Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Theory of pairing in the Cu-O Plane: Three-Band Hubbard Model and Beyond

Michele Cini, Gianluca Stefanucci, A. Balzarotti

Published Jan 1, 1999• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We calculate the effective interaction Weff between two holes added to the ground state of the repulsive three-band Hubbard model. To make contact with Cooper theory and with earlier Hubbard model cluster studies, we first use a perturbative canonical transformation, to generate a two-body Hamiltonian. Then, we extend the results to all orders. The approach is exact in principle, and we obtain a close analytic expression including explicitly the effects of all virtual transitions to 4-body intermediate states. Our scheme naturally lends itself to embody off-site, inter-planar, phonon-mediated and other interactions which are not considered in the Hubbard model but may well be important. The result depends qualitatively on the symmetry of the two-hole state: 1 B2 and 1 A2 pairs are special, because the bare holes do not interact by the on-site repulsion (W=0 pairs). The effective interaction in these channels is attractive and leads to a Cooper-like instability of the Fermi liquid; however Weff is repulsive for Triplet pairs. Bound two-hole states of the same nature were reported earlier in small cluster calculations by exact diagonalisation methods; only symmetric clusters are good models of the plane. Once Weff is known, the pair eigenfunction is determined by an integral equation. We present numerical estimates of the binding energy |∆ | of the pairs, which is in the physically interesting range of tens of meV if unscreened on-site repulsion parameters are used. 1 I.

Related papers

Theory of pairing in the Cu-O plane: Three-band Hubbard model and beyond

Michele Cini, Gianluca Stefanucci, Adalberto Balzarotti

We calculate the effective interaction $W_{eff}$ between two holes added to the ground state of the repulsive three-band Hubbard model. To make contact with Cooper theory and with earlier Hubbard model cluster studies, we first use a perturbative canonical transformation, to generate a two-body Hamiltonian. Then, we extend the results to all orders. The approach is exact in principle, and we obtain a close analytic expression including explicitly the effects of all virtual transitions to 4-body intermediate states. Our scheme naturally lends itself to embody off-site, inter-planar, phonon-mediated and other interactions which are not considered in the Hubbard model but may well be important. The result depends qualitatively on the symmetry of the two-hole state: $^{1}B_{2}$ and $ ^{1}A_{2}$ pairs are special, because the bare holes do not interact by the on-site repulsion (W=0 pairs). The effective interaction in these channels is attractive and leads to a Cooper-like instability of the Fermi liquid; however $W_{eff}$ is repulsive for Triplet pairs. Bound two-hole states of the same nature were reported earlier in small cluster calculations by exact diagonalisation methods; only symmetric clusters are good models of the plane. Once $W_{eff}$ is known, the pair eigenfunction is determined by an integral equation. We present numerical estimates of the binding energy $|Δ|$ of the pairs, which is in the physically interesting range of tens of meV if unscreened on-site repulsion parameters are used.

arXiv:cond-mat/9809278•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 1999•0 citations

Pairing in the Three-Band Hubbard Model of the Cu-O Plane

Michele Cini, Gianluca Stefanucci, A. Balzarotti

By a canonical transformation of the three-band Hubbard model, we introduce an effective Hamiltonian for the propagation of two holes doped into the ground state of the Cu-O plane. When the pair belongs to the $^{1}B_{2}$ or $% ^{1}A_{2}$ Irreducible Representations of the C$_{4v}$ Group, the bare holes do not interact by the on-site repulsion; the effective interaction between the dressed holes is obtained analytically in terms of renormalized matrix elements, and generalizes earlier findings from cluster calculations. The Fermi liquid is unstable and numerical estimates with reasonable parameters of the binding energy of the pair are in the range of tens of meV. Our scheme naturally lends itself to embody phonon-mediated and other interactions which cannot occur in the Hubbard model but may give important contributions.

