On a theory of low temperature electron decoherence in disordered conductors
Dmitry S. Golubev, Andrei D. Zaikin
Recently von Delft (JvD) attempted to revise our theory of low temperature decoherence of electrons in disordered conductors with electron-electron interactions [D.S. Golubev and A.D. Zaikin, Phys. Rev. B 59, 9195 (1999)] and argued [Intl. J. Mod. Phys. B 22, 727 (2008)] that by 'more accurate treatment of recoil efiects' he was able to obtain the electron decoherence rate that vanishes at T = 0. In this paper we demonstrate that this JvD's claim is in error, as it is based on ambiguous and uncontrolled manipulations violating basic principles of quantum theory, such as energy-time uncertainty relation, causality, fluctuation-dissipation theorem, detailed balance and the like. While our theory has a simple and transparent relation to the well known P ( E ) theory (which exactly accounts for all recoil efiects) JvD's approach is inconsistent with this theory thus being unable to correctly treat even recoil efiects it was explicitly aimed at.
Journal of Physics Conference Series•Oct 1, 2008•2 citations