© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

Optics and Photonics for Information Processing

Surpassing Rayleigh limit: Fisher information analysis of partially coherent source(s)

Kwan K. Lee, Amit Ashok

Published Sep 6, 2019• 6 citations

Abstract

Tsang et al. have shown that the Fisher information of the two incoherent point source separation, below the Rayleigh limit, is finite and achievable using optical modes measurements.1 However, recent claims regarding partial coherence of sources, no matter how small, leads to necessarily zero Fisher information as the source separation decreases below the Rayleigh limit approaching zero have proved to be controversial.2, 3 Thus, the impact of partial coherence on the photon counting optical modal measurements merits further exploration. In this work, we derive the mutual coherence function (image plane) of two partially coherent point sources and find the classical Fisher information of the source separation using both direct image plane and photon counting modal measurements. A classical Fisher information analysis of partially coherent source(s) leads to some rather surprising results for two-point source resolution as the source separation approaches zero. We find that the magnitude of the Fisher information strongly depends on the degree of (positive/negative) partial coherence, which can be understood using an intuitive semi-classical analysis of direct image plane and photon counting modal measurements. We also provide an error analysis of the maximum likelihood estimators for both measurements.

DOI: 10.1117/12.2528540

Related papers

Resurgence of Rayleigh’s curse in the presence of partial coherence

Walker D. Larson, Bahaa E. A. Saleh

The two-point resolution of an optical system is the minimum distance between two point sources that can be estimated with a prescribed precision from measurement in the image plane. When the sources are incoherent, then direct measurement of the optical intensity provides resolution limited by Rayleigh’s curse, i.e., the precision diminishes to zero as the separation is reduced to zero. By using quantum Fisher information bounds on the precision, it was shown recently that estimates based on optimal quantum measurements of the optical field can break Rayleigh’s curse and provide estimates with finite precision even at very small separations. We show here that if the point sources are partially coherent with an unknown real degree of coherence, no matter how small it is, then the curse resurges. Since a Lambertian source is not strictly incoherent, having a correlation width of the order of a wavelength, and light gains coherence as it propagates, Rayleigh’s curse endures as a fundamental dictum.

Optica•Oct 24, 2018•73 citations

Quantum-limited resolution of partially coherent sources

Ben Wang, Liang Xu, Hongkuan Xia +3 more

Discriminating two spatially separated sources is one of the most fundamental problems in imaging.Recent research based on quantum parameter estimation theory shows that the resolution limit of two incoherent point sources given by Rayleigh can be broken.However, in realistic optical systems, there often exists coherence in the imaging light field, and there have been efforts to analyze the optical resolution in the presence of partial coherence.Nevertheless, how the degree of coherence between two point sources affects the resolution has not been fully understood.Here, we analyze the quantum-limited resolution of two partially coherent point sources by explicitly relating the state after evolution through the optical systems to the coherence of the sources.In particular, we consider the situation in which coherence varies with the separation.We propose a feasible experiment scheme to realize the nearly optimal measurement, which adaptively chooses the binary spatial-mode demultiplexing measurement and direct imaging.Our results will have wide applications in imaging involving coherence of light.

Chinese Optics Letters•Jan 1, 2023•6 citations

Quantum-Limited Time-Frequency Multiparameter Estimation through Mode-Selective Photon Measurement

Vahid Ansari, John M. Donohue, Jano Gil-López +7 more

In optics, when attempting to find the distance separations s between two incoherent emitters, it is standard practice to take a full image and extract the single parameter s from it. In such scenarios, the smallest precisely measurable separation is limited by the point-spread function on the image plane, with a vanishingly small amount of information available for smaller and smaller separations especially when photon shot noise is the dominant noise source (as in, for example, astronomical observations). This limit can be formalised by the Fisher information, which quantifies the amount of information accessible per photon detection and is directly associated with Cramér-Rao lower bound. For direct intensity imaging, the Fisher information drops to zero for object separations smaller than the spread of the optical field, sometimes referred to as the Rayleigh's curse, which limits the usefulness of photon counting for metrology.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

Coherence effects on estimating two-point separation

Kevin Liang, S. A. Wadood, A. Nick Vamivakas

The quantum Fisher information (FI), when applied to the estimation of the separation of two point sources, has been shown to be non-zero in cases where the coherence between the sources is known. Although it has been claimed that ignorance of the coherence causes the quantum FI to vanish (a resurgence of Rayleigh’s curse), a more complete analysis including both the magnitude and phase of the coherence parameter is given here. Partial ignorance of the coherence is shown to potentially break Rayleigh’s curse, whereas complete ignorance guarantees its resurgence.

Optica•Dec 3, 2020•38 citations

Coherence effects on estimating two-point separation

Kevin Liang, S. A. Wadood, A. Nick Vamivakas

The quantum Fisher information (FI), when applied to the estimation of the separation of two point sources, has been shown to be non-zero in cases where the coherence between the sources are known. Although it has been claimed that ignorance of the coherence causes the quantum FI to vanish (a resurgence of Rayleigh's curse), a more complete analysis including both the magnitude and phase of the coherence parameter is given here. Partial ignorance of the coherence is shown to potentially break Rayleigh's curse, whereas complete ignorance guarantees its resurgence.

arXiv:2012.05311•Dec 9, 2020•0 citations

Back to sources -- the role of coherence in super-resolution imaging revisited

Stanisław Kurdziałek

The fundamental limit on the precision of the separation estimation between two partially coherent sources is derived. Photon losses, inevitably associated with imperfect imaging, are properly taken into account. We begin our analysis with a simple and common imaging model based on the 4f system. We then show that our results are valid for any passive, linear, translationally invariant optical imaging system. We obtain the expression for the Quantum Fisher Information, which is consistent with the already computed classical Fisher Information and latest experimental work. We also identify the source of discrepancies in the results obtained earlier and show how to correctly interpret them.