arXiv:cond-mat/9808209•Aug 19, 1998•0 citations

The "W=0" Pairing Mechanism from Repulsive Interactions in Symmetric 2d Models

Michele Cini, Gianluca Stefanucci

In two-dimensional systems possessing a high degree of symmetry, the repulsive electron-electron interaction produces a pairing force; the mechanism would fail in the presence of strong distortions. We have studied this in the one-band and three-band Hubbard Model. From partially occupied orbitals one obtains pair eigenstates of the Hamiltonian with no on-site repulsion (the W=0 pairs). The concept of W=0 pairs allows to make qualitative and quantitative predictions about the behaviour of interacting many-body systems, a quite remarkable and unusual situation. Exact numerical solutions for clusters with ``magic'' hole numbers reveal attraction between the holes in W=0 pairs. The effect occurs in all fully symmetric clusters which are centered on a Cu site; then holes get paired in a wide, physically relevant parameter range and show superconducting quantization of the magnetic flux. A canonical transformation of the Hamiltonian, valid for clusters and for the full plane, leads to a Cooper-like equation for the W=0 pairs. We have evaluated the effective interaction and found that W=0 pairs are the bare quasiparticles which, once dressed, become two-hole bound states. We applied the above theory to the doped antiferromagnet, and found that the ground state at half filling is the singlet component of a determinantal state. We write down this determinant and the ground state wave function explicitly in terms of a many-body W=0 eigenstate. Our analytical results for the $4\times 4$ square lattice at half filling and with doped holes, compared to available numerical data, demonstrate that the method, besides providing intuitive grasp on pairing, also has quantitative predictive power.

arXiv:cond-mat/0204311•Apr 15, 2002•0 citations

Cluster approach to the three-band Hubbard model of the Cu-O plane: Superconducting pairs

Michele Cini, A. Balzarotti

The fully symmetric Cu-O clusters with a central Cu have two-hole singlet eigenstates which are not affected by the on-site repulsion. These pairs become bound states if the number of holes in the cluster is appropriate; moreover, the quantization at half-integer values of a magnetic test flux is consistent with a superconducting pattern. To investigate the mechanism of pairing, we study the symmetric clusters with $<~$21 atoms and four holes by exact diagonalization. Further, by the diagrammatic expansion of the ground-state energy and of the scattering amplitude, we obtain the spin-flip diagrams for the effective interaction, which is attractive for singlets and repulsive for triplets. A criterion for pairing in cluster calculations is thereby obtained.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 1, 1997•12 citations

CANONICAL TRANSFORMATION OF THE HUBBARD MODEL AND W = 0 PAIRING: COMPARISON WITH EXACT DIAGONALIZATION RESULTS

Michele Cini, A. Balzarotti, R. Brunetti +2 more

We have recently developed a canonical transformation of the Hubbard and related models, valid for systems of arbitrary size and for the full plane; this is particularly suited to study hole pairing. In this work we show that exact diagonalization results of the one band Hubbard model for small clusters with periodic boundary conditions agree well with the analytical ones obtained by means of our canonical transformation. In the presence of a pairing instability, the analytic approach allows us to identify the Cooper pairs. They are W = 0 pairs, that is, singlet two-hole eigenstates of the Hubbard Hamiltonian with vanishing on-site repulsion. Indeed, we find that the Coulomb interaction effects on W = 0 pairs are dynamically small, and repulsive or attractive, depending on the filling.

arXiv:cond-mat/0005242•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Oct 30, 2000•3 citations

W= 0 pairing in Hubbard and related models of low-dimensional superconductors

A. Balzarotti, Michele Cini, Enrico Perfetto +1 more

Lattice Hamiltonians with on-site interaction $W$ have W=0 solutions, that is, many-body {\em singlet} eigenstates without double occupation. In particular, W=0 pairs give a clue to understand the pairing force in repulsive Hubbard models. These eigenstates are found in systems with high enough symmetry, like the square, hexagonal or triangular lattices. By a general theorem, we propose a systematic way to construct all the W=0 pairs of a given Hamiltonian. We also introduce a canonical transformation to calculate the effective interaction between the particles of such pairs. In geometries appropriate for the CuO$_{2}$ planes of cuprate superconductors, armchair Carbon nanotubes or Cobalt Oxides planes, the dressed pair becomes a bound state in a physically relevant range of parameters. We also show that W=0 pairs quantize the magnetic flux like superconducting pairs do. The pairing mechanism breaks down in the presence of strong distortions. The W=0 pairs are also the building blocks for the antiferromagnetic ground state of the half-filled Hubbard model at weak coupling. Our analytical results for the $4\times 4$ Hubbard square lattice, compared to available numerical data, demonstrate that the method, besides providing intuitive grasp on pairing, also has quantitative predictive power. We also consider including phonon effects in this scenario. Preliminary calculations with small clusters indicate that vector phonons hinder pairing while half-breathing modes are synergic with the W=0 pairing mechanism both at weak coupling and in the polaronic regime.

