal and charge-grading operations. Furthermore, we present a complete description of the quantum mechanics of Klein–Gordon fields that is based on the construction of a Hilbert space with a relativistically invariant, positive-definite, and conserved inner product. In particular we offer a natural construction of a position operator and the corresponding localized and coherent states. The restriction of this position operator to the positive-frequency fields coincides with the Newton–Wigner operator. Our approach does not rely on the conventional restriction to positive-frequency fields. Yet it provides a consistent quantum mechanical description of Klein–Gordon fields with a genuine probabilistic interpretation.
Recently, much research has been carried out on Hamiltonians that are not Hermitian but are symmetric under space-time reflection, that is, Hamiltonians that exhibit PT symmetry. Investigations of the Sturm-Liouville eigenvalue problem associated with such Hamiltonians have shown that in many cases the entire energy spectrum is real and positive and that the eigenfunctions form an orthogonal and complete basis. Furthermore, the quantum theories determined by such Hamiltonians have been shown to be consistent in the sense that the probabilities are positive and the dynamical trajectories are unitary. However, the geometrical structures that underlie quantum theories formulated in terms of such Hamiltonians have hitherto not been fully understood. This paper studies in detail the geometric properties of a Hilbert space endowed with a parity structure and analyses the characteristics of a PT-symmetric Hamiltonian and its eigenstates. A canonical relationship between a PT-symmetric operator and a Hermitian operator is established. It is shown that the quadratic form corresponding to the parity operator, in particular, gives rise to a natural partition of the Hilbert space into two halves corresponding to states having positive and negative PT norm. The indefiniteness of the norm can be circumvented by introducing a symmetry operator C that defines a positive definite inner product by means of a CPT conjugation operation.
The positivity of the energy in relativistic quantum mechanics implies that wave functions can be continued analytically to the forward tube T in complex spacetime. For Klein-Gordon particles, we interpret T as an extended (8D) classical phase space containing all 6D classical phase spaces as symplectic submanifolds. The evaluation maps ez:f→f(z)e_z: f\to f(z)ez​:f→f(z) of wave functions on T are relativistic coherent states reducing to the Gaussian coherent states in the nonrelativistic limit. It is known that no covariant probability interpretation exists for Klein-Gordon particles in real spacetime because the time component of the conserved "probability current" can attain negative values even for positive-energy solutions. We show that this problem is solved very naturally in complex spacetime, where ∣f(x−iy)∣2|f(x-iy)|^2∣f(x−iy)∣2 is interpreted as a probability density on all 6D phase spaces in T which, when integrated over the "momentum" variables y, gives a conserved spacetime probability current whose time component is a positive regularization of the usual one. Similar results are obtained for Dirac particles, where the evaluation maps eze_zez​ are spinor-valued relativistic coherent states. For free quantized Klein-Gordon and Dirac fields, the above formalism extends to n-particle/antiparticle coherent states whose scalar products are Wightman functions. The 2-point function plays the role of a reproducing kernel for the one-particle and antiparticle subspaces.
We construct a concrete realization of the generalized parity (P), time-reversal (T), and charge-conjugation (C) operators, that were initially defined in the study of the PT-symmetric and pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonians, for Klein-Gordon fields. We show that PT and C operators, that signify certain symmetries of the system, correspond to the ordinary time-reversal and charge-conjugation transformations, respectively. Furthermore, we construct a positive-definite and relativistically invariant inner product on the space of Klein-Gordon fields and show that the generator h of time-translations viewed as acting in the Hilbert space calH{cal H}calH defined by this inner product is Hermitian. The quantum system having calH{cal H}calH as its Hilbert space and h as its Hamiltonian is unitarily equivalent to the one defined by a Hermitian Hamiltonian acting in the Hilbert space L2(R3)oplusL2(R3)L^2(R^3)oplus L^2(R^3)L2(R3)oplusL2(R3). We give the explicit form of the corresponding unitary transformation and use it to construct position operators, localized and coherent states, and a set of wave functions for the Klein-Gordon fields. Our approach provides a consistent quantum mechanical description of the Klein-Gordon fields that admits a genuine probabilistic interpretation.