•Mar 22, 2021•3 citations

Tsang et al. have shown that the Fisher information of the two incoherent point source separation, below the Rayleigh limit, is finite and achievable using optical modes measurements.1 However, recent claims regarding partial coherence of sources, no matter how small, leads to necessarily zero Fisher information as the source separation decreases below the Rayleigh limit approaching zero have proved to be controversial.2, 3 Thus, the impact of partial coherence on the photon counting optical modal measurements merits further exploration. In this work, we derive the mutual coherence function (image plane) of two partially coherent point sources and find the classical Fisher information of the source separation using both direct image plane and photon counting modal measurements. A classical Fisher information analysis of partially coherent source(s) leads to some rather surprising results for two-point source resolution as the source separation approaches zero. We find that the magnitude of the Fisher information strongly depends on the degree of (positive/negative) partial coherence, which can be understood using an intuitive semi-classical analysis of direct image plane and photon counting modal measurements. We also provide an error analysis of the maximum likelihood estimators for both measurements.

The two-point resolution of an optical system is the minimum distance between two point sources that can be estimated with a prescribed precision from measurement in the image plane. When the sources are incoherent, then direct measurement of the optical intensity provides resolution limited by Rayleigh’s curse, i.e., the precision diminishes to zero as the separation is reduced to zero. By using quantum Fisher information bounds on the precision, it was shown recently that estimates based on optimal quantum measurements of the optical field can break Rayleigh’s curse and provide estimates with finite precision even at very small separations. We show here that if the point sources are partially coherent with an unknown real degree of coherence, no matter how small it is, then the curse resurges. Since a Lambertian source is not strictly incoherent, having a correlation width of the order of a wavelength, and light gains coherence as it propagates, Rayleigh’s curse endures as a fundamental dictum.

Discriminating two spatially separated sources is one of the most fundamental problems in imaging.Recent research based on quantum parameter estimation theory shows that the resolution limit of two incoherent point sources given by Rayleigh can be broken.However, in realistic optical systems, there often exists coherence in the imaging light field, and there have been efforts to analyze the optical resolution in the presence of partial coherence.Nevertheless, how the degree of coherence between two point sources affects the resolution has not been fully understood.Here, we analyze the quantum-limited resolution of two partially coherent point sources by explicitly relating the state after evolution through the optical systems to the coherence of the sources.In particular, we consider the situation in which coherence varies with the separation.We propose a feasible experiment scheme to realize the nearly optimal measurement, which adaptively chooses the binary spatial-mode demultiplexing measurement and direct imaging.Our results will have wide applications in imaging involving coherence of light.

In optics, when attempting to find the distance separations s between two incoherent emitters, it is standard practice to take a full image and extract the single parameter s from it. In such scenarios, the smallest precisely measurable separation is limited by the point-spread function on the image plane, with a vanishingly small amount of information available for smaller and smaller separations especially when photon shot noise is the dominant noise source (as in, for example, astronomical observations). This limit can be formalised by the Fisher information, which quantifies the amount of information accessible per photon detection and is directly associated with Cramér-Rao lower bound. For direct intensity imaging, the Fisher information drops to zero for object separations smaller than the spread of the optical field, sometimes referred to as the Rayleigh's curse, which limits the usefulness of photon counting for metrology.

The quantum Fisher information (FI), when applied to the estimation of the separation of two point sources, has been shown to be non-zero in cases where the coherence between the sources is known. Although it has been claimed that ignorance of the coherence causes the quantum FI to vanish (a resurgence of Rayleigh’s curse), a more complete analysis including both the magnitude and phase of the coherence parameter is given here. Partial ignorance of the coherence is shown to potentially break Rayleigh’s curse, whereas complete ignorance guarantees its resurgence.

The quantum Fisher information (FI), when applied to the estimation of the separation of two point sources, has been shown to be non-zero in cases where the coherence between the sources are known. Although it has been claimed that ignorance of the coherence causes the quantum FI to vanish (a resurgence of Rayleigh's curse), a more complete analysis including both the magnitude and phase of the coherence parameter is given here. Partial ignorance of the coherence is shown to potentially break Rayleigh's curse, whereas complete ignorance guarantees its resurgence.

The fundamental limit on the precision of the separation estimation between two partially coherent sources is derived. Photon losses, inevitably associated with imperfect imaging, are properly taken into account. We begin our analysis with a simple and common imaging model based on the 4f system. We then show that our results are valid for any passive, linear, translationally invariant optical imaging system. We obtain the expression for the Quantum Fisher Information, which is consistent with the already computed classical Fisher Information and latest experimental work. We also identify the source of discrepancies in the results obtained earlier and show how to correctly interpret them.