arXiv:cond-mat/0411101•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Nov 13, 2004•4 citations
We calculate the effective interaction Weff between two holes added to the ground state of the repulsive three-band Hubbard model. To make contact with Cooper theory and with earlier Hubbard model cluster studies, we first use a perturbative canonical transformation, to generate a two-body Hamiltonian. Then, we extend the results to all orders. The approach is exact in principle, and we obtain a close analytic expression including explicitly the effects of all virtual transitions to 4-body intermediate states. Our scheme naturally lends itself to embody off-site, inter-planar, phonon-mediated and other interactions which are not considered in the Hubbard model but may well be important. The result depends qualitatively on the symmetry of the two-hole state: 1 B2 and 1 A2 pairs are special, because the bare holes do not interact by the on-site repulsion (W=0 pairs). The effective interaction in these channels is attractive and leads to a Cooper-like instability of the Fermi liquid; however Weff is repulsive for Triplet pairs. Bound two-hole states of the same nature were reported earlier in small cluster calculations by exact diagonalisation methods; only symmetric clusters are good models of the plane. Once Weff is known, the pair eigenfunction is determined by an integral equation. We present numerical estimates of the binding energy |∆ | of the pairs, which is in the physically interesting range of tens of meV if unscreened on-site repulsion parameters are used. 1 I.
We calculate the effective interaction WeffW_{eff}Weff​ between two holes added to the ground state of the repulsive three-band Hubbard model. To make contact with Cooper theory and with earlier Hubbard model cluster studies, we first use a perturbative canonical transformation, to generate a two-body Hamiltonian. Then, we extend the results to all orders. The approach is exact in principle, and we obtain a close analytic expression including explicitly the effects of all virtual transitions to 4-body intermediate states. Our scheme naturally lends itself to embody off-site, inter-planar, phonon-mediated and other interactions which are not considered in the Hubbard model but may well be important. The result depends qualitatively on the symmetry of the two-hole state: 1B2^{1}B_{2}1B2​ and $ ^{1}A_{2}$ pairs are special, because the bare holes do not interact by the on-site repulsion (W=0 pairs). The effective interaction in these channels is attractive and leads to a Cooper-like instability of the Fermi liquid; however WeffW_{eff}Weff​ is repulsive for Triplet pairs. Bound two-hole states of the same nature were reported earlier in small cluster calculations by exact diagonalisation methods; only symmetric clusters are good models of the plane. Once WeffW_{eff}Weff​ is known, the pair eigenfunction is determined by an integral equation. We present numerical estimates of the binding energy ∣Δ∣|Δ|∣Δ∣ of the pairs, which is in the physically interesting range of tens of meV if unscreened on-site repulsion parameters are used.
By a canonical transformation of the three-band Hubbard model, we introduce an effective Hamiltonian for the propagation of two holes doped into the ground state of the Cu-O plane. When the pair belongs to the 1B2^{1}B_{2}1B2​ or % ^{1}A_{2} Irreducible Representations of the C4v_{4v}4v​ Group, the bare holes do not interact by the on-site repulsion; the effective interaction between the dressed holes is obtained analytically in terms of renormalized matrix elements, and generalizes earlier findings from cluster calculations. The Fermi liquid is unstable and numerical estimates with reasonable parameters of the binding energy of the pair are in the range of tens of meV. Our scheme naturally lends itself to embody phonon-mediated and other interactions which cannot occur in the Hubbard model but may give important contributions.
