A Physical Axiomatic Approach to Schrodinger's Equation

Rajesh R. Parwani

Published Aug 17, 2005• 8 citations

Abstract

The Schrodinger equation for non-relativistic quantum systems is derived from some classical physics axioms within an ensemble hamiltonian framework. Such an approach enables one to understand the structure of the equation, in particular its linearity, in intuitive terms. Furthermore it allows for a physically motivated and systematic investigation of potential generalisations which are briefly discussed.

Related papers

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Generalizations of the Mathematical Axiomatic Derivation of the Schrödinger Equation

Olavo Leopoldino da Silva Filho

An axiomatic approach to quantum mechanics that has, as a theorem, the Schrödinger equation may be of enormous value to cope with interpretation issues, since all the interpretation constructs must be present in the axioms, or directly derived by them from their mathematical unfolding. Thus, it is critical to show that this axiomatic derivation is reliable beyond any possible doubt. To show this, it is possible to make generalizations and extensions of the axioms to derive the Schrödinger equation in the underlying generalized or extended formats. In previous papers, we have shown that the axiomatic approach we propose can be used to derive the Schrödinger equation as a direct axiom. Since then, we have also shown that it was possible to generalize that derivation to coordinate systems other than the Cartesian, as well as its relativistic extensions that lead to the relativistic wave equations. An extension to dissipative systems was also performed, allowing us to mathematically derive the Caldirola–Kanai equation from first principles. All these derivations were performed using pure states and in the absence of the electromagnetic field. This means that we can further generalize the approach to embrace these two possibilities. Being an axiomatic approach, we show that we need only to slightly modify the axioms to derive the Schrödinger equation for these two contexts. Despite being quite direct, the algebraic complexity of these derivations should give the reader the desired confidence in the proposed axioms.

MathematicsJun 3, 20260 citations

Derivation of the Schrödinger equation V: Relativistic Equations of Quantum Mechanics and its epistemological impacts on teaching

Olavo Leopoldino da Silva Filho, Marcello Caio Ramon e Barros Ferreira

In this paper, we present a derivation of the relativistic equations of Quantum Mechanics. We focus on the second order equations (both Klein Gordon’s and Dirac’s), since the linear Dirac equation can be derived from these. This derivation is an extension of the same method applied to the non-relativistic case in a in a previous series of articles by us. We show that, to extend the theoretical framework to the relativistic case, we have only to extend the axioms in a relativistically compatible way, as should be the case with any extension of an axiomatic method. We also show that this quantization method throws light in a different way to interpret some descriptors of the usual formalism, mainly those regarding the expression for the probability density function. This, on the other hand, gives the teacher following this approach in classes on the subject to assess the epistemological issue of the role of manuals in the learning of Quantum Mechanics.

Revista Brasileira de Ensino de FísicaJan 1, 20251 citation

Quantum Mechanics as a Classical Theory I: Non-relativistic Theory

L. S. F. Olavo

The objective of this series of three papers is to axiomatically derive quantum mechanics from classical mechanics and two other basic axioms. In this first paper, Schreodinger's equation for the density matrix is fist obtained and from it Schroedinger's equation for the wave functions is derived. The momentum and position operators acting upon the density matrix are defined and it is then demonstrated that they commute. Pauli's equation for the density matrix is also obtained. A statistical potential formally identical to the quantum potential of Bohm's hidden variable theory is introduced, and this quantum potential is reinterpreted through the formalism here proposed. It is shown that, for dispersion free {\it ensembles% }, Schroedinger's equation for the density matrix is equivalent to Newton's equations. A general non-ambiguous procedure for the construction of operators which act upon the density matrix is presented. It is also shown how these operators can be reduced to those which act upon the wave functions.

arXiv:quant-ph/9503020Mar 28, 19953 citations

Non-Relativistic Schrödinger Equation

Z. Ficek

The major problem in quantum physics is to find the wave function of a given physical system and to understand (predict) how the wave function of the system evolves in time, or how it changes under external influences. In 1926, Erwin Schrodinger predicted that the wave function of a given physical system might be completely determined if the total energy of the system was known. Since the equation represents a real physical system, it must satisfy the following conditions: the equation must be linear and coefficients appearing in this equation should only depend on the parameters characteristic of the particle. This chapter focuses on to the non-relativistic case only. It considers the case of a free particle moving in one dimension. The chapter shows that the Schrodinger equation can be obtained from the energy of the free particle. It shows that the Schrodinger equation guarantees the conservation of normalization of the wave function.

Mar 3, 20170 citations

Schrödinger group and non-linear generalizations of quantum mechanics

Marcel Reginatto

Abstract A free particle may be characterized abstractly in terms of its invariance group. Both the Hamilton-Jacobi and Schrödinger equations for classical and quantum free particles are invariant under the same group, the Schrödinger group. The aim of this paper is to discuss possible restrictions on non-linear generalizations of quantum mechanics. The basic idea is to search for those non-linear generalization of quantum mechanics for which a description of the non-relativistic free particle includes a representation of the Schrödinger group, as in classical and quantum mechanics. This condition imposes strong constraints on possible models of free particles. To carry out such an investigation it is necessary to select an appropriate mathematical formalism, one which can describe physical systems of non-relativistic particles and allows for the incorporation of non-linearities in a natural way. Here the formalism of ensembles on configuration space is used, which is an approach that is capable of describing both classical and quantum systems and, in addition, allows for more general theories that describe mixed classical-quantum systems. Modifications of the equations involving derivatives of up to fourth order are considered

Journal of Physics Conference SeriesAug 1, 20200 citations

Revisiting Dirac and Schrödinger: A Proof Offered for the Non-Relativistic Time-Dependent Schrödinger Equation

Sanayei, Ali

In this paper, three plausible axioms together with two definitions are employed to build an axiomatic framework, and then with the help of the Dirac formalism, it is demonstrated that the time-dependent Schrödinger wave equation is no longer a postulate for the whole theory, but a theorem. Subsequently, a proof for the theorem is presented. The result implies that the other remaining axioms of the picture essentially involve the Schrödinger equation, and this consequence lets the whole theory become stronger.

arXiv:1309.1787Sep 6, 20131 citation