In two-dimensional systems possessing a high degree of symmetry, the repulsive electron-electron interaction produces a pairing force; the mechanism would fail in the presence of strong distortions. We have studied this in the one-band and three-band Hubbard Model. From partially occupied orbitals one obtains pair eigenstates of the Hamiltonian with no on-site repulsion (the W=0 pairs). The concept of W=0 pairs allows to make qualitative and quantitative predictions about the behaviour of interacting many-body systems, a quite remarkable and unusual situation. Exact numerical solutions for clusters with ``magic'' hole numbers reveal attraction between the holes in W=0 pairs. The effect occurs in all fully symmetric clusters which are centered on a Cu site; then holes get paired in a wide, physically relevant parameter range and show superconducting quantization of the magnetic flux. A canonical transformation of the Hamiltonian, valid for clusters and for the full plane, leads to a Cooper-like equation for the W=0 pairs. We have evaluated the effective interaction and found that W=0 pairs are the bare quasiparticles which, once dressed, become two-hole bound states. We applied the above theory to the doped antiferromagnet, and found that the ground state at half filling is the singlet component of a determinantal state. We write down this determinant and the ground state wave function explicitly in terms of a many-body W=0 eigenstate. Our analytical results for the 4×44\times 44×4 square lattice at half filling and with doped holes, compared to available numerical data, demonstrate that the method, besides providing intuitive grasp on pairing, also has quantitative predictive power.
The fully symmetric Cu-O clusters with a central Cu have two-hole singlet eigenstates which are not affected by the on-site repulsion. These pairs become bound states if the number of holes in the cluster is appropriate; moreover, the quantization at half-integer values of a magnetic test flux is consistent with a superconducting pattern. To investigate the mechanism of pairing, we study the symmetric clusters with $<~$21 atoms and four holes by exact diagonalization. Further, by the diagrammatic expansion of the ground-state energy and of the scattering amplitude, we obtain the spin-flip diagrams for the effective interaction, which is attractive for singlets and repulsive for triplets. A criterion for pairing in cluster calculations is thereby obtained.
We have recently developed a canonical transformation of the Hubbard and related models, valid for systems of arbitrary size and for the full plane; this is particularly suited to study hole pairing. In this work we show that exact diagonalization results of the one band Hubbard model for small clusters with periodic boundary conditions agree well with the analytical ones obtained by means of our canonical transformation. In the presence of a pairing instability, the analytic approach allows us to identify the Cooper pairs. They are W = 0 pairs, that is, singlet two-hole eigenstates of the Hubbard Hamiltonian with vanishing on-site repulsion. Indeed, we find that the Coulomb interaction effects on W = 0 pairs are dynamically small, and repulsive or attractive, depending on the filling.
Lattice Hamiltonians with on-site interaction WWW have W=0 solutions, that is, many-body {\em singlet} eigenstates without double occupation. In particular, W=0 pairs give a clue to understand the pairing force in repulsive Hubbard models. These eigenstates are found in systems with high enough symmetry, like the square, hexagonal or triangular lattices. By a general theorem, we propose a systematic way to construct all the W=0 pairs of a given Hamiltonian. We also introduce a canonical transformation to calculate the effective interaction between the particles of such pairs. In geometries appropriate for the CuO2_{2}2​ planes of cuprate superconductors, armchair Carbon nanotubes or Cobalt Oxides planes, the dressed pair becomes a bound state in a physically relevant range of parameters. We also show that W=0 pairs quantize the magnetic flux like superconducting pairs do. The pairing mechanism breaks down in the presence of strong distortions. The W=0 pairs are also the building blocks for the antiferromagnetic ground state of the half-filled Hubbard model at weak coupling. Our analytical results for the 4×44\times 44×4 Hubbard square lattice, compared to available numerical data, demonstrate that the method, besides providing intuitive grasp on pairing, also has quantitative predictive power. We also consider including phonon effects in this scenario. Preliminary calculations with small clusters indicate that vector phonons hinder pairing while half-breathing modes are synergic with the W=0 pairing mechanism both at weak coupling and in the polaronic regime.